science fraud is common place

Hasn't justintime noticed that all the science in the world amounts to 100% of science in the world?

None of his arguments grasp the notion of percentage as a fraction of a whole, such that over-unity is meaningless.

He has quoted elementary discussions that set up percentage as just another way to express a ratio, but he ignores the part of the same discussion that forbids what he's trying to do.

Reading between the lines of his various posts, I gather that he simply thinks the higher the number, the more dastardly science is -- apparently on some open-ended scale. Qualitatively we see that his definition fraud is all-encompassing, including even innocent errors. Quantitatively we see him reaching for the highest possible misconduct rates regardless of the reliability of the source, and for any random multiplier he can lay his hands on. All this points to a deliberate padding of the values.

But obviously none of that trumps the sheer idiocy of vastly over-unity answers. We throw around the word "innumeracy" enough in this thread. But I don't know if that adequately captures the notion of an argument so bereft of numerical legitimacy as to make it simply a number salad.
 
According to Betrayers of the Truth [William Broad, Nicholas Wade] for every fraud a 100 go undetected.

Can you show that this number is real, and not imagined ?

for every 1 scientists a 100 goes undetected.

No, that doesn't follow. A scientist who commits fraud is more likely to be a repeat offender. So your x100 factor on PAPERS might mean a x40 factor on actual scientists (those are examples.)

If 2% of scientists are admitting to fraud. It means 2 out of every hundred are admitting to fraud.

Wow. You've actually managed to get that one right.

Now if 2 out of every hundred are committing fraud then 2 x 100 = 200

200 as a percent is 200/100 x 100 = 200%

Yes, and that little arithmetic should signal to you that the x100 factor is impossible, since you cannot have more fraudulent people than you have people.
 
According to Betrayers...

Asked and answered several times. That factor is admitted speculation.

200 as a percent is 200/100 x 100 = 200%

Asked and answered several times. Over-unity answers to this question are statistically impossible.

method 2 x 100 = 200 now convert to percent 200 /100 x 100 = 200%. Answer 200%
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9779741&postcount=1244

No, your mistake has been explained ad nauseam. Do not simply repeat it.
 
Hasn't justintime noticed that all the science in the world amounts to 100% of science in the world?


It isn't the first time he's had problems with percentages. He thinks Earth having been visited by extraterrestrial spaceships is more likely than the existence of extraterrestrial intelligence:
There are more sightings of UFOs and ancient records of alien visitations than there are of extraterrestrial intelligent life. That fact alone would favor the former over the latter.
 
According to Betrayers of the Truth [William Broad, Nicholas Wade] for every fraud a 100 go undetected. Taken in that context.
for every 1 scientists a 100 goes undetected.

Ninja scientists? OMFG, there may be hundred of undetectable scientists sneaking around in your home, right now! Panic!
 
justintime said:
Now if 2 out of every hundred are committing fraud then 2 x 100 = 200
I've been afraid that someone would accuse me of misrepresenting justintime's arguments when I say he thinks 2 out of every 1 paper are fraudulant. However, here he is saying exactly that--2 out of ever 1 scientists is a fraud in justintimeland. The mind absolutely boggles.
 
According to Betrayers of the Truth [William Broad, Nicholas Wade] for every fraud a 100 go undetected. Taken in that context.
for every 1 scientists a 100 goes undetected.

If 2% of scientists are admitting to fraud. It means 2 out of every hundred are admitting to fraud.

Now if 2 out of every hundred are committing fraud then 2 x 100 = 200

200 as a percent is 200/100 x 100 = 200%

This was explained in my post#1244 and the method applied to arrive at the percentages.

Here is how percent works as well.

There are 100 scientists doing a test.
If 1 scientist cheats what percent of scientists are cheats? Answer 1%

method 1/100 x 100 = 1%

Now if 2 scientists cheat what percent of scientists are cheats? Answer 2%

method 2/100 x 100 = 2%

But for every 1 scientist who got caught for cheating a 100 more were cheating. What percent of scientists are cheaters if 2 were caught?

method 2 x 100 = 200 now convert to percent 200 /100 x 100 = 200%. Answer 200%
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9779741&postcount=1244[/

Trust me on this, if I'm telling you your maths is wrong then you are in serious trouble! Your own explanation started with exactly 100 scientists doing a test. You then flip-flopped suddenly into hundreds more taking the test all of whom were cheating. Where did they come from?! You simply don't have the faintest idea what you are talking about.
 
Hasn't justintime noticed that all the science in the world amounts to 100% of science in the world?

There are purely abstract concepts in mathematics as well which many here may not be familiar with and as I have pointed out there are also percent greater than 100 which is also relatively new here.

What is also surprising is science fraud is common pace. But many here are not aware of it, if you have followed the debate.
 
justintime said:
There are purely abstract concepts in mathematics as well which many here may not be familiar with...
Typical evasion: "If you can't understand my math, you're obviously not as advanced as me!"

Unfortunately, this is pretty simple math. There's nothing abstract about "What percent of scientists engage in fraud?" 100% means that every scientist on Earth engages in fraud. 200% means that more scientists engage in fraud than exist, which is an impossibility.

Your math would get a failing grade in any fourth-grade classroom. And you have the audacity to demand we accept that we simply are too stupid to understand it!!!

...and as I have pointed out there are also percent greater than 100 which is also relatively new here.
No, pretty much everyone is familiar with percentages higher than 100%. They are possible in certain conditions--for example, if contamination concentrations double in a year it's justifiable to say "Contamination concentrations are 200% higher than those encountered twelve months ago." What's not possible is having 2 out of every 1 scientists be a fraud.

What is also surprising is science fraud is common pace.
Well, the idea that 0.005% can be considered common place certainly has raised a few eyebrows.

But many here are not aware of it, if you have followed the debate.
Anyone following the debate will see only your increasingly transparent attempts to hide from the fact that your position is untennible.
 
There are purely abstract concepts in mathematics as well which many here may not be familiar with...

No, do not simply bluff and accuse your critics of being ignorant. This is not "abstract" or higher mathematics. Instead it is simple fractions, what everyone learns in elementary school.

...and as I have pointed out there are also percent greater than 100 which is also relatively new here.

Asked and answered twice previously. The source you cite actually refutes your use of percentages in this way as an impossible excess of the whole.

What is also surprising is science fraud is common pace.

Repeating your belief several times a day does not prove it nor make it any more true.

But many here are not aware of it, if you have followed the debate.

You are unable to prove fraud occurs in science at any appreciable rate. Accusing your critics of being somehow blind to the truth is not a valid rejoinder, nor is it a credible one when they have given you dozens of rational reasons not to believe your claims. You have generally ignored every single response, so it is not a very wise course of action to accuse your critics of closed-mindedness.
 
What is also surprising is science fraud is common pace. But many here are not aware of it, if you have followed the debate.

Anyone following the debate here can see that your math is horrible. The true number is 0.005%, based on your own numbers, though in reality I expect it to be higher than this.
 
No, do not simply bluff and accuse your critics of being ignorant. This is not "abstract" or higher mathematics. Instead it is simple fractions, what everyone learns in elementary school.

Dunning-Kruger at its absolute fullest, n'est-ce pas ?

But of course we know Justin knows this.
 
justintime said:
There are 100 scientists doing a test.
If 1 scientist cheats what percent of scientists are cheats? Answer 1%

method 1/100 x 100 = 1%

Now if 2 scientists cheat what percent of scientists are cheats? Answer 2%

method 2/100 x 100 = 2%

But for every 1 scientist who got caught for cheating a 100 more were cheating. What percent of scientists are cheaters if 2 were caught?

method 2 x 100 = 200 now convert to percent 200 /100 x 100 = 200%. Answer 200%
100 scientists are taking a test. 200 scientists are cheating on the test. This is because each of the scientists taking the test is calling a SECOND scientist who is NOT at the test and getting help from him/her. They need help because they have never seen math as bad as justintime's on any other exam or anywhere else.
 
According to Betrayers of the Truth [William Broad, Nicholas Wade] for every fraud a 100 go undetected. Taken in that context.
for every 1 scientists a 100 goes undetected.

If 2% of scientists are admitting to fraud. It means 2 out of every hundred are admitting to fraud.

Now if 2 out of every hundred are committing fraud then 2 x 100 = 200

200 as a percent is 200/100 x 100 = 200%

This was explained in my post#1244 and the method applied to arrive at the percentages.

Here is how percent works as well.

There are 100 scientists doing a test.
If 1 scientist cheats what percent of scientists are cheats? Answer 1%

method 1/100 x 100 = 1%

Now if 2 scientists cheat what percent of scientists are cheats? Answer 2%

method 2/100 x 100 = 2%

But for every 1 scientist who got caught for cheating a 100 more were cheating. What percent of scientists are cheaters if 2 were caught?

method 2 x 100 = 200 now convert to percent 200 /100 x 100 = 200%. Answer 200%
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9779741&postcount=1244
No, you're multiplying when you ought to be dividing.

2% = 2 per centum = 2 per hundred = 2 out of every hundred = 2/100

Now if you multiply that fraction by 100:
2/100 x 100 = 2/100 x 100 [the denominator and multiplier cancel each other out] = 2

Seriously, I learned this in elementary school.
 
now the point has been proved that scientific fraud is no where near as prevalent as the op stated and certainly not on the scale indicated, next topic please.
 
The survey of scientists were not based on a group of scientists from a particular community or location or institution
You are mistaken, justintime.
There is no "the survey of scientists": How Many Scientists Fabricate and Falsify Research? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Survey Data
(my emphasis added)
Each survey is basically "based on a group of scientists from a particular community or location or institution".

None of the surveys were a sample of all scientists. This makes any extension from the sub-populations of scientists (seems to be biomedical and one economic) to the population of all scientists invalid. This is a big issue with the paper - the authors do not emphasize this and keep on about scientists in general rather than the scientists in the sampled populations.

The samples do not include scientists in physics where there is a high degree of replication and refinement of experimental results. Experimental physicists really like to take old experiments and get more accurate results :eek:.
Thus there is an implication that the numbers in the meta-analysis are too high.

The rest of the post repeats your previous mistakes:
* private misconduct is not scientific fraud!
* math (or reality) errors: 100 scientists take a test and you state that 200 of them cheat!
 
Last edited:
another fundamental mistake (or is it a bait and switch...) is treating the set of scientists who admit to fraud as a subset of the set of withdrawn scientific papers that have been withdrawn due to fraud.

You don't have to be a rocket surgeon to see the problem here - the sets are comprised of different objects.
 
No, you're multiplying when you ought to be dividing.

2% = 2 per centum = 2 per hundred = 2 out of every hundred = 2/100

Now if you multiply that fraction by 100:
2/100 x 100 = 2/100 x 100 [the denominator and multiplier cancel each other out] = 2

Seriously, I learned this in elementary school.

Seriously that is all you retained.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom