Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

I'd imagine a place with a dense atmosphere, for example, wouldn't be as ideal for viewing the stars.
But a place with no atmosphere, and that toured the galaxy would be even better.
Does this mean god designed the universe to mock us?
 
Seems backwards to me. We're designed for the universe we exist in. Once life arose natural selection ensures that we must be able to survive in the universe around us or we will be killed off before reproducing. Before life arose only chemical reactions that follow the laws of the universe could take place, therefore when one of these reactions that leads to life occurs it must follow the rules of the universe.



Which life? Life that currently exists in this universe perhaps. But did he also prove that any type of life would be impossible in these other universes? Are the laws we have the only ones that can support any form of life.

there are theories that postulate the existance of more than one universe (Membrane theory?), if this is true then it may turn out that life arose in this universe because it could, others may not be so lucky, and still others may have totally different life because their laws are different.
Just what I wanted to say on the issue :) : The idea is upside down. The universe, which includes life, is adapted to the laws of physics, not the other way around. That not all hypothetical variations of the laws of physics will support a universe, or a universe with life is, at best, of academic interest, since we have absolutely no idea of the scope for variations within possible laws of physics.

Hans
 
The whole argument boils down to:

"Because life exists, the universe must have been designed to allow this."

IDers may consider this to be an argument, but it looks like an unsupported assertion to me.
 
The whole argument boils down to:

"Because life exists, the universe must have been designed to allow this."

IDers may consider this to be an argument, but it looks like an unsupported assertion to me.
Mmm, more precisely, I think it boils down to: Since the universe fits life, it must be designed for it.

Then the counter will be: Since life fits the universe so well, it must have evolved to fit it.

Hans
 
Last edited:
Mmm, more precisely, I think it boils down to: Since the universe fits life, it must be designed for it.

Then the counter will be: Since life fits the universe so well, it must have evolved to fit it.

Hans

Why is life so important? Why couldn't the universe have been designed to create hydrogen? It is doing a great job so far.
 
.... we have absolutely no idea of the scope for variations within possible laws of physics.
Hans, usually you make sense. However, computations changing the basic constants show that lifeforms like us are occuring on a knife-edge of physics constants that cannot vary more than a very small percentage, ending with the galactic and solar system relationships concerning the earth/moon/gas planets system; carbon cycle, etc etc.
 
Hammegk said:
Hans, usually you make sense. However, computations changing the basic constants show that lifeforms like us are occuring on a knife-edge of physics constants that cannot vary more than a very small percentage, ending with the galactic and solar system relationships concerning the earth/moon/gas planets system; carbon cycle, etc etc.
Emphasis mine.

~~ Paul
 
Agreed, and a probable conclusion is that the universe is teeming with lifeforms "like us". Others types of lifeforms may be possible, although reaching the self-aware and able to manipulate evironment stage is sfaik best served on based on carbon-oxygen chemistry.
 
Agreed, and a probable conclusion is that the universe is teeming with lifeforms "like us". Others types of lifeforms may be possible, although reaching the self-aware and able to manipulate evironment stage is sfaik best served on based on carbon-oxygen chemistry.

Speculation really though isn't it, given the fact we know of only one planet with life like us.
 
Agreed, and a probable conclusion is that the universe is teeming with lifeforms "like us". Others types of lifeforms may be possible, although reaching the self-aware and able to manipulate evironment stage is sfaik best served on based on carbon-oxygen chemistry.
You are probably right, but if we talk about laws of physics that are somewhat different from ours, carbon-oxygen chemistry could lose out to some other chemistry.
 
Only a slightly different note, I always find it hilarious that ID proponents claim ID isn't religious when talking about biological ID (well, an alien could have done it!), but in the same breath bring in Cosmological ID arguments that are a blatant appeal to God.

To me, Cosmological ID is just one great big argument from ignorance and reverse logic.

"Hey, isn't it amazing that that the sun sets at night so that you don't have trouble sleeping?"
 
Cosmological ID was the basis for Robert J. Sawyer's excellent sf book Calculating God. It's reassuring to know the premise of that book was wrong, even though the book was very good.
 
Hans, usually you make sense. However, computations changing the basic constants show that lifeforms like us are occuring on a knife-edge of physics constants that cannot vary more than a very small percentage, ending with the galactic and solar system relationships concerning the earth/moon/gas planets system; carbon cycle, etc etc.
[old grudge] Hypocrisy! You accept such computations at face value when convenient. You dismiss them as inherently flawed when not (e.g. evolution simulations that demonstrate speciation) [/old grudge]
 
Hans, usually you make sense. However, computations changing the basic constants show that lifeforms like us are occuring on a knife-edge of physics constants that cannot vary more than a very small percentage, ending with the galactic and solar system relationships concerning the earth/moon/gas planets system; carbon cycle, etc etc.
Keyword is "life-forms like us". As I say, we are adapted to this universe.


Hans
 
Hans, usually you make sense. However, computations changing the basic constants show that lifeforms like us are occuring on a knife-edge of physics constants that cannot vary more than a very small percentage, ending with the galactic and solar system relationships concerning the earth/moon/gas planets system; carbon cycle, etc etc.

True, but if a small galaxy contains at least 200,000,000 stars , what are the chances that a planet will exists with water in a temerature gradient appropriate for the CHON life forms that exist on earth? If there at least one, then it would not exclude the idea that life could arise there and if there are thousands then the odds have a better chance of a hit.
The precursors to life seem fairly evenly distributed on the small part of our galaxy that we can see.
 
Keyword is "life-forms like us". As I say, we are adapted to this universe.
My use of "like-us" to me means the big-bang mass/energy was of the correct amount give us a hydrogen-helium cloud and time to allow stellar evolution to fusion things into iron, and via high energy neutron capture to continue to produce the chemical elements in the correct proportions and spread them around so that planets formed, and provided a mechanism to add water at the appropriate time.

That fusion is tuned to carbon rather than oxygen is also a nice feature, as are the actual abundance of radioactive elements that provide internal planetary heating.

Apparently "life" dependent on silicon physics rather than hydrocarbon chemistry is a slight possibility. That would be interesting evolution, huh?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom