science fraud is common place

Now compare the scientific method to what Christians are required to follow.

Christians are taught:
1. You shall have no other gods before Me.
2. You shall not make idols.
3. You shall not take the name of the LORD your God in vain.
4. Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy.
5. Honor your father and your mother.
6. You shall not murder.
7. You shall not commit adultery.
8. You shall not steal.
9. You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor.
10. You shall not covet.

Scientists are taught:
The steps of the scientific method are to:

1. Ask a Question
2. Do Background Research
3. Construct a Hypothesis
4. Test Your Hypothesis by Doing an Experiment
5. Analyze Your Data and Draw a Conclusion
6. Communicate Your Results

Note: There is no mention of integrity. There is no oversight mechanism, it is all left to the individual. No thought of stealing, lying, murdering, plagiarism, honor, respect or coveting the success of others etc. etc.

Is it any wonder scientists start out with a half deck and never quite end up a whole person? :jaw-dropp

Yet you are demonstrating here that you do not follow that particular commandment - why?
 
No thought of stealing, lying, murdering, plagiarism, honor, respect or coveting the success of others etc. etc.

That's because the scientific method deals in fact. It's not a prescription for morals because it isn't meant to. And beign a social species, the don't kill stuff was a good idea even before God decided to tell us that. So again he's redundant, except for that "obey me !" stuff.
 
No it's not common place. You have never been able to show this. And since basic statistics seem to elude you, I don't think you'll ever be able to. Just give up.

This OP is not for those who have vested interest in concealing science fraud for personal profit or are embarrassed by it. It is to make the public aware how common science fraud is and perhaps solicit their participation in stemming out this blight on the unsuspecting public and to curtail as soon as possible any future aspirations of criminal activity by the scientific community.

Some points raised by the article:

In several contexts, the term "science" has become synonymous with "fraud."
The scientific community loses credibility by the day
Science may yet destroy us

The downfall of science and the rise of intellectual tyranny

http://www.naturalnews.com/031073_science_tyranny.html
 
This OP is not for those who have vested interest in concealing science fraud for personal profit or are embarrassed by it.

Oh, I see. You've finally figured out a way to dismiss your critics here who are scientists and who dispute your vilification of them. Now you're saying you don't have to listen to them because they're emotionally or financially invested.

See how much credibility gets you. It's far more likely you know you can't answer any of your critics so you need an excuse to ignore them.

It is to make the public aware how common science fraud is...

Showing pseudo-math that gives you an answer of 7000 percent, for example, is not a good way to win over the public. The general public is not typically as scientifically illiterate as are the ideologically-motivated critics of science.

...any future aspirations of criminal activity by the scientific community.

You're just raising the stakes on your hypocrisy. You happily enjoy the benefits of science, but you won't acknowledge that you do. And now scientists aren't just frauds, they're "criminals." Doesn't your use of the products you now admit are those of science constitute participation in (or at least acceptance) of that "criminal activity?"

The downfall of science and the rise of intellectual tyranny

Quoting other people's fact-free rants is no different that posting original fact-free rants of your own. Especially when you just keep quoting the same sources over and over.
 
Natural news is not known as an unbiased source do you have any independent kook website free evidence for your assertions?
 
Last edited:
Natural news is not known as an unbiased source do you have any independent kook website free evidence for your assertions?

Natural News is not only a biased source, it's one of the biggest organs of the holistic and health healing industries. That's right, I said industries.

I suspected we might be getting into this when Justintime mentioned how people are going back to natural remedies. Quite a lot of vitriol directed against mainstream science comes from the "natural healing" industry. They know they can't compete against rational medicine on effectiveness or safety, so they have to build their marketing around a moralist argument. And this requires a very healthy dose of accusing all their market competitors of criminal activity, fraud, etc. But it's not a matter of ideological supremacy; it's just business. Real doctors, medicines, etc. erode these people's business. They have to make you feel guilty for patronizing their competitors.

The hypocrisy is palpable, of course. How many of the practitioners served by the publications Justintime is using to support his claims have been actually convicted of fraud, of practicing medicine without a license, etc.? I can think of a few just in the past few years. They get marched off to jail shouting nonsense about how they've been framed, how mainstream medicine is fraudulent, how they wouldn't be persecuted if they weren't onto something.

Move along, folks. It's just not-so-clever marketing by people whose products and services are worthless and can't compete fairly.
 
Hard to find unbiased sources when so many science publishers are listed as Predatory Publishers.

Your list is of "open-source" (i.e., self-published) sources. Not the standard peer-reviewed journals that have served science for, in many cases, more than 100 years. Straw man.

One is forced to seek more moderate publications.

Explain how Natural News fits a definition of "moderate." It is the flagship publication of an industry with an avowed goal of supplanting scientific medicine with whatever their adherents claim works. Explain how that cannot be biased.
 
Last edited:
This OP is not for those who have vested interest in concealing science fraud for personal profit or are embarrassed by it.

You mean the 0.005% of science fraud ?

Do the math. 25 million articles, 2000 rejected ones, 65% of which were fraudulent. You keep ignoring the 25 million pool and focus on the 2000. You also keep assuming that the number is much higher, and confusing that study with your 14% from another source, which is not the same thing. You're also forgetting that this 14% doesn't mean what you originally claimed it meant.
 
Your list is of "open-source" (i.e., self-published) sources. Not the standard peer-reviewed journals that have served science for, in many cases, more than 100 years. Straw man.



Explain how Natural News fits a definition of "moderate." It is the flagship publication of an industry with an avowed goal of supplanting scientific medicine with whatever their adherents claim works. Explain how that cannot be biased.

Sorry to disappoint those who are expecting a source that reports favorably about science fraud. Fraud is fraud and no one is about to applaud scientists for committing fraud. Fraud is found across scientific disciplines and shows no signs of abating.
 
Sorry to disappoint those who are expecting a source that reports favorably about science fraud. Fraud is fraud and no one is about to applaud scientists for committing fraud. Fraud is found across scientific disciplines and shows no signs of abating.

At 0.005% occurance, I wager it's not particularily alarming for anyone.
 
I wonder what justintime has against fraudulent science. He considers them evil and their inventions to be negative. Fraudulent science would invent less things, wouldn't that be a net positive in justintimes universe?
 
Sorry to disappoint those who are expecting a source that reports favorably about science fraud. Fraud is fraud and no one is about to applaud scientists for committing fraud. Fraud is found across scientific disciplines and shows no signs of abating.

Are you 7000% sure of that?
 
Sorry to disappoint those who are expecting a source that reports favorably about science fraud.

Straw man and begging the question.

First, you beg the question that science is fraud. You have no argument for this premise that doesn't fall apart immediately when examined, and which never rises above "I don't know what science is, but I know I hate it." Loudly insisting that science must be fraud is not a substitute for proof.

No one is asking for "favorable" reporting of fraud in science. Instead the question is about unbiased reporting for whether fraud actually occurs. You allege that your source is unbiased, but in fact it is a fairly outspoken and rabid mouthpiece of an industry (yes, a money-making endeavor) that has explicitly set its sights upon mainstream science in an ideological sense.

That is fairly strong evidence of bias over the issue of whether science is rife with fraud. Your posts addresses none of those reasons. It simply tries to change the subject, suggesting that you know there is no way to defend the rather obvious bias in your source.

Fraud is found across scientific disciplines and shows no signs of abating.

Nope. After a dozen pages, you have provided no proof of widespread fraud in science. Just lots of insistent handwaving.

You have, however, relied increasingly upon sources attached to an industry well known for fraud. When I say "fraud" I mean actual convictions in court, not statistical handwaving.

Answer that, if you please.
 
Straw man and begging the question.

First, you beg the question that science is fraud. You have no argument for this premise that doesn't fall apart immediately when examined, and which never rises above "I don't know what science is, but I know I hate it." Loudly insisting that science must be fraud is not a substitute for proof.

No one is asking for "favorable" reporting of fraud in science. Instead the question is about unbiased reporting for whether fraud actually occurs. You allege that your source is unbiased, but in fact it is a fairly outspoken and rabid mouthpiece of an industry (yes, a money-making endeavor) that has explicitly set its sights upon mainstream science in an ideological sense.

That is fairly strong evidence of bias over the issue of whether science is rife with fraud. Your posts addresses none of those reasons. It simply tries to change the subject, suggesting that you know there is no way to defend the rather obvious bias in your source.



Nope. After a dozen pages, you have provided no proof of widespread fraud in science. Just lots of insistent handwaving.

You have, however, relied increasingly upon sources attached to an industry well known for fraud. When I say "fraud" I mean actual convictions in court, not statistical handwaving.

Answer that, if you please.

2% of scientists admit to fraud according to peer review study. For every major fraud committed a 100 goes undetected. When these numbers were presented for independent calculations.
jt512 replied. OMG 200% of science is fraudulent.

Another way to approach this is to take the total number of papers published
About 25 million papers are published. 14% of scientist are reported by their peers as guilty of fraud. what is 14% of 25million? 3,500,000 papers are fraudulent.

for every fraud a 100 goes undetected.
3.5 million papers x 100 = 350,000000. OMG 1,400% of papers are fraudulent.

If only 2000 papers studied are retracted out of the 25 million published. What is the percent of fraudulent papers that are not retracted of the 25 million papers published.

3,500,000 - 2000 retracted = 13.992% of the 25,000,000 papers are not retracted.

Only if we ignore Broad and Wades speculation for every one major fraud a 100 goes undetected. We still end up with 14% of papers are fraudulent or 3,500,000 papers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom