Fundamentalist Christianity.
+1
Which is to say, Justintime's arguments most closely resemble those promoted by American Fundamentalist Chrisitianity to support Creationism. I say "most closely" because not all Fundamentalists embrace the natural-foods and natural-medicine movements, which have also appeared here.
American Fundamentalism is staunchly in the literal Creationist camp. This means that sciences such as astrophysics, paleontology, and evolutionary biology produce findings that substantially contradict that belief. Since this branch of religion is also considerably literalist in other ways, revising doctrine to account for scientific observation is generally not an option
[1].
It becomes vital to the survival of the doctrine, and therefore of the church, to show that the scientific findings are wrong. In a very few cases, this necessity takes the form of scientific counter-inquiry. Or more accurately, pseudo-scientific counter-inquiry, since it bears only cursory resemblance to legitimate science. More often the effort takes the form of
ad hominem attacks on science and scientists themselves.
Scientists are portrayed as unscrupulous and dishonest, suggesting that their findings should be dismissed. Science is portrayed as "destroying" religious faith, employing violent language and imagery to amplify the perception of animus toward religion. Since religious faith is a greatly-admired thing of beauty in Fundamentalism, it is easy to spin the work of science as something intent on destroying beauty. Similarly, since great reverence is given for the word of God, anything that "flagrantly" contradicts it can have quite a lot of emotional baggage pinned to it.
The more outspoken Fundamentalists
literally believe scientists are the minions of Satan, put on the Earth to destroy faith and lead astray the children of God into temptation and damnation. The zeal with which this is taught is evident to anyone who spends much time in the American South or Midwest.
Conversely, the natural-foods and natural-medicines movements have more complex motivations. There is certainly a Neo-Luddite influence, the abstract belief that natural methods are safer, more effective, and morally preferred
[2]. There is also a great overlap with radical environmentalism.
But most salient, in my opinion, is the simple economic influence. On the one side there is considerable resentment over the profits and success of businesses and individuals who offer mainstream methods and products, often on a large scale. These are generally named Big ______, where you fill in the blank with Pharma, Oil, or whatever suits your personal disapprobation. There is the notion that profits in those industries are ill-got, and that scientists are a facilitating arm of that enterprise.
On the other side there is a simple desire to advance one's own commerce. This is not necessary badly motivated; one may truly believe that his product is superior according to various criteria. I garden, and I enjoy the product of my labors. In my mind it tastes better, but I have no desire to test that objectively. Yes, were I to advertise to others that it's better and ask them to believe it, I'd want more objective tests and proof. But it's very easy to see why some of the promoters of natural healing and natural foods are excited about what they do.
But of course those aren't the bad eggs (pun intended). In the rush to promote one's product or service, it's easy (and commonplace) among natural-methods promoters to place greater emphasis on the moral rectitude of the service than on its effectiveness, safety, or objective quality. You buy "organic" food, for example, in part because it's the "right" thing to do, not just because you think it's better quality. And this leads one to characterize traditional and/or scientific methods as the "wrong" thing to do.
Natural healers, for example, denigrate mainstream medicine on the grounds that what they do is intuitive and granted to them by nature, whereas medical scientists have no such inherent talent and must rely on "crude" methods. This goes further to say that mainstream doctors know their methods are ineffective and unsafe, but conspire to hide this from the public in order to protect their commerce. This also provides ammunition when natural healers are prosecuted for practicing medicine without a license, or other such crimes -- they can credibly argue that the Establishment is inappropriately squelching the competition.
Natural foods/"supplements" advocates do similar things, for similar reasons and by similar tactics. The game is still that one's inability to compete in the market based on merit is converted to treating the marketplace as an ideological battleground where mainstream drug-makers are nefarious schemers bent on hooking the public on their products, etc. Here as well, scientists are considered the pawns and facilitators of these corporate shenanigans.
So while it's readily apparent that the real argument here is just the vilification of science, I think it's a little premature to lay that at the feet of just one instigating line of thought.
------------
[1] Biblical literalism is predicated on the assertion that the Bible is read literally, with no interpretation imposed or implied. Of course to read is necessary also to interpret, but Biblical literalism denies that this takes place. Consequently it is difficult to change doctrines exacted from a "literal" reading of the scripture. To do so would admit that a different meaning is possible, which then presupposes that interpretation occurs while reading the Bible.
[2] Not necessary a religious sense of morality, however. While there seems to be a connection between natural-methods advocacy and New Age religion, I have yet to see any doctrinal crossover or causation.