Romney’s Bain Yielded Private Gains, Socialized Losses

I agree it was a big omission, and Francesca was right to ask for that part, but it does seem he has now provided it. Why is it still significant that it wasn't provided in the OP?
See above. I don't see how a mandatory pension scheme insurance premium amounts to socialising losses.

I think socialising losses means that the taxpayer takes the hit somehow. And I think most people understand this too. So I think the thread title is inaccurate so far.
 
And where is/was the call on the state (taxpayer)?

Compulsory pension scheme insurance doesn't make the losses socialised any more than compulsory vehicle insurance does.

I disagree. We've just seen that the legal definition of tax can be pretty broad. I have no problem with seing compulsory contributions (by anyone) to a government investment protection agency as a tax. [ETA: There is no comparable government entity insuring autos.]

I think a more important question is, how did the fund become underinvested? Did Bain raid the pension? Did previous management do so and Bain counted on the "socialized" insurer taking up that slack so they could still profit from taking over the company?
 
Last edited:
I disagree. We've just seen that the legal definition of tax can be pretty broad. I have no problem with seing compulsory contributions (by anyone) to investment protection insurance as a tax.
I find that pretty unuseful. On that score, any employer who fires anybody is privatising gains and socialising losses. Therefore there are no grounds to attack private equity funds for it, except for apparently finding the numbers offensive, not the practice itself. In which case the thread title is not a critique of anything.
 
See above. I don't see how a mandatory pension scheme insurance premium amounts to socialising losses.

I think socialising losses means that the taxpayer takes the hit somehow. And I think most people understand this too. So I think the thread title is inaccurate so far.

So again your argument is based on the premise that people who make compulsory payments to the government are not taxpayers. Seems like whether or not it's "socializing" losses shouldn't depend on such definitions, but if it does, I'm sure the Supreme Court would have to agree that this is funded by a tax.
 
The problem really is not about the losses were borne by taxpayers or by other investors.
It's the way of doing business that made huge profits for Bain while lots of other people got screwed. Unsecured lenders received two-tenths of a cent on the dollar while Bain made off with obscene profits. But of course, that's just good business! Nothing wrong with that! Right? They learned a valuable lesson!
 
So again your argument is based on the premise that people who make compulsory payments to the government are not taxpayers.
Compulsory insurance payments in order to carry on a type of business, correct. I do not see those payments as tax. You can ask your SCOTUS but I bet they don't either. AFAIK that kind of thing most surely is constitutional under your "commerce clause"

As above, you have to deal with "socialising losses" widening to cover a huge swathe of economic (downside) activity. In which case I don't think there remains any reason to view it as "bad" (assumes the OP wished to do this).
 
The problem really is not about the losses were borne by taxpayers or by other investors.
It's the way of doing business that made huge profits for Bain while lots of other people got screwed. Unsecured lenders received two-tenths of a cent on the dollar while Bain made off with obscene profits. But of course, that's just good business! Nothing wrong with that! Right? They learned a valuable lesson!
Were those investors mislead? Forced to buy Accuride debt they didn't want?

Why should I care about their plight?
 
Your thread title is too early then. Or incorrect. Agree?

No.

When losses are "socialized" that means that they are borne by society. Limiting that strictly to the government is splitting hairs. In any case, a government agency had to step in and take over the payments.

In the two years following the acquisition in 1993 of GS Industries, a steel mill, for $8 million, Bain Capital increased the company’s debt to $378 million on operating income of less than a 10th of that amount. Some of this was used to pay Bain Capital a $36 million dividend in 1994. That degree of leverage was excessive in light of the cyclicality and capital-intensive nature of the steel industry.

By the time the company went bankrupt in 2001, it owed $554 million in debt against assets valued at $395 million. Many creditors lost money, and 750 workers lost their jobs. The U.S. Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp., which insures company retirement plans, determined in 2002 that GS had underfunded its pension by $44 million and had to step in to cover the shortfall.
 
The problem really is not about the losses were borne by taxpayers or by other investors.
It's the way of doing business that made huge profits for Bain while lots of other people got screwed.
But that wasn't the criticism implicit in your title. So, you moved your goalposts.
 
No.

When losses are "socialized" that means that they are borne by society. Limiting that strictly to the government is splitting hairs. In any case, a government agency had to step in and take over the payments.
And GS Industries would have been a prosperous company today had not Bain bought them out?

And that's a curious definition of "socialized" you have there. Did you learn it from Michelle Bachmann?
 
Of course! Why should you care about their plight! Screw 'em! That's the old Republican spirit!
People lose money in business ventures all the time. Why should I care, so long as no laws were broken?

Were the investors mislead by cooked books? Fraudulent financial statements? Or did they take what they knew was a risky investment because they thought the potential rewards outweighed the risk?
 
No.

When losses are "socialized" that means that they are borne by society. Limiting that strictly to the government is splitting hairs.
Disagreed, unless you're talking about damage to the environment or something, but you're not. I am assuming this agency's fund is fully financed by company contributions and ring fenced. And that the overhead of running the agency itself comes from the contributions as well. I could be wrong but IMO it is the safest assumption. In that case society is not paying for any of it.

In any case, a government agency had to step in and take over the payments.
I assume this meant that the fund that the agency operates had to pay out, and nobody's taxes increased.

Again--if you really want to insist this is socialising losses, then any job loss where the redundant person gets unemployment insurance (and more things than this which I haven't thought of) is a socialised loss.
 
And GS Industries would have been a prosperous company today had not Bain bought them out?

It very well could be the case if Bain hadn't loaded them up with debt and then taken a $36 million dollar dividend on a company they bought for $8 million.
 
Were the investors mislead by cooked books? Fraudulent financial statements? Or did they take what they knew was a risky investment because they thought the potential rewards outweighed the risk?

I'd say that Bain taking $36 million out of the company was probably not something they expected.

Oh well, the clever guys made a killing and the marks got fleeced, so I guess there's nothing wrong with that as long as no laws were broken.
 
It's an op-ed piece, not a straight news article, by a gentleman named Anthony Gardner. And, unless there are two Anthony Gardners at Palomon Capital Partners, it appears that he donated $500 to Barack Obama's reelection campaign in August of last year.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom