science fraud is common place

2% of scientists admit to fraud according to peer review study. For every major fraud committed a 100 goes undetected. When these numbers were presented for independent calculations.
jt512 replied. OMG 200% of science is fraudulent.

Another way to approach this is to take the total number of papers published
About 25 million papers are published. 14% of scientist are reported by their peers as guilty of fraud. what is 14% of 25million? 3,500,000 papers are fraudulent.

for every fraud a 100 goes undetected.
3.5 million papers x 100 = 350,000000. OMG 1,400% of papers are fraudulent.

If only 2000 papers studied are retracted out of the 25 million published. What is the percent of fraudulent papers that are not retracted of the 25 million papers published.

3,500,000 - 2000 retracted = 13.992% of the 25,000,000 papers are not retracted.

Only if we ignore Broad and Wades speculation for every one major fraud a 100 goes undetected. We still end up with 14% of papers are fraudulent or 3,500,000 papers.

Numerous people have shown you the arithmetic and statistics errors you have made in this analysis. Many others have belabored that it cannot be a correct analysis because it results in an over-unity answer. Repeating the same broken analysis does not correct those errors.

I have asked you about the commercial nature of your sources. I have asked you to defend them against the evidence showing them to be admittedly biased. I have asked whether you have any excuse for the legally proven fraud arising in the industry you are allowing to inform you.

Please do not distract from those questions by repeating past arguments.
 
Numerous people have shown you the arithmetic and statistics errors you have made in this analysis. Many others have belabored that it cannot be a correct analysis because it results in an over-unity answer. Repeating the same broken analysis does not correct those errors.

I have asked you about the commercial nature of your sources. I have asked you to defend them against the evidence showing them to be admittedly biased. I have asked whether you have any excuse for the legally proven fraud arising in the industry you are allowing to inform you.

Please do not distract from those questions by repeating past arguments.

My source is from a peer review survey. Here is the link again.

How Many Scientists Fabricate and Falsify Research? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Survey Data
http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0005738
 
My source is from a peer review survey. Here is the link again.

Asked and answered many times. You take the reported occurrence of fraud and from that infer that the actual rate must be much higher. That is an improper inference, as you have merely set a rate that you desire, and purport without justification that the reported figure somehow supports your desired figure.

Since your inference produces an over-unity rate of fraud, it cannot possibly be a valid inference.

Then you conflate those results with the results of a different study, assuming without justification that they can be interchanged. It has been explained to you why the results of that study differ from the one used in your extrapolation.

This all has been explained to you several times and will not be repeated. Now please stop distracting from the questions I have asked you. Answer them forthwith, if you please.
 
Last edited:
This OP is not for those who have vested interest in concealing science fraud for personal profit or are embarrassed by it. It is to make the public aware how common science fraud is and perhaps solicit their participation in stemming out this blight on the unsuspecting public and to curtail as soon as possible any future aspirations of criminal activity by the scientific community.

Some points raised by the article:



The downfall of science and the rise of intellectual tyranny

http://www.naturalnews.com/031073_science_tyranny.html

Natural News? Good old Mike Adams, the Health Ranger.

Now that we are in 2014, lets see how his 2013 predictions turned out:
1.Global economic collapse: "When record-low tax revenues are reported in April because of Obama's planned destruction of the U.S. economy, ratings organizations will downgrade U.S. debt, setting off a global selloff that could thrust America into a "nightmare" scenario of being unable to sell more debt." (Erm, does he want more or less taxes? Also, particularly funny in light of the government shutdown, brought about by Obama's opponents.)
2."Obama administration attempts to gut the Second Amendment."
3."Martial Law declared across America."
4."Extreme shortages of guns, ammo, magazines as their barter value skyrockets."
5."Tactical weapon strikes target Iran."
6."Massive false flag attack carried out in USA and blamed on patriots."
7."DHS arms the TSA and begins insane abuses of Americans on roadway checkpoints."
8."Secret resistance groups begin to form across America." (Which will be easy to verify, given that secret groups are usually well-documented, right?)
9."Attacks on the First Amendment accelerate as government seizes websites." (At least, the government will shut down NaturalNews and Alex Jones' Infowars site, apparently)
10."The rise of violent rhetoric among the population as disagreements turn to threats." (Oh the irony!)
11."Global government makes its move" – "Expect to see UN troops in U.S. cities before the end of 2015. The planned rollout of conflict in the USA is going to be followed by UN troops arriving on the scene to "rescue" the USA."
12."Accelerated mainstream media attacks on patriots, preppers and veterans." (Because self-declared patriots are peaceful people.)
13."Disagreement with the government characterized a 'mental disorder.'"
14."Continued rise in unemployment, food stamps, welfare as Obama accelerates deliberate destruction of U.S. economy."
15."Criminalization of preparedness activities as government outlaws ammo storage of private citizens." (Again)
16."Riots in the streets, followed by Martial Law." (Again)
17."Deliberate food shortages used as a weapon of government control."
18."Weather becomes even more radicalized, with droughts, floods, freezes." (And who's stopping AGW mitigation?)
19."Solar weather gets nasty: Solar flares threaten communications."
20."You will be told the answer to all our problems is "MORE government!""

Courtesy of rationalwiki.
Guess that didn't work out too well, did it?

The original was here
Of course, now that it's 2014, it has been replaced with a new article stating the Health rangers new path. Here is the very first sentence of the new article.

The article which originally appeared here has been removed because it is no longer aligned with the science-based investigative mission of Natural News.
Yup. JustinTime's hero has turned to science.

In fact, if you use this google search term, you will find that the very same update article has been pasted over no less than 284 articles at NaturalNews.

Which ones? I hear you ask. The nuttiest ones.

The Health Ranger seems to be unaware that the wayback machine exists, and it has 12 snapshots of the page in 2013 starting at 12-Jan-2013 right here.
 
The Health Ranger seems to be unaware that the wayback machine exists, and it has 12 snapshots of the page in 2013 starting at 12-Jan-2013 right here.

You mean voodoo predictions don't work? Gee, what word would describe someone who sets himself up as a guru, but revises his statements constantly as they fail scrunity, only doesn't tell anyone that's what he's doing. Asking people for money on the basis of clandestinely revised statements -- seems like fraud to me.
 
Numerous people have shown you the arithmetic and statistics errors you have made in this analysis. Many others have belabored that it cannot be a correct analysis because it results in an over-unity answer. Repeating the same broken analysis does not correct those errors.
I have solicited independent calculations so as not to appear biased and received several number crunching answers which I have listed in post#819.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9753674&postcount=819

I also presented my calculations in post#872.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9759536&postcount=872

The methods for calculating the percentages have been clearly outlined as well as the rationale behind their use. Unless someone can prove 2% x 100 is not 200%. I stand by those numbers.

I have asked you about the commercial nature of your sources. I have asked you to defend them against the evidence showing them to be admittedly biased. I have asked whether you have any excuse for the legally proven fraud arising in the industry you are allowing to inform you.

Please do not distract from those questions by repeating past arguments.
I have not noticed any evidence of bias in my sources that needs to be defended nor am I obligated to defend what is referenced in the public domain. I make no excuse for the fraud arising in the industry nor do I hold myself responsible or accountable for the scientists engaged in fraudulent activities. But I am alarmed science fraud is common place as portrayed in the OP video. Yes I am receptive to information that inform me about the status of fraud in the scientific community.

The past arguments are on record and is being referenced where applicable.
 
Natural News? Good old Mike Adams, the Health Ranger.

Now that we are in 2014, lets see how his 2013 predictions turned out:
Quote:
1.Global economic collapse: "When record-low tax revenues are reported in April because of Obama's planned destruction of the U.S. economy, ratings organizations will downgrade U.S. debt, setting off a global selloff that could thrust America into a "nightmare" scenario of being unable to sell more debt." (Erm, does he want more or less taxes? Also, particularly funny in light of the government shutdown, brought about by Obama's opponents.)
2."Obama administration attempts to gut the Second Amendment."
3."Martial Law declared across America."
4."Extreme shortages of guns, ammo, magazines as their barter value skyrockets."
5."Tactical weapon strikes target Iran."
6."Massive false flag attack carried out in USA and blamed on patriots."
7."DHS arms the TSA and begins insane abuses of Americans on roadway checkpoints."
8."Secret resistance groups begin to form across America." (Which will be easy to verify, given that secret groups are usually well-documented, right?)
9."Attacks on the First Amendment accelerate as government seizes websites." (At least, the government will shut down NaturalNews and Alex Jones' Infowars site, apparently)
10."The rise of violent rhetoric among the population as disagreements turn to threats." (Oh the irony!)
11."Global government makes its move" – "Expect to see UN troops in U.S. cities before the end of 2015. The planned rollout of conflict in the USA is going to be followed by UN troops arriving on the scene to "rescue" the USA."
12."Accelerated mainstream media attacks on patriots, preppers and veterans." (Because self-declared patriots are peaceful people.)
13."Disagreement with the government characterized a 'mental disorder.'"
14."Continued rise in unemployment, food stamps, welfare as Obama accelerates deliberate destruction of U.S. economy."
15."Criminalization of preparedness activities as government outlaws ammo storage of private citizens." (Again)
16."Riots in the streets, followed by Martial Law." (Again)
17."Deliberate food shortages used as a weapon of government control."
18."Weather becomes even more radicalized, with droughts, floods, freezes." (And who's stopping AGW mitigation?)
19."Solar weather gets nasty: Solar flares threaten communications."
20."You will be told the answer to all our problems is "MORE government!""

Courtesy of rationalwiki.
Guess that didn't work out too well, did it?
Well, now, hold on- let's apply JiT's Mad Math Skilz here and see what we can come up with:
If you assume that for, every wrong prediction, ten are right, then, obviously, the predictions were not only all correct, OMG, they were 200% correct. And, since there were 20 predictions, the whole thing was 4000% right! OMG, etc...And, since none of the predictions were retracted, you have to double that- OMG, he was 8000% correct in his predictions even when they were all wrong!

Beat that, evolutionist atheist scum!
 
Unless someone can prove 2% x 100 is not 200%. I stand by those numbers.

Asked and answered repeatedly. Unless you can explain how you can have 200 percent of an actual thing, your inferences are self-evidently bogus.

I have not noticed any evidence of bias in my sources that needs to be defended...

Irrelevant -- the evidence has been identified by others and put to you. Your unwillingness to notice evidence contrary to your beliefs is not a rebuttal. Please reconcile as asked.

...nor am I obligated to defend what is referenced in the public domain.

"Public domain" is irrelevant. You have cited these sources and implied that they are trustworthy. You are indeed obligated to answer evidence showing them not to be trustworthy. Since you decline to even acknowlege the question, it stands to reason you are aware of how compromised your sources must be and simply don't wish to face it.

I make no excuse for the fraud arising in the industry nor do I hold myself responsible or accountable for the scientists engaged in fraudulent activities.

Irrelevant. The "industry" I refer to is the natural health industry that you have alluded to and from which your sources are drawn. You are being asked to account for incidents of legally proven fraud in that industry, pursuant to an argument that you employ a double standard.

You are patently unable to do so, hence I conclude you have a double standard.

But I am alarmed science fraud is common place...

Asked and answered. You have proven no such thing occurs.

I instead am alarmed at the occurrence of legally proven fraud in the industry from which your arguments arise, and their admitted bias in reporting on mainstream science. I am further alarmed that someone who purports such a keen interest in exposing and combatting fraud is so utterly disinterested where such fraud has been proven. This tends to prove you have a double standard.

Yes I am receptive to information that inform me about the status of fraud in the scientific community.

You are being asked to account for evidence suggesting that your sources are not trustworthy when reporting on alleged fraud in the scientific community. You refuse to answer. What do you wish us to infer from your inability to answer accusations of fraud in your sources?

The past arguments are on record and is being referenced where applicable.

You are selectively citing past discussion. Since you are willing to look back in the thread but have assiduously ignored the refutations intermingled with the posts you want us to re-read, I conclude you have no answer for any of them and wish to pretend they do not exist.
 

Oh yes, your 'calculations':

The study found 2% of scientists admit to fraud. It was also reported elsewhere scientists publish under several different names to avoid detection or to enhance their chances of getting publicity. Let us give it a number say 5 different publishers or publications.
2% x5 = 10% of publications are fraudulent.

2% is a nice simple number, but then you pluck another number out of thin air by which to multiply it. Sorry, but your understanding of how percentages work is completely wrong - 2% is 2%, no matter how many publishers are involved. By your 'logic' if there are 50 publishers involved then every published article is fraudulent despite only 2% of authors publishing fraudulent work.

If we have 100 researchers publishing a paper each in 5 journals (we'll ignore, just as you have, multi-authored papers), then we have 500 papers. If 2% of of those authors have submitted consistently fraudulent papers, then this is 10 papers, not 50. If it's 1000 papers, we have 20 frauds. That is how percentages work, not how you've used them.

Once you get your head around that, you'll realise that the rest of your maths is equally useless.


The methods for calculating the percentages have been clearly outlined as well as the rationale behind their use. Unless someone can prove 2% x 100 is not 200%. I stand by those numbers.

See above.
 
Well, now, hold on- let's apply JiT's Mad Math Skilz here and see what we can come up with:
If you assume that for, every wrong prediction, ten are right, then, obviously, the predictions were not only all correct, OMG, they were 200% correct. And, since there were 20 predictions, the whole thing was 4000% right! OMG, etc...And, since none of the predictions were retracted, you have to double that- OMG, he was 8000% correct in his predictions even when they were all wrong!

Beat that, evolutionist atheist scum!

There are several problems with your math. You start out with 20 predictions and for ever wrong prediction you claim 10 are right. But you don't say how many predictions were wrong which you need to know so you can get multiples of what could be calculated as right. You don't start with a percent either but treat multiples of a number as percentage....that is quite different from what I did. Math isn't for everyone and getting predictions right is even harder.
 
There are several problems with your math.

Actually what he's doing is applying your previous method to a subject that's more near-and-dear to you, getting you to take emotional umbrage at it so you'll finally begin to see where your math goes wrong. Looks like you just supplied your own refutation.

Math isn't for everyone and getting predictions right is even harder.

Math is for me. I'm an engineer, and math is a tool I use every day. I'm legally accountable for the correctness and utility of my math. You are not.

You did it wrong, for the reasons I and others have belabored.
 
Last edited:
Oh yes, your 'calculations':



2% is a nice simple number, but then you pluck another number out of thin air by which to multiply it. Sorry, but your understanding of how percentages work is completely wrong - 2% is 2%, no matter how many publishers are involved. By your 'logic' if there are 50 publishers involved then every published article is fraudulent despite only 2% of authors publishing fraudulent work.

If we have 100 researchers publishing a paper each in 5 journals (we'll ignore, just as you have, multi-authored papers), then we have 500 papers. If 2% of of those authors have submitted consistently fraudulent papers, then this is 10 papers, not 50. If it's 1000 papers, we have 20 frauds. That is how percentages work, not how you've used them.

Once you get your head around that, you'll realise that the rest of your maths is equally useless.




See above.

But that is not the explanation I offered.
If 2% of scientists admit to fraud and for every fraud a 100 goes undetected then 2% x 100 = OMG 200% of science is fraudulent!!!
 
Justintime you are continuing to deliberately violate the 9th commandment - do you feel that it does not apply to you or that you have special reasons that allowed you to ignore it?

....Or are you not Christian as you seem to be claiming.
 
Now compare the scientific method to what Christians are required to follow.

Christians are taught:
1. You shall have no other gods before Me.
2. You shall not make idols.
3. You shall not take the name of the LORD your God in vain.
4. Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy.
5. Honor your father and your mother.
6. You shall not murder.
7. You shall not commit adultery.
8. You shall not steal.
9. You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor.
10. You shall not covet.

Scientists are taught:
The steps of the scientific method are to:

1. Ask a Question
2. Do Background Research
3. Construct a Hypothesis
4. Test Your Hypothesis by Doing an Experiment
5. Analyze Your Data and Draw a Conclusion
6. Communicate Your Results

Note: There is no mention of integrity. There is no oversight mechanism, it is all left to the individual. No thought of stealing, lying, murdering, plagiarism, honor, respect or coveting the success of others etc. etc.
whole person

It's not mentioned simply because it's not necessary. Results are always subject to reinterpretation by different hypotheses, and correlated with additional data.
Consider results communicated by Dr. Joe Blow. If those results are consistently wrong or inconsistent, then one hypothesis would be Dr. Blow is a liar. Another might be that Dr Blow is incompetent. In either case, the results will be considered useless, and won't be used by other researchers.
So Dr Blow's "results" won't have much, if any, effect on the subject of study, in the long term. OTOH, another hypothesis might be that there's some confounding variable of which Dr. Blow was unaware. And then the raw data might be useful to some later researcher, even though Dr. Blow drew possibly incorrect conclusions from it.

Science isn't about how to structure a society. It's about how to evaluate what facts about the universe are true. So it's not concerned with the people that discover the information. It's concerned with the information itself. I'm pretty sure there have been some scientists that I would heartily dislike, were I to meet them.

As a sidenote:
I've never gotten the whole "coveting" thing as a sin. I mean, it's a waste of your time, but as a sin, who is the victim? 1 through 4 you could claim God was the victim. 5 through 9 have fairly obvious human victims. But coveting? Doesn't deprive the neighbor of the coveted item's use. Doesn't waste your time any more than, say, an equivalent amount of time playing solitaire, or posting on the internet.
 
There are several problems with your math. You start out with 20 predictions and for ever wrong prediction you claim 10 are right. But you don't say how many predictions were wrong which you need to know so you can get multiples of what could be calculated as right. You don't start with a percent either but treat multiples of a number as percentage....that is quite different from what I did. Math isn't for everyone and getting predictions right is even harder.

I don't normally like debate by smilie, but this seems like the only appropriate answer here:
:duck:
(And only because I can't find a proper face-palm)
 
But that is not the explanation I offered.
If 2% of scientists admit to fraud and for every fraud a 100 goes undetected then 2% x 100 = OMG 200% of science is fraudulent!!!

You are not even trying now. That is so poor a line of unreasoning that it has overtaken realms of laughable and moved into the fast lane of sad.
 
2% of scientists admit to fraud according to peer review study. For every major fraud committed a 100 goes undetected. When these numbers were presented for independent calculations.
jt512 replied. OMG 200% of science is fraudulent.

Another way to approach this is to take the total number of papers published
About 25 million papers are published. 14% of scientist are reported by their peers as guilty of fraud. what is 14% of 25million? 3,500,000 papers are fraudulent.

for every fraud a 100 goes undetected.
3.5 million papers x 100 = 350,000000. OMG 1,400% of papers are fraudulent.

If only 2000 papers studied are retracted out of the 25 million published. What is the percent of fraudulent papers that are not retracted of the 25 million papers published.

3,500,000 - 2000 retracted = 13.992% of the 25,000,000 papers are not retracted.

Only if we ignore Broad and Wades speculation for every one major fraud a 100 goes undetected. We still end up with 14% of papers are fraudulent or 3,500,000 papers.
This is brilliantly wrong.

14% of scientists report being aware of someone committing research fraud. This doesn't mean that 14% of scientists have committed fraud. Witnesses are not criminals. I don't think I can put it any plainer than that.

You then take this incorrect figure of 14% (which actually refers to witnesses and not criminals, as it were) and pretend that these scientists are published papers. It may have escaped your notice (though god knows how it could have), but scientists and scientific papers are not the same thing.

Then you confidently state that "for every fraud a 100 goes undetected", although it's clear that this is a speculative figure. The real figure could be 2. Or 5.

And that's numberwang!

Kudos.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom