science fraud is common place

Add "completely lacking in humor, a sense of irony, and the capacity to understand the written word" to that. Just so no one needs to click the links, every one of those were mocking JiT's ideas by demonstrating the mathematical absurdity. I honestly didn't think it possible that JiT would take them seriously, but apparently I was wrong.

They were all showing scientific skepticism which you can call an absurdity now that there is math to back that claim.
 
Add "completely lacking in humor, a sense of irony, and the capacity to understand the written word" to that. Just so no one needs to click the links, every one of those were mocking JiT's ideas by demonstrating the mathematical absurdity. I honestly didn't think it possible that JiT would take them seriously, but apparently I was wrong.

It never occured to me that anyone but Justintime would take it as anything but satire.
 
You have my source and the numbers are taken from a peer-review study. I even solicited independent calculations from members to eliminate personal bias. And many volunteered their calculations.

jt512 wrote: OMG! 200% of science is fraudulent!
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9744168&postcount=680

Belz wrote: 25 million.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9751263&postcount=781

temporalillusion wrote: 6,500%!
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9751886&postcount=794

temporalillusion wrote: 25,000,000%!
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9752048&postcount=797

temporalillusion wrote: ∞% (which is symbol for infinity)
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9752771&postcount=815

...I wonder if you realize that, by the standard to which you want to pretend to hold "science", this post, composed as it is of equivocal misquotation is, in fact, fraudulent?
 
You have my source and the numbers are taken from a peer-review study.

No one is arguing against the numbers from the study, justintime.

Peoiple are arguing against your failed interpretation of those numbers, and your lack of understanding of what they actually mean.

Not to mention that you apparently seriously believe that you can have (for example) 200% of science be fraudulent.

Let me ask you a question, and please, I'd like to see you answer it.

If I you ate 200% of a pie, how much of that pie would you have eaten? Would it be more or less than if I you ate 100% of the pie?
Please give the answer in units of pie (i.e.-one pie, one-half pie, etc).

Or let's apply this to something else. Let's say you have $10,000...no more, no less. If you spend 50% of it, how much do you have left in dollars? If you spend 200% of it, how much do you have left?

ETA: If you'd like, I can get my 12 year old son to help here. He's covered percents and fractions in math and can understand these concepts.
 
You have my source and the numbers are taken from a peer-review study. I even solicited independent calculations from members to eliminate personal bias. And many volunteered their calculations.

jt512 wrote: OMG! 200% of science is fraudulent!
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9744168&postcount=680

Belz wrote: 25 million.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9751263&postcount=781

temporalillusion wrote: 6,500%!
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9751886&postcount=794

temporalillusion wrote: 25,000,000%!
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9752048&postcount=797

temporalillusion wrote: ∞% (which is symbol for infinity)
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9752771&postcount=815

The percentages are mocking you for completely failing to understand what a percentage is. The 25 million figure isn't from a calculation at all, but is a raw figure from one of your studies, which you conveniently keep ignoring.

In other words, this post is a monument to your complete failure to understand anything that's happening in the thread, including your own sources.
 
If someone asked me "Do you know any scientist who has committed fraud?" I would have to say yes. However, the fraud they committed had to do with accounting, not the actual scientific process--as far as the scientific process goes, this organization is actually quite good. So I'd be part of that 14%, but my results would enver add to the number of papers that contained fraud.

Certainly among college professors, shifting money from one funded project to another is common. If one project can be finished with fewer grad student man hours than anticipated, you use some of that money to pay someone who is working on a project that needs more work, or to compensate someone who worked many unpaid hours on a past project (or the same project under a previous grant). They don't think of that as fraud, as long as it is done in moderation.

Also common is claiming that something is done in an annual report when it's very clear it will be finished in a week or two.

So I would probably also answer yes, though nobody I have directly worked with has ever even considered submitting fraudulent data for publication or fraudulent claims in a grant proposal.
 
Modified said:
Certainly among college professors, shifting money from one funded project to another is common.
I can't go into details, for what should be obvious reasons. I will just say that it wasn't that--it was pretty clearly outside the bounds of what is acceptable.

To be clear, I'm a consultant. So things like grad students don't come into play, and I'm bound by federal guidelines when it comes to accounting practices.

Also common is claiming that something is done in an annual report when it's very clear it will be finished in a week or two.
Yeah, I've done that. Monthly reports get fun when they're for, say, December but the work wraps up on January 1 or 2. I just say "It's done" in the December monthly report. Technically I suppose someone could call that fraud, but when you call an accurate presentation of the state of the work fraud you've gone pretty far off the deep end.

So I would probably also answer yes, though nobody I have directly worked with has ever even considered submitting fraudulent data for publication or fraudulent claims in a grant proposal.
That's one reason we had that brief digressoin about the definition of scientific fraud up-thread. All of the fraud I've seen, by any definition, does not constitute a single instance of scientific fraud. In no case was someone presenting false data or withholding relevant data. The loose language JiT is using makes this sort of discussion problematic, to say the least.
 
No one is arguing against the numbers from the study, justintime.

Peoiple are arguing against your failed interpretation of those numbers, and your lack of understanding of what they actually mean.

Not to mention that you apparently seriously believe that you can have (for example) 200% of science be fraudulent.

Let me ask you a question, and please, I'd like to see you answer it.

If I you ate 200% of a pie, how much of that pie would you have eaten? Would it be more or less than if I you ate 100% of the pie?
Please give the answer in units of pie (i.e.-one pie, one-half pie, etc).

Or let's apply this to something else. Let's say you have $10,000...no more, no less. If you spend 50% of it, how much do you have left in dollars? If you spend 200% of it, how much do you have left?

ETA: If you'd like, I can get my 12 year old son to help here. He's covered percents and fractions in math and can understand these concepts.

Please read my post again. All the raw numbers came from a peer-review study and members volunteered their number crunching skills making this a totally independent unbiased exercise. I tried to put into context their numbers. Even allowing a +- 5% error in their calculations the numbers are so staggering some new quantum theory is required to explain how common science fraud has become and will be in the future.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9753674&postcount=819
 
Please read my post again. All the raw numbers came from a peer-review study and members volunteered their number crunching skills making this a totally independent unbiased exercise. I tried to put into context their numbers. Even allowing a +- 5% error in their calculations the numbers are so staggering some new quantum theory is required to explain how common science fraud has become and will be in the future.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9753674&postcount=819

We've all read it and came to the conclusion that you don't understand numbers and especially percentages beyond a grade school level.

We further understand that you willfully and repeatedly misrepresent what these number mean.


You're busted. Deal with it.
 
Please read my post again.
Please read the entire thread again. You seem to have missed...well, all of it really.

All the raw numbers came from a peer-review study and members a member volunteered their number crunching skills making this a totally independent unbiased exercise in order to demonstrate just how badly I'm failing to understand things.
Fixed that for you.

I tried to put into context their numbers.
And if you actually understood the context this would have been very helpful.

Even allowing a +- 5% error in their calculations
You're gonna need a bigger error bar than that.

the numbers are so staggering some new quantum theory is required to explain how common science fraud has become and will be in the future.
I propose we call it the Quantum Theory of Bull Poop.

(And now to check "quantum" off of the bingo card)
 
Last edited:
Belz arrived at 25 million.

I "arrived" at 25 million ? I'm repeating the ACTUAL number of papers, trying to put your ridiculously small number in perspective. You keep ignoring that number because it does not fit your preconceived ideas.

Given such high numbers, the authors of 'Betrayers of truth' Broad and Wade should not have called it a speculation. They should have labeled it a prediction.

What the hell are you on about ?

I wonder if most of the retracted fraudulent peer-reviewed papers end up in the public domain because they are worthless and therefore made available for free.

What about the other 24,998,000 ?
 
65% of 2000 papers studied were found fraudulent.

No, 65% of 2000 out of 25 million papers studied were found fraudulent. A quick calc makes it 0.0052%. That's not a lot.

But for every major fraud exposed a 100 goes undetected.

That is an unsupported assertion.

According to Belz 25million papers were published.

Not according to me. Do you have Dinwar on ignore ?

Now according to another study 2% of scientists admit to fraud. But when scientists are asked about their colleagues the admission number jumped to 14% suspected of committing fraud.

Even if we were to grant that this was all true, it's still a far cry from 65%.

jt512 offered his math. OMG! 200% of science is fraudulent!

That's a conclusion based on your ridiculous logic, not reality.
 
Lets try it this way. 25 million papers published. 14% of scientist are reported by their peers as guilty of fraud. what is 14% of 25million? 3,500,000 papers are fraudulent.

for every fraud a 100 goes undetected.
3.5 million papers x 100 = 350,000000. OMG 1,400% of papers are fraudulent.

No, Justintime. You just have no mathematical ability.

You cannot take that 14% speculation and move it to another metric, like that.
 
It is no longer a question are scientists fallible? 65% of papers studied were found to be fraudulent. Scientists are more than fallible they are willing to commit fraud to enhance their careers. Are scientists any different from the common criminal? What they have in common with them is the willingness to commit fraud.

Does higher education reduce criminal behavior? The survey presented found the more established and senior scientists were more likely to commit fraud. That certainly goes against common wisdom and behavioral studies.

Do scientist admit guilt when caught? It appears only 2% of scientist admit to fraud. 14% of scientists are reported by their peers/colleagues suspected of fraud. But by not admitting to it go undetected.

The ethical and moral social norms are replaced in the scientific community by an adherence to the scientific method which absolves them from fraudulent behavior. They are to be judged by their peers and a methodology developed to account for human failing in a scientific way. Scientists are not ordinary criminals. They are a special breed of criminals because they don't intend to deceive the public but only their peers and their sacred trust to adhere to the scientific method.

Science fraud is so common we should apply the existing laws to charge them with fraud and criminal activity with no exceptions. The scientific method is not an excuse for their failing....it is the cause for their failings.
 
Last edited:
You have my source and the numbers are taken from a peer-review study.

Yes but you seem unable to comprehend your own links, as demonstrated by your ridiculous reading of the 14% number.

Even allowing a +- 5% error in their calculations the numbers are so staggering some new quantum theory is required to explain how common science fraud has become and will be in the future.

Or, more likely, you just don't understand what you're reading.

Or, you're not serious.
 
It is no longer a question are scientists fallible? 65% of papers studied were found to be fraudulent.

That is a lie. I showed you that it's 0.005%, not 65%. That's an error of a factor of 10,000 by you.

Scientists are more that fallible they are willing to commit fraud to enhance their careers. Are scientists any different from the common criminal?

Yes. They don't break the law. What a stupid question.

Do scientist admit guilt when caught? It appears only 2% of scientist admit to fraud.

Why do you assume that the actual number would be much higher ? Also, do you know what is meant by "fraud' in this context ?

14% of scientists are reported by their peers/colleagues suspected of fraud.

No. This has been explained to you: 14% of scientists polled said they knew someone who commited fraud, in their opinion.

The ethical and moral social norms are replaced in the scientific community by an adherence to the scientific method which absolves them from fraudulent behavior.

No, it's just you not understanding what you read.

They are to be judged by their peers and a methodology developed to account for human failing in a scientific way. Scientists are not ordinary criminals. They are a special breed of criminals because they don't intend to deceive the public but only their peers and their sacred trust to adhere to the scientific method.

Stop trolling.
 
Last edited:
...
Science fraud is so common we should apply the existing laws to charge them with fraud and criminal activity with no exceptions. The scientific method is not an excuse for their failing....it is the cause for their failings.

You know justintime, what you should do? You should study to becomes a layweress so thats you can go after all of thems.
You'll show them all .... woohhahahahaha


Right now, not a chance.
 
It's like if someone asked a thousand people, out of a million population, whether they knew someone who has a white car, and 80% of them answered yes; Justintime would claim that 80% of humans have a white car. :rolleyes:
 
You know justintime, what you should do? You should study to becomes a layweress so thats you can go after all of thems.
You'll show them all .... woohhahahahaha

Right now, not a chance.

Careful, he sounds rather like a young Ken Cuccinelli in training.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom