Romney’s Bain Yielded Private Gains, Socialized Losses

Great, so now every company that ever goes bankrupt is socialising losses??

Again, I could care less about the "socializing losses" wording.

Yes, I believe that any company that gets bankruptcy protection releasing them from all or some of their debts is receiving a benefit from society (from the courts to be precise).

I think it's wrong that they be allowed to do that AND pay their investors an 800% return on their investment while costing hundreds of people their jobs. (I'm assuming the facts as presented in the Bloomberg article are correct and we're just discussing how to characterize them.)
 
I await a response to the question. What is, in your taxonomy, wrong with socialised losses then? Do you object to them and want to eliminate their incidence? Do you think that more regulations that reduce bankruptcies are viable? What?

I've made my position clear a number of times now. I don't care about the term "socializing losses". In fact, I think it's misleading. The investors suffered no loss. They socialized away their debt (or at least some of it) so that they could realize massive profits.

They got a government bailout to fix their underfunded pension (again, I assume that's because they raided the pension as the company slid--though I assume this happened before Bain entered the picture).

Yes, I think it is possible to tighten up regulations so that people enjoying the benefits of bankruptcy protection from their creditors aren't able to walk away with massive profits (or perhaps the other way around: people realizing a huge capital gain like this should not be allowed to get bankruptcy protection).
 
One more time.

A company that lays off a worker is socialising losses, according to you. OK. A company that retains a worker is privatising gains. (Right?).

A company that files for bankruptcy is socialising losses, again, according to you. A company that does not go bust and keeps trading is (obviously) privatising gains.

Some of these gains are paid back to society via the tax system. Fine.

So what is wrong with this highly frequent pattern of gains being privatised and losses being socialised (according to you)? Anything?

If nothing, then this thread is titled on a false pretense IMO. There is nothing to object about re Bain Caiptal enjoying private gains while losses are socialised (according to your definition). So, meh.
 
(again, I ass...u...me that's because they raided the pension as the company slid--though I assume this happened before Bain entered the picture).
Maybe you should verify that.

ps. Losses were not socialized by any rational meaning of the word.
 
The investors suffered no loss. They socialized away their debt (or at least some of it) so that they could realize massive profits.
Which investors? I assume the ones who bought the company which later failed were wiped out.

The Bain Capital investors made a profit, but then they didn't own a company that failed.

They got a government bailout to fix their underfunded pension (again, I assume that's because they raided the pension as the company slid--though I assume this happened before Bain entered the picture).
This is your conjecture. And, as above, if it is a government bailout, then unemployment insurance claims are government bailouts and chapter 11 laws are government bailouts. You say it like it's a bad thing.

Yes, I think it is possible to tighten up regulations so that people enjoying the benefits of bankruptcy protection from their creditors aren't able to walk away with massive profits (or perhaps the other way around: people realizing a huge capital gain like this should not be allowed to get bankruptcy protection).
You seem confused about who walked off with gains and who went bankrupt. They do not seem to be the same folks. Apparently you think that one group set the other up and hoodwinked third-party investors in to carry the can. Maybe, but that takes some proving IMO. And that is no longer a compliant about (what you describe as) private gains and socialised losses.
 
Great, so now every company that ever goes bankrupt is socialising losses?

I await a response to the question. What is, in your taxonomy, wrong with socialised losses then? Do you object to them and want to eliminate their incidence? Do you think that more regulations that reduce bankruptcies are viable? What?

This is what's wrong it: Bain didn't share in any of those losses. In fact they got away with obscene profits and left others with the losses.
 
Indeed, the inevitability of such bailouts demonstrates why we must abolish the practice of government-backed pension insurance.

Let's think about what would have happened if there was no government-backed pension insurance:

In the two years following the acquisition in 1993 of GS Industries, a steel mill, for $8 million, Bain Capital increased the company’s debt to $378 million on operating income of less than a 10th of that amount. Some of this was used to pay Bain Capital a $36 million dividend in 1994. That degree of leverage was excessive in light of the cyclicality and capital-intensive nature of the steel industry.

By the time the company went bankrupt in 2001, it owed $554 million in debt against assets valued at $395 million. Many creditors lost money, and 750 workers lost their jobs. The U.S. Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp., which insures company retirement plans, determined in 2002 that GS had underfunded its pension by $44 million and had to step in to cover the shortfall. The company's retirees lost their pensions because GS had underfunded its pension by $44 million.

So in this case the taxpayers are spared, but a lot of people lose their pensions. Maybe they have to go on public assistance, so the taxpayers end up paying anyway. Nothing changes for Bain Capital: They still make off like bandits with the loot while other people get screwed. How is that any less objectionable? To me, that is an even worse outcome.
 
Last edited:
This is what's wrong it: Bain didn't share in any of those losses. In fact they got away with obscene profits and left others with the losses.
As far as we know, Bain Capital did not have any exposure to the losses, since the bankruptcy was after the IPO. If you sell a stock you have zero claim thereafter on the cash flows it generates, positive or negative. The sharing you are calling for amounts to reaching back in time and haircutting prior owners' historic returns for something that happened after they divested. That might feel justified in this case, but it isn't (unless you can prove some malfeasance)
 
Let's think about what would have happened if there was no government-backed pension insurance:

You're assuming nobody's behavior would have changed in response. That isn't a safe assumption. In fact, the whole point is to change behavior. Get people off defined benefit plans and onto defined contribution plans, precisely because it insulates both employees and taxpayers against malfeasance or just plain failure by management.

But evidently, you want to keep socializing costs. I'm not sure why, since you're simultaneously complaining about it.
 
You're assuming nobody's behavior would have changed in response. That isn't a safe assumption. In fact, the whole point is to change behavior. Get people off defined benefit plans and onto defined contribution plans, precisely because it insulates both employees and taxpayers against malfeasance or just plain failure by management.

But evidently, you want to keep socializing costs. I'm not sure why, since you're simultaneously complaining about it.

I'm fine with defined contribution plans. They are the way of the future, and I agree that they are preferable. But that doesn't really solve the problem of what to do about all the people who have spent most of their careers working under defined benefit plans. It's also a side issue and not the main point of this thread, which is about Mitt Romney and all the people he screwed over on his way to the top.

Many financial transactions are win-win in nature: both parties benefit. This is the good side of capitalism. Every win-win transaction is a net benefit to society. Some transactions are win-lose however, and it seems like a lot of the deals that Mitt and Bain capital made fall into this latter category: Great for Bain, awful for the other parties, namely the companies that went bankrupt, their employees and their creditors. Was it all legal? Perhaps. But that doesn't necessarily make it right. They were smart, slick guys who took advantage of less sophisticated counterparties and loopholes in the law to make a series of win-lose transactions which made them rich and made other people poorer.
 
Last edited:
It's also a side issue and not the main point of this thread, which is about Mitt Romney and all the people he screwed over on his way to the top.

Well, you could have fooled me. I thought the thread was about socialized losses. Although in fairness, the OP actually had nothing of the sort in it, so I guess I should have concluded earlier that the title was meaningless.

Many financial transactions are win-win in nature: both parties benefit. This is the good side of capitalism. Every win-win transaction is a net benefit to society. Some transactions are win-lose however, and it seems like a lot of the deals that Mitt and Bain capital made fall into this latter category

Unless there's some sort of fraud or compulsion involved, them's the breaks. The fact that some people lost just tells me Romney was smarter than them. Plus, I wouldn't trust the press to give any sort of balanced representation of how much of Bain's dealings fell into which category. The press is notoriously bad about that sort of stuff even when they're not pushing an agenda.

Was it all legal? Perhaps. But that doesn't necessarily make it right.

Nor does the fact that some people lost money make it wrong. But that seems to be the only real objection you have on offer.
 
[ . . . ] it seems like a lot of the deals that Mitt and Bain capital made fall into this latter category: Great for Bain, awful for the other parties, namely the companies that went bankrupt, their employees and their creditors. Was it all legal? Perhaps. But that doesn't necessarily make it right.
What would make it righter?
 
Bain's holding period for American Pad and Paper seems to be either 4 years or 7 years depending on exactly what happened (the story isn't clear on it). That's hardly short term trading. Buying and selling whole companies or large chunks of them is illiquid in any case, so layering on restrictions that make it less liquid may do more harm than good overall.

In other words, reaching for the nearest thing that looks like a hammer because you've spotted what looks like a nail, is an on-the-fly policy recommendation that I would be sceptical of. It may work, but the case you've made is not yet convincing (rather--it is really just a couple of pleasant-sounding bromides)
 
Investing for the long term. Putting profits back into the company to improve the company instead of taking them out as soon as possible to realize a short term gain.
Well, there's a term for that - short term capital gains versus long term capital gains. By your logic, houses should never be flipped, and goods bought at auction should never be resold. Cars should not be bought at auction, and used car dealers' lots should be empty.

But consider - there is a difference between moving product from inventory and holding from investment. And short vs long term gains do not apply to inventory in and out.

As I see it Bain was something of a "Dealer" in companies, and from that vantage point long term holdings are not necessarily a good thing. You could argue that differently in the case of each company, perhaps. But is "Dealing" fundamentally a bad thing?

Although I'm opposed to "flipping houses", I think there are situations where it makes total sense.

Offsetting these factors is the negative incentive of higher taxes on short term holdings. Isn't that enough?
 
Bain's holding period for American Pad and Paper seems to be either 4 years or 7 years depending on exactly what happened (the story isn't clear on it). That's hardly short term trading. Buying and selling whole companies or large chunks of them is illiquid in any case, so layering on restrictions that make it less liquid may do more harm than good overall.

In other words, reaching for the nearest thing that looks like a hammer because you've spotted what looks like a nail, is an on-the-fly policy recommendation that I would be sceptical of. It may work, but the case you've made is not yet convincing (rather--it is really just a couple of pleasant-sounding bromides)

I'm not sure that was a policy recommendation, but rather a critique of romney's character for heading up a company that was making money through questionably ethical means. I'd agree with you that you'd need to be careful about putting in rules against what Bain did there, because that could have unexpected repercussions, but it's still legitimate to say that what they did was unethical.
 
I'm not sure that was a policy recommendation, but rather a critique of romney's character for heading up a company that was making money through questionably ethical means. I'd agree with you that you'd need to be careful about putting in rules against what Bain did there, because that could have unexpected repercussions, but it's still legitimate to say that what they did was unethical.

I disagree, it wasn't unethical. They OWNED IT, they could do whatever they wanted with it. Saying it was unethical implies there is some social or governmental interest in the buy/sell actions or timings of the company in question. Was there such an interest? If so, what is the evidence for it (not the claim).

There was (supposedly) for GM, Chrysler and various banks, ergo, those interests were exercised in terms of government control, takeovers and loans. Apparently there wasn't any such interest in the actions of Bain Capital. Or does ethics only apply (in the views of resident collectivists) to the actions of companies that are PROFITABLE by way of their decisions?
 
Compulsory insurance payments in order to carry on a type of business, correct. I do not see those payments as tax. You can ask your SCOTUS but I bet they don't either. AFAIK that kind of thing most surely is constitutional under your "commerce clause"

As above, you have to deal with "socialising losses" widening to cover a huge swathe of economic (downside) activity. In which case I don't think there remains any reason to view it as "bad" (assumes the OP wished to do this).

Any time the government points a gun at you and demands you give them money so you can keep doing what you're doing, it's a tax.

That they've rationalized to themselves that it's to ameliorate some of what you're doing doesn't change that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom