science fraud is common place

You provided a number 25 million papers published which gave us the number we could uses to calculate the actual percentage of science papers fraudulent rather than a study of only 2000 retracted papers which found 65% of them to be fraudulent.

Indeed, because you need to DIVIDE by 25 million.

14% of scientist are reported by their peers as guilty of fraud.

That is a vile lie, and you know it. 14% of polled scientists reported knowing someone who they believed was guilty of fraud. You are fooling NO ONE by trying to switch it around to mean something entirely different.

what is 14% of 25million? 3,500,000 papers are fraudulent.

Again, no. You have no idea how numbers work. Did you even go to elementary school ? Even ASSUMING that 14% of scientists are guilty of fraud, that doesn't mean that every paper that they every worked on are fraudulent. You need to explain how you get from one to the other.

Furthermore, you are attempting to apply 14%, a number arrived at in on study, to 25 million, a number from a different source. You have no reason to assume that you can apply one to the other.

Finally, and this cannot be stressed enough, 1300 papers were found to be fraudulent out of 25 million. You cannot assume that the number is much higher than this without adequate reasoning and evidence, which you have failed to provide.

for every fraud a 100 goes undetected.

I don't suppose you'll ever provide any evidence for this claim ?

3.5 million papers x 100 = 350,000000. OMG 1,400% of papers are fraudulent.

I would like to remind you that you cannot have 1400% of papers, just like you cannot have 1400% of a pie.
 
The 14% is from PLOS survey where 14% admitted they knew someone guilty of science fraud but were not detected.

Why do you NOW word it correctly ?

Only 2% of scientists actually admitted to science fraud. So working with real numbers and not just the scientists admitting fraud 14% was the more accurate number of actual scientists who committed fraud but not all were detected.

See, you're doing it again. Can you slow down and read the following :

Let's say that you live on a street with 100 people. I poll those 100 people and 14% of them (14, in this case) tell me that they know someone called Justin on their street. By your logic, this means there are 14 people named Justin on the street. But that's wrong. In reality there is ONE person called Justin, you, and 14 people know you.

This is what the 14% of the poll means. You cannot infer from it that 14 people are called Justin on your street 14% of scientists are frauds.

14% of 25,000,000 is 3.5 million papers are actually fraudulent which is all papers considered and not just the 2000 studied.

And you are again applying one number, that we know is wrong, to a completely different quantity, and assuming that every fraudulent scientist commits frauds on every paper he ever touches. Both those assumptions are wrong, in addition to using the wrong percentage on the wrong set of data. That's a four-fold error !

Here if we apply Board and Wade's analysis where for every major fraud 100 go undetected

Why would we do so ? He gives us no reason to take his speculation as anything more than just that: speculation.

then you have to multiply 3.5 million x 100 which equals 350,000,000

Now convert 350,000,000 to a percent of 25 million. ????

When you do that, you realise that you cannot have a factor of 100.

Mind you, you could do that with MY number, 0.0052%, because then you'd end up with half a percent of fraud, which is still pretty damn good, compared to other fields.
 
No, we discard them because you made them up. They do not derive from real data. The only reason why you think they do (and I know you don't) is because of total ignorance of mathematics, percentages and proportions, science, and pretty much everything else of relevance to this topic.



You don't know what the percentage are.

Coming back to the fraud thing; let's say you have written 10 novels. Someone who knows you says that you have made typos in your novels. Does that mean that all 10 novels contain typos ? No, it does not.


The question is


Sums up your argument, I guess.

Why are you using hypothetical examples? We know from the PLOS survey 14% of scientists are fraudulent even though only 2% admit to it. 25 million papers are published according to Belz. So at a minimum 3.5 million papers are fraudulent (14% of 25 million). Scientists especially the fraudulent ones use pseudonyms and use several publishers.
Why scientists use pen names or pseudonyms.
http://www.mbbp.com/resources/iptech/pseudonyms.html
If we average it to 5 per scientists we get 17.5 million fraudulent papers. which is about 70%. This does not take into account for every major fraud many more go undetected.

What is the cost to tax payers from fraudulent research ?
Senate Report Finds Billions in Waste on Science Foundation Studies.
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/201...ds-billions-waste-science-foundation-studies/

There is no way to justify or defend scientific fraud. The numbers are drawing the attention of people who manage and fund research and has shrunk funding because of the 10 fold increase in science fraud. Science fraud is common place. Let us stop denying it. Science fraud has been going on for decades. Public awareness and open discussion on forums like JREF will put an end to this nonsense.
 
Why are you using hypothetical examples?

In the hope that by paring down the problem to its essence, you can see the errors you've been making since you first started.

If we average it to 5 per scientists we get 17.5 million fraudulent papers. which is about 70%. This does not take into account for every major fraud many more go undetected.

Still more arithmetic voodoo. You're just plucking numbers out of thin air at this point and combining in them arbitrarily with pseudo-math that is arithmetically valid but does not abstract any sort of demonstrable real-life process.

Science fraud is common place. Let us stop denying it. Science fraud has been going on for decades.

No, simply returning to your predetermined belief every time your argument for it is shot down is not a convincing way to debate. You're committing a "fringe reset" on the order of several times per day now.

Public awareness and open discussion on forums like JREF will put an end to this nonsense.

Simply crying "fraud" is insufficient. Here and elsewhere you must actually present true facts and valid lines of reasoning to support your claims. Otherwise you end up no different that the actual fraudsters such as the industry behind Natural News that you have allowed to educate you.
 
Why scientists use pen names or pseudonyms.
http://www.mbbp.com/resources/iptech/pseudonyms.html

This article describes why fiction writers sometimes use pseudonyms. The only relevant example is that of doctor and scientist Michael Crichton, who wrote some fiction under a pseudonym. There is no evidence that he published any science under a pseudonym, nor does the article relate any further to allegations of pseudonyms in scientific publications.

Apples and oranges.

What is the cost to tax payers from fraudulent research ?
Senate Report Finds Billions in Waste on Science Foundation Studies.
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/201...ds-billions-waste-science-foundation-studies/

This study addresses wasteful expenditure on science. While the word "fraud" appears in the article, none of the examples cited is of fraudulent research. Rather, they are examples of research that some believe not to have any commensurate value. There is no allegation that it has been done deceptively or fraudulently.

Apples and oranges.
 
Every time an experiment confirms a hypothesis, the experiment succeeds. Every time an experiment disproves a hypothesis, the experiment succeeds. If properly designed and executed, an experiment succeeds every time, since it is designed to prove or disprove a hypothesis. If the results are ambiguous, the experiment needs to be redesigned.
 
Why are you using hypothetical examples?

You know how in school they use scenarios in order to teach you math and science ? I'm doing the same thing here. Pay attention.

We know from the PLOS survey 14% of scientists are fraudulent even though only 2% admit to it.

I've already corrected you on this. In fact I will continue to tell you this until you admit that you are wrong:

Let's say that you live on a street with 100 people. I poll those 100 people and 14% of them (14, in this case) tell me that they know someone called Justin on their street. By your logic, this means there are 14 people named Justin on the street. But that's wrong. In reality there is ONE person called Justin, you, and 14 people know you.

It's the same scenario with the scientists. 14% of them report knowing someone who MAY have been involved in fraud. It does not follow that another 14% of them are frauds, and it certainly doesn't follow even from that that 14% of all papers are frauds, because that would assume that all papers by all scientists who have ever commited fraud are fraudulent, which certainly makes no sense.

25 million papers are published according to Belz. So at a minimum 3.5 million papers are fraudulent (14% of 25 million).

First of all, even if your numbers are correct, which they are not, it would be a maximum, not a minimum. Second of all, see my explanation above for why you cannot apply that 14% to the 25 million.

If we average it to 5 per scientists we get 17.5 million fraudulent papers.

Why do you keep making up numbers ? 100 times more than detected, 5 per scientist, etc. You have given no reason, aside from your own personal preference, to use these factors.

which is about 70%. This does not take into account for every major fraud many more go undetected.

That's logically impossible. If 70% of papers are fraudulent, it is impossible that more go undetected, because it only leaves 30%, a smaller number.

What is the cost to tax payers from fraudulent research ?

Begging the question.

There is no way to justify or defend scientific fraud.

I think this is the first genuinely true and honest thing you've said in this thread. Good thing only 0.005% of published papers are known to be fraudulent.
 
Every time an experiment confirms a hypothesis, the experiment succeeds. Every time an experiment disproves a hypothesis, the experiment succeeds. If properly designed and executed, an experiment succeeds every time, since it is designed to prove or disprove a hypothesis. If the results are ambiguous, the experiment needs to be redesigned.

Science is beautiful.
 
Every time an experiment confirms a hypothesis, the experiment succeeds. Every time an experiment disproves a hypothesis, the experiment succeeds. If properly designed and executed, an experiment succeeds every time, since it is designed to prove or disprove a hypothesis. If the results are ambiguous, the experiment needs to be redesigned.

As I said upthread, the tl;dr version of scientific method is ask a question and pay attention to the answer. Properly asked questions are useful no matter what the answer, like playing "animal mineral vegetable" when you're kids.
 
justintime said:
So at a minimum 3.5 million papers are fraudulent (14% of 25 million). Scientists especially the fraudulent ones use pseudonyms and use several publishers.
Why scientists use pen names or pseudonyms.
http://www.mbbp.com/resources/iptech/pseudonyms.html
If we average it to 5 per scientists we get 17.5 million fraudulent papers. which is about 70%. This does not take into account for every major fraud many more go undetected.
I see what you did there. Dumb doesn't even begin to cover it. Good lord, where DID you go to school?
 
We know from the PLOS survey 14% of scientists are fraudulent even though only 2% admit to it.
Dinwar pointed this out already in a reply to an earlier post with the same mistake but here comes my explanation, justintime:

The PLOS meta-analysis of existing surveys does not say that. We cannot know what it does not say :D!
What the PLOS paper says is that 2% of the respondents admitted to committing misconduct (not only fraud) and that 14% of the respondents admitted to knowing about other people's misconduct (not only fraud).

You cannot apply an unknown amount of fraud within the 2% misconduct to the 25 million papers contained in PubMed for a couple of reasons:
* the surveys did not ask about published misconduct (except in one question in one survey as far as I can see)
* the % of scientists admitting fraud (unpublished or not) is between 0% and 2%, i.e. unknown.

The "10 fold increase in science fraud" is from 0.001% to 0.01% of the papers in PubMed and could be a 10 fold increase in science fraud detection.

Already pointed out by other posters but seemingly missed by you, justintime:
* http://www.mbbp.com/resources/iptech/pseudonyms.html is about why fiction writers use pen names or pseudonyms.
*Senate Report Finds Billions in Waste on Science Foundation Studies.
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/201...ds-billions-waste-science-foundation-studies/
is not about fraudulent research as in faking results - it is about what a politician (Sen. Tom Coburn) regards as wasteful research with some instances of fraudulent use of NSF funds.
 
If maths is a matter of opinion then I demand my A level is given a grade that reflects the answers I gave were correct in my opinion.
 
If science has no practical application please explain how you are able to use a computer, a car, a plane, electricity and all the practical applications most people take for granted in a developed modern society?

If none of this was a practical application of scientific discoveries then what was the agency by which they were all discovered and put to use?
 
Last edited:
If science has no practical application please explain how you are able to use a computer, a car, a plane, electricity and all the practical applications most people take for granted in a developed modern society?

If none of this was a practical application of scientific discoveries then what was the agency by which they were all discovered and put to use?

He's been asked this before. His response was something along the lines of 'mindless tinkering' like birds do when they pick-up a twig to build a nest. If pressed, goddidit.

But macht es nichts. JiT will lie, misquote, and contradict himself twice in one sentence to pursue his goals.
 
As I said upthread, the tl;dr version of scientific method is ask a question and pay attention to the answer. Properly asked questions are useful no matter what the answer, like playing "animal mineral vegetable" when you're kids.

And the properly-asked question must have the possibility of "no, your hypothesis is wrong" as an answer; it must be a falsifiable one. It's no good asking things like "is it possible goddidit?" because magical thinking (where the deity is assumed, by definition, to have whatever properties necessary to do whatever it is you're asking about) precludes falsifiability. You can't usefully test for a god that can do anything.
 
If science has no practical application please explain how you are able to use a computer, a car, a plane, electricity and all the practical applications most people take for granted in a developed modern society?

If none of this was a practical application of scientific discoveries then what was the agency by which they were all discovered and put to use?

If computers and other digital gadgets had any practical application, why do you see millions of them dumped annually in landfills like useless garbage or disposable waste? Billions are spend storing useless pieces of electronic conversations or archiving trash talk that have no socially redeeming value except to remind us how we wasted our time in mindless social networking with the least possibility all this effort would amount to anything.

All computers have done is afforded us an efficient way to waste our lives. Ironically we are here discussing how common science fraud is. But because we are using computers to communicate(eletronically), many feel obligated to give science fraud a pass.

We gave science a pass when they invented weapons and chemicals of mass destruction so we could destroy each other. We gave science a pass when they grouped humans with the apes with monkey theories that still resonate in the halls of science. Now we want to give science another pass because they allow us to waste our lives debating with ourselves and each other. When is science going to be used for something practical that makes people want to end science fraud instead of watching scientists slowly destroying our humanity.
 
justintime said:
If computers and other digital gadgets had any practical application, why do you see millions of them dumped annually in landfills like useless garbage or disposable waste?
For the same reason that you see knives tossed out in kitchens. A bad knife is still a useful tool (any hominin 10,000 years ago would have given his left arm for the worst of our modern cutlery)--it's just not as good as other tools, and usually gets replaced rapidly. Same with computers: they're often rapidly replaced by newer, better versions.

Secondly, the fact that a class of items is useful doesn't necessarily mean that everything within that class is useful. If my computer catches fire, it's no longer useful to me and is in fact a real threat. This does not negate the usefulness of computers; it does, however, mean that my computer will end up in a landfill pretty quickly.

Billions are spend storing useless pieces of electronic conversations or archiving trash talk that have no socially redeeming value except to remind us how we wasted our time in mindless social networking with the least possibility all this effort would amount to anything.
It's called "being human".

All computers have done is afforded us an efficient way to waste our lives.
That may be all you've used them for. Computers have enhanced my life profoundly. They've done more to advance science than any other tool. I've done cladistics and n-dimensional multivarient statistics by hand. It sucks, and my lifespan is finite. Computers are tremendously valuable for that. Plus, I can research papers from the comfort of my office, rather than physically tracking them down--something I've always loathed.

When is science going to be used for something practical that makes people want to end science fraud instead of watching scientists slowly destroying our humanity.
Well, since scientific fraud occurs at a rate of <0.005%, I'd say we're as close to ending it as we can reasonably expect to get. Plus, if you live in a developed country, above the third floor of a building, drive a car, use a computer, have recieved medical care in the past hundred years, watch TV, eat food (artificial refrigeration was a MAJOR scientific breakthrough), or do just about anything else, science has made your life better. This most recent post of yours can only be described as petulant.
 
If computers and other digital gadgets had any practical application, why do you see millions of them dumped annually in landfills like useless garbage or disposable waste? Billions are spend storing useless pieces of electronic conversations or archiving trash talk that have no socially redeeming value except to remind us how we wasted our time in mindless social networking with the least possibility all this effort would amount to anything.

All computers have done is afforded us an efficient way to waste our lives. Ironically we are here discussing how common science fraud is. But because we are using computers to communicate(eletronically), many feel obligated to give science fraud a pass.

We gave science a pass when they invented weapons and chemicals of mass destruction so we could destroy each other. We gave science a pass when they grouped humans with the apes with monkey theories that still resonate in the halls of science. Now we want to give science another pass because they allow us to waste our lives debating with ourselves and each other. When is science going to be used for something practical that makes people want to end science fraud instead of watching scientists slowly destroying our humanity.
Are you really arguing that science is an impractical waste of time and a fraud because it gives you the means to electronically argue that science is an impractical waste of time and a fraud?

Let's don't forget that computers can also be a source of amusement; of course, they need folks like you to really make it funny.
 
If computers and other digital gadgets had any practical application, why do you see millions of them dumped annually in landfills like useless garbage or disposable waste? Billions are spend storing useless pieces of electronic conversations or archiving trash talk that have no socially redeeming value except to remind us how we wasted our time in mindless social networking with the least possibility all this effort would amount to anything.

What's a practical application, for you ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom