Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

This is the anthropic principle. To the skeptic the anthropic principle is all powerful. Even if the prior probability of something is 1/googolplex, this doesn't surprise them in the slightest.

I used this argument to explain to them that my birth effectivelly couldn't have happened. Not one of them could understand what I was talking about.

You've obviously got it all backwards. You were born, rather then any other of 2^(how ever many other) potental ians. We're not going to be suprised that you are here, because, well, we know you're here and if you weren't it would be some other ian who might understand this.

You will find no skeptics wandering around saying "Ian exists, there must be a god!"
 
I like the image of throwing a dart at the wall, circling the spot where it hit, and then marvelling about how improbable it was that the dart landed in that circle.

Unfortunately the correct image is of throwing a dart randomly at a white wall whose surface area is in the range of something like a googolplex times a googolplex square miles, with one tiny black spot on it, and the dart landing dead centre in this black spot.
 
This is the anthropic principle. To the skeptic the anthropic principle is all powerful. Even if the prior probability of something is 1/googolplex, this doesn't surprise them in the slightest.

Is it that time of year again? I thought we weren't due for another "I don't understand the different between prior and posterior probabilities, therefore you are all stupid" thread from Ian for another four months!
 
what is the probability of a deck of cards being in the order that they are after shuffling? There is no "prior probability".

As I keep arguing, some sequences are special. If a special order of cards should transpire after shuffling the cards, then this is surprising. If there is a googolplex of cards and only one special sequence, then it is effectively something that couldn't happen, and we would know something fishy is going on should it transpire.
 
Is it that time of year again? I thought we weren't due for another "I don't understand the different between prior and posterior probabilities, therefore you are all stupid" thread from Ian for another four months!

Again I repeat like I said in the other threads. I acknowledge that the probability of an event which has happened, after it has happened is one. This doesn't address the issue one iota since it is a trivial tautology and utterly irrelevant to the issue at hand to boot.

If just the one person by buying one ticket a week had won the jackpot in the UK National Lottery every single week since it was first launched in 1994, then we would know something is fishy going on. Saying the a posterior probability is 1 is completely and totally irrelevant.
 
Again I repeat like I said in the other threads. I acknowledge that the probability of an event which has happened, after it has happened is one. This doesn't address the issue one iota since it is a trivial tautology and utterly irrelevant to the issue at hand to boot.

Yup. He doesn't understand the difference.

Nothing to see here, folks. Please, move along.
 
Von Neumann,
I think the opposite is probably true. Now that DNA/RNA is part of the explanation, it offers at least one plausible natural explanation for the origin of life. I won't try to explain it in a short post on an internet forum; if you want to look into it, I'd start by reading Richard Dawkins' The Ancestor's Tale..
DNA/RNA part of what explanation? The explanation you suggest is that thousands of bits of information appeared out of nowhere? DNA/RNA are already very complex systems. You are not talking about "gradualism" - or is gradualism not part of the "modern synthesis"? I've been waiting for decades to see a theory of precursors to DNA/RNA that has any meat. Boys, we will be waiting a while longer. When I got a copy of Stuart Kaufman's "Origins of Order", I was hopeful for an explanation but it was dissappointing. I think it was a good step and it is great stuff when contrasted to Dawkins stupid kindergarten magic show with his cybermorphs or whatever he calls it. Dawkins appears to me a politician posing as a scientist.

Just what contra-evidence is there? Is it just the Cambrian explosion, a few hoaxes, a re-evaluation of the lineage of the horse and the punctuated equilibrium/gradualism "controversy"*? .....
*A "controversy" that is much less controversial than some would have it seem, by the way. ... If that's it, then it's not much, compared to all the fossil evidence, DNA evidence and observed examples of speciation.
I'd like to learn from you what is "all the fossil evidence, DNA evidence..." and please give me an example of observed speciation. If you have the time, just let us see what you think is one best example of each.

If you think that the modern synthesis relies only on "chance", you don't understand it. Please, read a few good books on the subject; I'd recommend several of Dawkins' other books, including The Selfish Gene, The Blind Watchmaker, and Climbing Mount Improbable.
I've read the first two. Refresh me, what is the generating engine, the synthesizer of new information, that Dawkins theorizes that is not ultimately random (trying to use the term random in the mathematical sense).

By only considering "mechanistic reductionist explanations", science avoids the trap of finding an answer that is by its very nature final: god did it. Once we say "It's too complex; I don't understand it - god must have done it!" we stop looking. Science, at its best, refuses to stop looking.
Sure - everyone knows that. I understand why you keep bringing up god because you are an atheist. The idea of ID does not have to be YOUR idea of what a designer would be. The designer could come from the future (time loop?). That's one fallacy or 'interesting characteristic' I've noticed about this mind-set most of you have (and I used to have). And that is this: god does not exist YET. Quickly: bigbang begets H, He, etc, beget stars, beget family of elements, begets C-based life, begets human creativity, begets silicon artifacts, begets AI, begets ultra-advanced science, begets science greater than magic (immortality, pure energy minds, near infinite intelligence), begets GOD. So if you find all that palatable, why are you so sure that DIDN'T ALREADY HAPPEN? You are merely arguing where you are on a time line: Maybe IDers think we are farther to the right on the time-line than you do. Pretty trivial, right? This is merely 'pride' - the Greeks called it hubris.

Well, you just proved yourself wrong with your example!
Jon, you silly goose.

You have it exactly backwards. Taking Darwinism (as you insist on calling it) as proven - which it is - and accepted as a workable theory has led to further investigation of the mechanism by which it works. If that mechanism had showed something incompatible with natural selection (say, genes being generated randomly rather than inherited) then it would have called the theory into question. It didn't. There is no evidence which seriously calls into question the fact of evolution by natural selection. If there were, it would be presented and a new theory would have to be found. And the person who found it would likely be given the Nobel Prize.!
Darwinism does not have to be proven - it is axiomatic, right? I call it darwinism because nothing substantive to natural selection has been added since 'random mutation' was added - so it is old and tired. It is a simple explanation of preservation of species - I agree - it is good for that albeit an obvious idea known for thousands of years. I disagree that random mutation and natural selection (if there is more to the theory's basic functional blocks, educate me, I'm listening) is a sufficient mechanism for building significant-sized new information in this machine we call 'our universe'.

Thanks for playing. We have some lovely parting gifts.
I understand Jon. I used to be where you are.
 
Yup. He doesn't understand the difference.

Nothing to see here, folks. Please, move along.

No I don't understand the difference. I do not understand why people talk about the probability of something which has already occurred. Barring reverse time travel or reverse causality, then it seems to me to be meaningless to talk about the probability of something occurring which has already happened. Obviously it is certain that it happened after it has already happened. I suspect no-one ever talks about the probability of something happening after it has happened apart from the cretins on this board.

But whether or not I understand the difference doesn't alter the fact that we know something fishy is going on.

And BTW you're a disgrace to your University. You have demonstrated time after time after time to me that you are unbelievably stupid and understand none of my arguments.

But there again incorrigible stupidity seems to be ingrained into the skeptic's psyche.
 
Hugo Ross - this is the same guy giving a conference in Charleston in a few weeks, right? The guy who's spent his career trying to justify that religion and science can coexist? To this end, he's claiming he's found a way to prove creation happened. Scientific proof of creation. Now, look, sure, science and religion can coexist, as long as they both realize their limits. Science can't give us a moral code, and religion can't give us the universe. Ross just seems to me like someone who can't give up the religion that he can't justify to himself, and spent his whole life trying to prove that he didn't have to give it up.

Ian, imagine I made a lottery up and gave everyone on Earth a ticket. SOMEONE is going to win. The odds of winning are more than 1/6 billion, but SOMEONE will win. So when someone wins, yeah, the odds were incrediebly against it, but it had to happen to SOMEONE. So the odds of you being born may have been a billion to one, but odds were that someone was going to be born, and it just may have well been you as anyone else. The odds of getting A K Q J 10 of spades in your poker hand is the same as getting 2 of spades, 4 of hearts, 6 of diamonds, 8 of clubs, and Q of spades. But no one considers the last one to be remarkable. Like I said, if the universe wasn't suited for life, we wouldn't be here wondering why not.
 
Ian, imagine I made a lottery up and gave everyone on Earth a ticket. SOMEONE is going to win. The odds of winning are more than 1/6 billion, but SOMEONE will win. So when someone wins, yeah, the odds were incrediebly against it, but it had to happen to SOMEONE. So the odds of you being born may have been a billion to one, but odds were that someone was going to be born, and it just may have well been you as anyone else. The odds of getting A K Q J 10 of spades in your poker hand is the same as getting 2 of spades, 4 of hearts, 6 of diamonds, 8 of clubs, and Q of spades. But no one considers the last one to be remarkable. Like I said, if the universe wasn't suited for life, we wouldn't be here wondering why not.

I am really sick to death of hearing this.

It's happened all my life, people trying to explain the most simple stuff imaginable to me all the time. At school, at university by the lecturers, everywhere!

I'll say to you what I say to them. If I didn't understand this then I would be a retard.

I'll also say it's completely irrelevant.

Boy do I get sick of typing the same things all the time!
 
I have to ask, since you have no respect for anyone on the boards and consider us all to be morons, why ARE you still here?
 
DNA/RNA part of what explanation? The explanation you suggest is that thousands of bits of information appeared out of nowhere? DNA/RNA are already very complex systems. You are not talking about "gradualism" - or is gradualism not part of the "modern synthesis"? I've been waiting for decades to see a theory of precursors to DNA/RNA that has any meat. Boys, we will be waiting a while longer. When I got a copy of Stuart Kaufman's "Origins of Order", I was hopeful for an explanation but it was dissappointing. I think it was a good step and it is great stuff when contrasted to Dawkins stupid kindergarten magic show with his cybermorphs or whatever he calls it. Dawkins appears to me a politician posing as a scientist.

The modern synthesis, as I understand it (and I'm not a biologist) is evolution by natural selection, but with genes rather than organisms as the entity on which natural selection acts.

As for precursors to DNA/RNA, I understand there are several theories out there, including amino acid chains and crystalline clays. However, without a time machine, we will probably never know for sure.

I'd like to learn from you what is "all the fossil evidence, DNA evidence..." and please give me an example of observed speciation. If you have the time, just let us see what you think is one best example of each.

Fossil evidence includes homo habilis and h. erectus, to give two examples.

DNA evidence includes the fact that there is high DNA similarity between similar species, decreasing as the species become less similar. In addition, molecular genetics provides a timeline for historic speciation which agrees well with the fossil record.

Several examples of observed speciation are cited at the talk origins faq.

But you shouldn't be trying to "learn from me." I don't even pretend to be qualified to answer these questions fully. There is plenty of scientific literature out there that does, though.

I've read the first two. Refresh me, what is the generating engine, the synthesizer of new information, that Dawkins theorizes that is not ultimately random (trying to use the term random in the mathematical sense). .

I'm not sure what you mean by "random in the mathematical sense." There is obviously an element of randomness to natural selection - it is random mutations in genes that create the variation on which natural selection acts. This is the generating engine for evolution. The "synthesizer of new information" is the population of organisms, which combines genes in various permutations. This is the mechanism for random selection. This is very clearly set out in The Selfish Gene. Since you've read two of Dawkins' books, perhaps you could explain why you claimed earlier that "the evidence sought for darwinism turned up as contra-evidence" in light of the evidence presented in those two books.

Sure - everyone knows that. I understand why you keep bringing up god because you are an atheist. The idea of ID does not have to be YOUR idea of what a designer would be. The designer could come from the future (time loop?). That's one fallacy or 'interesting characteristic' I've noticed about this mind-set most of you have (and I used to have). And that is this: god does not exist YET. Quickly: bigbang begets H, He, etc, beget stars, beget family of elements, begets C-based life, begets human creativity, begets silicon artifacts, begets AI, begets ultra-advanced science, begets science greater than magic (immortality, pure energy minds, near infinite intelligence), begets GOD. So if you find all that palatable, why are you so sure that DIDN'T ALREADY HAPPEN? You are merely arguing where you are on a time line: Maybe IDers think we are farther to the right on the time-line than you do. Pretty trivial, right? This is merely 'pride' - the Greeks called it hubris.

Yeah, I read that short story by Asimov too. I admit, it's just as likely as any other ID explanation. However, how would such a scenario look any different from no ID?

Darwinism does not have to be proven - it is axiomatic, right? I call it darwinism because nothing substantive to natural selection has been added since 'random mutation' was added - so it is old and tired. It is a simple explanation of preservation of species - I agree - it is good for that albeit an obvious idea known for thousands of years. I disagree that random mutation and natural selection (if there is more to the theory's basic functional blocks, educate me, I'm listening) is a sufficient mechanism for building significant-sized new information in this machine we call 'our universe'.

Darwinism is not axiomatic. It is tested and proven every day, and if anything comes up to challenge it, it will fall. The germ theory of disease is just as old - would you call it "old and tired" and seek to throw it out solely based on its age?

(As an aside, I find it fascinating that theists will argue for religion because of how old it is, but pooh-pooh Darwinistic evolution as outdated.)

On the basis of what evidence do you disagree that random mutation and natural selection are insufficient to account for the diversity of life we see?

Edited to fix clumsy quoting.
 
Last edited:
This is the anthropic principle. To the skeptic the anthropic principle is all powerful. Even if the prior probability of something is 1/googolplex, this doesn't surprise them in the slightest.

I used this argument to explain to them that my birth effectivelly couldn't have happened. Not one of them could understand what I was talking about.

Two things should be borne in mind.

a) Skeptics are incorrigibly stupid.

b) Thier minds are set in concrete.

Discussing anything with them is a waste of time.

Ian has arrived. The thread is officially dead. Move along. Nothing to see here.
 
Ian has arrived. The thread is officially dead. Move along. Nothing to see here.

Perhaps that's Ian's paranormal ability - it's a variation of The Men That Stare at Goats, except it's The Man Who Posts on Threads :)

I'd still like to see VonNeumann's answers to the following questions, though.

a) How old is the Earth?
b) Do you believe that there is any extant evidence for speciation?
c) Do you, more specifically, believe that there is evidence that human and apes share recent common ancestry?
d) Is there any piece of evidence that could be found that would cause you to reject ID?

Actually, I'll add a couple more
e) What would you accept as adequate evidence for speciation?
f) How do you mathematically determine whether `biological information' has increased or decreased between two generations. What is the measure?

[Edit, I'm guessing 6000 years, no, no, of course not, a video of life's beginning to modern human, ummm]
 
Last edited:
As I keep arguing, some sequences are special. If a special order of cards should transpire after shuffling the cards, then this is surprising. If there is a googolplex of cards and only one special sequence, then it is effectively something that couldn't happen, and we would know something fishy is going on should it transpire.

Ian, what you don't understand about the Anthropic Principle and probability in general could (and has, in fact) fill several books.

The entire flaw in the Anthropic Principle is the conditions placed on "life". The probability of life on earth evolving in exactly the way it has, viewed from before it happened (that is, starting from scratch and saying "here's what qualifies, what are the odds?"), are astronomical and approach zero. But that doesn't prove anything. Your "special order" is only special because it has already happened. If life had evolved drastically differently from how it already has, then that would be the "special order". How many different ways can life evolve? Nobody knows. And without that knowledge the "specialness" of this particular way is not determinable. End of Story.

Your card analogy is fraught with the same difficulties. There are 8x10^67 different ways to order a deck of cards. No single order (say, 2-A by suits) is any less likely than any other specific order. That you choose to see a pattern, and therefore "design", in any random ordering does not make that random ordering remarkable in any way except that you choose to see it as "special". The best way I have heard this explained is "The odds of an honest poker player being dealt a full house are 693 to 1. Having been dealt a full house, what are the odds that player is honest?" The Anthropic Principle is answering the second question based on the information from the first. It doesn't apply.

But we're the stupid ones.....
 
And BTW you're a disgrace to your University. You have demonstrated time after time after time to me that you are unbelievably stupid and understand none of my arguments.

And BTW you're a disgrace to your Universe. You have demonstrated time after time after time to me that you are unbelievably stupid and understand none of my arguments.
 
Actually, expanding on my question f) above, I bet you could probably fit that into the $1,000,000 challenge:

Protocol for a single trial:
* Individual is given a DNA sequence from two generations of an asexually reproducing organism (some mutations must be present between the two)
* Individual must rank them into oldest/most recent based on information content of DNA sequence

Complete this for 10 out of 10 trials (since the claim is that information increase can never happen) and, voila, one million dollars.

Whaddya think? :D
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom