Please help with the "Wall of Harm"

Interesting site, Krelnik, with lots of scope for expansion- Thinking of your OP made this off topic thought pop into my head-
Do the Vietnames have an equivalent of "The Vietnam Wall"?
How many names on it?
 
Last edited:
Thanks! Work continues...

Thanks for all the suggestions, everyone! I've captured all the case information you've posted and am working on updating the database today.

Some of you may have noticed that I did a site update earlier in the week, incorporating several of the general suggestions. I've updated the FAQ, added a contact page and added other improvements. For one thing, you can like directly to a case by the person's name now, like this:

http://whatstheharm.net/chiropractic.html#les_limage

(The person links are always their names in lower case, minus any non-alphabetic characters, and with spaces replaced with underscores. When in doubt, view the HTML source and look for the <A name=""> tag).

Some of your suggestions will have to wait a bit. In particular, the various suggestions about different sorting or presentations of the data, summaries, subtotals and the like. I'm deliberately holding off on that stuff. I feel like right now I'm in "catch up" mode. I'm still finding many, many cases that are 10 or more years old. As a result, I feel like data-mining or other manipulation this data is premature. It's like trying to use a phone book that has pages ripped out.

For those who asked: the pages are sorted alphabetically by victim's name right now. However, I have deliberately rigged the sorting so that "anonymous" cases sort to the bottom of each list. I think cases with names are more compelling so I want them at the top.

I do have a search box on the site now, and it searches not only my site but also the pages I link to. So you can search cases based on details that I don't include. The search is a bit quirky right now because Google has only crawled me once, and missed a few pages. Keep googlebombing the site and that should clear up. I'm gonna tweak my search engine definition and sitemap too, which hopefully will goose the googlebot into covering me better.

Thanks again for all the help, and keep them coming!
 
Tips on finding & submitting cases

As I mentioned above, every time I whip out my Google-fu I can find more cases for the site. Many are years old, but often were never written about in the skepti-sphere. I find them buried in the oddest places, too. I found a woman who treated her cancer with homeopathy (with predictable outcome) in a theater review in the New York Times for petes sake!

I get the feeling that there are hundreds of these cases out there, just waiting to be found. You folks can help me with this!

Tip 1: Simply combining the name of some form of woo with the word "died" or "injured", often gets amazing results. For example, "naturopath died". It is worth nothing that Google will return variant forms of the word without you doing anything special, so for instance a search for "homeopath" will return an article with only "homeopathic" in it if the other search terms match. (It didn't used to work this way, I'm not sure when Google added that).

Tip 2: Use the archive search on Google News. Current news stories often get alot of attention here in the forums. That makes older stories much more useful. You can search older news at Google here:

http://news.google.com/archivesearch

There are tools there to limit the year as well, another good way to avoid cases I already have.

One amusing thing about this: the New York Times has over 100 years of archives online now, so if you search on "quack" or "homeopath", you can find stories from 1895 that seem not too different from the modern ones.

Remember, however, I'm deliberately confining What's The Harm to the last 50 years (with a few exceptions for notable stories). This is because I think the idea that people believed crazy stuff in 1780 is just not that surprising to anyone. For other guidelines on what I'm looking for in cases, see http://whatstheharm.net/contact.html.

Tip 3: Please check the site to see if I already have the case! No sense wasting your time on something I already have. However, if you find a link that is better than the link I'm using on a given story, feel free to send that in.

Tip 4: Pick a category I don't have many cases in. If you don't have a favorite form of woo that you would rather concentrate on, browse the whatstheharm.net topics list and pick a topic I have under 20 cases in. (There are a bunch). This makes it easier to avoid having to scroll through stories I already have while searching.

Tip 5: If you have non-web resources available, use them. Anybody have access to Lexis/Nexis or other non-public databases? Many news web sites cycle their stories very quickly. I've had some of my links go stale just in the four months I've been doing this. But those pay databases keep everything. I'm thinking the same search techniques that I mention above might work well there. If you can limit to older stories only, so much the better.


Finally, please start sending all CASE STORIES to this address:

SUBMIT (at) WHATSTHEHARM (dot) NET

I can manage the workload better using the email as a queue. One case per email with the victim's name in the subject line makes that even easier, but I'll take anything you send me!

Thanks again for all the help.
 
Thoughts on the "quackery" category?

It occurs to me that the "quackery" category I have is not that useful from the stand point of appealing to believers. What believer would ever click on it? Who ever thinks they are going to a quack?

I'm thinking about combining those cases under another sort of catch-all category I have which is "Alternative medicine". I use that one for woo-ish medical cases that don't obviously fit into one of the more precise categories like "homeopathy". (Though sometimes I double-tag cases that have multiple modalities, one vague and one specific).

Thoughts?
 
Last edited:
Hi Krelnik,

I just got this thrown in my face on the Hpathy forums:

Here's another issue you have to factor in--is a person with leukemia close to death because of all the inappropriate and toxic radiation and chemotherapeutic agents he has ingested? You cannot separate the two, because you can't show me a leukemia patient anywhere who is not burdened with this treatment.

So maybe there's a need for another category - Doing Nothing ??
 
Last edited:
I like the site -- I even blogged about it (ok, ok, only after Bad Astronomer blogged it, but still, I did MEAN to!). I think the descriptions of the cases could be a little bit longer. I'd be more than happy to devote a couple weekends to helping you out. Drop me a PM if you'd like -- though I understand that getting the site operational first is probably more your priority.
 
The super-short summaries was originally a limitation of the cheesy cobbled-together database I'm using to generate the site. But actually I think it is a good thing to keep them as short as possible. There's always the supporting links to go to for additional details.

That having been said, if there's a specific story that you think isn't coming across well in my summary, feel free to suggest a better summary! I'm not overly attached to my own verbiage.

Another great way you can help out right now is to follow the tips I posted in response #123 above, and find more stories to add to the site. They're pretty easy to find, the hardest part is avoiding duplication of stories I already have.
 
The super-short summaries was originally a limitation of the cheesy cobbled-together database I'm using to generate the site. But actually I think it is a good thing to keep them as short as possible. There's always the supporting links to go to for additional details.

The thing I think some people are worried about is that if you point someone to the site and say "yeah, THERE'S the harm," they might be put off or exasperated by the aggressively short descriptions, and certainly aren't going to be in a mindset to be following links and doing their own research. I mean, that's why we're pointing them to the site in the first place, right? Because they are misinformed? In any event, I think you're right -- getting the actual number of cases logged ought to be your first priority, then you can worry about prettyin' up the site :D. I'll do some google-fu this weekend if I have time!

ETA: PS -- if anyone has access to the Lexis-Nexis database, that would be an EXCELLENT source for news stories.
 
Last edited:
PS -- a couple friends I pointed towards the site didn't realize that the little "?" dealys are links to additional info. Just FYI!
 
PS -- a couple friends I pointed towards the site didn't realize that the little "?" dealys are links to additional info. Just FYI!

Yeah, I've gotten some emails in the last few days where it eventually became clear to me that the person never followed the links. One person even asked me where my supporting information was.

I need to do something with those icons to make it more obvious. I don't want to have the full title of the link because I think it will draw attention away from the stories. Hmmm, maybe something short like this:

Peter Sellers (actor)
Age: 54
Dorchester, England
Died (untreated heart condition)
July 24, 1980

A heart attack in 1964 had permanently damaged his heart. His doctors were advising bypass surgery, but he delayed it and instead saw psychic surgeons twice a year. He died of a massive heart attack. Discovery Channel Wikipedia
 
Just a little bump here to note that I put a bunch of updates on the site this weekend. There are several new categories including "alternative dentistry" and "reparative therapy".

Here are my two favorite recently added stories:

http://whatstheharm.net/herbalremedies.html#sedef_olcer
http://whatstheharm.net/conspiracytheories.html#richard_mccaslin

The latter one came from another thread here on JREF after I mentioned the site.

As always, there's still more work to do, including the design-related fixes such as changing the icons. And I still want to provide a way to jump to related categories from within a story.

Keep those new cases coming to submit (at) whatstheharm (dot) net, and thanks again to everyone. You've all been invaluable help.
 
I think it would be great if you could add links to Wikipedia for the cause of death.

Something like this:

Died (water intoxication)

Or you could add an icon (similar to what you have for links to news stories) with a link to Wikipedia.

It would make it easier for people to educate themselves.
 
Last edited:
That's a good idea. I've got some "structural" changes to the site (changing the way things link and stuff) coming, I'll put that on the list.
 
Last edited:
Hi Krelnik. I couldn´t find the contact links on your site, so I´ll just give my correction sugestion here. In the section on colloidal silver you present a link to Rosemary Jacobs website. The link leads to her old site, which contains a link to her new site. Being a man of few posts I´m not (yet) allowed to post the link to her new site, but if you follow the present link on your site you can easily get the correct web address.
 
Hi Krelnik. I couldn´t find the contact links on your site, so I´ll just give my correction sugestion here. In the section on colloidal silver you present a link to Rosemary Jacobs website. The link leads to her old site, which contains a link to her new site. Being a man of few posts I´m not (yet) allowed to post the link to her new site, but if you follow the present link on your site you can easily get the correct web address.


Is this the one you mean?
http://rosemaryjacobs.com/
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom