Tricky said,
I'll tell you again so you can remember.
The guy that taught me how to dowse made his first chunk of money by dowsing for uranium for the army engineers when they could not find any.
So he said. Did he provide any evidence, or was it strictly anecdotal? And if it was true, was he extremely wealthy? If not, why not?
I sat there and listened to 2 other dowsers that busted a gut L.T.A.O., when I told them about the ideomotor effect.
It is the most ridiculous explanation ever given as an excuse to hide the facts.
Yeah, I'll bet they did. Why don't you bring them out to take the challenge. Do you think either of them could use a cool million? Or are they just like you, full of stories and empty on evidence?
What I’m about to set up is the most sterile test ever for dowsing, no E.M.I. only the target.
What E.M.I.? If there were electromagnetic interference, then it should be easily detectable by instruments. Of course, if you're trying to find a place where no E.M.I. exists, then you'd better find an isolated planet. Ours is pretty much saturated with radio waves.
The target in our opinion will be the only metal there, it has to be unmistakably noticeable at that point.
You are looking for a place with no metals at all? How much do you know about geology, Edge? What makes you think your site is free of metals? You'd be much better off on the beaches of Florida.
And if your dowsing can't tell gold from any other metal, how do you use it to find gold in rocks that contain many other metals?
Plastic containers will be used to hold the target, there will be 10.
I have the target material.
That will consist of gold, lead, iron, and black sands, magnetic and non-magnetic plus what other elements are in the sand.
Just like in nature.
Almost anything you could have is "in nature". All of this preparation you are doing amounts to nothing. You can dowse any area, find the places where there is no response and put the targets there. That is assuming, of course, that you can actually determine if there is no response when dowsing. If you can't, well, then that pretty much shoots your claim to hell. But if you are determined to waste time and money, then I suppose you must do it your way. You will still lose, and when you do, you will make excuses, just like all dowsers who have taken the challenge.
I didn’t believe Tim either, even after he put me on the money.
I couldn’t believe it, till it worked for me and then found my own gold and not just once.
And where is Tim these days?
This then is the only way to be accurate in the test.
Sure, Edge. Preparing your excuses in advance, I see.
I should get ten for ten, remember when I took the test? , I said 7 out of 10.
And you got one out of ten, exactly as predicted by chance.
I had EMI problems then, when I tested my self before taking the test in Lauderdale.
But oddly, you didn't mention this until after you failed. Also, you got ten of ten in the open test, but you failed to mention that you had been cheating. What are you going to fail to mention this time?
Then if I fail I would say it’s unproveable, but that’s been changed by removing the metals in a certain area and getting no reaction what so ever.
You would say it's "unprovable"? Why wouldn't you simply say "it doesn't work".
Again, I ask, why can't you simply find a place where you get no reaction and place the targets there? You have never given any kind of answer to this question.
I wouldn’t even attempt this again with JREF, unless I could achieve neutrality of the ground.
Then introduce the target.
So you keep saying. You can talk the talk. Can you walk the walk?
So should I go for it or not?
I hope you do, if for no other reason that there is a very small possibility that it will jolt you into reality. But of course, I regret all the money you are wasting.
You see tricky this will lead to manipulation of natural energies that inter act with the magnetic field of the Earth.
Which energies are those? You realize that gold is not ferromagnetic, don't you? Neither is lead. How exactly do they interact witht he magnetic field of the Earth?
And by the way, dowsing has been around for centuries, yet no significant scientific advance has been made based on the principles of of dowsing. Compare and contrast with the discovery of atomic energy, discovered less than two centuries ago.
I see an end to fossil fuel.
Me too, or at least a major reduction in its quantity. If you have a plan to replace it, we'd all love to see it tested. Of course, many scientists are working on this, and, unlike you, they actually understand energy.
I think Tesla was sane and absolutely right.
He was right about some things, wrong about others. What are you claiming he was right about? And I don't believe Tesla was insane. His little feud with Edison brought out his very human anger and pride, but that's pretty much normal.
Remember what they told the Wright brothers?
That it was impossible for man to fly.
Who told them that? Man had already been flying before they had the first motorized flight. People had been predicting that man would fly long before the Wrights.
However, pay attention to the notable differences between the Wright brothers and you: They used science and knowledge of engineering to accomplish their feats. They tested their inventions. When they didn't work, they tried something else. Your methods nothing like theirs. You cling to your fantasy long after it has been
shown not to work.
In the old days I would have been burned at the stake, for witching.
It would depend on where you were. Lots of Christians believe in dowsing. I imagine you might be burned though if you told somebody you could find gold and then you couldn't. You are lucky that you will only lose some of your money when you fail this time.
The one thing that dowsing demonstrates is you can defeat gravity in a gravity field, and that is hard to do, to defeat gravity.
If you can demonstrate that, then do it. Can you make your dowsing rod attract a pendulum of gold the way a magnet would attract a pendulum of iron? No you can't. That would only be defeating a tiny amount of gravity, but you can't even manage such a simple task. Why do you think that is? I will tell you. Your dowsing doesn't work, Edge.