science fraud is common place

If 2% of scientists admit to fraud and for every fraud a 100 goes undetected then 2% x 100 = OMG 200% of science is fraudulent!!!

This is so unbelievably wrong. Math is not for you.

Explain how you can have twice as much of a thing as actually exists. In a normal numerical argument this would a huge red flag that you did the math wrong. For some reason in your argument, it somehow "proves" you're even more right.
 
You are not even trying now. That is so poor a line of unreasoning that it has overtaken realms of laughable and moved into the fast lane of sad.

This is the classic problem of how do you discuss rationally a position that 2 + 2 = 5 1/2, well you cannot, the other person is either an ancient Greek Mulberry bush, ill or a troll, either way you aren't going to get anywhere.
 

Here is how percent works as well.

There are 100 scientists doing a test.
If 1 scientist cheats what percent of scientists are cheats? Answer 1%

method 1/100 x 100 = 1%

Now if 2 scientists cheat what percent of scientists are cheats? Answer 2%

method 2/100 x 100 = 2%

But for every 1 scientist who got caught for cheating a 100 more were cheating. What percent of scientists are cheaters if 2 were caught?

method 2 x 100 = 200 now convert to percent 200 /100 x 100 = 200%. Answer 200%
 
Here is how percent works as well.

There are 100 scientists doing a test.
If 1 scientist cheats what percent of scientists are cheats? Answer 1%

method 1/100 x 100 = 1%

Now if 2 scientists cheat what percent of scientists are cheats? Answer 2%

method 2/100 x 100 = 2%

But for every 1 scientist who got caught for cheating a 100 more were cheating. What percent of scientists are cheaters if 2 were caught?

method 2 x 100 = 200 now convert to percent 200 /100 x 100 = 200%. Answer 200%

My grade school daughter is currently learning percentages. It is a new subject that began after her return from Christmas break so she was introduced to the topic for the first time about 10 days ago. She would laugh at the above.
 
Originally Posted by justintime View Post
But for every 1 scientist who got caught for cheating a 100 more were cheating. What percent of scientists are cheaters if 2 were caught?

method 2 x 100 = 200 now convert to percent 200 /100 x 100 = 200%. Answer 200%

That's the part you got wrong.

Please explain.
 
Last edited:
2% of scientists admit to fraud according to peer review study.

Ok.

For every major fraud committed a 100 goes undetected.

Evidence, please.

When these numbers were presented for independent calculations.
jt512 replied. OMG 200% of science is fraudulent.

Are you aware that 200% is impossible ?

Another way to approach this is to take the total number of papers published
About 25 million papers are published. 14% of scientist are reported by their peers as guilty of fraud. what is 14% of 25million? 3,500,000 papers are fraudulent.

No, you are dishonestly manipulating those numbers. The 14% are people who KNOW someone who might be guilty of fraud according to them. THAT DOESN'T MEAN 14% OF THEM ARE GUILTY. This has been repeated to you dozens of times.

The ONLY numbers you ACTUALLY have is 65% of 2000 rejected papers out of 25 million, which is 0.005%.

If only 2000 papers studied are retracted out of the 25 million published. What is the percent of fraudulent papers that are not retracted of the 25 million papers published.

Very few, probably, since they would have been retracted if they were fraudulent. That's why those 2000 were retracted -- because the system works. You are trying to apply the numbers twice.
 
I have not noticed any evidence of bias in my sources

If we assume that your sources would admit to being wrong 1% of the time, but that the rate of wrongness is actually 100 times higher, then they are wrong 100% wrong.

QED.

Unless someone can prove 2% x 100 is not 200%. I stand by those numbers.

200% is impossible. It is LOGICALLY impossible. You cannot stand by them.

Your x100 is imaginary.

...nor am I obligated to defend what is referenced in the public domain.

Yes, you are.

But I am alarmed science fraud is common place...

0.005% is not common.
 
Please explain.

The divisor in the computation of a percentage is not always 100. It is the size of the population from which the selected items were drawn.

That's all the remedial math you get from me today. If you cannot understand how an over-unity final result absolutely determines that your method is wrong, then no amount of remediation on my part can correct your misconception.
 
Please explain.

Oh, my. That's not how you convert something in percentages.

Let me help:

2000 papers were retracted. 65% of those were fraudulent. That's

2000 x 0.65 = 1300.

Now, what percentage of 25 million, the full number of papers, were found to be fraudulent ?

1300 / 25,000,000 = 0.000052

Multiply that by 100 to get 0.0052%

THAT's how you derive percentages. You have to divide by the total number, not 100.

Now, EVEN if I granted your imaginary x100 factor, it would still yield only half a percent of fraudulent papers.
 
The divisor in the computation of a percentage is not always 100. It is the size of the population from which the selected items were drawn.

That's all the remedial math you get from me today. If you cannot understand how an over-unity final result absolutely determines that your method is wrong, then no amount of remediation on my part can correct your misconception.

I learned that in junior high school.
 
The divisor in the computation of a percentage is not always 100. It is the size of the population from which the selected items were drawn.

That's all the remedial math you get from me today. If you cannot understand how an over-unity final result absolutely determines that your method is wrong, then no amount of remediation on my part can correct your misconception.

And in the example the divisor was 100.
 
Here is how percent works as well.

That's such spectacularly bad math it doesn't warrant refutation. However, I will point out that once you plug in real numbers (like, for example, a few million publications), it falls flat.

I have not noticed any evidence of bias in my sources
Not surprising. However, scientists frequently (habitually) DO acknowledge biases in their sources. Scientists are well aware of the biases, and often use them as part of their analysis--for example, using the sources most biased against what they want the answer to be, or taking sources with different biases to cancel each bias out. Only crackpots think their sources are free of all bias.

If only 2000 papers studied are retracted out of the 25 million published. What is the percent of fraudulent papers that are not retracted of the 25 million papers published.
I have presented a method for estimating exactly that. Your continued refusal to do so seems to me to indicate that you know the real facts will not support your pet hypothesis.

Belz.... said:
Your x100 is imaginary.
The source openly acknowledged it. The source of the quote--by justintime's own admission--said that they ASSUMED the rate was 100x higher. They just made the number up; there is no evidence supporting this number.
 
That's why the example is wrong. Get it now?

Here is how percent works as well.

There are 100 scientists doing a test.
If 1 scientist cheats what percent of scientists are cheats? Answer 1%

method 1/100 x 100 = 1%


But for every 1 scientist who got caught for cheating a 100 more were cheating. What percent of scientists are cheaters?

method 1 x 100 = 100 now convert to percent 100 /100 x 100 = 100%. Answer 100%

Which simply means when 2 or more scientists are caught cheating, the actual number of cheaters goes off the charts into the next generation of scientists.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom