science fraud is common place

another fundamental mistake (or is it a bait and switch...) is treating the set of scientists who admit to fraud as a subset of the set of withdrawn scientific papers that have been withdrawn due to fraud.

You don't have to be a rocket surgeon to see the problem here - the sets are comprised of different objects.

Justin isn't a rocket surgeon.
 
Seriously that is all you retained.

There's nothing in your posts to retain, Justin. Only things to correct and/or mock.

You still haven't answered my question: how can you have 200% of a pie; or if you prefer, how can you have more of X than you have of X ? You do realise that this is what 200% means, right ?
 
According to Betrayers of the Truth [William Broad, Nicholas Wade] for every fraud a 100 go undetected. Taken in that context.
for every 1 scientists a 100 goes undetected.

If 2% of scientists are admitting to fraud. It means 2 out of every hundred are admitting to fraud.

Now if 2 out of every hundred are committing fraud then 2 x 100 = 200

200 as a percent is 200/100 x 100 = 200%

You're still doing your addition wrong. If "for every fraud a 100 go undetected," then that would mean that there would be 101 (100 + 1) instances of fraud.

Now, that would mean, using your "math" for the "2% of scientists" it would be 202%, not 200. (200 + 2)/100 x 100 = 202% You keep on forgetting about the original person(s) that was caught.

Now, granted, your "math" and thesis is wrong in so many other areas, but I figured I would pick some nits.
 
This has to be the single most ignorant thing I have ever read.

...until you read the rest of this thread.

The anti-science argument here is wallowed in innumeracy. Leave aside the animus and moralism, which are arguably against JREF rules. The sheer volume of statistical facepalming boggles the mind.
 
justintime: 100 scientists take a test, how many of them cheat to get 200% cheating

You still haven't answered my question: how can you have 200% of a pie;...
It may be better to use his own example of scientists taking a test and X of them cheating since (presumably :D) justintime can understand what he writes.

If 100 scientists take a test, how many of them cheat to get 200% of the 100 scientists cheating, justintime?
 
Last edited:
According to Betrayers of the Truth [William Broad, Nicholas Wade] for every fraud a 100 go undetected. Taken in that context.
for every 1 scientists a 100 goes undetected.

If 2% of scientists are admitting to fraud. It means 2 out of every hundred are admitting to fraud.

Now if 2 out of every hundred are committing fraud then 2 x 100 = 200

200 as a percent is 200/100 x 100 = 200%

This was explained in my post#1244 and the method applied to arrive at the percentages.

Here is how percent works as well.

There are 100 scientists doing a test.
If 1 scientist cheats what percent of scientists are cheats? Answer 1%

method 1/100 x 100 = 1%

Now if 2 scientists cheat what percent of scientists are cheats? Answer 2%

method 2/100 x 100 = 2%

But for every 1 scientist who got caught for cheating a 100 more were cheating. What percent of scientists are cheaters if 2 were caught?

method 2 x 100 = 200 now convert to percent 200 /100 x 100 = 200%. Answer 200%
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9779741&postcount=1244

That is innumeracy and your reply gives a convincing impression of profound ignorance of simple arithmetic.
 
There's nothing in your posts to retain, Justin. Only things to correct and/or mock.

You still haven't answered my question: how can you have 200% of a pie; or if you prefer, how can you have more of X than you have of X ? You do realise that this is what 200% means, right ?

Well, haven't you seen The Fly? Just add an iteration...
 
No, you're multiplying when you ought to be dividing.

2% = 2 per centum = 2 per hundred = 2 out of every hundred = 2/100

Now if you multiply that fraction by 100:
2/100 x 100 = 2/100 x 100 [the denominator and multiplier cancel each other out] = 2

Seriously, I learned this in elementary school.

Seriously that is all you retained.
Oooh, an "I know you are, but what am I?" rebuttal. It's gettin' serious down in here, folks. :rolleyes:
 
Justintime has exceeded "not even wrong" -- in fact, I think he's gone past "fractal wrongness."

Probably gone to plaid...



edit: typo
 
There are purely abstract concepts in mathematics as well which many here may not be familiar with and as I have pointed out there are also percent greater than 100 which is also relatively new here.

What is also surprising is science fraud is common pace. But many here are not aware of it, if you have followed the debate.

How fast is a common pace? Mine is about six miles an hour.
 
Come on, Justin. Tell me what 200% of a pie would look like ?

That is pretty standard with pizzas. It is called a 2 for 1 deal.
OMG! 200% of science is fraudulent! Those are scientists who paid their way through college working in pizza take-outs and took the concept with them and sold it to the public without the pizzas.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom