Please help with the "Wall of Harm"

There's some stuff here --- see the OP and molbiogirl's post (message 12).

the State of Wisconsin said:
A person is not guilty of an offense under this section solely because he or she provides a child with treatment by spiritual means through prayer alone for healing in accordance with the religious method of healing … in lieu of medical or surgical treatment.

Yes, folks, in Wisconsin you can let your children die of neglect, so long as you think that's God's will.
 
Here's a good one I don't think you have yet.

Surinder Kaur Sidhu trusted a guru called Amar Singh to cure her breast cancer, and did not seek medical help in time. She also gave him land worth over $1M. Predictably enough, she died of the breast cancer, and there was a big court fight over the land. The judgment, which gave the land back to her family, is here.
 
Site Update! Now has RSS Feed & Geo data

Sorry I haven't updated in this thread lately, I've been busy with my day job and behind-the-scenes updates to the site.

This morning I rolled out the first in a set of updates that should make the site more useful as a day-to-day tool for skeptics. The notable updates today include:

An RSS Feed. You can now get a regular update of new cases posted on Whats The Harm in your favorite news reading tool. Just use this link to subscribe, or click the RSS icon you'll see on the site. The feed always contains the 100 most recent cases added to the site.

Geographic data. I've started coding each case with latitude and longitude so the data can be mapped. Soon I'll have map links on the category pages, but for now you can map the new cases via the RSS feed. For instance, here's the feed displayed in Google Maps.

Let me know if you see any problems with the new features, and be please be patient while I catch up with the case backlog.

Thanks for all your support and assistance!
 
One case a friend of mine's been talking about is Kaja Ballo, the daughter of a Norwegian MP who committed suicide after getting a bad result on the Scientology personality/stress test. Unfortunately, I don't speak Norse, nor do I know where to find a good English-language source. Everything that comes up for me is blogs, YouTube, etc.. Perhaps someone with better Google-fu than I could find something?
 
More maps!

Another update to the site this week.

Maps! Each page has a little mini-map on the left side showing a summary of where those cases occurred. Red icons indicate deaths, blue indicate injuries. Somewhat interesting to see a very rough idea of where each category of pseudoscience and so on is prevalent around the world. Here's the one for homeopathy:



Google Maps. If you click those mini-maps, Google Maps will open with the same data displayed in clickable form. Go ahead, try it on the sample above! From this map page you will also have a link to open the same data in Google Earth if you like (upper right). In both Maps and Earth you can click the icons to see the person's name and story, and click the link in the balloon to navigate back to the full info on the site.

Links. All off-site links now open in their own window. This is an experiment to see if I can get people to linger on the site longer. I've also gotten rid of the little round icons for links, it was clear to me from my email that many people did not understand that those led to the background story for each person.

Still ahead:

I haven't yet created the "one map to rule them all", a KML that links to all the other data, so you can see the entire Whats The Harm dataset on a world map. I suspect that said map would not load in Google Maps successfully due to the volume of data, but might be useful in Google Earth. If you really, really want to see this remind me and I'll get on it. (Though keep in mind I'm very busy preparing my presentation for TAM 6).

There are still a few older cases that have not been geocoded, I am aware of this and will make a pass through the data this weekend to clean that up.
 
Last edited:
New categories

I continually add new categories as relevant cases are found, but I haven't been calling much attention to them so far. Here are some categories that were added recently:

Alternative dentistry ("holistic" or "biological" dentists)
http://whatstheharm.net/alternativedentistry.html

Astrology
http://whatstheharm.net/astrology.html

Expert witnesses (pseudoscience in the courtroom)
http://whatstheharm.net/expertwitnesses.html

Home childbirth
http://whatstheharm.net/homechildbirth.html

Hypnosis (mostly wrongful convictions based on hypnotized witnesses)
http://whatstheharm.net/hypnosis.html

Reparative therapy (trying to "cure" gay people)
http://whatstheharm.net/reparativetherapy.html

I have several other categories waiting in the wings for a decent number of cases. I dislike putting new categories up with only one case in them if I can avoid it. If you have any ideas of cases for these, please chime in:

  • Numerology
  • Fear of electromagnetic fields
  • Healing touch (reiki and so on)
Remember, they've got to be in the last 50 years and show a real, concrete harm.

Thanks again for all the support!
 
Last edited:
I'd have a more than a few stories of my own from The Files of StopSylviaBrowne to add to the section about psychics. However, I don't know how interested you'd be, enspecially since there's a dearth of publicly available information.

On a short list of Sylvia's accomplishments, she's:

1. Once- and very possibly twice- accused a innocent man of murder, resulting in a lawsuit against Montel Williams and his show.
2. Possibly told a dying boy in advanced stages of multiple sclerosis that he'd live a long time when, in fact, he died less than a year later. She gave him and his family false hope, needlessly dragged him and his family from Hawaii to NYC and, seeing how this was part of an arrangement with the Make a Wish Foundation, quite possibly wasted precious funds.
3. Told an Iraq war widow who artificially conceived after her husband's death that she'd have a healthy child and a few months later, the poor woman had a prematurely born baby who died the day it was born. And then was shamelessly used by Montel William's show to showcase Sylvia's accuracy!
4. Took credit for finding a missing body in a classic "post-diction", retrofitting and shaping her original prediction and flat out lying, taking credit away from the police and volunteers and shamelessly exploiting a tragedy.
5. Contributed to the re-opening of a cold case that had, in fact, been declared solved. Distress to the victims' family, public funds wasted.
 
6. Briefly switched from victimizing the families of murder victims to victimize the families of two perpetrators/ alleged perpetrators on two separate occassions, by telling them their convicted killer sons were innocent, that there would be new evidence and that they'd get a favorable outcome on appeal. Neither did, and as far as I can tell, both.

To me, this is as despicable as victimizing the families of murder victims and missing people. We forget that the innocent families of perpetrators or accused perperators suffer very much, too, and that this is giving the same sort of false hope and false promises to them. If a person is indeed wrongly convicted, the last thing he needs is Sylvia Browne's lies and if he isn't, the last thing his family needs is to wrongly believe that he's been innocently convicted.

If you ask me, one of them was rightly convicted and the other was wrongly convicted and I think that it's a tragedy that Sylvia interfered in either one.

7. Told two victims of an unsolved rape who had come to her to find out their attacker's identity to stop the efforts to bring a rapist to justice, since he was "already dead". May I mention that they were 17 and 19 at the time and had been kidnapped, assaulted, tortured and raped and barely got out alive.
 
Another chiropractic victim goes public

Sandy Nette’s story, which has just hit the Canadian press, is definitely one for the Wall of Harm:

‘Look what you did to me’ (7 mins 57 secs)
Minutes after visiting an Edmonton, Alberta chiropractor for a routine neck adjustment on September 13th 2007, Sandy Nette suffered a paralyzing stroke. From her hospital bed she answers questions about her experience using a speech synthesising touch pad.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SHX7m09OZ8E&feature=PlayList&p=F324082BDDF8E50C&index=3


More details:

Paralyzed woman sues chiropractic for half billion
http://www.rabble.ca:80/news_full_story.shtml?x=72421

Complete Statement of Claim - Sandra Nette v. Gregory John Stiles et al.
http://chirowatch.com/Chiro-lawsuits/Stiles/lawsuit080612stiles.pdf
 
I did some searching on Lexis Nexis and sent 6 stories on various topic to the webmaster of WTH.net.

Here's one I'd like to share with all of you:


January 8, 2000, Saturday
Psychic scam started with a love letter

BYLINE: By Marisa Taylor

SECTION: DOMESTIC NEWS

LENGTH: 1223 words



FORT WORTH, Texas _ "I love you Kenneth," the letter read. Franklin Gross, an 83-year-old from Liberty, Ind., received the letter four years ago from a Texas woman who called herself Carol Baker. "Baker" said she was a psychic and could help Gross win back an estranged girlfriend.
"Baker," whose real name is Nancy Ruthy Tan, began demanding cash, credit cards and money orders from Gross, a widower since 1993. By the time his family started questioning the sincerity of Tan's love and mystical advice, Gross had given her more than $40,000.


"She told him it took a lot of money to make her happy," said Franklin Bridenhager, an attorney for the Gross family. "He was so depressed and lonely that he believed her."

Gross is one of at least 22 victims from across the country who were cheated out of more than $300,000 by seven Texas residents claiming to be psychics, Assistant U.S. Attorney Fred Schattman said. Such scams flourish across the country, but these cases are unusual because all of the defendants were members of two Fort Worth- Dallas families.

After a four-year investigation, five women and two men have been convicted in separate cases involving psychic fraud. Six have been sentenced.

Tan, of North Richland Hills, pleaded guilty in October to one count of mail fraud. Also suspected of conning 12 other people in addition to Gross, she faces up to five years in prison and a fine of up to $250,000.
She may also be subject to up to three years of supervised release after her prison term expires, Schattman said.

Also convicted and sentenced are:

_Spero Peter Evans, 32, who listed addresses in Fort Worth and San Antonio. He was sentenced in April to three years' probation and a $2,000 fine for mail fraud and aiding and abetting.

_Tina Evans, 29, who listed addresses in Dallas and Colleyville. She was sentenced in December 1998 to one year and two months in prison for mail fraud.

_Janet Mary Mitchell, 28, who lived in Hurst. She was sentenced in January to three years' probation and $2,902 in restitution for mail fraud.
_Angie Mitchell, 33, who listed addresses in Arlington, North Richland Hills, Euless, Bedford and Dallas. She was sentenced in October to nine months in prison for wire fraud.

_Dino Patrick McGill of Dallas, who was sentenced in December to eight months in prison for mail fraud.

_Tammy Sue Mitchell, 37, of Dallas and Irving. She was ordered in August to pay $58,937 in restitution to five people after pleading guilty to mail fraud.

The schemes usually unfolded like this: Victims responded to ads placed in tabloid newspapers by people offering to solve problems. The ads snared people from across the country, including Mansfield, Ohio; Fargo, N.D.; and Covington, Ky.

Several of the victims were elderly, ill or experiencing financial problems. One woman had recently discovered that her husband had cancer when she called for psychic advice, federal officials said.

In the local cases, the psychics placed ads promising to rekindle failed love affairs, cure illnesses, solve money woes and chase away evil spirits with special prayers and spiritual powers.

The seven people convicted are members of the Rom community, commonly known as Gypsies. One of the accused, Tammy Sue Mitchell, cited her heritage as a defense.

"Many women in the Gypsy culture are trained as palm readers and psychics when they are children," said Mitchell's attorney, Mike Heiskell of Fort Worth. "They're told early on this is their livelihood."

Mitchell's part in the scam included placing an ad in a magazine using the pseudonym Gloria Higgins, court papers say.

"Solves all problems, love marriage, health, business," her advertisement read. "Tired of lonely days/nights? Miracles are waiting for you."
Fortune-telling is a centuries-old tradition that is practiced legally by many Rom in the United States, said George Kaslov director of the Lawyers' Committee for Roma Rights and Recognition in New York.
Estimates vary, Kaslov said, but about 1 million gypsies reportedly live in the United States.

"You can't stereotype 99 percent of the Rom community just because of the 1 percent who might commit a crime," he said.

Schattman, the federal prosecutor, said people who believe in and contact psychics may not report a scam to authorities. In Gross' case, the family's attorney contacted the FBI in April 1997 because of concerns expressed about Tan. The FBI learned that Tan was a 43-year-old married woman who used the pseudonym Carol Baker and described herself as single and lonely.

"When something like this happens to a family member, you wonder who you can trust," said a relative of Gross'.

In some of the scams, victims were reassured that their money would benefit a church or religious organization, Schattman said.
Mitchell, for example, said she was a nun and told her victims that she would cleanse their cash of evil spirits, court papers say. She told them to mail cash to her and she promised to return it.

One Midwestern woman, who asked to remain anonymous, said Mitchell first asked for and returned about $400, claiming that she had cleansed it. About a week later, Mitchell asked for $20,000, which the woman sent, but it was never returned, she said.

"I've always trusted religious people," the woman said.

Mitchell told another woman that she had a vision that her parents would be in a terrible car accident, according to court documents. To lift the evil curse that supposedly hung over the family, the woman was told to send $12,205 in cash so it could be cleansed of evil.

Later, Mitchell also demanded a Presidential Rolex watch.
In 1997, the woman went to the FBI, triggering an investigation that led to Mitchell's arrest in 1998.

Federal officials described the psychics as brilliant con artists, but defense attorneys argued for mercy. Several of the defendants had mental illnesses and never completed high school, officials said.
One defendant, Tina Evans, a 29-year-old Arlington woman, said that her traditionally authoritarian husband, Dino Patrick McGill, forced her to pose as a psychic, court papers indicate. But prosecutors painted a harsh portrait of Evans as capable of convincing a 79-year-old woman to hand over thousands of dollars for a mystical cleansing.

In December 1998, a federal judge sentenced Evans to a year and two months in prison for mail fraud, lower than the maximum punishment of up to five years in prison and a $250,000 fine. A year later, McGill, who has since separated from Evans, was sentenced to eight months in prison for mail fraud.

Mitchell received no prison time but was ordered to pay the restitution.
But Heiskell said he doubts that his client can repay the debt because illness prevents her from working. If she cannot work, the government will need to determine whether she has other assets that can be tapped to fulfill the restitution, Heiskell said.
The woman who lost $20,000 doubts that her money will ever be returned.
"I was fooled," the woman said."I knew better when I was doing it, but she was very persuasive."

http://www.lexisnexis.com.proxy.wex...&treeMax=true&treeWidth=0&csi=138794&docNo=79
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom