science fraud is common place

I was just reading some old posts in a now locked thread, and came across this post.


It seems the argument is between two fallacies here. the first is that science fraud is rampant and common place. It happens all the time, everywhere.

The other fallacy is that it hardly ever happens, and when it does it is promptly dealt with somehow.

I don't believe either position.

Fortunately, reality is unfazed by what you choose to believe or disbelieve.
 
I am performing my civic duty by alerting the general public how common science fraud is and by supporting Maartenn100 in his endeavor to do the same.

Clearly, your 'civic duty' only goes so far. It stops short of actually doing something 'meaningful', you know, for the public.
You're not really serving the public very well by yelling fraud but clearly not willing to step up, you know, for the public.

No no, not you, others have to do that:
... the non-scientific population to bring criminal charges. ...


You wouldn't dare to step up.

:rolleyes:
 
Shoud this thread be moved to CT?

I would say yes, but it has gone so far, and has so many contributory responses that it would be difficult to separate the CT from the original thread.
 
I would say yes, but it has gone so far, and has so many contributory responses that it would be difficult to separate the CT from the original thread.

I said it before. Skeptics are caught between a rock and a hard place. They embrace the scientific method only to discover here science is fraught with fraud committed by scientists who adopted the scientific method as the basis for their discipline. It is not CT but exposure of willful deception by the scientific community.
 
I said it before. Skeptics are caught between a rock and a hard place. They embrace the scientific method only to discover here science is fraught with fraud committed by scientists who adopted the scientific method as the basis for their discipline. It is not CT but exposure of willful deception by the scientific community.

Your post above, clearly indicates CT.
 
I am performing my civic duty by alerting the general public how common science fraud is and by supporting Maartenn100 in his endeavor to do the same.
Except you haven't alerted anyone to how common science fraud is. To do that you would need to actually give a number for the amount of known science fraud, and you haven't done so. The best you've done is to show that science fraud has happened at least a handful of times--something the general public is already pretty well aware of.
 
I said it before. Skeptics are caught between a rock and a hard place. They embrace the scientific method only to discover here science is fraught with fraud committed by scientists who adopted the scientific method as the basis for their discipline. It is not CT but exposure of willful deception by the scientific community.

The problem is you have been caught lying before, so no one with any sense is going to believe you.

Remember: Your credibility is not a boomerang. When you throw it away, it's not coming back.
 
r-j said:
It seems the argument is between two fallacies here. the first is that science fraud is rampant and common place. It happens all the time, everywhere.

The other fallacy is that it hardly ever happens, and when it does it is promptly dealt with somehow.
Good, because that second position is what's called a "straw man argument".

What has been argued is that science is, given a long enough timeline, self-correcting; that it is the best tool we have for detecting fraud; and that scientific fraud is rare compared to fraud rates in other fields.

justintime said:
I am performing my civic duty by alerting the general public how common science fraud is and by supporting Maartenn100 in his endeavor to do the same.
Never mind the fact that you flat-out refuse to actually provide data to support your idea, your definition of fraud is self-serving and dishonest, and you consistently fail to differentiate between legitimate sources and obviously biased ones.

Sorry, but if anyone thinks YOU are capable of detecting fraud they aren't educated enough to comment on science at all.

It isn't going to be any easier for an independent public body to conduct the same oversight.
The fact that every single practicing scientist acts to conduct independent oversight still eludes you, eh? Funny how you can't respond to that statement.
 

Maybe Paul Brookes can learn some lessons from the way JREF members deal with their disenfranchisement with the scientific community over science fraud and how common place it has become.

JREF has a track record on exposing pseudoskeptics, pseudoscience and now science fraud. There is no need for inflammatory language, scientific fraud is despicable enough and the low esteem scientists are held at by the general public is criminally disgraceful.

We don't need to subject people who make serious attempts to make a science of educated guesses and speculation to arbitrary allegations of fraud. The percentage of exposed cases of fraud coupled with a higher percentage allowed to slip through is convincing enough scientists will go to any lengths to both conceal and defend their profession. The better educated the scientists the better will he argue to defend his colleagues. As Dr Shermer noted. "Smart people believe weird things because they are skilled at defending their beliefs." and that applies to scientists as well.
 
justintime said:
The percentage of exposed cases of fraud coupled with a higher percentage allowed to slip through is convincing enough scientists will go to any lengths to both conceal and defend their profession.
The only data provided is the rates of fraud in medical publications, and that's less than 1% of 1%. The rate of undetected frauds can be rigorously demonstrated. When you put that level of effort in, come tell us. Otherwise, you're just asserting this without support.

The better educated the scientists the better will he argue to defend his colleagues.
What you ignore is that they also are much better at ATTACKING their colleagues. This is something that you've completely ignored.
 
Justintime,

Could you please address Dinwar's concerns? Otherwise, you are just stating your unsubstantiated beliefs and this does not move the conversation forward.
 
I think that Justintime, myself and all the other people here just want one thing:

That science is what it must be: the scientific method. An objective, neutral method. A method wich excludes biases of all sorts. Every form of subjectivity must be excluded.

That's the scientific method itself.

No group of elite scientists who have more chance to get their articles published than a beginning young unknown scientist, for example.

Because the journal will have more readers with famous or popular scientists. Or it's better for the reputation of the journal. With names of famous universities.


But for the scientific method, only the validity of the content matters.

So, it's very important to exclude all these other factors, by using a system wich is free of all these poiitical or human influences,

No need for more money, no title to defend, no competetion, no paper from university x is more favorable than from university y, no reputation to defend, no economic reasons.

No human factors. No conflicts of intrests.

A double blind test of the content of the paper without knowing from who it comes is more favorable.

Only the scientific research itself is important. Only the content. That's the scientific method.

We all want this.


It would be better to build a robot or supercomputer to validate new theories on their logic consistancy or evidence based postulates. No humans are involved.
No competitor in your field has to decide wether your idea is good or false.

The outcome is true or false with detailed feedback. Neutral.
No subjectivity anymore.

Your idea must not even be in line with current theories.
Only logic consistancy and evidence based premisses. That's all.

That would be a very good filter, in my opinion.
 
Last edited:
Maartenn100 said:
I think that Justintime, myself and all the other people here just want one thing:

That science is what it must be: the scientific method.
If you understood enough about science to legitimately criticize it, you'd know why anyone making this statement is incompetent in science. You're trying to tie down science to the level of that presented in middle school. Reality is far, far, FAR more complex.

The rest of your post is nonsense, for numerous reasons. It's the clearest demonstration yet of why your opinions on science should be discarded without further consideration. You basically want science without the scientists! For example: double-blind reviews wouldn't help (if you could even set up such a thing). Once you get to the day-to-day work of scientists, you find that there are limited numbers of people in any field. I believe I've met, if not all, than at least the overwhelming majority of decapod paleontologists on the planet. I had supper with them a few times--ALL of them, at once. Similarly, there are only a few people who do research on, say, Martian stratigraphy. Given the fact that only so many people could possibly review your papers, there's simply no way to prevent the reviewers and authors from knowing who said what. It's too easy to tell from the writing style.

As for the computer idea, it's nonsense. No computer could possibly review a paper. It's impossible. Even a simple argument in science requires a tremendous number of interconnecting ideas, and so far only a human can perform that task. There's also issues of non-shared knowledge--even among experts, even in relatively small fields, some people will know things others don't. That's a useful and important part of science as it actually is practiced. "Have you considered ____'s publication?" is an important statement in science, one that every researcher appreciates but most non-scientists don't even know about. Then you get into issues like different paradigms. I work for a strict uniformitarian, while I myself an a neocatastraphist. It's fun to get us talking about ecological shifts; we can look at the same data and come to very different conclusions, both of which are perfectly reasonable. That's something a computer wouldn't be able to handle.

As I have argued repeatedly in the past, for the scientific process as it currently stands, content IS the only thing that matters--in the long term. Eventually the frauds are discovered; eventually prestige wanes and only the data and logic matter. However, science isn't always fast. This process may take years, decades; it may take longer than the life of any individual researcher. Still, it is inevitable--so long as researchers are free to follow the data wherever they lead, frauds WILL be outed, and bad data and arguments WILL be discovered. Your complaints boil down to "I don't want to wait that long."

Instead of speculating blindly about how science should be re-built from the ground up, why don't you take some time to learn how science is actually done? Even if you do so from the perspective of looking for ways to change it, it'll be very educational to you.
 
Justintime,

Could you please address Dinwar's concerns? Otherwise, you are just stating your unsubstantiated beliefs and this does not move the conversation forward.

The numbers are so alarming that the UK government has introduced new policies to curb the damage it is doing to their reputation and competitiveness as a global researcher.
The bad science scandal: how fact-fabrication is damaging UK's global name for research.
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/s...ing-uks-global-name-for-research-8660929.html

As for actual numbers of fraud committed, concealed, escaped detection or were just ignored is substantial. One article stated 65 percent of the 2,000 or so papers studied were retracted because of poor ethical judgment(2012).

Other studies indicate over 30% of the people queried said they were aware of someone they knew committing scientific fraud.
Another study reveals. "about a quarter of what the observers believed to be misconduct in the survey was by postdoctoral fellows, and about 22 percent was by a professor or senior scientist. "

If as earlier studies reported 1% of the fraud was discovered when the science fraud survey was initiated and there is a 10 fold increase in recent years. That would put the number at 10% today. For every science fraud that gets exposed a 100 go undetected. SO if only 1% of science fraud gets exposed how many can we extrapolate goes undetected....you do the math.

"In Betrayers of the Truth, Broad and Wade speculate that for every major of case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected, and that for each major case, another 1000 lesser violations are committed."
http://ischoollmpiadozo.wordpress.com/fraud-in-science/
 
justintime said:
As for actual numbers of fraud committed, concealed, escaped detection or were just ignored is substantial. One article stated 65 percent of the 2,000 or so papers studied were retracted because of poor ethical judgment(2012).
What percentage of papers were retracted? If it's 65% of 0.01% of all papers published, we're still talking negligible numbers. There are also alternative explanations for this number (only 45% of retracted papers are retracted for reasons other than fraud, including errors in research methodology, errors in interepteting the results, etc).

Anyone have the stats on how many papers Einstein retracted?

Other studies indicate over 30% of the people queried said they were aware of someone they knew committing scientific fraud.
Odd how you accept "I know this guy who did this thing" as a valid argument, but not rigorous methodology.

If as earlier studies reported 1% of the fraud was discovered when the science fraud survey was initiated and there is a 10 fold increase in recent years.
And if horses pooped apples I could make pies out of it. This ten-fold increase is pure fantasy.

SO if only 1% of science fraud gets exposed how many can we extrapolate goes undetected....you do the math.
I have provided methods for estimating the rate of undetected frauds. I note that you continue to refuse to actually follow anything resembling a reasonable protocol for estimating that number, and instead prefer to ramble on about pure fantasy numbers as if they were actually data.

Penn and Teller's Showtime show includes an episode on numbers. I'd highly recommend that to anyone reading justintime's post.
 
Originally Posted by justintime
As for actual numbers of fraud committed, concealed, escaped detection or were just ignored is substantial. One article stated 65 percent of the 2,000 or so papers studied were retracted because of poor ethical judgment(2012).

What percentage of papers were retracted? If it's 65% of 0.01% of all papers published, we're still talking negligible numbers. There are also alternative explanations for this number (only 45% of retracted papers are retracted for reasons other than fraud, including errors in research methodology, errors in interepteting the results, etc).

Anyone have the stats on how many papers Einstein retracted?

You are distorting the survey. Note: Out of 2000 papers or so studied 65% were retracted because of poor ethical judgement. The survey did not investigate all the research papers for that period. But out of the 2000 or so papers they investigated 65% were retracted. We are dealing with specifics here of random sampling.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom