VonNeumann
Muse
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2006
- Messages
- 914
DrFrank, you are a charming fellow and made me laugh.Hello VonNeumannI would like you to answer a few questions for me so that I can better understand where you're coming from (ID is such a broad, vague, nebulous thing, you see):
a) How old is the Earth?
b) Do you believe that there is any extant evidence for speciation?
c) Do you, more specifically, believe that there is evidence that human and apes share recent common ancestry?
d) Is there any piece of evidence that could be found that would cause you to reject ID?
I look forward to your replies.
aa) What is ID? You are right it is vague and I'm not sure myself.
a) How old is the Earth? I'll go with 4BYO (sounds too short to me but I dunno). If it is only a few thousand, then I could believe that sort of like I could believe that reality started this morning when I got out of bed and my past memories are really a dream.
b) ..believe.. speciation? I have not seen anything yet that moves me. Tell me what you think would be the best example (link?).
c) Humans apes share common ancestry? I'm surprised our genome is minimally a few million codes different than some apes. It is interesting that it takes that much information to revise an ape into a human - I might have thought it would take less. I do not know how changes to a common ancestor's genome, could result in that much informational difference in such a short period of time (use 10^100 years = "short period of time" - I'm being generous, see). I would feel much better about the idea of common ancestry if the informational difference were more trivial in magnitude.
d) Could I reject ID? I don't think anyone you or I know rejects ID. Let me explain. When I had faith that RM/NS could create new sequences of viable code, I ostensibly believed that there was some sort of creative power embedded in that mechanism. We, all of us, just read the various texts, use words like 'design' when describing biological processes etc. I used to extrapolate that faith into a belief that humans could create AI, without knowing how to do it exactly, by evolving it in a computer simulation. Then I realized that it was doubtful that there really is a creative power embedded in the basic structure of 'what is', of matter or some other natural source. ( ...sort of like this: the meaning of these words you are reading do not come from the phosphor pixels (drat: you have LCD!), they come from my mind, you see I'm way the hell over here, so don't explore too much the phosphor pixels) I do not reject that something designed everything and I bet neither do you. Some believe RM/NS has that capacity and I dissent and doubt. That does not help me tell you WHAT is doing the design. But don't we both agree that the design is intelligent? BTW, my main turning point away from RM/NS as a creative mechanism was the simple arithmetic one can do to calculate the amount of digits of pi you would have to go through to find a short sonnet. Design may not be possible in this universe, just as the words you are reading here were not designed and could not have been designed, by these here phosphor dots, they were designed by me and i'm way the hell over here. Look here, not there.
If we were drinking a few beers together I might tell you I sometimes am sure we live in a simulation - if nobody else were listening -sshhhhh.