matt.tansy
Muse
- Joined
- Feb 23, 2007
- Messages
- 991
One moving ship can "essentially" triangulate another moving ship--that's why I said "essentially triangulate." If we were talking about objects that moved much faster, like cars, no, that would be impossible. But for a cruise liner to "essentially" triangulate a target like the task force,
I am extremely skeptical that a cruise liner could repeatedly accurately measure radio waves from thousands of nautical miles away to estimate even the approximate location of any transmitter. The most accurate modern Navy shipboard RDF equipment is accurate to about 2°. And that accuracy is dependent on annual calibration on a calibration range.
which was strung out over several hundred yards and was moving no faster than 20 mph, it would not have been hard at all. Again, we're talking about "essentially" triangulating or "ballpark" triangulation.
Sure, except in this case the ballpark covers the entire northwest Pacific, the Sea of Japan, East China Sea, Yellow Sea, and the Inland Sea.
When you can take DF bearings over the course of several days on a large, slow-moving target, you can most certainly get a reasonably accurate triangulation if you are moving no faster, or slower than, the target.
You have it completely backwards. The task force would have to be moving very slowly and the cruise liner would have to be moving very fast and the TF would have to be on the liner's beam (i.e. the liner was moving perpendicular to the TF's bearing) so the bearings would have the geometry to cross over each other where the TF was actually located. If you knew the TF's course and speed and you had very accurate bearings you could fit the TF's track to match the bearings and derive its position. But those were complete unknowns. A ship at 20 knots will generate the same series of bearings as a ship at 10 knots that is half as far away on the same course, own ship's movement notwithstanding.
I navigated US Navy ships and submarines for 20 years as a quartermaster. I am an expert in visual, radar, celestial, satellite, bathymetric, and RDF navigation, target motion analysis (i.e. tracking targets with passve sonar and determining their range, course, and speed), and fleet operations so I know what I'm talking about. I also know when someone is trying to bluff their way through any of the above topics.
Last edited: