Maartenn100 said:
I think that Justintime, myself and all the other people here just want one thing:
That science is what it must be: the scientific method.
If you understood enough about science to legitimately criticize it, you'd know why anyone making this statement is incompetent in science. You're trying to tie down science to the level of that presented in middle school. Reality is far, far, FAR more complex.
The rest of your post is nonsense, for numerous reasons. It's the clearest demonstration yet of why your opinions on science should be discarded without further consideration. You basically want science without the scientists! For example: double-blind reviews wouldn't help (if you could even set up such a thing). Once you get to the day-to-day work of scientists, you find that there are limited numbers of people in any field. I believe I've met, if not all, than at least the overwhelming majority of decapod paleontologists on the planet. I had supper with them a few times--ALL of them, at once. Similarly, there are only a few people who do research on, say, Martian stratigraphy. Given the fact that only so many people could possibly review your papers, there's simply no way to prevent the reviewers and authors from knowing who said what. It's too easy to tell from the writing style.
As for the computer idea, it's nonsense. No computer could possibly review a paper. It's impossible. Even a simple argument in science requires a tremendous number of interconnecting ideas, and so far only a human can perform that task. There's also issues of non-shared knowledge--even among experts, even in relatively small fields, some people will know things others don't. That's a useful and important part of science as it actually is practiced. "Have you considered ____'s publication?" is an important statement in science, one that every researcher appreciates but most non-scientists don't even know about. Then you get into issues like different paradigms. I work for a strict uniformitarian, while I myself an a neocatastraphist. It's fun to get us talking about ecological shifts; we can look at the same data and come to very different conclusions, both of which are perfectly reasonable. That's something a computer wouldn't be able to handle.
As I have argued repeatedly in the past, for the scientific process as it currently stands, content IS the only thing that matters--in the long term. Eventually the frauds are discovered; eventually prestige wanes and only the data and logic matter. However, science isn't always fast. This process may take years, decades; it may take longer than the life of any individual researcher. Still, it is inevitable--so long as researchers are free to follow the data wherever they lead, frauds WILL be outed, and bad data and arguments WILL be discovered. Your complaints boil down to "I don't want to wait that long."
Instead of speculating blindly about how science should be re-built from the ground up, why don't you take some time to learn how science is actually done? Even if you do so from the perspective of looking for ways to change it, it'll be very educational to you.