Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

One moving ship can "essentially" triangulate another moving ship--that's why I said "essentially triangulate." If we were talking about objects that moved much faster, like cars, no, that would be impossible. But for a cruise liner to "essentially" triangulate a target like the task force,

I am extremely skeptical that a cruise liner could repeatedly accurately measure radio waves from thousands of nautical miles away to estimate even the approximate location of any transmitter. The most accurate modern Navy shipboard RDF equipment is accurate to about 2°. And that accuracy is dependent on annual calibration on a calibration range.

which was strung out over several hundred yards and was moving no faster than 20 mph, it would not have been hard at all. Again, we're talking about "essentially" triangulating or "ballpark" triangulation.

Sure, except in this case the ballpark covers the entire northwest Pacific, the Sea of Japan, East China Sea, Yellow Sea, and the Inland Sea.

When you can take DF bearings over the course of several days on a large, slow-moving target, you can most certainly get a reasonably accurate triangulation if you are moving no faster, or slower than, the target.

You have it completely backwards. The task force would have to be moving very slowly and the cruise liner would have to be moving very fast and the TF would have to be on the liner's beam (i.e. the liner was moving perpendicular to the TF's bearing) so the bearings would have the geometry to cross over each other where the TF was actually located. If you knew the TF's course and speed and you had very accurate bearings you could fit the TF's track to match the bearings and derive its position. But those were complete unknowns. A ship at 20 knots will generate the same series of bearings as a ship at 10 knots that is half as far away on the same course, own ship's movement notwithstanding.

I navigated US Navy ships and submarines for 20 years as a quartermaster. I am an expert in visual, radar, celestial, satellite, bathymetric, and RDF navigation, target motion analysis (i.e. tracking targets with passve sonar and determining their range, course, and speed), and fleet operations so I know what I'm talking about. I also know when someone is trying to bluff their way through any of the above topics.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps it's not what you meant, but it is exactly what you said:

No, it is not.

"You accuse FDR of conspiracy because you don't like FDR."
"It's very much the opposite: the more I read about FDR, the less I like him."

Being generous, it's not even a counter to the accusation. It's just... a nonsensical response. Please clarify.

I do not understand where your confusion comes from on my statement. I said the more I read about FDR, the more negative I feel toward him and his presidency. That is the exact opposite of saying that I posit a conspiracy because I don't like him.

"Liking" him has nothing to do with making judgments about his actions regarding Pearl Harbor and other issue.

Again, I do not understand how you are so egregiously misreading the plain English of my remark.
 
Pity all that didn't pan out after examination to be anything useful. But, as I said, hearing Japanese from the direction of Japan is largely unshocking.

But it most certainly did pan out to be something useful. Grogan's DF bearings closely match the route the task force took. Grogan noted that the ships he was tracking stopped on 12/2, which is powerful evidence that he was tracking the task force because we know Nagumo halted the fleet on 12/2 to refuel and to await final confirmation of orders. Grogan noted that the ships were trying to conceal their movements. Grogan noted that the ships were NW of Hawaii and heading east, and he deduced that they were trying to sneak up on Hawaii. Grogan noted that some of the ships were using automatic repeat-backs, which is additional proof that he was tracking the task force. Grogan knew from experience that it was very, very odd that Japanese naval ships would be in that part of the North Pacific, especially at that time of year.

So Grogan's information most certainly was useful. He turned it over to the intelligence office of the 14th Naval District on 12/3, and was assured the info would be passed along. We know the Navy received his logbook because documentation of its receipt was found, but the logbook itself has gone "missing," like so many other items of evidence that would prove foreknowledge. Luckily, we have the report that Grogan submitted to the Matson Line and the copy that he made of his logbook entries.

For more info, see:

Timothy Wilford and Brian Villa, "Warning at Pearl Harbor: Leslie Grogan and the Tracking of the Kido Butai," http://www.thestormunleashed.com/files/docs/warning_at_ph.pdf
 
I am extremely skeptical that a cruise liner could repeatedly accurately measure radio waves from thousands of nautical miles away to estimate even the approximate location of any transmitter. The most accurate modern Navy shipboard RDF equipment is accurate to about 2°. And that accuracy is dependent on annual calibration on a calibration range.

Sure, except in this case the ballpark covers the entire northwest Pacific, the Sea of Japan, East China Sea, Yellow Sea, and the Inland Sea.

You have it completely backwards. The task force would have to be moving very slowly and the cruise liner would have to be moving very fast and the TF would have to be on the liner's beam (i.e. the liner was moving perpendicular to the TF's bearing) so the bearings would have the geometry to cross over each other where the TF was actually located. If you knew the TF's course and speed and you had very accurate bearings you could fit the TF's track to match the bearings and derive its position. But those were complete unknowns. A ship at 20 knots will generate the same series of bearings as a ship at 10 knots that is half as far away on the same course, own ship's movement notwithstanding.

I navigated US Navy ships and submarines for 20 years as a quartermaster. I am an expert in visual, radar, celestial, satellite, bathymetric, and RDF navigation, target motion analysis (i.e. tracking targets with passve sonar and determining their range, course, and speed), and fleet operations so I know what I'm talking about. I also know when someone is trying to bluff their way through any of the above topics.

Your arguments are invalid. I did DFing under multiple conditions as a signals intelligence operator for over 20 years. You are misstating the science of DFing. A slow-moving object most certainly can DF a much larger slow-moving object when the DFer is able to take multiple readings over the course of several days. This is DF 101 material. I did this for a living and received extensive training in it.

Furthermore, we KNOW that Grogan DF'd the task force because his DF bearings closely match the route the task force took. Another reason we know that Grogan was tracking the task force is that no other ships in the North Pacific would have been using automatic repeat-backs. A third reason we know that Grogan was tracking the task force is that he noted that the flotilla stopped on 12/2, the same day that Nagumo halted the task force to refuel and to await final confirmation of orders.

The "ballpark" will not cover a huge area when multiple bearings are taken on a large, slow-moving target over the course of several days. Again, this is DF 101 material. And, to repeat, we must face the fact that Grogan's DF bearings pretty much mirror the route that the task force took, which proves they were within a reasonable degree of accuracy. They are not an exact match, but they are definitely close, close enough to render silly any suggestion of chance.

Add to this the other evidence--the automatic repeat-backs and the halting of the ships on 12/2--and you have a powerful case that Grogan tracked the task force.

Please read Wilford and Villa's article.
 
Last edited:
And the paperhanger's two fronts were a train ride away from each other. The fronts that the U.S. were fighting were more than 12 time zones apart.
More than 12? How do you do that?
 
Your arguments are invalid. I did DFing under multiple conditions as a signals intelligence operator for over 20 years.

No one who exhibits the level of knowledge of DFing that you have has ever seen a DF set let alone operated one.

You are misstating the science of DFing. A slow-moving object most certainly can DF a much larger slow-moving object when the DFer is able to take multiple readings over the course of several days.

DF, as in "direction finding", sure. Which means bearings only; not course, not speed, and certainly not position.

You keep stating the TF was "large" and you somehow think the size of the TF would make it easier to find its position. Such a bizarre notion could only come from someone trying to bluff their way through.

This is DF 101 material. I did this for a living and received extensive training in it.

Your fundamental knowledge of tracking bearings is so poor I can only conclude your only experience with working with radio signals was adjusting the rabbit ears on your TV.

Furthermore, we KNOW that Grogan DF'd the task force because his DF bearings closely match the route the task force took.

Up to 44° off never counts as a close match.

Add to this the other evidence--the automatic repeat-backs and the halting of the ships on 12/2--

"halting of the ships"??? Do you have any idea how stupid that sounds? Do you think the entire fleet just stopped their engines and floated around the ocean for a day?
 
Last edited:
Maybe, but the fact is that even if they had more clout, there is little evidence that the Japanese Doctrine of "Warships are the main target,other shipping is of little importance" would have changed,since most Japanese Submariners agreed with it and few advocated Merchant Shipping as a major target.
I 100% agree that Japanese Anti Submarine warfare was woefully short changed and inadequate.How a nation dependent on maritime traffic for it's survival should have been so short sighted is incredible.


I would say those things are symptomatic of a larger issue, the Japanese 'Bushido' warrior code. Only opposing warriors were deemed worthy targets, the ability to attack paramount, and self-sacrifice expected. So with the first you have Allied merchants ships not seen as targets worthy of a warrior's effort, nor for that matter of their own merchant ships worthy of much protection. The second means their fighter aircraft lack such essential things as pilot armour and self-sealing fuel tanks, which only increases their loss rates. The third means many good officers went down with their ships, as well as never investing in any capability to recover their downed pilots. (And, of course, the kamikaze attacks.)
 
I would say those things are symptomatic of a larger issue, the Japanese 'Bushido' warrior code. Only opposing warriors were deemed worthy targets, the ability to attack paramount, and self-sacrifice expected. So with the first you have Allied merchants ships not seen as targets worthy of a warrior's effort, nor for that matter of their own merchant ships worthy of much protection. The second means their fighter aircraft lack such essential things as pilot armour and self-sealing fuel tanks, which only increases their loss rates. The third means many good officers went down with their ships, as well as never investing in any capability to recover their downed pilots. (And, of course, the kamikaze attacks.)

And there command structure was horrible any soldier displaying initiative usually had it beaten out of him pretty quick
 
Ewa Beach or O-6 housing? I lived at Little Makalapa during my stint. Been up and down that channel a few times.

The O-6, don't remember the house number any more - great place, good spear fishing on the reef
 
...
The "ballpark" will not cover a huge area when multiple bearings are taken on a large, slow-moving target over the course of several days. ...

Wait a second. 20kts for, say, three days means you can travel, oh, close to 1,500 miles. You say that's a small area?
 
No one who exhibits the level of knowledge of DFing that you have has ever seen a DF set let alone operated one.



DF, as in "direction finding", sure. Which means bearings only; not course, not speed, and certainly not position.

You keep stating the TF was "large" and you somehow think the size of the TF would make it easier to find its position. Such a bizarre notion could only come from someone trying to bluff their way through.



Your fundamental knowledge of tracking bearings is so poor I can only conclude your only experience with working with radio signals was adjusting the rabbit ears on your TV.



Up to 44° off never counts as a close match.



"halting of the ships"??? Do you have any idea how stupid that sounds? Do you think the entire fleet just stopped their engines and floated around the ocean for a day?

I'd have to agree here. Bob is clearly not adept at DFing.
 
My friend Tracy White spent a few days dismantling the claims on the link listed above, so I won't bother going through that again. Bottom line is we have an CTista who's hot to trot with the Pet Theory and weak on fact checking. They don't make 'em like they used to.
 
I would say those things are symptomatic of a larger issue, the Japanese 'Bushido' warrior code. Only opposing warriors were deemed worthy targets, the ability to attack paramount, and self-sacrifice expected. So with the first you have Allied merchants ships not seen as targets worthy of a warrior's effort, nor for that matter of their own merchant ships worthy of much protection. The second means their fighter aircraft lack such essential things as pilot armour and self-sealing fuel tanks, which only increases their loss rates. The third means many good officers went down with their ships, as well as never investing in any capability to recover their downed pilots. (And, of course, the kamikaze attacks.)

Does anybody know of a good analysis of how much the militarists modified the Bushido code to fit their agenda, if at all? I've seen claims that the kikusui concept was a perversion of the original code, but not confirmation of that claim.
 
No one who exhibits the level of knowledge of DFing that you have has ever seen a DF set let alone operated one.



DF, as in "direction finding", sure. Which means bearings only; not course, not speed, and certainly not position.

You keep stating the TF was "large" and you somehow think the size of the TF would make it easier to find its position. Such a bizarre notion could only come from someone trying to bluff their way through.



Your fundamental knowledge of tracking bearings is so poor I can only conclude your only experience with working with radio signals was adjusting the rabbit ears on your TV.



Up to 44° off never counts as a close match.



"halting of the ships"??? Do you have any idea how stupid that sounds? Do you think the entire fleet just stopped their engines and floated around the ocean for a day?

ALso what does a 'large target' mean? Radio transmission s are a point source.

As already pointed out over several days the 'target' would have moved over a thousand miles if it was keeping 20kts. I don't know what Japanese fleet orders were but I know the RN would have been operating a 'zig zag' to throw off and confuse submarine contact so that would reduce the total distance and apparent speed but it would still be considerable. Plus how much radio traffic is being claimed? How many times a day was a bearing being taken?
 
"Large target" was probably thrown in to further insinuate that the Kido Butai was being tracked rather than, say, the Midway Bombardment Force. The idea is to try and tack some credibility onto this little theory.

Plus how much radio traffic is being claimed?

Obviously the Japanese, after being ordered to keep strict radio silence decided to disobey the orders issued by the puny little Commander of the Navy. It wouldn't matter if they were being tracked and the enemy thus alerted, now would it? I mean really, who's going to die if the USN drops the hammer on the force? Just the people who are broadcasting, no big lost, merely six carriers, their planes and crews, a mere drop in the bucket.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom