Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

While we lack your expertise with the primary sources, we should be able deal with it.

We can probably just look back through the pages of this thread for any required info. It's not like bob, or anyone else for that matter, is going to suddenly come up with something actually new. ;)
 
I think I'm going to reincarnate as a CTer.

Be afraid.


Don't think that. Believe that instead you'll be reincarnated as a 121.92-meter mutant fire-breathing lizard-thingy. That's something much more impressive to fear!
 
It's good to see taht Bob is keeping up with the fine CTer/Woo traditions:

a. The Fringe reset; followed by
b. The "post and run".

We've had dubious interpretations, third hand quotes, and just outright incorrect statements throughout - what else is coming - tune in next year to find out!
 
This is erroneous. The paperback edition of Stinnett's book alone lists and discusses a number of messages that were released after the hardback edition came out.

And your comment that you're not sure that Stinnett "could spell FOIA" is not only silly but shows the extreme degree of your bias. Stinnett has filed numerous FOIA requests. So, yeah, I'm pretty sure he knows how to spell it.


Which makes his many demonstratively erroneous claims and arguments even less excusable.

The idea that FDR knew the Japanese were going to attack started long before Stinnett ever started to research the issue. Some of the people who believed FDR had foreknowledge of the attack included Admiral Kimmel, Admiral Theobald, Admiral Halsey (who wrote a strong endorsement for Theobald's book), Captain Safford, Thomas Dewey (the GOP nominee in 1944), Congressman Martin Dies (whose committee uncovered a Japanese military map that indicated Pearl Harbor would be attacked), and Honolulu Chief of Police John Burns (who revealed shortly before his death that the FBI SAIC in Hawaii warned him days before the attack that Pearl Harbor was going to be bombed).


None of the above ever provided any real evidence; merely speculation, misinterpretation, opinion, and uncorroborated claims.

Indeed, Governor Dewey told General Marshall's aide, Col. Carter Clarke, that FDR knew Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that he should be impeached for not warning Kimmel and Short (but Marshall talked Dewey out of going public with the issue).


Dewey had no first-hand knowledge of this; his source was an anti-FDR Army officer who leaked the charge to the Dewey campaign. Further, you conveniently omit to mention that Marshall also told Dewey that the charge was false.

And Congressman Dies revealed in his memoir . . .


As noted, Dies has zero credibility, and no evidence corroborating his accusations has ever come to light.
 
All I have at the house is a bottle of Highland Park ATM, although I'm picking up a bottle of Glen Breton tomorrow.
 
Bob, or Mike if you prefer, it's been 12 days since your last post and the refutation of your assertions followed by us moving onto the far more important discussion of whiskey. Do you have anything to actually contribute?
 
Mike here! I know, different Mike that you're asking for but I have something relevant to discus. I live near the Maker's Mark distilleries in Kentucky. Awesome stuff, to be sure.
 
Never got to liking American whisky. I'm going to say that the only one I've tried is JD, and compared to the scotch or Irish stuff, it tasted wrong.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom