Seeing is believing

Has Egde told us how many targets he is using to get this 50%? Have I missed it?
 
I'm thinking of a way to make it a triple blind test and for me and Jeff, that will be proof enough.

Bwaaaah! This is hilarious! Like when other scamster talk about quatuum effects. It's clear that you have no idea what you're talking about, and saw 'double blind' studies and decided that 'triple' was better than 'double'. But the problem is, this isn't a children's forum, so the other people here actually know what a double blind study is, and that you're just talking out your ass.
 
Has Egde told us how many targets he is using to get this 50%? Have I missed it?
It's not terribly clear, but it sounds as if he hangs up seven coffee containers, six with wood weights, one with the actual target, and then dowses to find the one out of seven, getting it right about every other time. I could be wrong--the information comes in little pieces, and it's difficult to put together.

By the way, three years ago, Edge was writing a book. Stewie Griffin wanted me to ask him how he's coming along with that, but I told Stewie if he wanted to bug Edge, he could get his own account and ask him.
 
It's not terribly clear, but it sounds as if he hangs up seven coffee containers, six with wood weights, one with the actual target, and then dowses to find the one out of seven, getting it right about every other time. I could be wrong--the information comes in little pieces, and it's difficult to put together.

By the way, three years ago, Edge was writing a book. Stewie Griffin wanted me to ask him how he's coming along with that, but I told Stewie if he wanted to bug Edge, he could get his own account and ask him.
Stewie-Jelly-Family-Guy.jpg


So how's your book? You know, you know that book you're working on? Going gooooood? Is it? Coming along just fine? Yeah, I'm sure it is. Can't wait to read it.
 
Bwaaaah! This is hilarious! Like when other scamster talk about quatuum effects. It's clear that you have no idea what you're talking about, and saw 'double blind' studies and decided that 'triple' was better than 'double'. But the problem is, this isn't a children's forum, so the other people here actually know what a double blind study is, and that you're just talking out your ass.
Well, Edge is a big UFO (extraterrestrial visitors) believer too. Maybe a flying saucer will pick him up and give him an anal probe which will clear the way to let him tell the whole story.
 
L.M.A.O.
You guys talk a lot of sheiot, anal probes.
Tricky knows all about those!
Fart master.

The weather still sucks and we have to wait.
All of us have had phenomena, and it's lasted for weeks, however we are all on the road to recovery.

My book is more like my diary, it's on a hard drive that is in a box, because of the original computer frying through an electrical surge or something that fried it.
This computer won't support it, and it's slowly melting.
I'm still marking time and waiting.

I haven't forgot about you but have nothing new at this time except that I may have found some one else that will look at the actual process of mining with multiple dredges and proving that dowsing works that way.

No money except for what I mine. But there will be documentation.


The idea is to put 2 of them on the money and 2 of them on little or nothing, and to prove it in several different places and move around to several spots in those places.

It's something I have already done for my friends.

I have been on the Skepchick site giving them a hard time to get their numbers up but they are touchy.


The # of containers was 7.
The next set will have ten, and I have to do 2 more tests first to see if I have a shot at the double blind test, if I do, I then need two more people to do the double blind test, I’ll let you know,
4 tests in all.
So close but yet so far away!
 
L.M.A.O.
You guys talk a lot of sheiot, anal probes.
Tricky knows all about those!
Fart master.
That's not a probe I use for creative farting. It is a tuning fork.

The weather still sucks and we have to wait.
All of us have had phenomena, and it's lasted for weeks, however we are all on the road to recovery.
Sorry you were under the weather. Pneumonia is bad stuff (I'm assuming that's what you meant). Take care of yourself.

My book is more like my diary, it's on a hard drive that is in a box, because of the original computer frying through an electrical surge or something that fried it.
This computer won't support it, and it's slowly melting.
I'm still marking time and waiting.
That was your only copy? Jeez, Edge, put it on a disk and make copies.

I haven't forgot about you but have nothing new at this time except that I may have found some one else that will look at the actual process of mining with multiple dredges and proving that dowsing works that way.

No money except for what I mine. But there will be documentation.
If you're still thinking that you can use your field results, I can tell you right now that JREF is not going to accept those. It has to be a trial where you absolutely 100% know where the gold is, in other words, a target of gold that is placed there by one of the people participating in the double blind test.

There are many people here who have offered to tell you how to set up such a test.

The idea is to put 2 of them on the money and 2 of them on little or nothing, and to prove it in several different places and move around to several spots in those places.
Still no good. If you select the locations that are "on the money", then it is not a double blind test. Although your dowsing doesn't work, I feel certain that your mining experience will help you identify which places are better than others. Besides, assuming they believe you, who do you know with dredges that is going to agree to put them on places where there is no gold? That's a lot of work.

I have been on the Skepchick site giving them a hard time to get their numbers up but they are touchy.
What? With your charm and charisma?

The # of containers was 7.
The next set will have ten, and I have to do 2 more tests first to see if I have a shot at the double blind test, if I do, I then need two more people to do the double blind test, I’ll let you know,
4 tests in all.
You don't have to have ten containers. You can have as few as two, so long as you do enough tests to make the outcomes statistically significant. The fewer containers you have, the more tests you have to perform. That's why we suggest using ten or more. If you get three successes in ten tests using ten targets, that's significant, presuming the test was set up correctly.
So close but yet so far away!
You're half right.
 
If the Chinese didn't come here and dowse for the best gold easiest accessible areas, I probably would be rich, not to mention that the big dredge came through here and lets not forget the western prospectors, We still find what they didn't but there is less,. More washes in but it is a slow process, The price has changed from $10.00 an once to what is it today $445.50,they were getting rich at those prices. Those old timers were pulling pounds.
:g1:


Uhh, you DO realize that that $10 then was almost EXACTLY equal to 4 some dollars today. you know, with inflation and all. if they were "pulling pounds", they'd be making the equivalent of something like 7-8 thousand modern dollars a pound

anyone have any historical record of rich, chinese dowsers in the 1800s?
 
The containers have to be elevated, here's the thing.

....The only difference is the place, the containers, and elevated targets, nothing that should alarm JREF.

As far as I know it’s never been tested elevated, should be interesting.

What I want is 9 out of 10, or ten for ten then there will be no controversy.
Just refound this thread, so to toss my 2c worth in.

Edge, dowsing HAS been tested where the dowser has been elevated above the targets. I would suggest that a simpler protocol that the one described in the link would certainly NOT "alarm JREF". You can elevate the targets on the ground floor if you don't feel there is enough separation from whatever you think is affecting them.

I would hazard, that if you applied for the Challenge using a protocol similar to that in the link, in a building of your choosing, your submission would be accepted immediately.
 
I believe Edge is proposing to elevate the targets above the dowser, not vice-versa.

But a protocol should be fairly easy to work up:

1. In a location that the experimenter and the testers agree is satisfactory, five lines will be strung at a height of X feet off the ground. The lines shall be at least Y feet apart. Each line shall be a minimum of Z feet long.

2. On each line, separated by a distance no less than (minimum number) feet, two plastic coffee containers will be suspended by means of cords, for a total of ten containers.

3. Out of sight of the claimant and the JREF observer, two experimenters will determine by a random selection (coin tosses, for example) which container will hold the target. The target will be placed in this container. An inert weight (inert in that the claimant agrees it will not attract his dowsing rod) equal to the weight of the target will be placed in each of the remaining nine containers.

4. The two experimenters shall note which container has the actual target. They shall leave the area and signal, by means of a bell or buzzer, that the target is ready for testing.

5. Observed by the JREF representative, the claimant shall then use his dowsing rod, without touching any of the containers, to determine which container has the target in it.

6. The test shall be repeated ten times, with the target replaced by the same procedure after each attempt. Success shall be defined as locating the target six or more times out of the ten attempts.

Wouldn't that work as a protocol?
 
"...where an old man told him to deepen his shaft more 90m to find the "master lode"."

humor.gif
 
Last edited:
I believe Edge is proposing to elevate the targets above the dowser, not vice-versa.

But a protocol should be fairly easy to work up:

1. In a location that the experimenter and the testers agree is satisfactory, five lines will be strung at a height of X feet off the ground. The lines shall be at least Y feet apart. Each line shall be a minimum of Z feet long.

2. On each line, separated by a distance no less than (minimum number) feet, two plastic coffee containers will be suspended by means of cords, for a total of ten containers.

3. Out of sight of the claimant and the JREF observer, two experimenters will determine by a random selection (coin tosses, for example) which container will hold the target. The target will be placed in this container. An inert weight (inert in that the claimant agrees it will not attract his dowsing rod) equal to the weight of the target will be placed in each of the remaining nine containers.

4. The two experimenters shall note which container has the actual target. They shall leave the area and signal, by means of a bell or buzzer, that the target is ready for testing.

5. Observed by the JREF representative, the claimant shall then use his dowsing rod, without touching any of the containers, to determine which container has the target in it.

6. The test shall be repeated ten times, with the target replaced by the same procedure after each attempt. Success shall be defined as locating the target six or more times out of the ten attempts.

Wouldn't that work as a protocol?
My error Spektator - I was edRicing Edge's post from the 5th Nov where he was still "dowsing" containers sitting at his feet:

"I need a thirty- x- thirty area to do the test in.
So I'm going to see, and test in a place inside that will have the room and where the floor is at about a 4 foot elevation that also makes a difference in pulls from below the targets.
In other words for the target to be more noticeable than what is in the ground still."

I think that his idea to hang the samples is to fraught with variables, air movement, hitting the samples with his body or the stick etc etc.

FInding a 2 storey barn, one with the ground floor sufficiently above ground level (or just a couple of boxes) should do the job of what he was talking about above. The other alternative would be to suspend the samples from the ceiling of the ground floor and then dowse from above on the 1st floor.

My link was to show Edge that an indoor environment, one where he can separate the samples from the "influence" of the ground, a. can be done and b. *has* been done.

I just thought his lastest diversion of suspending the samples was to separate the samples from "background influence" and unthought the other diversion of his new claim on being able to move the suspended sample / dowsing rod ...
 
Each post Edge makes convinces me more and more that he is indeed stalling, and it could be for one of several reasons...

1. He's subconciously come to realise, after many months of making no living by dowsing for gold and from seeing all dowsers everywhere fail double blind tests, that dowsing doesn't actually work. We should not be blind to the fact that his subconcious may be way smarter than he is.

2. He's conciously come to realise that dowsing doesn't work for reasons already stated above, and is now trying to think of a way to cheat or save face, hence the stalling for preperation and planning.

3. He genuinely believes, in the face of all science, evidence and good sense, that dowsing works, and he's going to spend years trying to make a small piece of ground conform to how his stick with a coin on the end says it should be. This option involves a lot of work, expense and stalling.

:)
 
Hrm!

Sky cleared, freshly-washed sun gilded the tips of the trees. A deer peered out from the brush. After much promises of results, the woo'ing one has slunk back to his lair, and the peace was restored to the land.

But, really.

Philosophical question to Tricky: How can you stand to reason with someone who will not, for the life of him, answer direct questions with anything other than incomprehensible/confusing ramble, as well as refuse to admit that the numbers (of his own tests) are against him?
 
Sky cleared, freshly-washed sun gilded the tips of the trees. A deer peered out from the brush. After much promises of results, the woo'ing one has slunk back to his lair, and the peace was restored to the land.

But, really.

Philosophical question to Tricky: How can you stand to reason with someone who will not, for the life of him, answer direct questions with anything other than incomprehensible/confusing ramble, as well as refuse to admit that the numbers (of his own tests) are against him?
Call me a hopeless optimist. And in truth, Edge has moved his positions subtly. It isn't a quick process, but he has gradually "edged" closer to reality, admitting that his earlier protocols were not working, learning that his descriptions of what were happening were self-contradictory and even skirting around the possibility that he might be wrong. But its not just for him. Its for all who are watching (and I haven't seen you here before, so welcome.)

But the truth is, Edge is actually a nice guy overall, and I truly wish him the best. I don't want him to throw his life away on this hopeless pursuit. I'd like to think that the things that I and other skeptics saky to him make him reconsider. I could be wrong. They may make his resistance to reality even stronger, but I hope not.

So I will talk to Edge any time he comes here. I never ask any "believer" to leave this site. Reading the posts here is the best thing they could possibly do for themselves.

Nice poetic images in your first paragraph, by the way. I'm a big fan of poetry and all forms of creative writing.
 
Tricky: Mayhaps hard-core optimism is hereditary? While I see your points, I can't help but think that some individuals dig their own holes. As long as other people don't fall into those holes, it's allright to declare them hopeless and wander off to pursue some better things. (This, coming from a self-declared pessimist.)

Reading the JREF forums or doing a little 'serious' research would be good. It'd be curious to see how many "believers" actually come here and read the forums in-depth, though.

Creative writing is a long way of saying little. ;)
 
Tricky: Mayhaps hard-core optimism is hereditary? While I see your points, I can't help but think that some individuals dig their own holes. As long as other people don't fall into those holes, it's allright to declare them hopeless and wander off to pursue some better things. (This, coming from a self-declared pessimist.)
You may be right. Perhaps I do it because I get some kind of thrill out of torturing helpless creatures (I did fry ants with a magnifying glass when I was a kid.) Maybe I'm only fooling myself that it is serving some sort of noble purpose. Oh well.

And BTW, cynic sounds better than pessimist, but you get to do the same things. ;)

Reading the JREF forums or doing a little 'serious' research would be good. It'd be curious to see how many "believers" actually come here and read the forums in-depth, though.
Heck, nobody reads them all. There's too many. Even those of us without a life can't read everything (I stay away from the "gossip" threads, but I love the flame wars). But a few of the "believers" do look at lots of threads, even if they're not really reading them with understanding. We have a couple who can't keep from commenting on almost every thread in some forums.

Creative writing is a long way of saying little. ;)
Getting there is half the fun, and good writing will cover a multitude of sins.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom