science fraud is common place

Your x100 is imaginary.

Regardless of its source, if you estimate that a reported rate is underestimated by a factor of 100, that estimate can only apply to reported rates less than 1 percent. By definition. And if your reported rate includes empirical findings of both positives and negatives, then either the percentage must be vastly lower than 1 percent, or the under-reporting factor must be vastly lower than 100.

This is simply how those numbers work. You can't have more than unity in your answer. It's impossible in real life.

What Justintime appears to believe is that the higher the number, the more "strongly" fraudulent the findings must indicate. So if he says 200 percent of science is fraudulent, he doesn't interpret that as a logically impossible result, but as an even more convictive proof -- twice as believable as 100 percent. Hence the 6,000-7,000 "percent" fraud must really be impressive! (Instead of prima facie evidence of it being absurdly wrong.)
 
I'm just savoring the multi-layer irony of an argument that tries to use science to show that science is bogus -- and gets the science wrong.

There's simply no hope for someone who just can't get that abusing percentages to show more scientists committing fraud than there are scientists to begin with isn't even wrong.

I'm beginning to think that JiT should save everyone some time and just post his not-even-wrong stuff directly to the Stundies thread.
 
Which simply means when 2 or more scientists are caught cheating, the actual number of cheaters goes off the charts into the next generation of scientists.

No. Percentages do not somehow "spill over" into some other unrelated population. By definition a percentage deals with a fixed-size population that governs both the numerator and the denominator together, not each one separately.

Seriously, your arguments fail for want of a basic young-teenage level arithmetic. This is not ambiguous. Clearly arithmetic is a subject that puzzles you, but don't make the mistake of assuming that everyone is as puzzle as you are. You can't bluff your way through this. You're making elementary mistakes that everyone but you can see, so you won't make any rhetorical headway by trying to argue that your opponents are just as befuddled as you.

This is basic arithmetic, and you're getting it badly wrong.
 
Regardless of its source, if you estimate that a reported rate is underestimated by a factor of 100, that estimate can only apply to reported rates less than 1 percent. By definition. And if your reported rate includes empirical findings of both positives and negatives, then either the percentage must be vastly lower than 1 percent, or the under-reporting factor must be vastly lower than 100.

This is simply how those numbers work. You can't have more than unity in your answer. It's impossible in real life.

What Justintime appears to believe is that the higher the number, the more "strongly" fraudulent the findings must indicate. So if he says 200 percent of science is fraudulent, he doesn't interpret that as a logically impossible result, but as an even more convictive proof -- twice as believable as 100 percent. Hence the 6,000-7,000 "percent" fraud must really be impressive! (Instead of prima facie evidence of it being absurdly wrong.)
We deal with negative numbers in math. Science fraud calls for ultra positive numbers.
 
We deal with negative numbers in math.

True, but irrelevant to the problem with your arithemetic.

Science fraud calls for ultra positive numbers.

No, that's just rhetoric and hyberbole. You are patently unable or unwilling to understand why your psuedo-math argument fails. But fail it does, and everyone but you can see why.
 
So of the 25 million papers published 50 million of them were fraudulent? That's your claim?

My example calculated the number/percent of scientist possibly cheating but not exposed.

To calculate the actual number of fraudulent papers both retracted and undetected/ignored requires a different set of calculations.


Another way to approach this is to take the total number of papers published
About 25 million papers are published. 14% of scientist are reported by their peers as guilty of fraud. what is 14% of 25million? 3,500,000 papers are fraudulent.

for every fraud a 100 goes undetected.
3.5 million papers x 100 = 350,000000. OMG 1,400% of papers are fraudulent.

If only 2000 papers studied are retracted out of the 25 million published. What is the percent of fraudulent papers that are not retracted of the 25 million papers published.

3,500,000 - 2000 retracted = 13.992% of the 25,000,000 papers are not retracted.

Only if we ignore Broad and Wades speculation for every one major fraud a 100 goes undetected. We still end up with 14% of papers are fraudulent or 3,500,000 papers.
Now if you account for several publications by the same author under pseudonyms using 5 in our example.

Then 3,500,000 x 5 = 17,500,000 is the exact number of fraudulent papers both retracted and un-retracted.
It was first posted here in post# 1220
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9779417&postcount=1220
 
Last edited:
OMG 1,400% of papers are fraudulent.

Over-unity, ipso facto wrong.

Look, it's obvious you're desperate to discover some clever mathematical handwaving that somehow magically justifies an over-unity answer. But until you wrap your mind around the notion that you cannot have a fraud rate greater than 100% your critics are just going to continue lambasting you for your innumeracy.

14% of scientist are reported by their peers as guilty of fraud.

No, this is a misstatement of the actual finding. Do not change the words of the evidence to match your beliefs.

...for every fraud a 100 goes undetected.

No, this is speculation with no rational basis. Yet for some reason it's a mandatory factor in every computation you attempt. I've shown you why it cannot hold in every conceivable situation. Your only answer was that you need "big numbers."

By the way "negative numbers" don't save your answer either. When I say the only way the math works in reality is if the numbers are drastically smaller, I don't mean dropping into negative territory. You can't have a negative rate in this statistic, also by definition.

You're either yanking our chain, or else you really have absolutely no idea what these numbers actually mean. I promise you your critics are not as all-out-to-sea as you are. While your continued bluffing is entertaining, I promise you that you are no closer to proving your point.
 
My example calculated the number/percent of scientist possibly cheating but not exposed.

To calculate the actual number of fraudulent papers both retracted and undetected/ignored requires a different set of calculations.


Another way to approach this is to take the total number of papers published
About 25 million papers are published. 14% of scientist are reported by their peers as guilty of fraud. what is 14% of 25million? 3,500,000 papers are fraudulent.

for every fraud a 100 goes undetected.
3.5 million papers x 100 = 350,000000. OMG 1,400% of papers are fraudulent.

If only 2000 papers studied are retracted out of the 25 million published. What is the percent of fraudulent papers that are not retracted of the 25 million papers published.

3,500,000 - 2000 retracted = 13.992% of the 25,000,000 papers are not retracted.

Only if we ignore Broad and Wades speculation for every one major fraud a 100 goes undetected. We still end up with 14% of papers are fraudulent or 3,500,000 papers.
Now if you account for several publications by the same author under pseudonyms using 5 in our example.

Then 3,500,000 x 5 = 17,500,000 is the exact number of fraudulent papers both retracted and un-retracted.
It was first posted here in post# 1220
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9779417&postcount=1220

reported for using numbers wrongly with malice aforethought
 
We deal with negative numbers in math. Science fraud calls for ultra positive numbers.

Well at least that settles my earlier question about your honesty.

Good show.

You'll understand, of course, that it's hard to tell these days. Some people actually believe nonsense like what you've posted.

In any case this thread should serve as an interesting example of how to counter uncritical thinking. And if THAT was your goal, you are spectacular !
 
Here is how percent works as well.

There are 100 scientists doing a test.
If 1 scientist cheats what percent of scientists are cheats? Answer 1%

method 1/100 x 100 = 1%


But for every 1 scientist who got caught for cheating a 100 more were cheating. What percent of scientists are cheaters?

I see another problem with your math. You start out with 100 scientists. One of them got caught cheating. Now, for that one person who was cheating, 100 more were cheating and never got caught. Am I correct so far?

Here's the problem. If you have one and you have 100 more, that would mean that the total number of scientists who were cheating would be 101. Therefore, the percentage of cheaters would be 101%. This would mean that you would have MORE cheaters than the number of scientists available.

Can you explain that contradiction? How can you possibly have more cheaters than test takers?
 
But that is not the explanation I offered.
If 2% of scientists admit to fraud and for every fraud a 100 goes undetected then 2% x 100 = OMG 200% of science is fraudulent!!!
Would you please stop doing that? It's either "100" or "a hundred".

When you write "a 100" you are actually saying "a one hundred".

Never mind your wacko math.




ETA: 2% x 100 = .02 x 100 = 2

2% ≠ 2

Geeze.
 
Last edited:
If 2% of scientists admit to fraud and for every fraud a 100 goes undetected then 2% x 100 = OMG 200% of science is fraudulent!!!
I see you are still persisting with a fantasy of 1 in 100 frauds undetected and insisting in invalid mathematics, justintime.

Actual facts and valid math:
2000 retracted papers out of a total of 25 million papers is a tiny percentage

Actual reading comprehension: Misconduct is not fraud or even "reported criminal activity" :eek:!
How Many Scientists Fabricate and Falsify Research? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Survey Data concludes that 2% of the sampled scientists committed misconduct (not fraud). 14% admit they know of someone guilty of misconduct that may or may not have gone undetected (not a question in the surveys).

There is no "reported criminal activity" listed in this thread. Scientific fraud is not legal fraud.

One of these day you are going to have to actually look at the questions (e.g. Self-report questions included in review, and responses) in the surveys rather than seemingly ignorantly making assumptions about them, justintime!
 
But that is not the explanation I offered.

I don't care.

If 2% of scientists admit to fraud and for every fraud a 100 goes undetected then 2% x 100 = OMG 200% of science is fraudulent!!!

In addition to your maths fail, where do you get 100 undetected frauds? If they are undetected you do not know about them therefore you can not count them. These alleged 100 undetected frauds would actually fall into the 2% category because they are frauds that scientists admit doing irrespective of them being discovered. See the counting problem you have there? Dumb question I guess.

An honest, ethical researcher would not pluck figures out of thin air and wave imaginary proofs around without checking they were correct.
 
How science touches every aspect of our lives from food to the air we breathe to our ability to procreate. But is science a positive contributor or as the article ponders. Human race being terminated by 'scientific suicide'
http://www.naturalnews.com/035790_scientific_suicide_humans.html

"Scientists are death engineers and the human race is being murdered in the name of science."
So you see, I am not alone in my concerns.

If science is trying to murder us wouldn't you want it to be full of fraud and therefore be ineffective?

And if that is the case shouldn't you be pointing out that the "murder everyone" agenda is clearly failing as evidence for your side of this?

It is truly amazing how many people are living with cancer and the billions spent trying to treat them when the cause is attributed to radioactive nuclear waste, chemical contamination and poorly managed hazardous toxic storage spillage. Scientists are turning the only blue planet into a wasteland.

People get cancer by living longer than normal. Cells replicate in the human body every second of every day. Do it long enough and a harmful, malignant mutation will eventually arise. Blaming this on science is like blaming the lighthouse for the dangerous rocks it is built on.

Someone should remind the scientific community they are producing engineers of death when they are not engaging in science fraud.

:rolleyes:

Yeah, I'm gonna go tell a geologist that he's just part of the big plan to genocide us all.

It is time scientists stopped using religion as a scapegoat. Human aspirations have never been lower after science with its scientific determinism condemned mankind to the status of a primate whose existence is determined by the current state and immutable laws of the universe, with no possibility of choice.

Oooh. It's like I'm back in Philosophy 101!

I think this is the point where the brooding guy at the back of the class starts talking about Nietzsche.

Should we trust scientists when peer review survey reveals 65% of studied papers are found fraudulent?

Can I introduce some made up numbers too?

It is beyond all doubt that 5000% of all anti science activists have molested at least one otter.

Heh, that's kind of fun.

That scientists are not able to discipline members of their profession, the self correcting nature of the scientific method is a myth and the honor system is fraught with dishonorable criminal elements seizing the opportunity to exploit the naivety of scientists far removed from reality or practicality.

Scientific method is not an excuse for the sorry state of science fraud....it is the cause of scientific fraud.

I'd love to hear your alternate method.

Give it to me. What is the justintime alternate method to discover how cellular metabolism works?

What is the justintime method to find a new treatment for pancreatic cancer?

How does justintime propose we figure out how the Rocky Mountains formed?
 
I don't care.



In addition to your maths fail, where do you get 100 undetected frauds? If they are undetected you do not know about them therefore you can not count them. These alleged 100 undetected frauds would actually fall into the 2% category because they are frauds that scientists admit doing irrespective of them being discovered. See the counting problem you have there? Dumb question I guess.

An honest, ethical researcher would not pluck figures out of thin air and wave imaginary proofs around without checking they were correct.

but 18.6% of claimed ethical researchers were wrong 143% of the time. QED.
 
And the members are also wrong when they refuse to accept such a thing as 200%.

200% of all trees in the world is twice as many trees as exist. It's impossible. You can't have more frauds than you have papers.

You already know this, of course. I'm telling the lurkers, assuming some of them buy into this.

Well, here is another math tutorial on percentages taken from a math forum.

In some cases, yes. You can have a 1000% increase in something. But you can't have 1000% of item X that has quality Y.
 
And the members are also wrong when they refuse to accept such a thing as 200%.

Well, here is another math tutorial on percentages taken from a math forum.

Quote:
Doctor Rick wrote: There is nothing intrinsically wrong with using percentages greater than 100%.

So the answer is, there is such a thing as a percentage larger than
100%

http://mathforum.org/library/drmath/view/58166.html

Uh-huh. Quote-mining again? Doctor Rick also says-
There are situations in which a percentage greater than 100% makes no sense. For instance, "The Math Doctors answered 146% of the questions received last month." This makes no sense because if we received 5061 questions, we couldn't possibly answer more than all of them. It's just as nonsensical as saying "I ate 4/3 of the cake."

That's your situation; you've put yourself in the position of asserting that you can eat 200% of a cake that you only think you have.

Why? Refer to my sig...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom