Francesca R
Girl
I don't think it does release [companies] from all or some of their debts--it merely delays the requirement to pay while the firm reorganises.Yes, I believe that any company that gets bankruptcy protection releasing them from all or some of their debts is receiving a benefit from society (from the courts to be precise).
I think it's wrong that they be allowed to do that AND pay their investors an 800% return on their investment while costing hundreds of people their jobs. (I'm assuming the facts as presented in the Bloomberg article are correct and we're just discussing how to characterize them.)
It seems that Bain still owned a 35% stake of equity of Ampad when it filed (factcheck), and that, since the stock was delisted at that time, Bain lost all of that. Equity owners are normally last in line to be paid out, after creditors. But as above, bankruptcy procedures do not involve reaching back in time and clawing back some of the proceeds of owners who sold their stake in the past, nor doing the same to creditors who had already been paid. Much of Bain's return falls into those categories. If it was also a creditor at the time of bankruptcy (fees etc.), I don't know how whole it was able to be paid on such amounts.Yes, I think it is possible to tighten up regulations so that people enjoying the benefits of bankruptcy protection from their creditors aren't able to walk away with massive profits (or perhaps the other way around: people realizing a huge capital gain like this should not be allowed to get bankruptcy protection).