science fraud is common place

The new study raises that number to 28%.

" Only 2% of respondents admitted falsifying or fabricating data, but 28% of respondents claimed to know of colleagues who engaged in questionable research practices."

Note that I bolded the word one in that sentence. If the scientists in that survey, on average, knew only 10 other scientists, than the number would be 2.8% of scientists who were frauds. That is why the survey is meaningless if you want the know the actual number of scientists who are frauds; you would need to know how many other scientists the scientists who were questioned knew.
 
I have not changed or relaxed my definition of fraud.

I point out that your definition of "fraud" includes such things as honest mistakes. Hence I conclude you are desperately trying to pad your definition.

Fraud is fraud

Trite, but pointless. "Fraud" in any other context requires a deliberate intent to deceive. You include other things in your definition, so in your argument fraud is not just fraud.

...and science fraud is increasing and becoming more common place.

Not by any fact or evidence you've been able to produce. For 30-odd pages you have simply waved your hands wildly claiming this, but provide no substantiation that withstands even cursory scrutiny -- it is chiefly in the form of voodoo arithmetic.

The reasons offered for this increase in science fraud it the flawed peer review process and the self correcting belief in science is a myth.

Asked and answered. You ignored my response to the popular media article you posted allegedly supporting this claim. Hence I conclude that you are unable or unwilling to rehabilitate it and we should consider it no further.
 
The new study raises that number to 28%.

Did you understand the point ? Let me state it again:

Let's say that you live on a street with 100 people. I poll those 100 people and 14% of them (14, in this case) tell me that they know someone called Justin on their street. By your logic, this means there are 14 people named Justin on the street. But that's wrong. In reality there is ONE person called Justin, you, and 14 people know you.

It's the same scenario with the scientists. 14% of them report knowing someone who MAY have been involved in fraud. It does not follow that another 14% of them are frauds, and it certainly doesn't follow even from that that 14% of all papers are frauds, because that would assume that all papers by all scientists who have ever commited fraud are fraudulent, which certainly makes no sense.
 
If you ask Dr Math on the Math Forum if you can have greater that 100 percent. He says:

This has been answered already:

You cannot eat 200% of a pie. Once you have eaten 100% of the pie, there is no pie left to eat.

Similarily, you cannot have more than 100% (all) of all papers published that are fraudulent.
 
I have not changed or relaxed my definition of fraud. Fraud is fraud and science fraud is increasing and becoming more common place.
The reasons offered for this increase in science fraud it the flawed peer review process and the self correcting belief in science is a myth.

AFAICT, you've never usefully defined it at all ("useful" in the sense of "as a basis for conversation with someone beside yourself"). "Fraud is fraud" is not definition, it's a childish tautology. It's also circular to say "this is fraud" and "fraud is this"; you need a metric outside of your need to frame something as fraud to identify it as something you haven't even defined yet.
 
AFAICT, you've never usefully defined it at all ("useful" in the sense of "as a basis for conversation with someone beside yourself"). "Fraud is fraud" is not definition, it's a childish tautology. It's also circular to say "this is fraud" and "fraud is this"; you need a metric outside of your need to frame something as fraud to identify it as something you haven't even defined yet.

Indeed "fraud is fraud" just begs the question. The subtext is, "Fraud is what I say it is."

As for a frame of reference, I asked him to compare the nature of alleged fraud in science with the nature of proven fraud in the natural-methods movement, which he cited and alluded to as an agreeable alternative. The answer was predictably evasive.

One of the more credible points in the Economist article discusses the improper use of statistics. I sympathize with it, and have a statistician on retainer to help me when I think I'm getting stuck. But it's ironic and amusing that Justintime's arguments revolve primarily around the misuse and misunderstanding of statistics.
 
Indeed "fraud is fraud" just begs the question. The subtext is, "Fraud is what I say it is."

As for a frame of reference, I asked him to compare the nature of alleged fraud in science with the nature of proven fraud in the natural-methods movement, which he cited and alluded to as an agreeable alternative. The answer was predictably evasive.

One of the more credible points in the Economist article discusses the improper use of statistics. I sympathize with it, and have a statistician on retainer to help me when I think I'm getting stuck. But it's ironic and amusing that Justintime's arguments revolve primarily around the misuse and misunderstanding of statistics.

It is possible scientists do not know what fraud is, so they may not be aware it is fraud they are committing when they are committing it. But it is not the obligation of society to educated scientists what constitutes criminal behavior. It is the responsibility of scientists to be informed.

But the fact science fraud is becoming so common among scientists suggests whatever its definition scientists are not averse to committing fraud. They would like the benefit of believing when they are committing fraud they are actually committing something less damaging like research. But when told it is their research that is fraudulent we find ourselves in this semantic battle. Furthermore is it research fraud or misuse and misunderstanding of statistics?
 
It is possible scientists do not know what fraud is...

It is equally possible you don't know what fraud is.

...so they may not be aware it is fraud they are committing when they are committing it.

Irrelevant. The studies you're getting your figures from explicitly define the behavior that the reported rates cover. If you are not using those definitions, you may not apply the associated quantitative results to your argument.

But it is not the obligation of society to educated scientists what constitutes criminal behavior. It is the responsibility of scientists to be informed.

Not even remotely relevant, and passably insulting. You are using your own personal definition of "fraud" as it applies to science. I believe you're doing so in order to pad your list, and to inappropriately vilify scientists. You have the burden to prove it's the right way to define it and that it correlates to the reported behavior.

But the fact science fraud is becoming so common among scientists...

Not a fact. The rest of your post is moot, given this.

Please explain why your personal definition of fraud is the right one.
 
I'm not sure his use of numbers rises to the level of statistics.

He is nevertheless attempting a statistical argument. The fact that he's failing badly at it doesn't necessarily affect what it's trying to be.

But the paradox in his argument is that by quoting The Economist where scientists are accused of, among other things, getting statistical analysis wrong and saying this constitutes "fraudulent" science, he makes his own argument suspect when it attempts to rely on science (e.g., the reported rates of misconduct) and then gets its own statistical analysis wrong.

Can't have the cake and eat it too.
 
He is nevertheless attempting a statistical argument. The fact that he's failing badly at it doesn't necessarily affect what it's trying to be.

But the paradox in his argument is that by quoting The Economist where scientists are accused of, among other things, getting statistical analysis wrong and saying this constitutes "fraudulent" science, he makes his own argument suspect when it attempts to rely on science (e.g., the reported rates of misconduct) and then gets its own statistical analysis wrong.

Can't have the cake and eat it too.

But there is a big difference. The article berates scientists for not understanding statistics and for rejecting negative results by focusing only on the positives. That is not an attack on statistics as applied here.
 
justintime said:
It is possible scientists do not know what fraud is...
Only in the same manner in which it is possible they are reptilian aliens. Scientists are pretty thoroughly trained in what fraud is, and even in school the punishments are pretty extreme. It's imbeddedin our culture, and every student is exposed to the dire consequences that result from committing fraud, as numerous high-profile cases are discussed in pretty much every science class at universities. For my part, I was shown fraudulant data, and techniques for determining that it was fraudulant (the fossil material coming out of China includes a lot of flat-out fabrications, and being able to identify them is useful for someone who stands a reasonable chance of encountering them).

They would like the benefit of believing when they are committing fraud they are actually committing something less damaging like research.
You know, the fact that justintime considers research "damaging" certainly explains a lot.

The article berates scientists for not understanding statistics and for rejecting negative results by focusing only on the positives.
To be fair, justintime has not committed this error. He has not gotten to the point where we can reasonably accuse him of doing something so innocent as unjustifiably ignoring data. His main error is flat-out making stuff up.
 
But there is a big difference.

Nope. If it's wrong for them to make statistics mistakes -- even innocently -- it's wrong for you to make them.

No double moral standard for you.

The article berates scientists for not understanding statistics and for rejecting negative results by focusing only on the positives.

The article is a popular puff piece that provides absolutely no evidence to support its contention that scientists don't know statistics.

Asked and answered.
 
His main error is flat-out making stuff up.

Agreed. Whether it's a rate of malfeasance or voodoo mathematics to make the numbers come out grossly exaggerated -- which is what Justintime admits he's trying to do -- it's a "fraudulent" finding as he defines it for others.

In other words, no moralist argument he might wish to make can fly here now.
 
Unreliable Research Trouble in the Lab.
Quotes from link....
The link is missing, justintime.
JayUtah provided it though: Trouble in the Lab..
JayUtah also addresses the quotes you extracted from the Economist article.

This news article is irrelevant to this thread because it is not about fraudulent science except for one paragraph:
Fraud is very likely second to incompetence in generating erroneous results, though it is hard to tell for certain. Dr Fanelli has looked at 21 different surveys of academics (mostly in the biomedical sciences but also in civil engineering, chemistry and economics) carried out between 1987 and 2008. Only 2% of respondents admitted falsifying or fabricating data, but 28% of respondents claimed to know of colleagues who engaged in questionable research practices.
The 28% figure in the quote is wrong - it was 14.12%:
How Many Scientists Fabricate and Falsify Research? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Survey Data
A pooled weighted average of 1.97% (N = 7, 95%CI: 0.86–4.45) of scientists admitted to have fabricated, falsified or modified data or results at least once –a serious form of misconduct by any standard– and up to 33.7% admitted other questionable research practices. In surveys asking about the behaviour of colleagues, admission rates were 14.12% (N = 12, 95% CI: 9.91–19.72) for falsification, and up to 72% for other questionable research practices.

The link to scientific fraud (as opposed to private, unpublished misconduct) is unknown since the surveys did not ask that question.

Any extension to scientists in general is dubious since the surveys were mostly in the biomedical field not of the general scientific community.

And of course - these are surveys with their inherent problems.
 
Last edited:
And of course - these are surveys with their inherent problems.

And the irony is still palpable, that Justintime is using scientific findings -- and implicitly considering them authoritative -- to support his contention that science is fraudulent. That has to be the grandaddy of all circular arguments.
 
The article berates scientists for not understanding statistics and for rejecting negative results by focusing only on the positives.
This an attack by the reporter on the competency of scientists, not their honesty, justintime.

The scientists are not "rejecting negative results" as you state, they are not designing tests to minimize "false negatives in which a real signal is missed in the noise", e.g. making the sample sizes as large as possible.
This is a complaint about scientists missing real signals.

There is a mention of false positives in which a erroneous signal is extracted from the noise:
A type I error is the mistake of thinking something is true when it is not (also known as a “false positive”). A type II error is thinking something is not true when in fact it is (a “false negative”).
 
Last edited:
Not a link or citation in that whole rant.

And practically no citations in the article itself, once it was found. The Economist author basically just spouts a lot of unsubstantiated assertions, peppered with unreferenced quotes to a handful of scientists.

As I said, we get a hit-and-run piece like this every couple of years, and it follows the same sort of formula. It's largely sensationalist.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom