Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Regarding Captain Ranneft's attempt to ask Admiral Stark in 1960 about what ONI told him about Japanese carriers near Hawaii and why Pearl Harbor was caught off guard, someone asked the silly question, gee, why didn't Ranneft try to talk to Stark after the attack?

Uh, maybe because Rannneft knew that that would be a raw, sore subject at that moment? Maybe because he knew that Stark and the rest of the Navy were a bit busy dealing with the aftermath of Pearl Harbor and with the war that they now found themselves fighting in the Pacific? As a foreigner, Ranneft had the good sense and decorum not to raise the subject with his American counterparts at that time.

If anything, the fact that Ranneft wanted to meet with Stark in 1960 to discuss ONI's foreknowledge and Pearl Harbor's lack of preparedness is further evidence of Ranneft's account and of his sincerity. If he had just made it all up, he would hardly have wanted to discuss it with Stark, of all people, 19 years later.

Spin it anyway you want; it's a second hand anecdote told decades after the event without a shred of proof to substantiate any of its details.
 
Throughout, navigation was full of hardships owing to poor visibility (dense mist) and rough weather. But we thanked heaven for them, because they reduced the chances of being discovered by the enemy. As for the supply, it was done almost every if weather permitted [which logically means there were times when weather did not permit]. . . . During the voyage, stress was laid on the economy of fuel; heaving was not done in spite of severe winter and electric lights were reduced to the minimum necessary. (Goldstein and Dillon, The Pearl Harbor Papers, p. 38)​

So they were so concerned about being spotted that they even cut down on lighting...but were happily using the radio?

By the way, where's the documentation that shows the Japanese viewed these low frequencies as safe from eaves-dropping, and that the orders to KB did not cover all ferquencies?
 
Regarding Captain Ranneft's attempt to ask Admiral Stark in 1960 about what ONI told him about Japanese carriers near Hawaii and why Pearl Harbor was caught off guard, someone asked the silly question, gee, why didn't Ranneft try to talk to Stark after the attack?

Uh, maybe because Rannneft knew that that would be a raw, sore subject at that moment? Maybe because he knew that Stark and the rest of the Navy were a bit busy dealing with the aftermath of Pearl Harbor and with the war that they now found themselves fighting in the Pacific? As a foreigner, Ranneft had the good sense and decorum not to raise the subject with his American counterparts at that time.

If anything, the fact that Ranneft wanted to meet with Stark in 1960 to discuss ONI's foreknowledge and Pearl Harbor's lack of preparedness is further evidence of Ranneft's account and of his sincerity. If he had just made it all up, he would hardly have wanted to discuss it with Stark, of all people, 19 years later.

Some people wind up believing their own ********, Bob. You know what that's like, don't you?
 
Regarding Captain Ranneft's attempt to ask Admiral Stark in 1960 about what ONI told him about Japanese carriers near Hawaii and why Pearl Harbor was caught off guard, someone asked the silly question, gee, why didn't Ranneft try to talk to Stark after the attack?

Because then he may have remembered that the two carriers being tracked west of PH were the two American Carriers returning from Wake? Given that Kido Butai was much more NORTH than west on December 2, 1941 and all that.

Uh, maybe because Rannneft knew that that would be a raw, sore subject at that moment? Maybe because he knew that Stark and the rest of the Navy were a bit busy dealing with the aftermath of Pearl Harbor and with the war that they now found themselves fighting in the Pacific? As a foreigner, Ranneft had the good sense and decorum not to raise the subject with his American counterparts at that time.

But not the good sense and decorum to not accuse the US government of being aware that they were to be attacked and let it happen 19 years later, based on his not understanding that the carriers they showed him were US ones?

If anything, the fact that Ranneft wanted to meet with Stark in 1960 to discuss ONI's foreknowledge and Pearl Harbor's lack of preparedness is further evidence of Ranneft's account and of his sincerity. If he had just made it all up, he would hardly have wanted to discuss it with Stark, of all people, 19 years later.

The question would be more why didn't he discuss the matter with Stark, say 18 years earlier? Or during the several inquiries into PH?
 
Another good question is why would we believe Rannneft actually saw that chart. CTers will accept the unsupported word of one person if they like it, and reject the coherent testimony of thousands of people if they don't like what's being said. This is pathological.
 
(aircraft) Carrier Pigeon?
That explains this recently declassified USN photo of a captured IJN carrier pigeon. I borrowed Robert Prey's red crayon to circle the naval avian's tailhook, I hope Robert doesn't mind.
picture.php
 
That explains this recently declassified USN photo of a captured IJN carrier pigeon. I borrowed Robert Prey's red crayon to circle the naval avian's tailhook, I hope Robert doesn't mind.[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=1035&pictureid=7794[/qimg]

I looked into that. Seems the message was a Viagra ad.
 
Why buy them at all? Unless of course you're trapped in a bus station in Northern Ontario, the cafeteria's closed and you need something to read (and don't feel like purchasing Playboy for the articles for reals).
 
I use them for tracking back, to see where the author cherry picked the original sources.

Sadly I buy them also. Paid way to much for some of Wilfords work.

I have a copy of the diary pages. I should post them here when I get the chance.

I have some of Toland's interviews.

John Toland is not a very good source to say the least.
 
For this one it appears to be more of a "willfully ignored" than "cherry picked" the original sources.

Bob? Sure, but the author has to read the sources to find those little snippets that he can whittle down to "incriminating" items, and they are usually arrogant enough to list those sources. For instance, Stinnett cited "Pearl Harbor: How, Why, and Fleet Salvage", which in turn listed the Pearl Harbor Hearings, proving Stinnett had a hemorrhoid in his teeth when talking about certain "smoking guns".
 
Regarding Captain Ranneft's attempt to ask Admiral Stark in 1960 about what ONI told him about Japanese carriers near Hawaii and why Pearl Harbor was caught off guard, someone asked the silly question, gee, why didn't Ranneft try to talk to Stark after the attack?

Uh, maybe because Rannneft knew that that would be a raw, sore subject at that moment? Maybe because he knew that Stark and the rest of the Navy were a bit busy dealing with the aftermath of Pearl Harbor and with the war that they now found themselves fighting in the Pacific? As a foreigner, Ranneft had the good sense and decorum not to raise the subject with his American counterparts at that time.

If anything, the fact that Ranneft wanted to meet with Stark in 1960 to discuss ONI's foreknowledge and Pearl Harbor's lack of preparedness is further evidence of Ranneft's account and of his sincerity. If he had just made it all up, he would hardly have wanted to discuss it with Stark, of all people, 19 years later.
Have you any evidence this event actually happened? As I've pointed out your "source" is demonstrably wrong.
 
At some point in the attack on PH, radio silence must be abandoned. Has BTF identified the when and why of that? Ever?

He did mention the blazingly obvious messages, "Tora, tora, tora", etc. But he can't explain the calliope idea, that the Kido Butai went across the Pacific sounding off like a calliope in a circus parade. Not surprising, it never happened.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom