Seeing is believing

I believe those links prove you wrong....

Tricky post that NewsWeek link here.
 
That old post dowsing 2 is corrupt it takes forever to come up and function .
That's why I started this post.
This post deals with today and tomorrow not yesterday.
 
I believe those links prove you wrong....

Tricky post that NewsWeek link here.
Here's the link to the Newsweek story. I'll quote the pertinant parts, with Edge's real name left out (posting names is against forum rules, I believe).

Newsweek said:
Randi's not without detractors. While he insists he conducts fair, double-blind tests, Gary Schwartz, a University of Arizona professor and an expert on the paranormal, says Randi alters testing parameters. "The phenomena are very sensitive," says Schwartz. "He doesn't optimize conditions." (Edge), who failed to prove he could find gold, agrees. He says taking the "Challenge" in an office threw off his channeling ability. (Edge) wants to retake it: "They're going to have to come to me."

What the Newsweek article doesn't mention is that Edge agreed that the conditions were just fine before he failed the test. Also Edge claims he wants to retake the test, but still hasn't filled out an application in two years. He's busy making all sorts of conditions for the test, but he has not even discussed what conditions are mutually acceptable between him and JREF.

Edge said:
That old post dowsing 2 is corrupt it takes forever to come up and function .
It works just fine for me.

Edge said:
That's why I started this post.
This post deals with today and tomorrow not yesterday.
That's because yesterday, you were a big failure. (I believe the same will be true "tomorrow".) But here's the thing. If you forget yesterday, then you don't learn anything from it. You are making exactly the same kinds of errors today as you were yesterday. Look through that old thread and you will see the same questions coming up over and over again. You have never answered those questions with evidence.

BTW, sorry to hear about Green Eyes. Hope she's doing okay now.
 
Your faith is touching.
And I hope to discribe what I'm touching.
Shes fine now ,It was an added juorney and a walk in faith.
Thank God ,now onward and upward.
Sometimes you have too crash and burn to be able to fly.
I leared what the tests were, and am staged and ready.
Times on my side.

It's raining on the snow now.
 
Shes fine now.
I am very glad to hear that, both for her sake and yours.

Sometimes you have too crash and burn to be able to fly.
If you crash and burn, then wouldn't that mean you were already flying?

But your point is taken. You should learn from your mistakes. I hope you will, but sadly, I see no evidence of it. You never have for one minute seemed to consider the possibility that dowsing doesn't work. Instead, you try more and more elaborate plans when the question is so very very simple. You can detect hidden gold, or you can't. All of the handwaving about "natural settings" and "clearing interference" and such are just misdirections. If your dowsing rod is attracted to gold, it will be attracted to gold whether it is in the ground, under a coffee cup, hung in a tree or anywhere. If it isn't, then it is useless for finding gold.
I leared what the tests were, and am staged and ready.
You don't appear to be ready. You still haven't tested yourself with a properly prepared double-blind test. I assure you this is what JREF will insist upon. If you want to practice, this is what you should practice on. You don't prepare for a math test by studying a spelling book.

Times on my side.
Dowsers have had hundreds or thousands of years to prove their claims, and in that time, not one has been able to do so in a proper test. History is against you, Edge. Time is not on your side.
 
Edge, Tricky is making a very blunt, obvious point.

Can your stick detect gold or not?

Why do you need to go through all these fancy hoops?

Come on, man. I mean, if your stick points to gold, why do we need you holding it?

Seriously?

Why can't we just strap it to something, you can bring gold to it, and if the stick bends towards the gold, then wammo, million bucks!

We have every reason to believe that, because you're holding the stick, and because you're going through so many hoops trying to set up all these elaborate test procedures when a very simple test will suffice.

Come on, buddy.

Eh?

Be a pal.

Be a pal and make the stick find the gold.

Come on.
 
Soon The weather has to clear.
You don't need the weather to clear. You can do it in your house.

If your stick can detect a few flakes of gold in very low concentrations, mixed in with all sorts of other rocks and probably metallic components, then it should be able to detect a large lump of pure gold separated from your stick by an eighth of an inch of porcelain. Think about it Edge. The only way your scenario can be plausible is if you believe that gold stops being attracted once you get it out of the ground. But we know that is not your belief, because you were concerned about gold (more precisely, gold colored things) in Randi's office, which were very much out-of-the-ground.

Try the gold pendulum, Edge. If you can attract it with your dowsing rod, you will have an answer. Remember that you said the force was so strong it nearly ripped the stick out of your hands. Surely you can make a piece of gold on a string swing with a force that strong.

We're trying to save you some trouble. Why are you so resistant to easy tests?
 
We're trying to save you some trouble. Why are you so resistant to easy tests?

Because Edge, as polite and seemingly cooperative as he may be, is a con artist who really wants that million dollars. He can already feel it burning a hole in his pocket, and he just has to figure out how to set up a test where he's sure to win.

After all, this is how he makes his living, is it not?
 
L.M.A.O.
Look I explained everything and cheating is not an option.
I stated in that article they have to come here.
I'm not going to tell them to come till I see 70% + hits then it will not be gambling.
I'm thinking of a way to make it a triple blind test and for me and Jeff, that will be proof enough.
If I blindfold my self.
There will be no mistaken results.

Till I do more testing there will not be any more information.
You will not be an influence to me, to make me rush into this.
Everything I told you I have done.
I am in the gold fields where I can get neutral ground only because I can vacuum it clean here.

The only rush I have right now is to see if I can find a spot to do it before July or August.
That is what may occur.
I have to maintain my position and pay the bills.
The million doesn't mean anything to me right now.
In a couple of days it might.
I’m thinking for the two of us, Jeff and I, a blind fold and ear plugs.
That should make it double blind test and make my senses keener. Then when they get here I may still do that, and make it triple blind.

It may be testable then again it may not.
I am about to find out.

I will know with out any doubt.
 
Tricky said,"Try the gold pendulum, Edge. If you can attract it with your dowsing rod, you will have an answer. Remember that you said the force was so strong it nearly ripped the stick out of your hands. Surely you can make a piece of gold on a string swing with a force that strong."


If it worked that way I wouldn't need to shovel or dredge.
The gold would jump out of the creek and all I would have to do is collect it.
IT WORKS PERFICTLY WHEN I MINE.
I need twenty more % Positive hits.
It's just a matter of time before I find the right spot to do the test in.
I will find that spot here or there will be no test.
Or at least till July.
It broke the stick tricky and that was ground that I mined twenty years ago, more than an Ounce a day.
That ground after I got done with it has for 18 years been worked to death.
 
Remember that you said the force was so strong it nearly ripped the stick out of your hands.

Edge, if this is the case, then there should be no problem swinging some gold on a string. It doesn't have to tear the gold off, just swing it a bit.

But if it's a "one way" force as you describe it, then my question still stands:

Why do we need you to hold the stick???

Why can't we fasten the stick to something, and swing gold in front of it? Shouldn't the stick bend towards the gold?
 
(snip)Look I explained everything and cheating is not an option.
I stated in that article they have to come here.
I'm not going to tell them to come till I see 70% + hits then it will not be gambling.
I'm thinking of a way to make it a triple blind test and for me and Jeff, that will be proof enough.
If I blindfold my self.
There will be no mistaken results....(snip).

1. An attempt to cheat is always a possibility--this is not to say that you intend to cheat (I don't think you do), but any legitimate test must take into account the POSSIBILITY of cheating.

2. If you run a truly double-blind test, I seriously doubt you will ever see 70% + hits, and so I also seriously doubt you will ever re-apply.

3. You can put on four blindfolds, and that will not make it a quadruple-blind test. Several people have attempted to explain to you what a double-blind test means. It does not mean that you wear a blindfold. You went through one double-blind test at the JREF, so you should know more about setting up a scientifically acceptable double-blind test.
 
You went through one double-blind test at the JREF, so you should know more about setting up a scientifically acceptable double-blind test.

I know exactly how they did it?

Don't you worry.
 
I will run two tests in the park and if they are good I will take two more with the third person.
Is that simple enough.
I said I want to make sure.

I can't wait, it's trying to clear here.
 
Jesus tap dancing Christ, edge. Seriously.

Say someone makes the rediculous claim that they can detect gold underground by holding a stick. Purely hypothetical.

Now, say an organization offers money if he can prove his claim under appropriate testing conditions. Again, just imagine this.

He unzips his pants and whips out his stick, getting ready to find "the gold" when they say "hold on buddy, not so fast. We need to make sure the test is 'double blinded' first". He gets nervous and tucks his stick back in his pants.

"You're stick can always detect gold, right?"

"Yes, sometimes it jumps out of my hands, it wants that puna...*ahem* gold so bad!" he replies.

Now, the test makers aren't stupid. They know you have an interest in winning the money, and there is a very real possibility that you might cheat.

But they also know that they are holding on to that money, so they don't want it to seem as though they rigged the test to keep you from passing.

So we have two subjective biases here, right? So far so good.

So now we find some objective third party, someone who agrees to participate in the test that has no reason to care about the million dollars.

They go into a room, where, a bunch of containers, some empty, some containing gold, are lined up in a long row.

They shuffle the containers around when no one is there, including the guy with the stick.

Everyone goes into the room, the stick man then proceeds to walk up and down the row, loudly proclaiming which containers his stick says have gold in them.

His proclamations are written down.

The containers are opened by the third party.

The rest, well, you can imagine.
 
Good try, Bagtagger, but allow me to be even more explicit.

Let me see if I can simplify; Edge, there are three people involved. The tester is the person who is doing the dowsing. The observer is watching the tester dowse to make sure he doesn't cheat. The third party arranges the target without contect with either the tester or the observer.
  • The third party is not going to get any reward, regardless of the outcome. He has no incentive whatsoever to cheat.
  • The tester and the observer leave the room (or testing area) and the third party arranges the targets and records the location of the gold. THe third party should not "decide" where to put the real gold. He should use some sort of random number generator, because he may fall into patterns that a clever tester could recognize.
  • The third party does not tell, or even see the other participants in the test. He leaves the room before either the tester or the observer return.
  • The tester and observer return. They have had no contact whatsoever with the third party, so neither one knows in advance where the targets are.
  • The tester does his thing and dowses each of the targets. The observer merely records his results and makes sure the tester doesn't cheat (like by peeking under the targets) but the observer still doesn't know which targets contain the gold. At no time during this procedure is the third party present.
  • After the test is complete, the third party joins the others and shows where the actual location of the gold is. The tester never touches the targets (in case he is a clever slight of hand artist).
  • The dowser's guesses are compared to the actual location provided by the third party.
It is called "double blind" because neither the dowser nor the observer knows the actual location of the gold. The two of them are both "blind" as to the location. It seems simple, but it is difficult to make sure that there is no possibility that the third party can communicate with the tester or the observer, either intentionally or accidentally.

Now if you perform this procedure honestly and carefully, I believe you will see that your "50% for finding the gold among seven targets" will suddenly disappear. You will be right one out of seven times on the average.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom