Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Although that had been revised down considerably to two weeks by the time she got to Pearl. I think the ships long lead time in getting back to Pearl gave everyone time to organize parts game plan etc.
Part of that was "We don't need to do that right now!" ;)
And you can imagine the mood of the repair crews at the dock. The Yorktowns back and she's just given the japanese a huge kick in the rear end...amazing what moral can do :)
Or morale for that matter.

:p
 
CT snowball. Once you believe in one you are more likely to believe in more.

It goes even further than that: once you believe in one conspiracy theory, you are even more likely to believe in another conspiracy theory that's in direct conflict with the first.
 
I'll just butt in on this one.

One doesn't. One might speculate (based on what, I couldn't say), but using only direction finding, one cannot know.

And why would they broadcast so frequently that we could track them A-B-C-D-E? And who were they talking to? The ships within blinker distance? (The logs show the entire force stayed together with the except of one ship that rejoined the next day after a storm at night.) And why didn't Tokyo object to their broadcasting?

[Mr. Moto]"Honorable morons, please to be shutting up!" [/Mr. Moto]
 
For damaged ships being put back into action look up HMS Warspite and the HMS Queen Elizabeth.

Warspite was badly damaged twice the first time by the first guided missile.
 
And you can imagine the mood of the repair crews at the dock. The Yorktowns back and she's just given the japanese a huge kick in the rear end...amazing what moral can do :)


I'm not sure I'd call the Battle of the Coral Sea kicking the Japanese in the rear end—that battle was a tactical loss for the U.S. (It was a strategic victory, however.)
 
And why would they broadcast so frequently that we could track them A-B-C-D-E? And who were they talking to? The ships within blinker distance? (The logs show the entire force stayed together with the except of one ship that rejoined the next day after a storm at night.) And why didn't Tokyo object to their broadcasting?

[Mr. Moto]"Honorable morons, please to be shutting up!" [/Mr. Moto]

It would have probably have been

閉じ込める (shutup)


and not

私のホバークラフトは鰻でいっぱいです


If you want to have an excellent read and a look at the Japanese navy I can recommend Japanese Destroyer Captain by Tameichi Hara, he survived the war fought many battles in the Solomons and commanded the light cruiser that sortie with the Yamato in its suicide attack
 
Last edited:
If one is aligning and realigning one's directional antenna to pick up distant radio transmissions, how exactly does one know that the ships one is tracking are trying to conceal their movements?

As the others have mentioned, one doesn't transmit numerous times a day over several days and expect one's movement to be concealed. It is a self-debunking claim.

If you want to deceive a SIGINT net about a fleet's movement then have one ship continue on the original course and continue to transmit while the fleet commences radio silence and sails toward their target. It goes without saying that if the decoy ship continues to sail with the fleet this tactic will not succeed!
 
I'm not sure I'd call the Battle of the Coral Sea kicking the Japanese in the rear end—that battle was a tactical loss for the U.S. (It was a strategic victory, however.)

But to those that had seen success after success for Japanese forces it would have been a huge moral boost. And yes the battle itself was a tactical loss, but forcing the invasion fleet to abandon it's Port Moresby attack was a massive positive for the US forces
 
As the others have mentioned, one doesn't transmit numerous times a day over several days and expect one's movement to be concealed. It is a self-debunking claim.
Now we just have to get the CTers to understand that.
If you want to deceive a SIGINT net about a fleet's movement then have one ship continue on the original course and continue to transmit while the fleet commences radio silence and sails toward their target. It goes without saying that if the decoy ship continues to sail with the fleet this tactic will not succeed!
The Kido Butai sent their usual telegraphers south to Tokyo to spoof USN eavesdroppers into thinking the carriers were in the Sagami Wan.

For fun, feed this to Google Earth:

44°57'57.39" N 147°40'53.58" E

That's Hitokappu Bay, where the Attack Force assembled. Note the population density. This is one of the things they did to keep the attack secret. Then we get clams that they transmitted. Not just an accidental transmission, but a peace-time routine of transmissions.

Such a stupid claim.
 
And why would they broadcast so frequently that we could track them A-B-C-D-E? And who were they talking to? The ships within blinker distance? (The logs show the entire force stayed together with the except of one ship that rejoined the next day after a storm at night.) And why didn't Tokyo object to their broadcasting?

[Mr. Moto]"Honorable morons, please to be shutting up!" [/Mr. Moto]
It's just so typical. Every CT seems to require a Batman (60's TV version) type foe that could have been foiled if we just had the services those meddling kids and their dog!
 
Last edited:
As the others have mentioned, one doesn't transmit numerous times a day over several days and expect one's movement to be concealed. It is a self-debunking claim.

If you want to deceive a SIGINT net about a fleet's movement then have one ship continue on the original course and continue to transmit while the fleet commences radio silence and sails toward their target. It goes without saying that if the decoy ship continues to sail with the fleet this tactic will not succeed!

Part of the plans for D-Day included a 'phantom' fleet, one or two telegraphers sending messages that made it look like their units were elsewhere. To an experienced listener the keying style of individuals is as distinctive as a voice.
 
I wonder if we could get away with a "What If" thread in "History". Like "What if the US did know about the attack in advance and ambushed the Kido Butai and sank all six carriers?"

The war in the Pacific might have been quite a bit different. Australia/New Zealand would not have been very worried about invasion for starters.
 
Part of the plans for D-Day included a 'phantom' fleet, one or two telegraphers sending messages that made it look like their units were elsewhere. To an experienced listener the keying style of individuals is as distinctive as a voice.

This, IIR, was a thing also picked up people doing ULTRA decryptions.
 
I wonder if we could get away with a "What If" thread in "History". Like "What if the US did know about the attack in advance and ambushed the Kido Butai and sank all six carriers?"

The war in the Pacific might have been quite a bit different. Australia/New Zealand would not have been very worried about invasion for starters.

Interesting question - might depend what Tojo and others might have done rather than face the Emperor with the news. There were never any actual plans to invade Australia, however the Japanese might have presented a much larger force for the New Guinea campaign, with an eye to invading northern Australia
 
Interesting question - might depend what Tojo and others might have done rather than face the Emperor with the news. There were never any actual plans to invade Australia, however the Japanese might have presented a much larger force for the New Guinea campaign, with an eye to invading northern Australia

The Japanese plans, as of August, 1941, at least, were to eventually extend their domain from the Arctic Circle to India, then south to Australia and east as far as the International Date Line. So I imagine plans were drawn up for the conquest of Australia, at least by the cloistered planners like Genda.
 
The Japanese plans, as of August, 1941, at least, were to eventually extend their domain from the Arctic Circle to India, then south to Australia and east as far as the International Date Line. So I imagine plans were drawn up for the conquest of Australia, at least by the cloistered planners like Genda.

There were no formal plans drawn up - Both the navy and army threw ideas out but nothing was formally approved or agreed on. Perhaps the closest they came to a real concept was the Malay barrier plan, which required landings in Australia at Darwin and Townsville as a way to protect their own operations.

The army rightfully pointed out it simply did not have the resources, and their estimates ran to about 200,000 troops just to secure strips of land on the North West and North East coasts, and they are scathing in their attitude to the navy being able to keep up resupply.

And dont get me wrong, everybody was convinced they were coming and highly controversial plans were drawn up the defense of the nation. Google Brisbane plan sometime.

At the end of the war, we were all intensely surprised to discover they really didn't think we were a big enough threat to need neutralizing lol
 
No one who exhibits the level of knowledge of DFing that you have has ever seen a DF set let alone operated one.

Given your subsequent comments, I would respectfully suggest that this statement applies to you, not to me.

DF, as in "direction finding", sure. Which means bearings only; not course, not speed, and certainly not position.

You must be kidding. Or you must be bluffing in the hope that I'm bluffing. When you take numerous DF bearings over the course of several days, of course you most certainly can get a good idea of the target's speed. And it goes without saying to anyone who understands even the basic of DF triangulation that you can determine with a reasonable degree of accuracy the position and course of the target--again, if you take multiple DF bearings over the course of several days.

You keep stating the TF was "large" and you somehow think the size of the TF would make it easier to find its position. Such a bizarre notion could only come from someone trying to bluff their way through.

Again, you must be kidding. Talk to anyone who has done DFing in a tactical environment using pre-satellite DF equipment. There are tens of thousands of us around still. The size of the target most certainly does matter when you're trying to obtain the target's position and track when we're talking about a multiple-vehicle/ship target when more than one of the vehicles/ships is transmitting signals.

The task force stretched over 300 miles during the day and some 90 miles at night. It is a whole lot easier to get a reasonably accurate composite reading on the target's location when the target's components occupy such a large area.

Your fundamental knowledge of tracking bearings is so poor I can only conclude your only experience with working with radio signals was adjusting the rabbit ears on your TV.

Your comments lead me to believe that when you wrote your reply you were gambling that I was just making up stuff or something.

Up to 44° off never counts as a close match.

That was one one-off reading. When you're taking numerous DF bearings, you will occasionally get such anomalous readings, which is why you don't use such readings in your location determination. When I first did DFing in the Army in 1984, our unit was still using very old DF equipment (such as the very early versions of the TRQ system), which was not even as good as the equipment that Grogan and Asplund used. Out of every 10 readings, one reading, sometimes two, would be way off from the others. One of the first things you're taught in DF training is to not use such anomalous readings.

"halting of the ships"??? Do you have any idea how stupid that sounds? Do you think the entire fleet just stopped their engines and floated around the ocean for a day?

This is not a serious argument. So you're saying the task force did not stop on 12/2? Are you aware that Yamamoto's Combined Fleet Operations Order No. 5 ordered the task force to advance to a "standby point" by 12/2 (12/3 in Japan)? What do you think a "standby point" is?

But let's assume that the task force disobeyed orders and did not "stand by" on 12/2: Would you be willing to allow that the task force at least markedly reduced its speed on 12/2 and began to bunch up, which even an experienced radio operator using DF bearings would reasonably interpret as a halt?

Of course, I did not say the "entire fleet stopped their engines and just floated around." Obviously, outer patrol ships would have kept moving. The fleet as a whole, however, could be said to have "stopped" at the standby-point.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom