Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

John Toland is not a very good source to say the least.
Which is too bad, as I enjoyed some of his earlier works, especially Battle: The Story of the Bulge. I'm glad I never dropped any cash on his Pearl Harbor crap, and now I wouldn't even if I found it in the 25 cent bin.
 
A review of two books on the Pearl Harbor controversy.
http://codoh.com/library/document/3001

A fair amount of his case rests on a sizable number of messages from ships and units of the Japanese navy that Stinnett was able to make public for the first time, not without diligent effort, under provisions of the Freedom of Information Act.

Really? He got those messages from the back of Pearl Harbor: How, Why, and Fleet Salvage, by Adm. Homer Wallin. Wallin got them from the Pearl Harbor Hearings, he cites volume and page. They're in the Hearings because we sent questionnaires to the Japanese and Dug-out Doug sent the answers back to Congress. I'm not sure Stinnett could spell FOIA.
 
Really? He got those messages from the back of Pearl Harbor: How, Why, and Fleet Salvage, by Adm. Homer Wallin. Wallin got them from the Pearl Harbor Hearings, he cites volume and page. They're in the Hearings because we sent questionnaires to the Japanese and Dug-out Doug sent the answers back to Congress. I'm not sure Stinnett could spell FOIA.

This is erroneous. The paperback edition of Stinnett's book alone lists and discusses a number of messages that were released after the hardback edition came out.

And your comment that you're not sure that Stinnett "could spell FOIA" is not only silly but shows the extreme degree of your bias. Stinnett has filed numerous FOIA requests. So, yeah, I'm pretty sure he knows how to spell it.

The idea that FDR knew the Japanese were going to attack started long before Stinnett ever started to research the issue. Some of the people who believed FDR had foreknowledge of the attack included Admiral Kimmel, Admiral Theobald, Admiral Halsey (who wrote a strong endorsement for Theobald's book), Captain Safford, Thomas Dewey (the GOP nominee in 1944), Congressman Martin Dies (whose committee uncovered a Japanese military map that indicated Pearl Harbor would be attacked), and Honolulu Chief of Police John Burns (who revealed shortly before his death that the FBI SAIC in Hawaii warned him days before the attack that Pearl Harbor was going to be bombed).

Indeed, Governor Dewey told General Marshall's aide, Col. Carter Clarke, that FDR knew Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that he should be impeached for not warning Kimmel and Short (but Marshall talked Dewey out of going public with the issue).

And Congressman Dies revealed in his memoir that when his committee came across the Japanese map that indicated planning for an attack on Pearl Harbor, he told Secretary of State Cordell Hull about it, and that Hull asked him to keep quiet about it because of the “extremely delicate” diplomatic situation between America and Japan. Dies also reported that representatives from the State Department, the Army, and the Navy examined the map. Said Dies,

Early in 1941 the Dies Committee came into possession of a strategic map which gave clear proof of the intentions of the Japanese to make an assault on Pearl Harbor. The strategic map was prepared by the Japanese Imperial Military Intelligence Department. As soon as I received the document I telephoned Secretary of State Cordell Hull and told him what I had. Secretary Hull directed me not to let anyone know about the map and stated that he would call me as soon as he talked to President Roosevelt. In about an hour he telephoned to say that he had talked to Roosevelt and they agreed that it would be very serious if any information concerning this map reached the news services. . . . I told him it was a grave responsibility to withhold such vital information from the public. The Secretary assured me that he and Roosevelt considered it essential to national defense. (Martin Dies Story, New York: Bookmailer, 1963, p. 165)​
 
Last edited:
Bob, this very allegation was dealt with just over a year ago.

Next you'll be telling us that FDR encouraged the attack to take the pressure off the Soviets.
 
Did someone just come out of hibernation? Is it Woospawn season already? Where did the winter go?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom