Sean Hannity makes the case for NSA under Bush...

Please cite a source dating from the Bush era where it was revealed the NSA was collecting the metadata for every phone call made in the USA.
I'd be happy to if I made that claim. But I didn't. In fact, my post asserted the we (the public) don't know very much about the details of NSA activities. IOW, I asserted we don't have enough (any?) information to judge decades old NSA activities in contrast to present day efforts. Do I need a cite to back up my claim that the NSA operates in secrecy?
 
I've no idea what the hell this is. Next time you might want to provide a pull quote and a little less attitude. You've yet to provide a source for your claims and I'm guessing all I'm going to get are dead links, right?
It's an article that shows that the NSA is currently collecting metadata from every single call made in the USA, domestic and international. I didn't quote from it because I assume the OP has at least minimal understanding of the subject they're starting a thread about. This has been all over the news and this forum lately, do I have to cite sources every time I mention that the NSA is currently collecting the metadata from every phone call made in the USA?

He didn't make that claim. He said we knew damn little then and we know damn little now.
We know more now than we did before. And that little bit more we do know now is extremely significant.

Look, it's simple WC, it's YOUR claim that has not been sourced.
I did source my claim, you're just choosing to remain ignorant by not reading the link or bothering to educate yourself on the very subject you started a thread about.

The fact is that public knowledge about the scope of NSA information gathering has gone from "only international communications" in the Bush era to "every call and email" today. That's not my opinion, it's a fact.
 
We know more now than we did before. And that little bit more we do know now is extremely significant.

It's only "extremely significant" to those who want to excuse Bush and blame the black guy. To those of us who were against this the entire time, this knowledge is next to nothing. The claim by the Bush admin that this activity would be restricted to "international calls" and "terrorists" was rejected and looked at with skepticism by everyone who wasn't a Bush apologist. This conservative grasping for any reason to excuse Bush and blame Obama is simply a way for them to claim some credibility they never had.
 
It's only "extremely significant" to those who want to excuse Bush and blame the black guy.
I already cited what was known about this in the Bush era. Compare/contrast to what we know now, and honestly say nothing has changed. And immediately playing the race card is a dead giveaway that you don't have an actual argument.


To those of us who were against this the entire time, this knowledge is next to nothing. The claim by the Bush admin that this activity would be restricted to "international calls" and "terrorists" was rejected and looked at with skepticism by everyone who wasn't a Bush apologist.
Oh look, 20/20 hindsight. Will you next claim you predicted the score of last year's Super Bowl?

This conservative grasping for any reason to excuse Bush and blame Obama is simply a way for them to claim some credibility they never had.
Sorry, we know far more about the scope of NSA data collecting now. And there's precious few people here who were up in arms about Bush's NSA who are equally upset about the now known scope of NSA data collection under Obama.

There's certainly hypocrisy here, just not by who you claim.
 
To say that Hannity will criticize something under
President Obama that he justified under president Bush is like saying the sun will come up tomorrow.
But in my opinion what we thought the program was then is much has developed into something that appears more intrusive now.
 
It's only "extremely significant" to those who want to excuse Bush and blame the black guy. To those of us who were against this the entire time, this knowledge is next to nothing. The claim by the Bush admin that this activity would be restricted to "international calls" and "terrorists" was rejected and looked at with skepticism by everyone who wasn't a Bush apologist. This conservative grasping for any reason to excuse Bush and blame Obama is simply a way for them to claim some credibility they never had.

None of what you say above about excusing Bush has happened in this thread.
 
It's an article that shows that the NSA is currently collecting metadata from every single call made in the USA, domestic and international. I didn't quote from it because I assume the OP has at least minimal understanding of the subject they're starting a thread about. This has been all over the news and this forum lately, do I have to cite sources every time I mention that the NSA is currently collecting the metadata from every phone call made in the USA?
This is rhetoric. It's browbeating.

We know more now than we did before. And that little bit more we do know now is extremely significant.
Rhetoric.


I did source my claim....
No you didn't.

The fact is that public knowledge about the scope of NSA information gathering has gone from "only international communications" in the Bush era to "every call and email" today. That's not my opinion, it's a fact.
Argument by assertion. [citation missing]
 
I already cited what was known about this in the Bush era.
Source?

Look, you are claiming things have changed with the NSA (they look at every phone call instead of just calls from war zones) from when Bush was in office. Can you demonstrate that? Yes or no?
 
Last edited:
It's an article that shows that the NSA is currently collecting metadata from every single call made in the USA, domestic and international.

Currently? NSA has been doing that for years.

The fact is that public knowledge about the scope of NSA information gathering has gone from "only international communications" in the Bush era to "every call and email" today. That's not my opinion, it's a fact.
Not quite. The collection of domestic communications was certainly public knowledge during the Bush era.

https://www.eff.org/nsa-spying
http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/news/2006/04/70619
http://www.pbs.org/now/shows/307/spy-scandal.html
http://www.privacysos.org/technologies_of_control/naurus
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A

James Bamford has been writing about the NSA for years. My copy of Body of Secrets is from April 2002. The Shadow Factory was published in 2008, and The Puzzle Palace was published way back in 1982.

He's also written a couple of interesting articles regarding the NSA:

http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2013/06/general-keith-alexander-cyberwar/all/
http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2012/03/ff_nsadatacenter/

Some of us don't find this this latest whistleblowing all that surprising.

RayG
 
To say that Hannity will criticize something under
President Obama that he justified under president Bush is like saying the sun will come up tomorrow.
But in my opinion what we thought the program was then is much has developed into something that appears more intrusive now.

Maybe it's iust me, but none of these revelations were really susprising. I fully expected the NSA to be doing stuff like this - and probably more we don't know about.
 
The Hannity apologists are well represented here, 100% as one would predict.
Against Hannity - His own words
Defending Hannity - nothing, no evidence, just dodge, weave and dance.
Well done skeptics.
 
Source?

Look, you are claiming things have changed with the NSA (they look at every phone call instead of just calls from war zones) from when Bush was in office. Can you demonstrate that? Yes or no?

No he isn't. He is claiming that public knowledge and understanding of the NSA has changed. Do you honestly not get the difference?
 
What an odd concept. It is a classic tu quoque ad hominem attack. It is an appeal to hypocrisy, hell it is right in your post.

No it isn't. Do you also not know what ad hominem means?

It is suggested that his criticism of the present program is not valid because he took an inconsistent position when bush was president.

No it isn't. It is directly stated that he is a hypocrite because of these conflicting views which he has not reconciled by doing the easy thing and saying he was wrong before.

It is of course not a direct defense of the act, because it is simply a fallacious attack on a critic, which is very much why it is a fallacy in the first place!

It isn't fallacious at all as long as one doesn't do, as you have, and create straw men. The claim is not that Hannity is wrong to criticize the NSA program because the NSA program is fine and dandy.
 
Maybe it's iust me, but none of these revelations were really susprising. I fully expected the NSA to be doing stuff like this - and probably more we don't know about.

It's not just you. I don't approve of what the NSA is doing, but I objected and was upset long ago. The new stuff just doesn't phase me that much. Suddenly because I'm not outraged right now I'm an 'Obama apologist' and partisan. I've already done my criticizing.
 
Odd concept that we are not supposed to point out moral inconsistency and political expediency. But I'm curious, are we supposed to agree with Hannity under Bush or Hannity under Obama?
 
It's only "extremely significant" to those who want to excuse Bush and blame the black guy.

True, our resident cons are a hypocritical lot. I'm not sure they're little bitches in the Hannity mold though.

Yes, Hannity's partisanship would go just fine with a guy who is so partisan that he thinks any criticism of Obama is due to racism.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom