krelnik
Graduate Poster
Skeptics, I need your help. But first, a story. (Apologies for the length, I promise it's worth it).
A couple of months ago I was thinking about the topic of the upcoming TAM: Skepticism & Activism. I thought I should find a project to work on to be more of a positive contributor to the skeptical community. Around that time, this Sylvia Browne thread got me thinking about the “what’s the harm” idea that comes up periodically on skeptic websites. There are many threads on this here at JREF as well.
I like the harm discussions that include actual cases, but there's two problems with them. One is that the news links within tend to expire pretty quickly, and the details of the stories get lost. Another is that this information is scattered around the web and not easily found. As a result, you don’t easily get a sense of scope.
Thinking about scope, I flashed on an image of the Vietnam Memorial in Washington DC. If you’ve never seen it, it is a huge black stone wall that has carved into it the names of all of the 58,000+ Americans who died in that war. Standing in front of it can fill you with a sense of awe. There are several reasons it is a powerful experience, but one is that it really drives home the scope. People in general have a hard time with large numbers. You can intellectually understand the scope of "58,000 people died," but seeing those names on that wall stretching out for hundreds of feet creates an emotional impact.
It occurred to me that we skeptics could use something like that to create an emotional impact of the power of non-critical thinking. Perhaps this can become a tool to keep ourselves motivated. Of course, I’m not proposing we build a stone monument. But we can build one made of bits.
And so I present "The Wall of Harm" currently temporarily located here: [nfurl]krelnik.home.mindspring.com/harm/[/nfurl].
As I write this, it contains info on 2,396 people who have died and 17,631 people who have been hurt in some way by some form of woo. The cases are grouped by categories for browsing, and every one includes a supporting link or two.
My general philosophy on what cases I’ve included:
The Purpose of this Thread:
PLEASE do not blog about the wall of harm yet. Do not post it anywhere but on this forum. It is only in prototype form, a "beta" if you will. I plan to clean it up based on your comments here and move it to a more permanent home very soon. At that time I’ll be begging you to link to it, so be patient.
I would like to thank JeffWagg, scotth, ottle, Cleon, RemieV, moopet, Zygar, Loon and others in the JREF IRC channel who helped me with links and suggestions as I worked on this.
A couple of months ago I was thinking about the topic of the upcoming TAM: Skepticism & Activism. I thought I should find a project to work on to be more of a positive contributor to the skeptical community. Around that time, this Sylvia Browne thread got me thinking about the “what’s the harm” idea that comes up periodically on skeptic websites. There are many threads on this here at JREF as well.
I like the harm discussions that include actual cases, but there's two problems with them. One is that the news links within tend to expire pretty quickly, and the details of the stories get lost. Another is that this information is scattered around the web and not easily found. As a result, you don’t easily get a sense of scope.
Thinking about scope, I flashed on an image of the Vietnam Memorial in Washington DC. If you’ve never seen it, it is a huge black stone wall that has carved into it the names of all of the 58,000+ Americans who died in that war. Standing in front of it can fill you with a sense of awe. There are several reasons it is a powerful experience, but one is that it really drives home the scope. People in general have a hard time with large numbers. You can intellectually understand the scope of "58,000 people died," but seeing those names on that wall stretching out for hundreds of feet creates an emotional impact.
It occurred to me that we skeptics could use something like that to create an emotional impact of the power of non-critical thinking. Perhaps this can become a tool to keep ourselves motivated. Of course, I’m not proposing we build a stone monument. But we can build one made of bits.
And so I present "The Wall of Harm" currently temporarily located here: [nfurl]krelnik.home.mindspring.com/harm/[/nfurl].
As I write this, it contains info on 2,396 people who have died and 17,631 people who have been hurt in some way by some form of woo. The cases are grouped by categories for browsing, and every one includes a supporting link or two.
My general philosophy on what cases I’ve included:
- Good documentation. I avoided anonymous web postings, unless the site posting it is very well trusted. Mostly I used news links (often two) or scientific journal papers.
- Clear harm. Someone was injured or died, or lost significant money as a direct or indirect result of some type of woo. "Wasted their free time for years ghost-hunting" is not compelling. "Committed suicide after replacing anti-depressants with homeopathy," on the other hand, is compelling.
- Details, details, details. Cases with name, date, place and especially a victim photo are more compelling.
- Recent. I stayed within the last fifty years. After all, are stories about people believing crazy stuff back in 1607 in any way surprising?
- No "hate crimes". There are too many of these, they'd overwhelm the other categories. And, like ancient stuff, they aren't surprising to anyone.
The Purpose of this Thread:
- DO: Help me find more cases to add.
- DO: Help me find categories I haven’t covered. There has got to be a cryptozoologist who drowned in Loch Ness, or a UFO person who caught pneumonia camping out to wait for the aliens to arrive. Help me find them!
- DO: Offer corrections on the existing data. Note that cases can appear in multiple categories, feel free to point out opportunities I’ve missed in that area. (The religion areas could probably use some help in tagging).
- DO: Comment on the overall presentation and ways to make it more compelling. (Yes, I know my HTML is lame).
- DO NOT: Argue that some of these folks brought it on themselves.
- DO NOT: Argue about the value of anecdotes.
- DO NOT: Argue about how as skeptics we should be more scientific and precise than this.
- DO NOT: Argue about causality vs. correlation between the woo and the harm in these cases.
PLEASE do not blog about the wall of harm yet. Do not post it anywhere but on this forum. It is only in prototype form, a "beta" if you will. I plan to clean it up based on your comments here and move it to a more permanent home very soon. At that time I’ll be begging you to link to it, so be patient.
I would like to thank JeffWagg, scotth, ottle, Cleon, RemieV, moopet, Zygar, Loon and others in the JREF IRC channel who helped me with links and suggestions as I worked on this.
Last edited: