Seeing is believing

[snipper]
I would like to know how tiny muscles work through gloves?
Can you still move your fingers? Tiny muscles still work.

Muscles as a whole are not all-or-nothing but consist of subsets of all-or-nothing. It's tiny movements of muscle, not tiny muscles, that cause the effect, as in when one tries to hold anyting perfectly still with rigid muscles: there is some quavering. Hold a bottle at arm's length and, with a rigid arm, try and force it to hold still by telling all muscles concerned to flex and not relax.
 
The containers were hung off a string.
I still can’t get past 50%.
I have one more place to try, the park.
Preliminary tests indicate that there is little interference there.
20 more % is what I need.

We did one more test and that was to dowse with gloves.

Very interesting.

Tricky, gold is non-magnetic it doesn’t work that way.

I need to see at least 70 % twice in the park.
Other wise I may have to wait till July.

I would like to know how tiny muscles work through gloves?

How, exactly, were they hung? Can we safely presume they were hung in such a way that there was ABSOLUTELY no swaying, no spinning, and no balance-tilting to indicate the presence of a weight within the container? Essentially, you'd need a stabilized harness of some sort to effectively remove any sway, spin, or lean - I'd say this is an absolutely unnecessary step, which would offer FAR too many visual clues for the supposed dowser, without a description of a good suspension procedure.
 
An Israeli conjuror used to do a magic trick in which he could spot which covered containers were filled with water. Johnny Carson, with someone else's help, arranged it so the conjuror could not receive visual cues by bumping the table on which the containers rested. The conjuror could no longer do the trick.

I agree with zaayrdragon on this one--unless they are very carefully arranged, hanging containers offer visual cues that would invalidate a dowsing test. And the test doesn't sound as if it is double-blind.
 
The containers were hung off a string.
Well there you go. Your target is a pendulum. So if your rod is attracted to the target, then the target must also be pulled towards the rod. (If you don't understand this, ask a high school physics teacher). Thus, the targets on the string should begin to swing when you exert your dowsing power.

If it is not a force that is acting between you and the target, then all of the movement of the rod is coming from you, something you have repeatedly denied.

However if you can indeed prove that there are some forces for which there is not an equal and opposite force, you will rewrite all the science books.

I still can’t get past 50%.
And you still (apparently) can't figure out how to run a double-blind test. At least, you've never described your tests in such a way.

I have one more place to try, the park.
Preliminary tests indicate that there is little interference there.
20 more % is what I need.
If you can consistantly identify a target among nine non-targets 50% of the time, that will more than suffice to win the prize.

We did one more test and that was to dowse with gloves.
I would like to know how tiny muscles work through gloves?
How do muscles work through skin, Edge? Just imagine the gloves as very thick skin. And as has been pointed out, no-one said anything about "tiny muscles". I'm guessing that you saw something about "tiny muscle contractions" or something similar. It was the contractions that are tiny, Edge, not the muscles. (If you don't understand this, ask a high school English teacher.)
Tricky, gold is non-magnetic it doesn’t work that way.
You claim that there is an attractive force between the dowsing rod and the target. You haven't identified what kind of force, but if it is an attractive force, then both the rod and the target are attracted. That's the way force works.

I need to see at least 70 % twice in the park.
Other wise I may have to wait till July.
If you don't get 70%, will you conclude that dowsing doesn't work? No you won't because credulous people like yourself always have an excuse for why their pet theories fail. You will either have an excuse for not taking the test or you will have an excuse (probably several) when you fail the test. You've made excuses before, you will do it again.
 
edge demonstrates how you can use foggy language to cloud even the most basic reasoning and logic.
"I have a singularity in this box here."
"Really."
"Yeah."
"Can I see it?"
"No."
"Why not?"
"Because I told you I have a singularity in the box. I've shown people the box and they agreed I have a singularity in here."
"Right, but I don't believe you."
"That's because you are closed minded and just don't know how the laws of the Universe really work."
"Well, I know that there's no way you could have a singularity in that dinky little shoe box."
"Well, I do. It's in here. It's been proven."
"How?"
"I told you. Other people saw the box. They confirmed it."
"But no one saw the singularity."
"Yes they did."
"So you opened the box for them?"
"Yeah, of course."
"Really?"
"Er... yeah..."
"So can you open the box for me?"
"No."
 
Tricky said,
"However if you can indeed prove that there are some forces for which there is not an equal and opposite force, you will rewrite all the science books".

That is exactly what I think is happening.

Even certain animals can tell when there are changes about to happen and there are several theorys about what causes them to sense earth quakes.
One of them is that when plates are crushed and move, energy is relesed in the qaurtz and they sense that eletrical energy, also sound waves.

I'm trying to get a higher % for that reason.
At 50 %, it's like a gambling percentage.

It doesn’t really answer the question about a new form of science .

It works 99 percent of the time in the river.
It doesn't work that way in a manipulated test environment.

Every container had a counter weight so you could not tell which had the target, "a piece of wood".
It would do me no good to cheat and Jeff knows better than to give me cues.
I have no third person to help.

Another factor is duration of the test.
I got some more testing to do yet.

I have tried to manipulate the stick to cause a reaction and I can't do that.
Everybody that tries to prove a new theory goes through the , YOUR CRAZY thing...

Let’s have some fun now.
I'm going to e-mail Sylvia Brown to see if I can beat the JRFE test.


Interested? Let’s just see what she says first.

The whether should clear by tomorrow, so I can test at the park.
 
Last edited:
Everybody that tries to prove a new theory goes through the , YOUR CRAZY thing...

And most of the time, they are crazy.

No one thought Einstein was crazy. They were a little skeptical at first, but his substantial papers and work helped win over the scientific community. But that's because he actually had a profound insight into a fundamental truth about the Universe, one that could be tested and verified in many different ways.

You have a stick and you claim you can detect things with your stick.

You haven't really written anything to indicate to us or the rest of the science community that anything you have to say is more than the ravings of a man with a stick.

There is a big difference between:
Lorentz2.gif


and:
Overdone.Dowser.jpg
 
Let’s see if Sylvia answers back.

She is protected in a cocoon and blocks and is definitely in it for ?
 
Tricky said,
"However if you can indeed prove that there are some forces for which there is not an equal and opposite force, you will rewrite all the science books".

That is exactly what I think is happening.
Wow! That's pretty amazing. A completely new form of energy which defies Newtonian physics. A tug of war where one side pulls on the rope, but the other side feels nothing. And although you have no more than a basic science education (if that), you think you are smarter than all the physics professors in the world. That is indeed quite a claim, Edge. I'll say one thing for you, Edge. You don't think small. When you go off the deep end, you go way off the deep end.

Even certain animals can tell when there are changes about to happen and there are several theorys about what causes them to sense earth quakes.
One of them is that when plates are crushed and move, energy is relesed in the qaurtz and they sense that eletrical energy, also sound waves.
It is possible that certain animals are sensitive to small compressional and shear waves that humans are not. However, tests of this theory are very inconclusive. However, there is nothing paranormal suggested. They are not proposing a new kind of energy.

I'm trying to get a higher % for that reason.
At 50 %, it's like a gambling percentage.
how many targets are you using, Edge? Fifty percent with two targets is exactly random. Fifty percent of ten targets will win you the prize if you can do it consistantly.

It doesn’t really answer the question about a new form of science.
One-way forces? That's definitely new. If you can show they exist, you will add the Nobel Prize to the Randi million.

It works 99 percent of the time in the river.
It doesn't work that way in a manipulated test environment.
So the more control you have over the environment, the more the effect disappears. What does that tell you, Edge?

But if it works 99% of the time in the river, do the test in the bloody river. Put the targets in weighted waterproof boxes and put them in the river. Weight them down with river stones if you're worried about interferance. You have not shown that you can dowse successfully in any environment. All you've shown is your capacity for inventing excuses.

Every container had a counter weight so you could not tell which had the target, "a piece of wood".
It would do me no good to cheat and Jeff knows better than to give me cues.
You obviously don't understand why double blind tests are required. Do you need it explained again?

I have no third person to help.
What about Green Eyes?

Another factor is duration of the test.
I got some more testing to do yet.
How does duration affect the test. Does it make it easier if the test is long or harder?

Don't get me wrong though. I think the fact that you are testing youself is a great step forward. I only hope that the fact that you are not achieving your expected results is sending you the message that your power does not work. But I find that unlikely.

I have tried to manipulate the stick to cause a reaction and I can't do that.
To cause what kind of reaction? If you're talking about duplicating the ideomotor effect, then manipulation won't work. It is, by definition, unconscious.

Let’s have some fun now.
I'm going to e-mail Sylvia Brown to see if I can beat the JRFE test.
LOL. That may be paranormal in and of itself. She doesn't publish her email address.

Interested? Let’s just see what she says first.
I'd find that interesting, but then, she's a total woo-woo, so I wouldn't count on you winning many points with skeptics even if the unlikely possibility occurs that you do get her endorsement.

The whether should clear by tomorrow, so I can test at the park.
Keep a log. Describe everything you do. I'm interested in knowing how many targets you are using as well as how you are conducting the single blind.
 
Last edited:
.....Every container had a counter weight so you could not tell which had the target, "a piece of wood".
It would do me no good to cheat and Jeff knows better than to give me cues.
I have no third person to help......

Edge, people do give cues, even if they try not to do so. Poker players are notorious for learning to read "tells" that show them what kind of hands their opponents have--even when everyone at the table is trying to maintain a poker face and not give cues. Look up "Clever Hans." He was a horse whose trainer really thought he could do amazing tricks, that he was a horse genius. When he was carefully investigated, however, it turned out that the horse was reading very subtle cues that the trainer was unconsciously giving him. If a horse could do that, a person could. You might be picking up on tiny sensory clues that Jeff is giving without meaning to or being aware that he is doing it. You might not even be aware yourself that you're picking them up--it's just that "something tells me this container has gold in it." The something just might be Jeff's increased rate of blinking, or the way he shifted his weight, or something else that you noticed without thinking of it. The test really does need to be double-blinded.
 
God, I love this forum!

I sincerely apologize if I've missed it in the above 5 pages, BUT don't JREF dowsing applicants actually do a dry run before the actual test, i.e. they walk over the ten bags (or whatever) with the dowsing stick with full knowledge of what is in the open containers? THEN, after this "calibration" they do the real test.

I'm sorry, but this procedure seems like an iron-clad guarantee that the (failed) dowser doesn't have a leg to stand on when later trying to make excuses.
 
I sincerely apologize if I've missed it in the above 5 pages, BUT don't JREF dowsing applicants actually do a dry run before the actual test, i.e. they walk over the ten bags (or whatever) with the dowsing stick with full knowledge of what is in the open containers? THEN, after this "calibration" they do the real test.

I'm sorry, but this procedure seems like an iron-clad guarantee that the (failed) dowser doesn't have a leg to stand on when later trying to make excuses.

Yes they do indeed - details are here: http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html

(Page one, Dragon's response)
 
I sincerely apologize if I've missed it in the above 5 pages, BUT don't JREF dowsing applicants actually do a dry run before the actual test, i.e. they walk over the ten bags (or whatever) with the dowsing stick with full knowledge of what is in the open containers? THEN, after this "calibration" they do the real test.

I'm sorry, but this procedure seems like an iron-clad guarantee that the (failed) dowser doesn't have a leg to stand on when later trying to make excuses.
Exactly correct, as Kiless pointed out. Edge did this in his first test at the JREF offices. As expected, he got every one "right", in that he got a positive response for all targets and no response for any non-targets.

It took him some time, a period of a few weeks, to formulate an excuse. He claimed that he knew at the time that his "power" wasn't working right, but he wasn't going to pass up his chance at the million by telling Randi this. So when Randi asked him after the "open" test, if the conditions were suitable, he lied (or so he later claims).

Of course, no mention of the problems was made at the time. He did mention some "problem areas", like the gold leaf on the books on the library (which of course has no gold in it), but he agreed that they were not enough to throw him off. They certainly didn't interfere when he did the open test.

So when he finally started formulating his excuses, they were all over the boards. Turns out you can't dowse in Florida, or in a building (which should come as a shock to those dowsers which claim to be able to find where the wires in a building are.) In fact the only place you can dowse for gold is in the field. However, now it has to be a field that has been cleared of gold. Unless of course you suspend the target from a tree. Then it works 50% of the time.

What a long strange trip it's been.
 
My students are formulating their own dowsing test as an end of year written task.

One student will be using a forked branch of the river red gum, which apparently is the best for finding water in Australia.

I plan to use Sparkle the fluffy toy sheep, who has recently received a 75% vote of 'no confidence' by the class. :(

I'll see if any written reports they make can be summarised for here. :)
 
The ballast in the florescent light is the one distraction that got me, it went straight up and pointed to the ceiling.

this seems good enough for a challenge - a light in a sealed box
if it's on or off, you should be able to tell by your dowsing methods.

how about it?
 
That would be a good way to do it.
Such a strong reading from those ballast’s.


Tricky I was getting the same thing at their office as I am getting here.
Empties giving off a reading.

I thought I could tell the difference.

The open test is visual.

Why it should work so well in the creek while mining and not under a controlled setting ?
I'm working on it.

While mining the only difference is the duration of the scan.

It worked too well in Florida, but there is no way to check what it is that you’re feeling.

I should know more tomorrow, I test in the park.

It seems to be a good spot very little interference there.

I can go down to the creek and put my self right on the gold.

My logic says I should get a higher percentage of hits.
I need to run several more tests.

I’m going to try copper wire and the use of the gloves, to see if that cuts down or filters out what comes as interference.

The massive target that I’m going to use should override everything just on the proximity of the target.

Jeff reads out of a book when I’m locating, I don’t look at him and he knows not to cue me.

He writes down where he puts it and I tell him the number and he at the end adds it up.

I don’t know anything till we are done with whatever the number of tries is.

Wish I could afford to do a ballast test, I thought of that the other day too.

It was a very amazing reaction, very prominent.

What ever it is it is not muscles I have used several different ways of holding it, and the copper wire is unstoppable, when it goes it goes and there is no stopping it.
I can stop the wood but not the copper.

You know when my muscles get tired they cramp up,
dowsing makes me feel like I have been mildly shocked after a hour or so.

Totally a different feeling.
 
Why it should work so well in the creek while mining and not under a controlled setting ?
I'm working on it.

Behold, the process of 'rationalization' at work. It's just too painful for him to admit that it just doesn't work.

Jeff reads out of a book when I’m locating, I don’t look at him and he knows not to cue me.

'Jeff' shouldn't even be in the same area - nowhere within visual OR hearing range - during the testing. Learn what 'double-blind' means, edge.

What ever it is it is not muscles I have used several different ways of holding it, and the copper wire is unstoppable, when it goes it goes and there is no stopping it.

Seems to me that removing the human element would make such a device even more effective - you should try attaching the copper to some kind of wooden pole on wheels, or something, and see how well that works. Especially if the 'copper wire is unstoppable'.
 
That would be a good way to do it.
Such a strong reading from those ballast’s.
A detail you failed to mention when you took the first test. That excuse came weeks later.

Tricky I was getting the same thing at their office as I am getting here.
Empties giving off a reading.
Hmm... Do you think that could be something silly like your power doesn't work!
I thought I could tell the difference.
But you couldn't. What does that tell you?

The open test is visual.
Only if you decide to use visual rather than your dowsing. You got a response with your dowsing rod on all the open tests. You have told us time and time again that you cannot control the movements of your dowsing rod. Yet, when your brain knew where the target was, your dowsing rod responded. This is exactly what the ideomotor response describes. Unless you intentionally caused your dowsing rod to respond. Did you?

Why it should work so well in the creek while mining and not under a controlled setting ?
It seems like it is working well in the creek because it is not controlled. You have no standard to compare it to, so you convince yourself it is working. This is what the Randi challenge is all about; showing people that their paranormal abilities disappear when they are tested under fair conditions.

I should know more tomorrow, I test in the park.
What were the results? We're all eager to learn.

It seems to be a good spot very little interference there.
Good.

I can go down to the creek and put my self right on the gold.
But with no control. You seem to forget that you don't find gold at every place you identify by dowsing. Selective memory plays a big part in paranormal beliefs too.

My logic says I should get a higher percentage of hits.
I need to run several more tests.
You also need to double-blind your tests. If you don't take this precaution, you will end up with inaccurate results.

I’m going to try copper wire and the use of the gloves, to see if that cuts down or filters out what comes as interference.
And if that doesn't work, will you conclude that dowsing doesn't work, or will you just try something else?

The massive target that I’m going to use should override everything just on the proximity of the target.
Just what we've been telling you all along. But didn't you have a fairly massive target in your first JREF test? Wouldn't that have overridden any other sources of interference? That, after all, was the purpose of the open test.

Jeff reads out of a book when I’m locating, I don’t look at him and he knows not to cue me.
He writes down where he puts it and I tell him the number and he at the end adds it up.
Not good enough. If you run a true double-blind, you'll see a difference.
By the way, you've still never answered my question about how many targets you are using. When you say "50%", we need to know 50% out of what. If you have one real and nine fake targets, then 50% will win you the JREF prize if you can do it consistently.

I don’t know anything till we are done with whatever the number of tries is.
BS. You surely can tell if you are getting hits or misses.

Wish I could afford to do a ballast test, I thought of that the other day too.

It was a very amazing reaction, very prominent.
It would be very easy to set up. One way to do it would be to go to a two story building. Have someone control the fluorescent lights in the room below you (making sure you can't tell whether they are on or off) and see if you can tell when the ballast box is on. I assume that your rod will detect ballast boxes below you as well as above.

What ever it is it is not muscles I have used several different ways of holding it, and the copper wire is unstoppable, when it goes it goes and there is no stopping it.
You have told us before that you couldn't stop the wood either. Are you changing your story? But remember your first test which showed otherwise? You could make it go when you knew which cup contained the target. You could make it stop when you know which cups were empty. The only time you seemed unable to control it was when you you didn't know where the target was.

You know when my muscles get tired they cramp up,
dowsing makes me feel like I have been mildly shocked after a hour or so.

Totally a different feeling.
That's the purpose of the open tests; to see if your power is working. If you are honest, you'll rely on your skill, not visual clues. If you are unable to let the visual clues keep from influencing you, then perhaps you might realize that the signals are coming from your brain, not the target.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom