Von Neumann,
Most of the points you raised in response to my last post have been addressed by others (thanks everybody!

) but there's one or two things I'd like to add.
Perhaps in the modern synthesis, there are fewer who are inclined to posture that there is a a natural explanation for life origins than there used to be.
I think the opposite is probably true. Now that DNA/RNA is part of the explanation, it offers at least one plausible natural explanation for the origin of life. I won't try to explain it in a short post on an internet forum; if you want to look into it, I'd start by reading Richard Dawkins'
The Ancestor's Tale.
I would rather see that darwinism prominently display a disclaimer when it comes to claiming to have evidence. I believe it is more accurate to say that the evidence sought for darwinism turned up as contra-evidence. Darwinism appears to remain only because there is no better naturalistic explanation - not because darwinism is a good explanation.
Just what contra-evidence is there? Is it just the Cambrian explosion, a few hoaxes, a re-evaluation of the lineage of the horse and the punctuated equilibrium/gradualism "controversy"*? If that's it, then it's not much, compared to all the fossil evidence, DNA evidence and observed examples of speciation.
And what kind of disclaimer do you want? The only accurate "disclaimer" I can think of would be this:
The vast majority of biologists, and every single peer-reviewed paper published in the last 75 years, support the idea of evolution through natural selection. However, a few self-styled scientists with no peer-reviewed publications and a handful of specious arguments are desperately clinging to the belief that humans occupy a special place in the universe, that we were designed by an infinitely powerful being they won't even name anymore, and that we have a special destiny. Be aware that these people will attack you viciously if you mention "evolution" or "common descent".
As long as darwinism is accepted on faith in spite of the contra-evidence, it is no better than ID. I think darwinism says "I don't know, so 'chance' did it." What is chance that it has such an embedded creative power?
If you think that the modern synthesis relies only on "chance", you don't understand it. Please, read a few good books on the subject; I'd recommend several of Dawkins' other books, including
The Selfish Gene,
The Blind Watchmaker, and
Climbing Mount Improbable.
Of course ID is antithetical to evolution. No doubt the idea of "purpose" and "design" and "teleology" have been weeded out because of a legal interpretation. Science is an artifact of man as is law. Neither science nor law is "truth" necessarily. But the 'rules' say that science will only consider mechanistic reductionist explanations - that is dogma - not intrinsic truth.
By only considering "mechanistic reductionist explanations", science avoids the trap of finding an answer that is by its very nature final: god did it. Once we say "It's too complex; I don't understand it - god must have done it!" we stop looking. Science, at its best, refuses to stop looking.
It is like the central dogma of DNA. Because Crick was a darwinist, he believed DNA transcribed to RNA which transcribed to protein, one to one and with no backward transription. When we discovered humans only have 20,000+ genes instead of 100,000 genes, it was obvious the central dogma was wrong.
Evidence?
In any event, the discovery you refer to was made by ... wait for it ... scientists!
This kind of dogma keeps science from progressing as fast as it would if minds would be more open.
Well, you just proved yourself wrong with your example!
Darwinism closes minds. At the least, I think ID is valuable for opening minds to the possibility that, just as there is no naturalistic mechanistic explanation for the origins of pre-biotic complexity in this universe, the simple mechanistic explanation of darwinism also does not explain origins of differential biotic complexity. Taking darwinism on faith allows us to haughtily pretend we have 'the answer' when we do not.
You have it exactly backwards. Taking Darwinism (as you insist on calling it) as proven - which it is - and accepted as a workable theory has led to further investigation of the mechanism by which it works. If that mechanism had showed something incompatible with natural selection (say, genes being generated randomly rather than inherited) then it would have called the theory into question. It didn't. There is no evidence which seriously calls into question the fact of evolution by natural selection. If there were, it would be presented and a new theory would have to be found. And the person who found it would likely be given the Nobel Prize.
Thanks for playing. We have some lovely parting gifts.
*A "controversy" that is much less controversial than some would have it seem, by the way.