Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

I agree with that whole post. So we stand on the same ground about what science is for.
The major difference being the value we place on the pursuit.

Lets try something else to induce thinking outside your box. Let's assume that 100 years from now we find some weird stuff with quantum physics or something and we determine that we live in a simulation. Perhaps some of the simulator starts showing through in some quantum experiments we do. Maybe we find that this simulation we live in is, by design, incapable of calculating 'intelligence' and 'creativity'. Imagine that our universe is like the graphics card, but the CPU (where our 'selves' are) is where our self awareness and creativity calculates. The material universe (the graphics card) is what we've been studying all along and our brains are a sort of remote-terminal that joins our CPU selves with our graphics-card simulation. The creators of the simulation chuckle to think we are dumb enough to think that everything self-created in the limited graphics card and that so many of us believe the delusion that the graphics card is all there is. Some are imaginitive enough to suspect that there must be another domain and other agents (the programmers of the simulation) but are angrily dismissed by those who believe the delusion.
Woo rule #1: when all else fails, invoke quantum physics.

There's a guy called Iacchus who had an idea kind of like this.

I'm offering this as a metaphor so that you might consider that ID is for everyone. Open your mind but think critically. Maybe the darwinists are the ones who believe in the tooth fairy.
I'm glad you brought it up. Let's talk about ID.
 
What is an athiest but someone who is certain there is(are) no God(s)?
What is a theist but someone who is certain that most Gods don't exist? In fact, I suspect that most theists are more "certain" about this than most atheists are that no Gods exist. In fact, it's a matter of faith to them.
 
Last edited:
Problem: gaps in the fossil record:
1. Cambridge explosion. Darwin-faith-speak fills the gap with the explanation that the fossil record is lacking because the precursors' body parts were too soft to be preserved (explain away lack of evidence).

I'm sorry to learn of the Cambridge explosion. It was a lovely little town with some very nice people in it. I've some personal experience of a nice young lady from there who had delightfully soft body parts - they'll be sadly missed.
;)
 
This thread is a wild read, but simply put, All I say to ID proponents is prove your god exists before you claim this unproven object created evolutionary time after time began.

They are jumping the gun.

But wicked read, good stuff.
 
I'm sorry to learn of the Cambridge explosion. It was a lovely little town with some very nice people in it. I've some personal experience of a nice young lady from there who had delightfully soft body parts - they'll be sadly missed.
;)

Dammit, I went punting there recently and, torturously difficult though it was, I'll miss not having a second chance.

However, since I visited the place only a few months ago, surely this proves that the Cambridge explosion is actually much more recent than Darwinists claim (with their stupid 500 million years number), and thus falsifies evolution outright? ;)

Hello VonNeumann :) I would like you to answer a few questions for me so that I can better understand where you're coming from (ID is such a broad, vague, nebulous thing, you see):

a) How old is the Earth?
b) Do you believe that there is any extant evidence for speciation?
c) Do you, more specifically, believe that there is evidence that human and apes share recent common ancestry?
d) Is there any piece of evidence that could be found that would cause you to reject ID?

I look forward to your replies.
 
Last edited:
Has anyone ever shown that it is possible for the laws of physics to be anything other than what they are?

It seems a bit daft for people to say "Ah, well, if the strong nuclear force was X instead of Y, life could not exist" if they are unable to show that the various forces could actually be different.
 
That would require a meta-set of laws that would govern the laws of physics that we know of. I do not think we are quite there yet to determine if such metalaws exist.
 
Problem: gaps in the fossil record:
1. Cambridge explosion. Darwin-faith-speak fills the gap with the explanation that the fossil record is lacking because the precursors' body parts were too soft to be preserved (explain away lack of evidence).
Cambrian. (Others here are more polite than I am, I guess). The "soft body" hypothesis can be tested--and yes, we have found more than enough precambrian fossils to know that it is a reasonable hypothesis. Read this, for one nice summary.
2. Hoaxes: Piltdown man hoax, Nebraska man hoax (used in Scopes trial), etc. How do we know that H. Habilis is not just an ape - all alleged hominid fossil discoveries are guesses at best - wild conjectures.
These hoaxes, of course, were discovered to be hoaxes by...oh! Scientists! Not by creationists! Your hoaxes are actually evidence in favor of the methods of science. To suggest that the fossil record is all hoaxes would strain even a creationist's capacity for belief.
Here, educate yourself about Piltdown Man.
3. Equus family tree was conjured 100+ years ago and finally dispelled in the 1950s yet still appears in some school texts. Why? Because the darwin-faith club needs to fill the gap with conjured nonsense because they afraid to let the question hang until evidence tips the balance towards a SUPPORTABLE answer.
Some school texts? Why? Because of sloppy writing and editing, laziness, and a lack of scientific knowledge among people whose job it is to print books, not do science. Somebody here has a sig quote saying something like "never ascribe to malicious intent that which can be explained by ignorance."

More to the point...what about the other school texts? The ones that show a more modern rendering of our understanding of the Equus lineage?This strawman of yours is another that has been well addressed long ago.
3. The recurring problems we keep discovering with fossil record showing stasis instead of gradual change. Gould/Eldridge of the darwin-faith club couldn't totally ignore it so instead of explaining it, they gave it a cool sounding name "punctuated equilibrium". Why not name it "the stasis contra-evidence problem"?
The process of competing explanations, each amassing evidence, testing hypotheses, and eventually reaching a common consensus based on the evidence, is how science works. When a better explanation comes along, we explore it. This "objection" of yours is not a weakness of science, but a strength. And it is quite obviously not faith-based, despite your assertion, unless you have been borrowing Iacchus's dictionary.
4. I've got more ...
You don't even have these.
 
Last edited:
You have not studied about self-replicating molecules and self-organizing clays, have you? To say it is not very firmly grounded is as funny as 'scientists do not yet know everything there is to know about the human mind.'

Yes, actually, I have studied the theories about them. Tests are (and have been) performed to examine these ideas. However, this is specific to abiogenesis, not evolutionary theory (just to make that distinction clear. Abiogensis answers "How did life start?", evolution answers "What happens to life once it gets going?").

There is a downfall of science, and that is that it constantly allows itself to become subject to the established politburo. If you are on grant who signs your check? Ford Foundation? Rockefeller Foundation? Go read how the UN edited the scientists' paper on global warming to suit their political goals (i'm too lazy to get the link but it was june 12, 1996 in the wall street journal by former honcho of the Academy of Science named Seitz). Established science is a whore. You are probably too young to have figured that out yet.

Um, yeah. The only research ever funded is by the government, is that your view? You are probably too old to change your entrenched dogma (although I actually believe you to be rather young, based solely on your posting style and propensity to shift directly to insult rather than reasoned argument). The majority of funding for research comes from private companies, universities, and non-government grants. While the government funds a lot of research, it isn't the majority. Not to mention that, you have now posited that every government in the world has similar goals, at least in regards to the directions of science, because research is not just carried out in the U.S.A.

Unless you are a paleontologist/zoologist and know the facts but are too entrenched to admit evolution is wrong, then you could not possibly have educated yourself nor studied the relevant evidence with an open mind. What did you study, your (government-run) high school biology textbook? Its OK Huntsman, I was hook-line-sinker too (when I was young) and thought I was well educated too. No offense - its not your fault.

Thank you for the absolutely unsupported as hominem. No, I do know the facts because I took time to look for the evidence. Before I knew the subject, I thought much as you did. Then I started looking into the literature for these supposed fossil gaps. I started looking at the similarities of DNA across species. I started looking at morphology and how it related to species and classification. I marvelled at how an arbitrary classification system coincided so well with genetic evidence (with some exceptions).

Then I started reading the ID arguments again, and found that they were 30% bald assertions with no supporting evidence, 30% outright lies, 30% ad hoc explanations to explain away each new transitional fossil found, and only about 10% truth (just enough to confuse). The vacuous nature of evidence and argument on the ID and creation side is what really started me questioning the Bible and turned me away from faith. It wasn't the godless heathens, it was the religious scholars and proponents that made me realize religion was bunk. Much as yourself.

As to what I studied, I've studied quite a bit more than a high-school biology text. In fact, I studied a college-level biology text (from a private, Christian-funded college, matter of fact). Then I went omn to study various books written by experts in the field, and began to examine research and articles on my own through various journal publications. An expert? No, but I am a well-educated layman. I've gone beyond just books, to looking at specific finds and research papers, replications of those papers, documented observations pertinant to the field, and other material.
 
These hoaxes, of course, were discovered to be hoaxes by...oh! Scientists! Not by creationists! Your hoaxes are actually evidence in favor of the methods of science. To suggest that the fossil record is all hoaxes would strain even a creationist's capacity for belief.
This is a point that always particularly rankles with me too - whenever a fossil find is shown to be a fake, Creationists always seem to imply that the hoax was located through the diligent efforts of their fellow scientific Creationists to keep those lying `evolutionists' from spreading their evil. Of course, the fact is that they were painstakingly analysed by evolutionary biologists who care for the quality of evidence they present, something sadly lacking in the case of Creationists/IDiots.

On a different note, I always find amusing assertions that all hominid fossils are either purely human or purely ape. The great thing about this is that no two Creationists agree on which ones are which. Moreover, given that a child could probably accurately distinguish between ape and human skulls this seems to raise two possibilities:

a) Creationists are morons or
b) Each hominid fossil is more apelike than any human skull, and more humanlike than any ape skull, thus leading to possible classification as either depending on which features are examined.

OK, a) and b) aren't strictly mutually exclusive ;)
 
Last edited:
The ID'ers often forget that even the majority of Christians do not believe in ID. In fact, the spiritual leader of the world's largest Christian faith, catholicism, has publicly declared for evolution. In other words, evolution is not incompatible with faith in a god. I would even believe that evolution is not incompatible with ID! ID really only claims that design is intelligent, but not how that design was achieved. Evolution could be the method used by the designer to reach her goal!

It is only the fanatics who take the Bible literally who have to be at odds with science.
 
The ID'ers often forget that even the majority of Christians do not believe in ID. In fact, the spiritual leader of the world's largest Christian faith, catholicism, has publicly declared for evolution. In other words, evolution is not incompatible with faith in a god. I would even believe that evolution is not incompatible with ID! ID really only claims that design is intelligent, but not how that design was achieved. Evolution could be the method used by the designer to reach her goal!

It is only the fanatics who take the Bible literally who have to be at odds with science.

I think that you're being a little naive here. The Intelligent Design movement is nothing more than Biblical Creationism slightly rebranded - what it's really about is God reaching down and literally creating the different `kinds' of animals, hence why many IDers point out problems with hominid fossils and deny speciation.

The approach you refer to sounds like theistic evolution, a much more rational position to take, where you accept evolution but have faith that God is somewhere under there guiding it. Most theistic evolutionists, in my experience, have no problem in stating that the faith of God's role of evolution is unprovable and non-scientific.

Theistic evolution is very different from ID, where they are literally trying to point where God got his hands dirty and thus scientifically `prove' God's existence.
 
Von Neumann,

Most of the points you raised in response to my last post have been addressed by others (thanks everybody! :) ) but there's one or two things I'd like to add.

Perhaps in the modern synthesis, there are fewer who are inclined to posture that there is a a natural explanation for life origins than there used to be.

I think the opposite is probably true. Now that DNA/RNA is part of the explanation, it offers at least one plausible natural explanation for the origin of life. I won't try to explain it in a short post on an internet forum; if you want to look into it, I'd start by reading Richard Dawkins' The Ancestor's Tale.

I would rather see that darwinism prominently display a disclaimer when it comes to claiming to have evidence. I believe it is more accurate to say that the evidence sought for darwinism turned up as contra-evidence. Darwinism appears to remain only because there is no better naturalistic explanation - not because darwinism is a good explanation.

Just what contra-evidence is there? Is it just the Cambrian explosion, a few hoaxes, a re-evaluation of the lineage of the horse and the punctuated equilibrium/gradualism "controversy"*? If that's it, then it's not much, compared to all the fossil evidence, DNA evidence and observed examples of speciation.

And what kind of disclaimer do you want? The only accurate "disclaimer" I can think of would be this:

The vast majority of biologists, and every single peer-reviewed paper published in the last 75 years, support the idea of evolution through natural selection. However, a few self-styled scientists with no peer-reviewed publications and a handful of specious arguments are desperately clinging to the belief that humans occupy a special place in the universe, that we were designed by an infinitely powerful being they won't even name anymore, and that we have a special destiny. Be aware that these people will attack you viciously if you mention "evolution" or "common descent".

As long as darwinism is accepted on faith in spite of the contra-evidence, it is no better than ID. I think darwinism says "I don't know, so 'chance' did it." What is chance that it has such an embedded creative power?

If you think that the modern synthesis relies only on "chance", you don't understand it. Please, read a few good books on the subject; I'd recommend several of Dawkins' other books, including The Selfish Gene, The Blind Watchmaker, and Climbing Mount Improbable.

Of course ID is antithetical to evolution. No doubt the idea of "purpose" and "design" and "teleology" have been weeded out because of a legal interpretation. Science is an artifact of man as is law. Neither science nor law is "truth" necessarily. But the 'rules' say that science will only consider mechanistic reductionist explanations - that is dogma - not intrinsic truth.

By only considering "mechanistic reductionist explanations", science avoids the trap of finding an answer that is by its very nature final: god did it. Once we say "It's too complex; I don't understand it - god must have done it!" we stop looking. Science, at its best, refuses to stop looking.

It is like the central dogma of DNA. Because Crick was a darwinist, he believed DNA transcribed to RNA which transcribed to protein, one to one and with no backward transription. When we discovered humans only have 20,000+ genes instead of 100,000 genes, it was obvious the central dogma was wrong.

Evidence?

In any event, the discovery you refer to was made by ... wait for it ... scientists!

This kind of dogma keeps science from progressing as fast as it would if minds would be more open.

Well, you just proved yourself wrong with your example!

Darwinism closes minds. At the least, I think ID is valuable for opening minds to the possibility that, just as there is no naturalistic mechanistic explanation for the origins of pre-biotic complexity in this universe, the simple mechanistic explanation of darwinism also does not explain origins of differential biotic complexity. Taking darwinism on faith allows us to haughtily pretend we have 'the answer' when we do not.

You have it exactly backwards. Taking Darwinism (as you insist on calling it) as proven - which it is - and accepted as a workable theory has led to further investigation of the mechanism by which it works. If that mechanism had showed something incompatible with natural selection (say, genes being generated randomly rather than inherited) then it would have called the theory into question. It didn't. There is no evidence which seriously calls into question the fact of evolution by natural selection. If there were, it would be presented and a new theory would have to be found. And the person who found it would likely be given the Nobel Prize.

Thanks for playing. We have some lovely parting gifts.

*A "controversy" that is much less controversial than some would have it seem, by the way.
 
I'm getting a PhD in astrophysics, VonNeumann. So yes, I've studied a lot of physics and astronomy to get where I am. And the funny thing about science is how you can't seem to leave it in the office at the end of the day - it follows you home. I just don't see the need for religion, personally. And I don't believe in a God; I think we'll find an explanation for everything someday without His/Her/It's/Their help. Doesn't really bug me that I probably won't be around to see it, although it sounds like I'll be living a bit longer than you, because yes, I am young. But not naive. I was merely expressing surprise that the IDers didn't consider this argument all that useful in their assertations, but perhaps it's too early to tell - when they manage to get evolution out of the schools, I'm sure they'll move on to cosmology next. We won't have to wait too long.
 
What is a theist but someone who is certain that most Gods don't exist? In fact, I suspect that most theists are more "certain" about this than most atheists are that no Gods exist. In fact, it's a matter of faith to them.
Well said - amen. I do need to look up the diff between deist and theist.
 
There is an interesting book entitled "Starmaker" by Olaf Stapledon. It is about the history of the universe.In it, the Starmaker experiments with different universes where the physical laws are different. Thought provoking.
 
I was merely expressing surprise that the IDers didn't consider this argument all that useful in their assertations, but perhaps it's too early to tell - when they manage to get evolution out of the schools, I'm sure they'll move on to cosmology next. We won't have to wait too long.
I think evolution should be taught just as communism should be taught. People need to be educated in the whole spectrum so they know what are the relative weaknesses/strengths in human thought/ideas.

Again, you are surprised IDers did not consider the argument about natural laws being food for thought regarding design. You must have discounted my previous response or I was not clear: IDers DO (from what I've read) consider this subject useful if not most salient. They just don't have the microphone.

I read a couple books published at least 10 years ago that summarizes some of the cosmological interesting new discoveries and gives the 'other side' as well. You may not want to read it because the author is a christian (says so right up front), but he is a serious scientist's attempt to enumerate some interesting issues on this subject and explain the various arguements. All I can remember right now is his name is Hugh Ross (sp?).
 
The best I could come up with as an answer is, if the universe WASN'T perfectly suited for us in it's basic laws, we wouldn't be here to ask 'why not?'.

This is the anthropic principle. To the skeptic the anthropic principle is all powerful. Even if the prior probability of something is 1/googolplex, this doesn't surprise them in the slightest.

I used this argument to explain to them that my birth effectivelly couldn't have happened. Not one of them could understand what I was talking about.

Two things should be borne in mind.

a) Skeptics are incorrigibly stupid.

b) Thier minds are set in concrete.

Discussing anything with them is a waste of time.
 
This is the anthropic principle. To the skeptic the anthropic principle is all powerful. Even if the prior probability of something is 1/googolplex, this doesn't surprise them in the slightest.

I used this argument to explain to them that my birth effectivelly couldn't have happened. Not one of them could understand what I was talking about.

Two things should be borne in mind.

a) Skeptics are incorrigibly stupid.

b) Thier minds are set in concrete.

Discussing anything with them is a waste of time.
what is the probability of a deck of cards being in the order that they are after shuffling? There is no "prior probability".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom