Please help with the "Wall of Harm"

Great idea. I wouldn't quite call myself a "skeptic" but I try to look at things with an open mind. In other words, I try to examine both sides of the arguement to find my own conclusion.

Anyway, great idea. Although I'm not sure how much I can help but I support you.
 
Hey krelnik,
I love the work you have done. I decided the work of my next video was going to focus around the harmfulness of psychics. I just came across your site and much like www.stopsylviabrown.com your site has done a ton of research for me. This time I am thinking of doing something way different than my rip off of Anonymous. So I got two questions. One: do you care if I rip a hug amount of my research out of your site. Two: if you don’t care I use it would you like to be credited in my video?

-Kyle
 
much like www.stopsylviabrown.com your site has done a ton of research for me. This time I am thinking of doing something way different than my rip off of Anonymous. So I got two questions. One: do you care if I rip a hug amount of my research out of your site.

That is absolutely one of the intended purposes of the site. Rip away!

Two: if you don’t care I use it would you like to be credited in my video?

Sure, if you can stick the URL in the credits I would much appreciate it. Thanks!
 
Alright, thanks! It maybe a while before I get this video done because I need to plan and make the whole thing by myself. When I am done I will be sure to put a link on the board for you to check out.

-Kyle
 
Krelnik- I have the perfect story for you about Satanic ritual abuse (and perhaps witchcraft). As a matter of fact, I can't believe that you haven't included it already.

I'm sure just about everyone here has heard of the West Memphis 3? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Memphis_3

Long story short, three young boys were murdered, molested and terribly mutilated. Due to the mutilations- I believe one boy was castrated- Satanic ritual abuse was deemed the culprit.

Three teenagers were arrested, tried and convicted, mainly, it seems, for the crime of wearing black, listening to heavy metal, dabbling in "witchcraft" and being maladjusted misfits. The enormous miscarriage of justice on the part of the police played a huge part but the boys were convicted, it seems, solely because of the fear of Satanic ritual abuse. I believe a "expert" on Satanic rituals who had gotten his degree by mail testified at trial, among many other mockeries of justice.

The result being that two of the boys are currently serving life sentences and the third is on death row in Arkansas.
 
Yes, actually the West Memphis 3 are sitting in my to-do queue right now. I'm trying to figure out how to write it up properly. For technical and other reasons, the stories have to be VERY short, and the fact that they haven't yet been exonerated is hard to dance around.

Suggestions on how to word this are welcome.
 
Krel,
Provide links to the WM3 stories; allow others to make an informed decision. State the facts, and provide information.
 
My suggestion:

"Due to a combination of local hysteria of Satanism and gross misconduct on the part of police, three boys were most likely wrongly accused of murder and child molestation. While all three are still currently in prison, there was no forensic evidence to link them to the scene of the crime and the police's investigation and the proecution's case were, at best, extremely suspect. It should be noted that the arrests were made solely on the testimony of a mentally handicapped boy with a IQ in the double digits, interogated for hours without his parents or a lawyer present. Harm: man wrongly sentenced to death and jailed for nearly a decade, two other men serving life sentences, the rightful murderer never arrested or convicted, countless tax payer dollars wasted and several families torn apart."
 
Last edited:
Krelnik- I have a great one for you about repressed memory therapy. Have you ever heard of Arnold and Jesse Friedman? Or maybe of the movie Capturing the Friedmans?

Long story short, a father and son on Long Island in the 1980s as well as a friend of the son's were (most likely) wrongly accused of dozens of instances of pedophilia based on the testimonies of about a dozen children put through hypnosis and "repressed memory therapy". The father was sentenced to life in prison and commited suicide there while the son served 13 years in prison.

As with the West Memphis 3, there were many other culprits besides pseudoscience (hysterical parents, a botched police investigation, unbelievable misconduct on the part of the police, overzealous prosecutors, terrible defense lawyers who gave the defendants very bad legal advice, a media that just about convicted the alleged child molesters.)

The fact remains, however, that the therapists (and the police, who in one known instance intimidated a child into incriminating the suspects by removing his parents from the room and accusing him of being gay!) are to blame for almost all of the counts of molestation, sodomy and rape that the Friedmans were charged with. Tragic, tragic, tragic.

Edit: By the way, there was no forensic or medical evidence of the alleged molestations. None. No boys showing physical symptoms of abuse, no sperm or blood found at the scene of the alleged crimes, no photographs of the boys being abused. Just trumped up charges, manufactured memories and coerced confessions.

Friedman actually was an admitted pedophile who did rape several strange children in his lifetime and his collection of pornography was discovered but the evidence shows he and his son never touched the children under his care. How sad and how tragic- to go unpunished for your actual crimes and be punished for the false ones.
 
Last edited:
...

On the Jehovah's front, the thing that always stands out to me is the fact that the church formerly prohibited organ transplants, and then reversed themselves in a later ruling. (Of course, what use is allowing transplants if you don't allow transfusions? Is it even possible to transplant anything other than maybe a cornea without a transfusion?) They've also reversed themselves on vaccinations. If I were a JW, I'd be wondering: when is the reversal on transfusions coming, and is it going to be soon enough to save my kid?

Actually, there is something known as a autologous transfusion, which means donating blood to yourself ahead of time for a planned surgery. It is consistent with the JW's befiefs and is commonly used among JWs (as well as for patients who choose it for medical and/or practical reasons.)

Of course, it's of no help at all in an emergency...

So, krelnik, have you decided to use any of the articles I sent you? I haven't noticed anything new up recently.

Also, if you have anything you'd like me to specifically look for, feel free to ask me.

Edit: didn't realize the question had already been answered!
 
Last edited:
Yes, I am using all of the articles you sent me. You're right, I haven't posted any updates lately because I've been recovering from TAM6, getting caught up at my day job and the like. I will update soon and many of your submissions will be in there.

Thanks much!
 
Yes, I am using all of the articles you sent me. You're right, I haven't posted any updates lately because I've been recovering from TAM6, getting caught up at my day job and the like. I will update soon and many of your submissions will be in there.

Thanks much!

You're welcome! Glad to help with a good cause.

For what it's worth, I think you should also put the West Memphis 3 case in under "expert witnesses" because of the "expert witness" on Satanic ritual abuse that testified at their trial. And if you include Jesse and Arnold Friedman, it should be both under both "repressed memory therapy" and "hypnosis".

This is a little off-topic but I'm surprised at the coverage these things get in the media. Searching for stories about psychic surgery, it seems that almost all of the articles are neutral or favorable. John of God, for example, gets very few unfavorable or critical articles when he's covered at all in the press. And even those don't happen to be of any help to what you're doing.

The same with psychic detectives- it varies but I'd say that most are either neutral or supportive.

The only woos that seem to really get it are the ones who are on the very fringes even in woo.
 
Last edited:
I just had a bright idea.

Your wall for conspiracy theories doesn't have anything included relating to JFK nonsense. Since it was less than 50 years ago, what about listing that one guy brought to trial by that lunatic DA (falsely accused), the state of Louisiana (expenses of an investigation and trial) the American federal government and the American taxpayers (money and time wasted investigating a non-conspiracy) and Lyndon Johnson (falsely accused), various other figures (falsely accused) and the American movie-going public (having another Oliver Stone film foisted on us)? :D

And, since you mention one Holocaust conspiracy theorist who lost his job for making his views known, how about other people who've been arrested, sued, lost their jobs, been banned from entering certain countries, been assaulted or otherwise sanctioned for this belief?

What about David Irving and other people who've been arrested in countries in which denial is a crime? I can't bring myself to feel sorry for them but it's a fair point that they've been hurt by their own actions.

Edit: And, as for the victims of conspiracy theorists, both Penn & Teller and Bill Maher have been harrassed by wackjobs after mocking them on their respective shows. Penn has stated that they and their crew have actually received threats from these lunatics.

Edit 2: Come to think of it...I'm not sure how honest it would be to blame the Oklahoma City bombing on a conspiracy theory but Timothy McVeigh and his conspirators certainly were conspiracy theorists and certainly were motivated by a fanatical hatred and fear of the allegedly all-evil, allegedly all-powerful government.

Edit 3: If you want to go into the Princess Diana conspiracy theory, I'd mention the British authorities who spent precious time and money investigating her death as the losers. Not that I'm not glad that they did everything they could to set the record straight- but a three-year investigation to determine that a tragic accident was a tragic accident, all because some people just don't have common sense? And every believer on Earth dealt with it by...just ignoring it!

And the father of her boyfriend, who's still spending his time and money trying to prove that there was a conspiracy.
 
Last edited:
Hey, Eeney, thanks again for all the great news stories you've been emailing me. I've been going through them this morning and there are some real jewel stories in there. (Also some stories that I already have, but fill in some details I couldn't find). Much appreciated.

I just had a bright idea.

Your wall for conspiracy theories doesn't have anything included relating to JFK nonsense. Since it was less than 50 years ago, what about listing that one guy brought to trial by that lunatic DA (falsely accused), the state of Louisiana (expenses of an investigation and trial) the American federal government and the American taxpayers (money and time wasted investigating a non-conspiracy) and Lyndon Johnson (falsely accused), various other figures (falsely accused) and the American movie-going public (having another Oliver Stone film foisted on us)? :D

Any of those that actually went to court, yes those would fit.

I try to avoid alot of "money wasted" claims unless there is someone who sued about it, because they seem too vague to me. Likewise false accusations unless they result in an actual lawsuit. I'm trying to stick with harm that is very clear-cut when you read it.

For instance, the JFK assassination and Diana's death did have to be investigated. So one could argue any money spent on those investigations was going to happen anyway, no matter what crazy allegations get made in the process. Even if you argue that it made the investigation longer or more costly, how do you put a price on that?

Another good example is psychics. I'd never list a person who spent thousands on a psychic but doesn't regret it, because that person could easily argue that they viewed it as entertainment. Who am I to judge how they spend their entertainment money? (Heck, some would argue I personally spend too much money on CDs and DVDs).

Remember, the site is not just aimed at skeptics. The hope is that some "believers" or "potential believers" will read it and possibly be dissuaded from continuing in their irrational belief. So the stories need to be really compelling and clear cut, or people will tend to latch on to a weak story and use it to discount the entire site.

(This is not to say I don't have any weak stories on their now. Please, anyone feel free to point them out. As the database is growing, I can afford to lose a few stories here or there at this point, if it strengthens the overall message).

And, since you mention one Holocaust conspiracy theorist who lost his job for making his views known, how about other people who've been arrested, sued, lost their jobs, been banned from entering certain countries, been assaulted or otherwise sanctioned for this belief?

What about David Irving...

Yes, that's a good point. I need to get David Irving, Ernst Zündel, Fredrick Toben, Robert Faurisson and others who have been jailed for writing holocaust denial stuff into there.

Thanks for reminding me of that!

Edit: And, as for the victims of conspiracy theorists, both Penn & Teller and Bill Maher have been harrassed by wackjobs after mocking them on their respective shows. Penn has stated that they and their crew have actually received threats from these lunatics.

Again "threats", while incredibly disquieting to the target, are not really compelling as stories on the site. One might imagine that celebrities get threats all the time over the dumbest things. It also dances very close to the concept of a "hate crime" which I have deliberately excluded from the site simply because they happen so often.

Edit 2: Come to think of it...I'm not sure how honest it would be to blame the Oklahoma City bombing on a conspiracy theory but Timothy McVeigh and his conspirators certainly were conspiracy theorists and certainly were motivated by a fanatical hatred and fear of the allegedly all-evil, allegedly all-powerful government.

Yes, you have a point. There might be something usable there. The whole militia movement in the US was driven by this a sort of paranoid conspiracy-theory thinking about the aims and methods of the US Government. I may have to pick up a book on that and see what I can mine out of it.

Again, thanks for all the great input! You're definitely keeping me busy....:D
 
You're very welcome. :) I'm glad to be to lend my research skills to someone who could use them.

Well, it's not my site but I actually appreciate it that you include a wide variety of stories of very differing magnitudes. I actually think that it's more enlightening, more illuminating and does alot to strenghten your case.

When I tell a relative or a friend about, let's say, a lunatic judge who consults alleged criminals' horoscopes or someone who was murdered because of a belief in curses, they are likely to say "You're just cherrypicking the marginal and extreme cases. That doesn't happen every day and you're making it sound as though it is."

To me highlighting money wasted, law enforcement time wasted, investigations that yielded nothing, needless trips, false accusations made that thankfully didn't lead to arrests or lawsuits, threats, harrassment, cons that cost their victims small amounts of money, charges that got quickly dropped, things like an insurance company having to pay for someone's acupuncture a few times and other minor harm is pointing out harms that are not so obvious but should be considered.

The message to me is "You might not think it's the end of the world but it does cost you in ways you might not even have thought of".

I don't think any of your stories are weak; I actually think that the more and more there are, the more compelling the overall picture is.

Oh yeah, I've been giving you alot of work lately. :D Awful sorry about that! :D
 
Site updated

A few notable site updates recently, along with a bunch of new cases:

Two new categories: dowsing and numerology. (Thanks much to EeneyMinnieMoe for supplying the cases that enabled these).

I've changed the "kids" meta-category to "children". Nobody complained about it to me, but I was reminded that the word "kids" bugs some people. "Children" is also probably more easily understood if English is your second language.

A few minor cosmetic tweaks here and there such as additional white space in the navigation bar (thanks Jutta) and dropping some lame category links.

Oh and a couple new cases I'd like to point out because of their sheer weirdness:

Lee Muk-yui who was working in the Bank of China and decided to "swap out" bills that had lucky serial numbers, using two accomplices in branch banks. Note: he did not steal the money, he simply swapped the lucky bills for other ones that weren't as lucky. And yet, the Honk Kong authorities gave him 7 months in prison!

The strange tale of Christine Jessop, a missing child in Canada who later turned up dead. Early on, dowsers and psychics got consulted by the cops first, while credible eyewitnesses waited weeks to be called. Finally, they arrested Guy Paul Morin and railroaded him using flimsy pseudoscientific fiber and hair evidence, only to have his conviction overturned by DNA evidence later. This case just has misinformation oozing out the seams, and is a tragedy all around.

Thanks to everyone who keeps sending me cases, especially Eeney who is probably going to keep me busy until the end of the year singlehandledly. ;)
 
Excellent!

My pleasure, Tim. And I think I have to thank you. :) As a researcher dependent on someone else to publish your information, there's nothing more gratifying than to actually have someone give your findings a forum. And to see the fruit of your work available to the public where it ca(hopefully) do some good. As a matter of fact, the best way to thank me is to put everything up as soon as possible. :)

By the way, I'm sorry about swamping your email. :D Incidentally, if you were keeping track, how many Word/ PDF pages did I send you? :blush:

I'm sure it couldn't have been more than 1,500. :D

Edit: That's true about the weirdness. Being a skeptic kind of makes you an expert on All Things Weird! and Some Very, Very Strange People (not that all paranormal is "strange" or all woos are "weird"- some are actually very accepted and very mainstream and believed by otherwise perfectly normal people) but even now, there are things that stop me in my tracks and make me go "What...in...heaven's...name?!"

Like the story of "Mrs. A"- it stood out even to me for the sheer weirdness.
 
Last edited:
Here you go:

http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/news/...t:+'Your+dead+mum+is+here+with+us'/article.do

Just when you thought you've heard it all! :eye-poppi

When I heard that I was torn between laughter, shock and being totally creeped out. Kinda gaped at the screen for a few moments, shaking my head.

Edit: And while we are on the subject of stories that could shock even long-time skeptics, I was stunned and appalled at the story of Christine Jessop. Having investigated over a hundred of Sylvia Browne's murder/missing persons' cases, I know firsthand the enormous damage that psychic detectives can do but even I've never heard of something like this.

Maybe I'm naive and think too well of the police and law enforcement but I can hardly believe that police could be so negligent and so stupid. If it wasn't in legitimate news sources and official documents, I would have had trouble believing this story myself.

If anyone ever asks you what's the worst thing that could happen with a psychic detective, please do me a favor and point them to this.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom