Please help with the "Wall of Harm"

Those of you who hang out in the JREF chatroom may have heard that I was interviewed by ABC News on last Friday. Well Google just informed me that the article is up...

Victimized by Astrology and...Veganism?
Web Site Warns of the Dangers Associated With Odd, and Not so Odd, Beliefs
By TUAN NGUYEN
July 22, 2008

Tim Farley's interest in skepticism, which seeks to expose dubious claims, started when he began listening to comedian and outspoken doubter Penn Jillette's radio show. It was through the show that he heard about the skeptic community, became involved through meetings and decided to find a way to contribute.

So in February, the software engineer from Atlanta started compiling news reports of those victimized by psychics, faith healing and other new age beliefs and posting them on his Web site.

"A lot of stories I see of people getting harmed by these various types of belief systems often appear and disappear very quickly," Farley says. "So I was hoping to capture some of this and create a resource for skeptics to point to when they make their arguments."

The site he created, Whatstheharm.net, serves as a virtual warehouse of cautionary tales.

It's unfortunate that he chose to focus so much on the vegetarianism page, which I've found to be a bit of a lightning rod of controversy. Most people don't notice that its almost entirely about babies and toddlers, who have unique nutritional needs.

Nice quote from Shermer though.

"I think it's excellent," Michael Shermer, president of The Skeptics Society, says of the site.
 
Last edited:
Those of you who hang out in the JREF chatroom may have heard that I was interviewed by ABC News on last Friday. Well Google just informed me that the article is up...

Victimized by Astrology and...Veganism?
Web Site Warns of the Dangers Associated With Odd, and Not so Odd, Beliefs
By TUAN NGUYEN
July 22, 2008

Awesome, krelnik! Well done, you!

Have you thought about adding a "Media" page to your site? You could list articles such as this one (as well as any others that spring up as well), any white papers that you write, as well as perhaps a standard press release that the media might use for future stories. Just a thought!

Congrats again.
 
This is an awesome site! I wonder if there has been anyone who has tried to figure out just how much Johnny Gosch's mom has spent, how many have exploited her, etc. She's clearly been driven quite mad by people who've manipulated her in one form or another over the years.

Also, maybe Kelly would let you link to some of the stories she has about victims' families who've been exploited by psychics?
 
Oh thanks for reminding me of that, I've been meaning to add some of Kelly's "Jason Project" stories to the site, just haven't done the research yet.
 
Another Jehovas witness story here and here.
Sorry that it´s only in German, but I did not find an English language article on that case.

Short summary:
A young woman, pregnant, refusing blood transfer and dying in hospital July this year. She did not want the blood, and the wacko husband supported her decision since he is also a member of the club. The unborn would have died anyway, so you can´t blame that on her. In another article I have read that she leaves another child (six years old) behind though. Sad.

While I do like your site a lot, I do not follow this line of reasoning:

So I deliberately decided to put in some non-woo topics to show how some misinformation is less obvious than others. I don't think vegetarianism is woo either, but I think you can get into trouble if you take it too far (such as choosing a vegetarian diet for a small baby).

You might want to read my answer to FAQ question #7, which is closely related.


If vegetarianism itself is not the reason for the harm caused, it should not be the headline in my opinion. That does give the impression that you are biased against it, be it true or not. Maybe "faith based nutrition" or something else would suit better?
Otherwise you could add "cars" to the topics as well. They are not woo, but people die if they "take it too far"......
What about "drinking water"? Of course not woo, but people have died because of drinking too much in too short a time etc., or, in other words, you could add about anything to your site, which does not make sense to me.
After a short glance on the veg. cases I did not see one where vegetarianism itself was the cause of the harm. Veganism seems to be a different story....

Disclaimer: I´m a meat eater, so I do not have an agenda here. My daughter, who lives with the mother, is raised vegetarian though, and I do not have a problem with that, since the mother does about everything to ensure that my daughter gets all the nutrients she needs.

Please do not feel attacked, it is meant as a well-intentioned critique.
More people like you or RSL are needed that do not only talk, but are actually willing to do the work.
 
Last edited:
I disagree. Not eating meat and dairy products can be dangerous, even lethal, for both children and adults.

Vegetarianism can be religious, such as in Eastern religions, or cultural. It can also resemble a ideology and like all ideologies, may or may not lead to real trouble.

It can also be irrational, which is what the site seeks to combat.
 
I disagree.


You are entitled to do so :).


Not eating meat and dairy products can be dangerous, even lethal, for both children and adults.


That sentence is true, but does not really contradict my point. As far as I´m informed, vegetarianism just means: no meat, no fish. Eating no meat, eggs and dairy products is a very special form of vegetarianism, namely veganism. This is what I said regarding that point:

I did not see one where vegetarianism itself was the cause of the harm. Veganism seems to be a different story....


Most vegetarians would be ovo-lacto vegetarians (no meat, but eggs and dairy products), and absolutely no harm arises from that. Of course there could be harm if the diet is not balanced, but that´s the same as with a diet containing meat (fast food anyone?), which means, the harm is not caused by vegetarianism itself.
Not eating meat is not harmful. Feel free to look for contradicting evidence.

Vegetarianism can be religious, such as in Eastern religions, or cultural.


Yes. So?
Not drinking alcohol can be religiously motivated. Not killing anyone can be religiously or culturally motivated.
What´s your point?


It can also resemble a ideology and like all ideologies, may or may not lead to real trouble.


Then the ideology that causes harm should be attacked. Vegetarianism itself is not harmful. To say so despite contradicting evidence makes an impression of bias, which should be avoided.

It can also be irrational, which is what the site seeks to combat.


Maybe you did not read my post completely. I did not say it would be better to not raise the point at all. I said I would change the headline for this section. Absolutely nothing wrong with highlighting cases where lack of critical thinking regarding nutrition causes harm, but they should be presented in a "fair" manner and not raise the impression that they are there to push another ideology: Not eating meat is bad.
I do not think this is what krelnik is out for, but I see the possibility that it gives that impression.
 
....Maybe you did not read my post completely. I did not say it would be better to not raise the point at all. I said I would change the headline for this section. Absolutely nothing wrong with highlighting cases where lack of critical thinking regarding nutrition causes harm, but they should be presented in a "fair" manner and not raise the impression that they are there to push another ideology: Not eating meat is bad.
I do not think this is what krelnik is out for, but I see the possibility that it gives that impression.

If you should listen to krelnik (Tim Farley) being interviewed here:
http://www.skepticality.com/sn_Ep84.html ... He mentions that he will change that section, possibly to something that has to do with child nutrition.
 
Not eating meat is not harmful. Feel free to look for contradicting evidence.

...

Yes. So?
Not drinking alcohol can be religiously motivated. Not killing anyone can be religiously or culturally motivated.
What´s your point?

...

Then the ideology that causes harm should be attacked. Vegetarianism itself is not harmful. To say so despite contradicting evidence makes an impression of bias, which should be avoided.

I think of vegetarianism a little like I think of fireworks: most of the time, it's harmless and it's ok for children if it's done safely but it sometimes gets way out of hand or a simple mistake is made and a real tragedy results.

I've lent Mr. Farley a hand with locating news stories since I have access to databases he doesn't and even I'm surprised at the number of stories I have found about vegetarianism gone very wrong. There are dozens of stories of children being starved, malnourished, injured, removed from their parents, etc. - even the occasional story of an adult hurting themselves. I'd have thought that these stories would be sad but rare but it's convinced me that it's an issue worth pointing out.

Granted, most of them are to be blamed on extremism and fanaticism (and most involve veganism, fruitarianism or raw food diets) but sometimes you have to fault vegetarianism itself. Changing your diet, setting an improper diet or experimenting with unknown foods can lead to a disaster.

I can think of several hypothetical situations of religious vegetarianism leading to harm. Such as Hindu law punishing a non-vegetarian person for killing a cow or a family in a poor country struggling to feed themselves but refusing to eat meat to survive, even though they should.

Here's one sad case where religious vegetarianism is a least partially to blame:

http://www.boston.com/news/local/ar...nge_student_says_he_was_denied_adequate_food/
 
I think of vegetarianism a little like I think of fireworks: most of the time, it's harmless and it's ok for children if it's done safely but it sometimes gets way out of hand or a simple mistake is made and a real tragedy results.


I think of nutrition a little like I think of fireworks: most of the time, it´s ok for children if it's done safely but it sometimes gets way out of hand or a simple mistake is made and a real tragedy results.

I've lent Mr. Farley a hand with locating news stories since I have access to databases he doesn't and even I'm surprised at the number of stories I have found about vegetarianism nutrition gone very wrong.


Corrected it for you.

There are dozens of stories of children being starved, malnourished, injured, removed from their parents, etc. - even the occasional story of an adult hurting themselves. I'd have thought that these stories would be sad but rare but it's convinced me that it's an issue worth pointing out.


No disagreement here, see my former posts.

Granted, most of them are to be blamed on extremism and fanaticism (and most involve veganism, fruitarianism or raw food diets) but sometimes you have to fault vegetarianism itself. Changing your diet, setting an improper diet or experimenting with unknown foods can lead to a disaster.


No disagreement except for the bolded part. Since not eating meat and fish (and that is the definition of vegetarianism) itself does not cause harm, I´d like to know how that is even theoretically possible.

I can think of several hypothetical situations of religious vegetarianism leading to harm. Such as Hindu law punishing a non-vegetarian person for killing a cow


Then the religion is to blame, not the vegetarianism. See the difference?

or a family in a poor country struggling to feed themselves but refusing to eat meat to survive, even though they should.


Poor families seldom eat meat because it is more expensive than veggies etc.
I´d actually like to see the cases of poor families that do not have enough vegetarian stuff to eat but would have enough meat to compensate. Got any?

Here's one sad case where religious vegetarianism is a least partially to blame:

http://www.boston.com/news/local/ar...nge_student_says_he_was_denied_adequate_food/


From your link:

Rather, he said, it reflected mean and stingy treatment by his host family and a language barrier that made it difficult to communicate.

when the family observed a fast limiting the amount of animal protein he was given.


So it´s a mixture of bad character and religious nuttery that is to blame.
Animal protein does not equal meat and fish. The vegetarianism did not cause the harm.

If you should listen to krelnik (Tim Farley) being interviewed here:
http://www.skepticality.com/sn_Ep84.html ... He mentions that he will change that section, possibly to something that has to do with child nutrition.


Thanks for the link, can´t listen to it now, since I post from work, but will do later at home. Your statement indicates that krelnik, whom, to mention it once more, I have a lot of respect for, is willing to accept and examine criticism. Great! Go, krelnik!
 
Yes, I've already made the change to the vegetarian page that I mentioned in that interview. The very first sentence on the page is now:

There is no harm in a properly balanced vegetarian diet.


Experience has shown that I will still get complaints from vegetarians, however. I'm getting used to it. The other day some random dude (not a vegetarian as far as I can tell) accused me of being intolerant. This was the gist of his email:

I think the more important question here, which your site and skeptics in general tend to ignore, is: What is the harm to YOU PERSONALLY? Of course misinformation is causing harm to people all the time, either to themselves or their children, but if belief in ooky-spooky religions or psychic powers or practice in weird rituals etc. doesn't personally harm YOU, I don't see what gives you the right to become a holy crusader against all that is wrong with the world. Stupidity abounds, but it really is not your problem. What you are practicing here is just another brand of intolerance.

My friends, family, and teachers will tell you I'm exceedingly rational in my decisions and debates. So basically I'm not just some religious nut writing in to complain at you because you have a different opinion from me. I just happen to feel that no one has any business interfering in the lives of others in any way, regardless of how they feel about what others believe or how they act.

If it does not affect your life personally, or if it affects you to a degree roughly equivalent to how you affect them, then I don't see why you can't just leave people to live whatever lives they want to.


I don't even know how to reply to that.
 
Last edited:
I don't even know how to reply to that.

"Stupidity abounds, but it really is not your problem."

The thing is that it IS your problem, Tim. It's my problem, it's everyone's problem.

If the foolishness and stupidity is doing such wonderful PR in the anti-vaccination movement for example, and causes enough kids to go un-vaccinated, we're going to have problems. If the homeopathy movement starts to get money directed away from real science in favour of quack treatments, then we all suffer. If Scientology remains unchecked, we'll see more Tom Cruise and Will Smith on TV and in the movies, and that's unthinkable.

Maybe it's not your problem if some crazy vegan tries to feed their kid soy milk, but the issue is larger than any one story.
 
that guy said:
I just happen to feel that no one has any business interfering in the lives of others in any way, regardless of how they feel about what others believe or how they act.

So then why bother to interfere in the life of krelnik and his site? ;)
 
Poor families seldom eat meat because it is more expensive than veggies etc.
I´d actually like to see the cases of poor families that do not have enough vegetarian stuff to eat but would have enough meat to compensate. Got any?

As a matter of fact, I can think of one pretty good example.

The famous black American leader and activist Malcolm X was raised by a Seventh Day Adventist widowed mother who practised vegetarianism and banned him and his six siblings from eating certain types of meat and enspecially pork, even though they were living on the brink of starvation.

I believe she even prevented her sons from hunting on their own or accepting food from friends and neighbors, even as they had no income, were living off of welfare in 1930s Michigan and had a baby and several very small children at home.

Sadly, corrupt social workers looking for an excuse to separate the children latched onto the fact that she wouldn't eat certain types of meat even under dire circumstances as proof of insanity and placed the children in foster homes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom