Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.

I like to ask atheists here:


1. Is it possible to prove to an atheist that God maker of everything exists?


2. And is it possible for himself to prove to himself that God maker of everything exists?
​




Yrreg



1. Is it possible to prove to an atheist that God maker of everything exists?

Yes.


2. And is it possible for himself to prove to himself that God maker of everything exists?

Yes.


3. Is it possible to prove to an adult that Santa Claus bringer of gifts exists?

Yes.


4. And is it possible for himself to prove to himself that Santa Claus bringer of gifts exists?

Yes.


5. Are any of the above likely?

No.
 
.
The event where those two words could be expected to be encountered is probably just this single thread, of the billions of threads extant.
Knowing to combine them in that way is pure genius!

Oh I don't know. The opportunity is almost certain to arise in any Gerry thread.
 
Reminds me of a (very) old joke:

Cardinal: Your holiness, I have some good news and some bad news...
Pope: What is the good news, my son?
Cardinal: We have definite, undeniable proof of God's existence.
Pope: That IS good news, but what is the bad news?
Cardinal: She's black...

:o

If She looks like Halley Barry, I still envision all those college aged males coming ... to church, of course! :cool:

ETA: Ok, next time I'll use Multi Quote.
 
Last edited:
Is the maker of everything a troublemaker?
Well yes, it seems to follow. Witness some of the trouble makers he crafted in his own image and likeness: Moses, Abram/Abraham. (See my sig for a possible reason why this might amuse the maker of everything.)

The neat thing about trouble is that through trouble, one can learn how to adapt and overcome, and in so doing become better.

DR
 
If I wait to use them, I forget them. It came to me a few hours before I typed it in. I think probably some post upstream, here or in another thread, suggested it to me, but I'm not going to go looking for it.

Honestly, I've avoided yrreg's threads pretty religiously until this week, and will probably go back to doing so.
You are a sneaky bugger, aren't you?

Thanks for that grin. :D
 
Is this a serious discussion or not? If so, please reply.

I now see that the American people in its vast majority are the ones most entitled to judge on both scores.

And their conclusion overall is atheists are the most distrusted minority in their country.


This response confirms my suspicion that you might be using the phrase "proven to an atheist" differently than I was when I initially answered your question. (see my previous post)

When you ask "who will judge whether it has been proven to an atheist that God maker of everything exists?" are you intending to present the following scenario?


  1. The theist provides the atheist some "proof" that God, maker of everything, exists.

  2. Now that the atheist has been shown "proof" that God, maker of everything, exists it can be judged by a third party that it has been "proven" to the atheist that God, maker of everything, exists.

  3. Even if the atheist refuses to admit the truth of God's existence, the judgment by the third party - that it has been "proven" to the atheist that God, maker of everything, exists - still stands.

What possible value could this scenario have when you pick as the judge a party that is already clearly biased against the atheist?

Also, judging atheists untrustworthy is not the same thing as judging whether or not an atheist has "proven to himself that God exists, but he refuses to admit the proof by an oral or written assent to the truth of God's existence."


God is the maker of everything and He does not have to make Himself.

Why? Because it is not necessary to do so since He is already God the maker of everything.


I think you may be misunderstanding the intention of some of the posters on this forum. You, on several occasions, asked what is wrong with your definition.

The issue (for some) is not whether or not God actually exists or how exactly He made everything. All that can be argued later. The problem is that your definition leaves unstated something that you claim is an important feature of the object of the definition. Namely the idea that it is the only thing in all of existence that didn't need to be made. The typical arguments for God that follow are dependent on this distinction.

If you would say "God, the maker of the universe," this distinction can be inferred (God not part of universe). Another possibility would be something like Aquinas's "Uncaused cause," which makes the distinction more explicit.

Your definition does have a weakness when critically examined (which is what you asked us to do, by the way) and only those with certain preconceptions about the word God can infer the parts you leave unstated.
 
What is proof and what is certainty?

Is it possible to prove the existence of God maker of everything?


There are several questions which must be settled first in order an answer in the affirmative can be made to that question.


First of course is, what is it to prove the existence of something?


Next what is certainty for humans?



Other questions will come up as we go about with the topic of this thread in the quest for an answer to the inquiry on the possibility of proving the existence of God maker of everything.


Any ideas from you guys, atheists here, on what is it to prove the existence of something?

And any ideas from you guys, atheists here, on what is certainty for humans?




Yrreg
 
Three assumptions at the foundation of human discourse.

But before everything we must agree on some assumptions otherwise the exchange of ideas among us humans would be impossible or an exercise in futility.


The first assumption is that we exist as humans.

The second assumption is that we have reason and it is a dependable faculty for thinking and arriving at certainty.

The third assumption is that the only certainty we can have is what I call human certainty.



What do you guys here, atheists, say about the three assumptions?




Yrreg
 
Any ideas from you guys, atheists here, on what is it to prove the existence of something?
Photographic evidence helps but isn't great.
Video evidence is better, but is still fakable.
A body would be best.
 
Gerry, will you just come to the point already and provide some evidence of the existence of this god of yours other than the arguments from incredulity and ignorance that you have presented?
 
But before everything we must agree on some assumptions otherwise the exchange of ideas among us humans would be impossible or an exercise in futility.

Yrreg

You will have to specify ALL of the attributes of your god(s) before anything else or this thread will become another exercise in futility.
 
I like to ask atheists here:


1. Is it possible to prove to an atheist that God maker of everything exists?


2. And is it possible for himself to prove to himself that God maker of everything exists?
​

1. Yes.

2. Meaningless question.
 
Let me see if you have the courage to accept necessary assumptions.

I am asking you guys to agree on the assumptions I present before you, because unless we adhere to the assumptions human discourse of any worth is impossible.


But as usual you guys keep avoiding what is crucially necessary to have any constructive and thus productive discourse on the issue at hand.




Why are you always afraid?

That is why I always believe that the only productive study of atheists is their psychology of being angry at God because they are afraid of God whereas there is no need to fear God whatever if you guys will just face God and live with God.


Okay, tell me if you are not accepting any of these three assumptions, and why?




The first assumption is that we exist as humans.

The second assumption is that we have reason and it is a dependable faculty for thinking and arriving at certainty.

The third assumption is that the only certainty we can have is what I call human certainty.

​


Let me see if someone among you have the courage to either accept these the assumptions or to point out which assumption(s) you cannot accept and why.





Yrreg
 
I am asking you guys to agree on the assumptions I present before you, because unless we adhere to the assumptions human discourse of any worth is impossible.


But as usual you guys keep avoiding what is crucially necessary to have any constructive and thus productive discourse on the issue at hand.




Why are you always afraid?

That is why I always believe that the only productive study of atheists is their psychology of being angry at God because they are afraid of God whereas there is no need to fear God whatever if you guys will just face God and live with God.


Okay, tell me if you are not accepting any of these three assumptions, and why?




The first assumption is that we exist as humans.

The second assumption is that we have reason and it is a dependable faculty for thinking and arriving at certainty.

The third assumption is that the only certainty we can have is what I call human certainty.

​


Let me see if someone among you have the courage to either accept these the assumptions or to point out which assumption(s) you cannot accept and why.





Yrreg

OK, I'll bite. I cannot accept assumption three until you define 'human certainty' and explain how it is different from just plain old certainty.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom