No one who exhibits the level of knowledge of DFing that you have has ever seen a DF set let alone operated one.
Given your subsequent comments, I would respectfully suggest that this statement applies to you, not to me.
DF, as in "direction finding", sure. Which means bearings only; not course, not speed, and certainly not position.
You must be kidding. Or you must be bluffing in the hope that I'm bluffing. When you take numerous DF bearings over the course of several days, of course you most certainly can get a good idea of the target's speed. And it goes without saying to anyone who understands even the basic of DF triangulation that you can determine with a reasonable degree of accuracy the position and course of the target--again, if you take multiple DF bearings over the course of several days.
You keep stating the TF was "large" and you somehow think the size of the TF would make it easier to find its position. Such a bizarre notion could only come from someone trying to bluff their way through.
Again, you must be kidding. Talk to anyone who has done DFing in a tactical environment using pre-satellite DF equipment. There are tens of thousands of us around still. The size of the target most certainly does matter when you're trying to obtain the target's position and track when we're talking about a multiple-vehicle/ship target when more than one of the vehicles/ships is transmitting signals.
The task force stretched over 300 miles during the day and some 90 miles at night. It is a whole lot easier to get a reasonably accurate composite reading on the target's location when the target's components occupy such a large area.
Your fundamental knowledge of tracking bearings is so poor I can only conclude your only experience with working with radio signals was adjusting the rabbit ears on your TV.
Your comments lead me to believe that when you wrote your reply you were gambling that I was just making up stuff or something.
Up to 44° off never counts as a close match.
That was one one-off reading. When you're taking numerous DF bearings, you will occasionally get such anomalous readings, which is why you don't use such readings in your location determination. When I first did DFing in the Army in 1984, our unit was still using very old DF equipment (such as the very early versions of the TRQ system), which was not even as good as the equipment that Grogan and Asplund used. Out of every 10 readings, one reading, sometimes two, would be way off from the others. One of the first things you're taught in DF training is to not use such anomalous readings.
"halting of the ships"??? Do you have any idea how stupid that sounds? Do you think the entire fleet just stopped their engines and floated around the ocean for a day?
This is not a serious argument. So you're saying the task force did not stop on 12/2? Are you aware that Yamamoto's Combined Fleet Operations Order No. 5 ordered the task force to advance to a "standby point" by 12/2 (12/3 in Japan)? What do you think a "standby point" is?
But let's assume that the task force disobeyed orders and did not "stand by" on 12/2: Would you be willing to allow that the task force at least markedly reduced its speed on 12/2 and began to bunch up, which even an experienced radio operator using DF bearings would reasonably interpret as a halt?
Of course, I did not say the "entire fleet stopped their engines and just floated around." Obviously, outer patrol ships would have kept moving. The fleet as a whole, however, could be said to have "stopped" at the standby-point.