science fraud is common place

I have provided methods for estimating the rate of undetected frauds. I note that you continue to refuse to actually follow anything resembling a reasonable protocol for estimating that number, and instead prefer to ramble on about pure fantasy numbers as if they were actually data.

Penn and Teller's Showtime show includes an episode on numbers. I'd highly recommend that to anyone reading justintime's post.

You did not address my point. "In Betrayers of the Truth, Broad and Wade speculate that for every major of case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected."

For every science fraud that gets exposed a 100 go undetected. SO if only 1% of science fraud gets exposed how many can we extrapolate goes undetected....you do the math.

"In Betrayers of the Truth, Broad and Wade speculate that for every major of case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected, and that for each major case, another 1000 lesser violations are committed."
http://ischoollmpiadozo.wordpress.com/fraud-in-science/
 
justintime said:
You are distorting the survey.
It is not possible that you can believe that this is true. You said that 65% of retractions were due to fraud. I'm asking how many papers total were published in that period. Since the assertion of this thread is "science fraud is common place", it is n ot sufficient that you present merely the percentage of retracted papers that involved fraud--you must prove that the papers involving fraud represent a significant number of the TOTAL NUMBER OF PAPERS PUBLISHED.

To present this 65% number without reference to the total number of papers is dishonest. To suggest that this was a random sampling of papers, rather than a random sampling of a specific subset of scientific papers, is also dishonest. Both can be considered fraud.
 
justintime said:
You did not address my point.
Yes, I did. You are SPECULATING that 1% of fraud is uncovered. I've provided a means of ESTIMATING it. Of the two, only estimations have anything of rigor. Speculation is useless in science.

The fact that you feel that speculation is higher-quality data than estimations tells us all we need to know about your understanding of science, and the value of your opinion on the topic.
 
It is not possible that you can believe that this is true. You said that 65% of retractions were due to fraud. I'm asking how many papers total were published in that period. Since the assertion of this thread is "science fraud is common place", it is n ot sufficient that you present merely the percentage of retracted papers that involved fraud--you must prove that the papers involving fraud represent a significant number of the TOTAL NUMBER OF PAPERS PUBLISHED.

To present this 65% number without reference to the total number of papers is dishonest. To suggest that this was a random sampling of papers, rather than a random sampling of a specific subset of scientific papers, is also dishonest. Both can be considered fraud.

The survey only included 2000 papers out of which 65% were retracted because of poor ethical judgment. There is no suggestion of bias in the sampling. But the survey resulted in some recommendations.

"In light of these findings, researchers and other observers have proposed several initiatives to help the scientific community with its apparent honesty issues. One suggestion was the creation a Retraction Index. Unlike the Impact Factor, which is based on a journal’s citation rate, the Retraction Index would indicate the number of retractions a journal has for every 1,000 papers published....."
http://www.the-scientist.com/?articles.view/articleNo/33695/title/Top-Science-Scandals-of-2012/
 
Last edited:
Yes, I did. You are SPECULATING that 1% of fraud is uncovered. I've provided a means of ESTIMATING it. Of the two, only estimations have anything of rigor. Speculation is useless in science.

The fact that you feel that speculation is higher-quality data than estimations tells us all we need to know about your understanding of science, and the value of your opinion on the topic.

Where did you address my point??

"In Betrayers of the Truth, Broad and Wade speculate that for every major of case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected, and that for each major case, another 1000 lesser violations are committed."
http://ischoollmpiadozo.wordpress.com/fraud-in-science/"

SO if only 1% of science fraud gets exposed how many can we extrapolate goes undetected....you do the math.
 
Dinwar:

I suspect his claim of "65% of 2000" is simply a repeat of his earlier mirepresentation/innumeracy. The study found that 65% of the papers retracted were retracted for fraud, not 65% of the papers sampled. It's the same study that actually shows the rate of fraud as that less than 1% of 1%.

Unless justintime has a link to the source for his claim of a 65% fraud rate being detected? I'm more than willing to be corrected, if you have any actual evidence.
 
Where did you address my point??

"In Betrayers of the Truth, Broad and Wade speculate that for every major of case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected, and that for each major case, another 1000 lesser violations are committed."
http://ischoollmpiadozo.wordpress.com/fraud-in-science/"

SO if only 1% of science fraud gets exposed how many can we extrapolate goes undetected....you do the math.

In Betrayers of the Truth, Broad and Wade speculate that for every major of case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected, and that for each major case, another 1000 lesser violations are committed. Aside from such guesses, however, or indications in surveys, exact figures do not exist

I've posted the exact quote from the cut-n-paste in that crap journal you referenced, with appropriate highlighing.
 
Where did you address my point??

When I pointed out the fact that it's based on speculation. Since your point is based on nothing but someone's fantasy, your point is unsupported by evidence and can therefore be dismissed. This counts as addressing a point in scientific discussions.

I have gone further by pointing out that I've provide a rigorous methodology for estimating the numbers that are thus far merely speculative, and the fact that you cower away from such rigor, preferring to cling to baseless and unsupported speculation.

The survey only included 2000 papers out of which 65% were retracted because of poor ethical judgment. There is no suggestion of bias in the sampling.
Given the number of lies you've told, I don't believe you. I strongly suspect (see below) that those 2,000 papers were not randomly sampled, but were rather sampled from the subset "retracted papers".

This is nothing more than you fraudulantly and dishonestly attmepting to convince us that 65% of all papers are fraudulant, ignoring the fact that the data actually show that 65% of the retracted papers (<1% of all papers) included fraud.

What this means is that you are guilty of the crime for which you wish to dismantle all of science. To be consistent, you should put YOURSELF on trial for fraud. When you put yourself on trial, I'll believe you're actually serious--until then, you're just running your mouth, attacking something you can't understand because it makes you feel bad.

Hellbound said:
I suspect his claim of "65% of 2000" is simply a repeat of his earlier mirepresentation/innumeracy. The study found that 65% of the papers retracted were retracted for fraud, not 65% of the papers sampled. It's the same study that actually shows the rate of fraud as that less than 1% of 1%.
I don't doubt that you're right.
 
Given the number of lies you've told, I don't believe you. I strongly suspect (see below) that those 2,000 papers were not randomly sampled, but were rather sampled from the subset "retracted papers".

No need to guess:
(...) lead author Arturo Casadevall at Albert Einstein College of Medicine and his colleagues identified more than 2,000 articles listed in Pubmed as retracted since the first identified article was retracted in 1977.

http://www.the-scientist.com/?articles.view/articleNo/32687/title/Fraud-Breeds-Retractions/
 
It's intellectual dishonesty at the least.

Well, I was actually intending to direct that to justintime, with his unusually broad band of what defines scientific fraud (the researcher got a traffic fine on the way to the lab...FRAUD!).

But yeah, at best it reveals a complete lack of competency to read and comprehend English. At worst it reveals a specific intent to manipulate people into a certain point of view with an utter disregard for the very truth and integrity one claims to be championing.

I know which bet I'd take*


*-Both!
 
Dinwar:

I suspect his claim of "65% of 2000" is simply a repeat of his earlier mirepresentation/innumeracy. The study found that 65% of the papers retracted were retracted for fraud, not 65% of the papers sampled. It's the same study that actually shows the rate of fraud as that less than 1% of 1%.

Unless justintime has a link to the source for his claim of a 65% fraud rate being detected? I'm more than willing to be corrected, if you have any actual evidence.

Read the article again. It is exactly as I quoted it.

http://www.the-scientist.com/?articles.view/articleNo/33695/title/Top-Science-Scandals-of-2012/

"In fact, more than 65 percent of the 2,000 or so papers studied were retracted because of poor ethical judgment. "

How many papers were studied ? 2000
What percentage were retracted ? 65%

Put that together.
In fact, more than 65 percent of the 2,000 or so papers studied were retracted because of poor ethical judgment.
 
Read the article again. It is exactly as I quoted it.

http://www.the-scientist.com/?articles.view/articleNo/33695/title/Top-Science-Scandals-of-2012/

"In fact, more than 65 percent of the 2,000 or so papers studied were retracted because of poor ethical judgment. "

How many papers were studied ? 2000
What percentage were retracted ? 65%

Put that together.
In fact, more than 65 percent of the 2,000 or so papers studied were retracted because of poor ethical judgment.
"Of the papers studied". These are papers that were retracted, not a random sampling of published papers.
 
"Of the papers studied". These are papers that were retracted, not a random sampling of published papers.

There was no suggestion of bias, all 2,047 biomedical and life-science research articles indexed by PubMed as retracted on May 3, 2012 were studied to arrive at the statistics which:

" revealed that only 21.3% of retractions were attributable to error. In contrast, 67.4% of retractions were attributable to misconduct, including fraud or suspected fraud (43.4%), duplicate publication (14.2%), and plagiarism (9.8%). Incomplete, uninformative or misleading retraction announcements have led to a previous underestimation of the role of fraud in the ongoing retraction epidemic. The percentage of scientific articles retracted because of fraud has increased ∼10-fold since 1975. Retractions exhibit distinctive temporal and geographic patterns that may reveal underlying causes. "

Out of the different retracted publications biomedical and life-science were randomly picked for the study.

Related citations in PubMed

1. Retracted publications in the drug literature.[Pharmacotherapy. 2012]
2. Retractions in the scientific literature: is the incidence of research fraud increasing?[J Med Ethics. 2011]
3. Retractions in the research literature: misconduct or mistakes?
 
Last edited:
This is nothing more than you fraudulantly and dishonestly attmepting to convince us that 65% of all papers are fraudulant, ignoring the fact that the data actually show that 65% of the retracted papers (<1% of all papers) included fraud.

See, you are trying to analyze these numbers using math. Math is part of the corrupt world of science and logic, and the methods of logic themselves are invalid. According to the corrupt scientific method "65% of 0.001%" is much less than "65%", but that's the sort of high flung dung that justintime won't brook.

Justintime is reporting the conclusions of his own special unscientific method. According to this method, 65% of papers are fraudulent, because 0.001% plus Leviticus 3:12 equals tofurkey. Therefore 65%. QED. This conclusion is uncontaminated by high-flung science and its corrupt methodology.
 
There was no suggestion of bias, all 2,047 biomedical and life-science research articles indexed by PubMed as retracted on May 3, 2012 were studied to arrive at the statistics which:

" revealed that only 21.3% of retractions were attributable to error. In contrast, 67.4% of retractions were attributable to misconduct, including fraud or suspected fraud (43.4%), duplicate publication (14.2%), and plagiarism (9.8%). Incomplete, uninformative or misleading retraction announcements have led to a previous underestimation of the role of fraud in the ongoing retraction epidemic. The percentage of scientific articles retracted because of fraud has increased ∼10-fold since 1975. Retractions exhibit distinctive temporal and geographic patterns that may reveal underlying causes. "

Out of the different retracted publications biomedical and life-science were randomly picked for the study.

To repeat the point- it's not 65% of papers, but 65% of retracted papers. There is a vast difference, which you seem to want to gloss over.
 
How many papers total on PubMed since 1977?

EDIT: Wikipedia says 2.7 million. 1380 of them retract due to misconduct. That's what, 0.05%?

justintime's freaking out over 0.05%? Crazy.
 
Last edited:
To repeat the point- it's not 65% of papers, but 65% of retracted papers. There is a vast difference, which you seem to want to gloss over.


I can't tell if justintime's being deliberately dishonest, or if he's actually having trouble understanding the numbers. Probably a little of both.
 
I can't tell if justintime's being deliberately dishonest, or if he's actually having trouble understanding the numbers. Probably a little of both.

There were other retracted publications which I have listed earlier.

Note: Out of the different retracted publications biomedical and life-science were randomly picked for the study.

Related citations in PubMed

1. Retracted publications in the drug literature.[Pharmacotherapy. 2012]
2. Retractions in the scientific literature: is the incidence of research fraud increasing?[J Med Ethics. 2011]
3. Retractions in the research literature: misconduct or mistakes?

And out of the 2000 papers studies 65% were retracted because of poor ethical judgment.

Original quote from article. "In fact, more than 65 percent of the 2,000 or so papers studied were retracted because of poor ethical judgment. "
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom