Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Hello VonNeumann :) I would like you to answer a few questions for me so that I can better understand where you're coming from (ID is such a broad, vague, nebulous thing, you see):
a) How old is the Earth?
b) Do you believe that there is any extant evidence for speciation?
c) Do you, more specifically, believe that there is evidence that human and apes share recent common ancestry?
d) Is there any piece of evidence that could be found that would cause you to reject ID?
I look forward to your replies.
DrFrank, you are a charming fellow and made me laugh.
aa) What is ID? You are right it is vague and I'm not sure myself.
a) How old is the Earth? I'll go with 4BYO (sounds too short to me but I dunno). If it is only a few thousand, then I could believe that sort of like I could believe that reality started this morning when I got out of bed and my past memories are really a dream.
b) ..believe.. speciation? I have not seen anything yet that moves me. Tell me what you think would be the best example (link?).
c) Humans apes share common ancestry? I'm surprised our genome is minimally a few million codes different than some apes. It is interesting that it takes that much information to revise an ape into a human - I might have thought it would take less. I do not know how changes to a common ancestor's genome, could result in that much informational difference in such a short period of time (use 10^100 years = "short period of time" - I'm being generous, see). I would feel much better about the idea of common ancestry if the informational difference were more trivial in magnitude.
d) Could I reject ID? I don't think anyone you or I know rejects ID. Let me explain. When I had faith that RM/NS could create new sequences of viable code, I ostensibly believed that there was some sort of creative power embedded in that mechanism. We, all of us, just read the various texts, use words like 'design' when describing biological processes etc. I used to extrapolate that faith into a belief that humans could create AI, without knowing how to do it exactly, by evolving it in a computer simulation. Then I realized that it was doubtful that there really is a creative power embedded in the basic structure of 'what is', of matter or some other natural source. ( ...sort of like this: the meaning of these words you are reading do not come from the phosphor pixels (drat: you have LCD!), they come from my mind, you see I'm way the hell over here, so don't explore too much the phosphor pixels) I do not reject that something designed everything and I bet neither do you. Some believe RM/NS has that capacity and I dissent and doubt. That does not help me tell you WHAT is doing the design. But don't we both agree that the design is intelligent? BTW, my main turning point away from RM/NS as a creative mechanism was the simple arithmetic one can do to calculate the amount of digits of pi you would have to go through to find a short sonnet. Design may not be possible in this universe, just as the words you are reading here were not designed and could not have been designed, by these here phosphor dots, they were designed by me and i'm way the hell over here. Look here, not there.

If we were drinking a few beers together I might tell you I sometimes am sure we live in a simulation - if nobody else were listening -sshhhhh.
 
DNA/RNA part of what explanation? The explanation you suggest is that thousands of bits of information appeared out of nowhere? DNA/RNA are already very complex systems. You are not talking about "gradualism" - or is gradualism not part of the "modern synthesis"? I've been waiting for decades to see a theory of precursors to DNA/RNA that has any meat. Boys, we will be waiting a while longer. When I got a copy of Stuart Kaufman's "Origins of Order", I was hopeful for an explanation but it was dissappointing. I think it was a good step and it is great stuff when contrasted to Dawkins stupid kindergarten magic show with his cybermorphs or whatever he calls it. Dawkins appears to me a politician posing as a scientist.


I'd like to learn from you what is "all the fossil evidence, DNA evidence..." and please give me an example of observed speciation. If you have the time, just let us see what you think is one best example of each.


I've read the first two. Refresh me, what is the generating engine, the synthesizer of new information, that Dawkins theorizes that is not ultimately random (trying to use the term random in the mathematical sense).


Sure - everyone knows that. I understand why you keep bringing up god because you are an atheist. The idea of ID does not have to be YOUR idea of what a designer would be. The designer could come from the future (time loop?). That's one fallacy or 'interesting characteristic' I've noticed about this mind-set most of you have (and I used to have). And that is this: god does not exist YET. Quickly: bigbang begets H, He, etc, beget stars, beget family of elements, begets C-based life, begets human creativity, begets silicon artifacts, begets AI, begets ultra-advanced science, begets science greater than magic (immortality, pure energy minds, near infinite intelligence), begets GOD. So if you find all that palatable, why are you so sure that DIDN'T ALREADY HAPPEN? You are merely arguing where you are on a time line: Maybe IDers think we are farther to the right on the time-line than you do. Pretty trivial, right? This is merely 'pride' - the Greeks called it hubris.


Jon, you silly goose.


Darwinism does not have to be proven - it is axiomatic, right? I call it darwinism because nothing substantive to natural selection has been added since 'random mutation' was added - so it is old and tired. It is a simple explanation of preservation of species - I agree - it is good for that albeit an obvious idea known for thousands of years. I disagree that random mutation and natural selection (if there is more to the theory's basic functional blocks, educate me, I'm listening) is a sufficient mechanism for building significant-sized new information in this machine we call 'our universe'.


I understand Jon. I used to be where you are.

I just wanted to state how in awe I am of this poster - who has single handedly brought up points that evolutionary biologists are just stumped over, and have no answer for.

Finally the veil has been lifted and we can start to learn from ID! So
VonNeuman, let's get started. Please name one prediction the Theory of ID makes and show me an experiment or math that tests it? What's first?
 
Ian, what you don't understand about the Anthropic Principle and probability in general could (and has, in fact) fill several books.

The entire flaw in the Anthropic Principle is the conditions placed on "life". The probability of life on earth evolving in exactly the way it has, viewed from before it happened (that is, starting from scratch and saying "here's what qualifies, what are the odds?"), are astronomical and approach zero. But that doesn't prove anything. Your "special order" is only special because it has already happened.

Right, so we shuffle a deck of cards. We get a sequence ace - king by suits. But we wouldn't have thought this sequence was special beforehand.

If life had evolved drastically differently from how it already has, then that would be the "special order". How many different ways can life evolve? Nobody knows. And without that knowledge the "specialness" of this particular way is not determinable. End of Story.

This is not the discussion. It's the fact that intelligent life arose at all. I agree that the skeptic argument is applicable in the scenario you're concentrating on.
 
As I keep arguing, some sequences are special. If a special order of cards should transpire after shuffling the cards, then this is surprising. If there is a googolplex of cards and only one special sequence, then it is effectively something that couldn't happen, and we would know something fishy is going on should it transpire.

this is true only if you shuffle the deck a limited number of times. if you shuffle the deck enough times the occurance of a particular "special" order won't be so surprising.

Before you can calculate how "special" for our universe support our life is you must know how many failed big bangs there were before the one that resulted in a universe with our laws.

Then to calculate how "special" the occurance of life building up from the results of random chemical processes is you must know how many difference chemical mixtures were tried, how fast they could be tried, over how many millions of years they were tried.
 
DrFrank, you are a charming fellow and made me laugh.
aa) What is ID? You are right it is vague and I'm not sure myself.
a) How old is the Earth? I'll go with 4BYO (sounds too short to me but I dunno). If it is only a few thousand, then I could believe that sort of like I could believe that reality started this morning when I got out of bed and my past memories are really a dream.
b) ..believe.. speciation? I have not seen anything yet that moves me. Tell me what you think would be the best example (link?).
c) Humans apes share common ancestry? I'm surprised our genome is minimally a few million codes different than some apes. It is interesting that it takes that much information to revise an ape into a human - I might have thought it would take less. I do not know how changes to a common ancestor's genome, could result in that much informational difference in such a short period of time (use 10^100 years = "short period of time" - I'm being generous, see). I would feel much better about the idea of common ancestry if the informational difference were more trivial in magnitude.

OK, you're not a YEC, which means that you're not away with the fairies, at least ;)

For speciation, let's look at ourselves and apes:

* Our morphological similarities are enormous.

* when looking at the portions of the DNA that code for genes between chimpanzees and humans, the measured difference comes to about 1.5% (although there are quite a few different measures). Given the sexual maturity of an ape at 7 years old, so assume they'd reproduce by 8, and that the original ape/human line diverged 6mya (I read estimates of 5-7mya), then to produce that amount of change would require a divergence of 30 neutral point mutations per generation (in both groups) to get to where we are. All humans have quite a number of point mutations that make them differ from their parents, although I think estimates are a little below this, but it's definitely not such a large number.

However, my stupidly simple model above ignores any effects of insertions/deletions/reversals etc. that would significantly increase diversity, and also differing alleles that become predominant in the different reproductively isolated groups. There are undoubtedly other factors I've ignored due to my ignorance too which people can feel free to criticise :)

* We share the same pseudogene that should ideally aid production of Vitamin C that the apes do. Ever wonder why we need fruit and your pet dog doesn't?
Why on Earth would we share the identical non-functional gene as apes whereas basically every other animal has a functional one?

* There are several thousand hominid fossils detailing variations on a theme between apes and humans. Their traits, based on their age, show a general variation from more apelike to humanlike. That's got to be a damn big coincidence if it's not due to evolution.

* Humans have 23 pairs of chromosomes, apes have 24. Therefore, if we evolved from apes then a pair of chromosomes must have either split in the ape line or fused in our own. The human chromosome 2 demonstrates that a chromosomal fusion has taken place (remains of two centromeres), and the corresponding genetic material from two of the ape chromosomes is found there, supporting this theory. 1 in 1000 humans have a Robertsonian Translocation, which is a similar chromosomal fusion - these people are still fertile, and if interbred after a few generations could produce a child with 22 pairs of chromosomes without any problem (although they have an increased risk of miscarriage).

So, we have genetic evidence that shows how the (minor) differences in DNA occurred, both in terms of content and structure, and fossil evidence showing intermediate forms. Short of travelling back in time and videoing each step, I fail to see what else could be done.

Also, check out the transitional forms between the reptilian jaw and mammalian inner ear at Talk Origins

This is what is known as a lot of positive evidence supporting the ape/human speciation, and thus speciation in general, and that's only the stuff I can name off the top of my head.

[Edited: for a couple of corrections and to add stuff on divergence of DNA sequences]
 
Last edited:
this is true only if you shuffle the deck a limited number of times. if you shuffle the deck enough times the occurance of a particular "special" order won't be so surprising.

Before you can calculate how "special" for our universe support our life is you must know how many failed big bangs there were before the one that resulted in a universe with our laws.

Yes. How many Universes before ours were they that produced no life whatsoever? A million? A billion? A trillion? A quadrillion? A googolplex?
 
As I keep arguing, some sequences are special. If a special order of cards should transpire after shuffling the cards, then this is surprising. If there is a googolplex of cards and only one special sequence, then it is effectively something that couldn't happen, and we would know something fishy is going on should it transpire.

Any sequence is special to those in the sequence. You ever read Starmaker? It was by a philosopher that actually had something to say.
 
Unfortunately the correct image is of throwing a dart randomly at a white wall whose surface area is in the range of something like a googolplex times a googolplex square miles, with one tiny black spot on it, and the dart landing dead centre in this black spot.


If the black spot is you, it is special. It is like the lottery, the circle is relevant if it is you. Ya gotta read up on probability theory a bit.
 
Yes. How many Universes before ours were they that produced no life whatsoever? A million? A billion? A trillion? A quadrillion? A googolplex?

I think that a basic problem is that you don't have an appreciation for time and the magnitude of the universe. All those things could have happened many times over.

We are living in a Royal Flush. But at the same time there might very well be thousands of Royal Flushes and there might be places where Kangaroo Strights are the "special thing". You can't be so specicentric.
 
I think that a basic problem is that you don't have an appreciation for time and the magnitude of the universe. All those things could have happened many times over.

The hypothesis that many many Universes exist, or that there have been many many Big Bangs, basically makes this particular argument from design fail.

One could of course complain that the hypothesis of a huge number of Universes (whether "presently" existing or having existed), all wholly devoid of life, is somewhat metaphysically extravagant.
 
If the black spot is you, it is special. It is like the lottery, the circle is relevant if it is you. Ya gotta read up on probability theory a bit.

I don't think so. It seems my instinctive understanding of it far surpasses those skeptics on here who have actually studied it.
 
The hypothesis that many many Universes exist, or that there have been many many Big Bangs, basically makes this particular argument from design fail.

One could of course complain that the hypothesis of a huge number of Universes (whether "presently" existing or having existed), all wholly devoid of life, is somewhat metaphysically extravagant.

No, just one great big honkin' universe that is as old as anything.
 
I don't think so. It seems my instinctive understanding of it far surpasses those skeptics on here who have actually studied it.



eeeeeessssshhhhhhhh

Careful, the world is full of crackpots that say similar stuff about Einstein or physics generally. Such people often invent things and then get arrested.

I suggest that you may have a feel for it but that you don't apprehend it.
 
Right, so we shuffle a deck of cards. We get a sequence ace - king by suits. But we wouldn't have thought this sequence was special beforehand.

Appeal to incredulity, but ignoring that...

You only think it is special because you choose to see it that way. Mathematically, the sequence

2s3s4s5s6s7s8s9sTsJsQsKsAs
2h3h4h5h6h7h8h9hThJhQhKhAh
2c3c4c5c6c7c8c9cTcJcQcKcAc
2d3d4d5d6d7d8d9dTdJdQdKdAd

is no more special than

2cJd2s2h8d3hAc7d4cQs4sKcTh
8hAdTs5d5c4d4h9cKd9h8s6cJs
3d6h3sKs6sTc9sQc6dKh8c3cAh
Td7s5sJh5hQdQh2dJcAs9d7h7c

or

TdQs3c5dKdTsKc3s6sQc4hQhAc
9h2sAsKh9c8cJd5cAhKsAd4sJh
Tc2c5h7c8d3hJc7h7s9d9s3d2d
4d8s8h6hQd7d6d4c5sJs2h6cTh

regardless of your emotional attachment to the first one.

This is not the discussion. It's the fact that intelligent life arose at all. I agree that the skeptic argument is applicable in the scenario you're concentrating on.

They are exactly the same thing and that's why you keep missing the point. Nobody knows what the requirements for intelligent life to evolve are. Any speculation as to how unlikely it is for intelligent life to evolve are exactly that: pure speculation. For all we know intelligent life is as common in the universe as dirt and the conditions needed for intelligent life to arise may be as diverse as the number of stars in the universe. Without that information it is impossible to even guess how unlikely intelligent life is. You're marvelling at a dart hitting a black patch in a huge area without having any idea how much of that area is actually black. You're a puddle concluding that the hole you're in must have been designed for you simply because it fits so well.
 
How many do you think there were?

I have no reason to believe in any particular upper bound.

I have no complaints if you're appealing to this argument. However it does not apply to the question of my birth which you also argued against. You seem to be shifting your position.
 
Sure, but it limits the types of discoveries we can make.

In what way? We can't naturally see into the more interesting wavelengths but we can measure and simulate. Dolphins have evolved an echolocation system that works just fine. I personally have no problem with the concept that if we had always had a denser, less translucent atmosphere that we'd have evolved matching sense organs.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom