Romney’s Bain Yielded Private Gains, Socialized Losses

It's an op-ed piece, not a straight news article, by a gentleman named Anthony Gardner. And, unless there are two Anthony Gardners at Palomon Capital Partners, it appears that he donated $500 to Barack Obama's reelection campaign in August of last year.

Does that means his arguments don't stand or fall on their own merits?
 
Indeed, the inevitability of such bailouts demonstrates why we must abolish the practice of government-backed pension insurance.

Is it really inevitable that there will be such exploitive bailouts paid by government agencies?

Obviously the U.S. Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp., a government agency, exists to protect the pension beneficiaries. I have no problem with such a thing (same with the FDIC and FSLIC). I have a problem with people being able to take over an ailing company and pay out big dividends while receiving such a bailout to their pensions (assuming, as I do, the under-investment in the pension was the result of management raiding the fund).

I would actually be in favor of more government rules that would prevent such a thing from happening. Place very strict conditions on companies that receive such a bailout. [ETA: Or on the other side, perhaps tighter government regs preventing abuse of pension funds-- keeping them out of the hands of management altogether--such that a bailout of the pension fund would in all fairness have nothing to do with the profitability of the company.]
 
Last edited:
You sure? If it is funded by the companies who benefit from it, I think it is private insurance.

http://www.pbgc.gov/about/

Look right at the top: "Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, A U.S. Government Agency".

I've long held the position laid out in Orwell's "Politics and the English Language" that "socialism" is one of the "meaningless words" that is so ambiguous that its use is almost always misleading.

However, if we're operating with any definition currently in use (as in "Obamacare is socialized medicine"), surely a significant bailout from a government agency qualifies as "socialism".
 
Does that means his arguments don't stand or fall on their own merits?

I assume you have done about as many LBOs as I have, which is none. Which means, to a certain extent we are relying on the author's expertise to tell us what is normal and proper in such transactions. However, in this case there is certainly ample reason to doubt his impartiality. This is a skeptic site, isn't it? Or does skepticism fly out the window if something suits your confirmation bias?
 
http://www.pbgc.gov/about/

Look right at the top: "Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, A U.S. Government Agency".
Pardon me not opening the link, as I am on a mobile phone.

But the insurance fund is all contributions from other insured pension schemes as far as I know. It does not change that, or matter, if a government agency operates it. It is also likely IMO (I can't check) that the cost of running the agency also comes from these contributions.

This is not semantic IMO. The costs are all totally hypothecated and only levied on those who benefit, or stand to benefit from the insurance.

I agree "socialism" is badly used but I fail to see why you would want to make ever poorer use of it. (I don't think I have ever called Obamacare socialised medicine. That is also rather different because it does not depend on any form of commerce. That is why right wing states tried to challenge it as unconstitutional)
 
I assume you have done about as many LBOs as I have, which is none. Which means, to a certain extent we are relying on the author's expertise to tell us what is normal and proper in such transactions. However, in this case there is certainly ample reason to doubt his impartiality. This is a skeptic site, isn't it?

So what does his $500 contribution have to do with his qualifications?

Or does skepticism fly out the window if something suits your confirmation bias?
You seem to be misusing the term "confirmation bias". It refers to the failure to consider the evidence you would need to falsify a hypothesis (and only consider evidence that would support it).

There is no relationship between his $500 donation and his qualifications. So again, his arguments stand or fall on their own merits.

To do what you mean to do (question some of his expert judgments), you would at least need to find another expert who disagrees. If we had that, then we could see what the consensus of experts is on these matters, to see which opinion is closer to that consensus.

What we wouldn't do, is rate the value of an expert's qualifications by how much money they have donated to which candidate.
 
Is it really inevitable that there will be such exploitive bailouts paid by government agencies?

History keeps playing out that way. Not terribly surprising, since it's a moral hazard.

I would actually be in favor of more government rules that would prevent such a thing from happening.

What exactly would these rules be? Or do you just trust that somebody would be able to come up with such rules?

You know, government rules have a curious habit of not actually stopping bad things from happening. And they don't come for free. Furthermore, private pension bailouts pale in comparison to the looming public pension crisis.

Place very strict conditions on companies that receive such a bailout.

If a company dissolves with an underfunded pension, what conditions do you think you can place on them?

You know, there is an alternative that doesn't require any taxpayer liability at all: defined contribution plans. I'm not sure why you think we need to stick with an outdated model in the first place.
 
Pardon me not opening the link, as I am on a mobile phone.
It's the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp's .gov website. It is by no means a private insurance company. It is a government agency.


But the insurance fund is all contributions from other insured pension schemes as far as I know. It does not change that, or matter, if a government agency operates it.
I think you're trying to change the facts here. A government agency doesn't operate this corp--it is a government agency.

One could as well argue that federal and state gasoline taxes aren't taxes because they are "contributions" by other people buying gasoline.

What about unemployment insurance: is that paid for by taxpayers or merely mandatory contributors?

It is also likely IMO (I can't check) that the cost of running the agency also comes from these contributions.
And what to we call mandatory "contributions" that fund government agencies?

I agree "socialism" is badly used but I fail to see why you would want to make ever poorer use of it. (I don't think I have ever called Obamacare socialised medicine.
Question begging. IMO, it is not poorer use of the term to refer to a bailout from a government agency as "socialism".
 
If a company dissolves with an underfunded pension, what conditions do you think you can place on them?
The "nuclear" condition is that the company has to go bust first before it can default on pension oligations. And that is already the situation in countries which apply IAS19. Which IIRC includes the US.
 
History keeps playing out that way. Not terribly surprising, since it's a moral hazard.

I'll bet I could make a list of pension funds that have not received bailouts from the PBGC in any circumstances, and even fewer under circumstances where dividends were still paid out.

What exactly would these rules be?
Easy enough. If a company receives a bailout, they can't pay dividends. (Or vice-versa, if it makes more sense.)

You know, government rules have a curious habit of not actually stopping bad things from happening. And they don't come for free. Furthermore, private pension bailouts pale in comparison to the looming public pension crisis.
And I suspect the reason why is that raiding public pensions is a lot politically easier to do than raising taxes for budget shortfalls.

At any rate, as Puppycow pointed out, you are no longer arguing that "socializing" losses doesn't happen, just that it ought not happen. I suspect we're all in agreement on that point.
 
The "nuclear" condition is that the company has to go bust first before it can default on pension oligations. And that is already the situation in countries which apply IAS19. Which IIRC includes the US.

And that is similar to the kind of regs I support: if you're going to allow private companies to get government bailouts, then at least don't allow those bailouts to companies paying out dividends.
 
So what does his $500 contribution have to do with his qualifications?

Nothing. It has to do with his impartiality. And since we're on the subject, what exactly are his qualifications?

You seem to be misusing the term "confirmation bias". It refers to the failure to consider the evidence you would need to falsify a hypothesis (and only consider evidence that would support it).

Wikipedia defines confirmation bias:

Confirmation bias (also called confirmatory bias or myside bias) is a tendency of people to favor information that confirms their beliefs or hypotheses.

Sounds like my definition was on the money.

There is no relationship between his $500 donation and his qualifications. So again, his arguments stand or fall on their own merits.

There's that word qualifications again. What qualifications does Mr Gardner have?
 
I'll bet I could make a list of pension funds that have not received bailouts from the PBGC in any circumstances, and even fewer under circumstances where dividends were still paid out.
And the lottery is a great deal, I can make lists of people who have gotten rich off the lottery!

You're using the wrong metric here. Throughout the years we have data, what % of private pensions ultimately failed?
 
I'll bet I could make a list of pension funds that have not received bailouts from the PBGC in any circumstances

I'm sure you could. But if those funds are really at no risk, then they are unfairly being charged to cover the risk of other funds. In effect, they are being punished for doing the right thing. And since many funds are at risk, the structure of the PBGC still intrinsically puts taxpayers at risk, by design. And that's not a good design.

Easy enough. If a company receives a bailout, they can't pay dividends. (Or vice-versa, if it makes more sense.)

Can't pay dividends ever? Because you might as well just say you're going to kill any company that needs a pension bailout. And if you mean not for some period after getting a bailout, well, that's really not much of a disincentive for taking risks.

At any rate, as Puppycow pointed out, you are no longer arguing that "socializing" losses doesn't happen, just that it ought not happen.

Yes.

I suspect we're all in agreement on that point.

I'm not sure we're in agreement about what to do about it.
 
A government agency doesn't operate this corp--it is a government agency.
You are mixing up the organisation that operates/administers the fund with the fund itself. I am not going to explain this again, as you have enough information to know the difference. I bet the agency does not even manage the investments.

One could as well argue that federal and state gasoline taxes aren't taxes because they are "contributions" by other people buying gasoline.
If all you are interested in is winning a definition argument I suppose you could. But in what scenario would petrol taxes be used to socialise losses?

What about unemployment insurance: is that paid for by taxpayers or merely mandatory contributors?
Isn't it paid by employers?

And I already said that you would need to label every example of a private layoff as "private gains / socialised losses" if you push the OP's rationale.

So, in that case, what's wrong with private gains/socialised losses, according to you? I would appreciate an answer.
 
And that is similar to the kind of regs I support: if you're going to allow private companies to get government bailouts, then at least don't allow those bailouts to companies paying out dividends.
That standard isn't about government bailout. It says that companies cannot transfer pension liabilities off balance sheet and default on them without ceasing trading as a business.

So the US already has that. But you are not happy with that, apparently.

Or have you got no problem with what you define as socialised losses? If you haven't, then you're not really out of agreement with me or other posters you seem to be challenging.
 
That standard isn't about government bailout. It says that companies cannot transfer pension liabilities off balance sheet and default on them without ceasing trading as a business.

I understand that. I was suggesting other similar regulations.

Also, going back to the OP and the "socialized losses" issue--doesn't bankruptcy protection in the face of high profits also fit the bill?

Again, I wouldn't use the terms the OP (and the article cited) use, but I believe what Bain was allowed to do in this case was wrong. From the same source cited in the OP:

The company filed for bankruptcy in August 2002, because of its inability to service a $1.5 billion debt load. About 1,700 people lost their jobs while Bain Capital claimed capital gains (net of its losses in the bankruptcy) of roughly $216 million, an eightfold return.

Perhaps more importantly (and more relevant to the Politics subforum), this is the sort of thing that will haunt Romney's campaign.
 
Great, so now every company that ever goes bankrupt is socialising losses?

I await a response to the question. What is, in your taxonomy, wrong with socialised losses then? Do you object to them and want to eliminate their incidence? Do you think that more regulations that reduce bankruptcies are viable? What?
 
If all you are interested in is winning a definition argument I suppose you could.
I think you're the one basing an argument on the definition.

I'm fine with the idea of socializing losses being about spreading out loss and risk among the public at large and not necessarily taxpayers only. You're the one making much over whether or not it's technically a tax. You said it couldn't be socialism since the entity was a private insurance company. Turns out it's a government agency, funded by taxpayers.

Anyway, I don't think this is the image of what Bain Capital did that Romney wants people to know about. He'd like to paint a picture of investments leading to increased production and job creation. Profits paid out while people lose their jobs and debts go unpaid due to bankruptcy protection isn't what he had in mind.

I would happily abandon the "socialized losses" wording.


Re: unemployment insurance funded by a tax:
Isn't it paid by employers?
So? Does that make it not a tax?

And for practical purposes, would it be anything different if it were paid by employees out of higher wages paid by employers?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom