Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

They had no hope of controlling the sea lanes between T. H. and the Mainland. Their disdain for submarine warfare in general made it next to impossible conduct effective interdiction of supply routes anywhere during the war that wasn't supported heavily by surface ships. I'm not aware of a USN vessel lost to submarine action east of Hawaii after 1941. Anybody know that one way or the other?

Not so much disdain for Submarine Warfare, but disdain for Merchant and Transport shipping as targets. The IJN Sub force believes that Warships were the only really suitable targets. Than,and the doctrine that tied most of the Japanese Submarine force to Surface Fleet operations were why the Japanese Submarine force was not nearly as effective as the US and German Submarine forces were.
 
I was wondering what would have happened if the Japanese tried to bring a troop ship along with a few destroyers into Pearl Harbor right after the second attack wave and covered it with the third wave they had ready to go? Would they have been able to hold the island for a while and do more damage?

Ranb
 
I was wondering what would have happened if the Japanese tried to bring a troop ship along with a few destroyers into Pearl Harbor right after the second attack wave and covered it with the third wave they had ready to go? Would they have been able to hold the island for a while and do more damage?

Ranb

Not all of the ships in the harbor sank or were damaged to the point of non-functionality. In fact, part of the reason the third strike was canceled was because Japanese losses were correspondingly higher in the second wave, due to effective anti-aircraft fire. In particular, Nevada was active and under power, and sat beached near the harbor entrance. She could've blown any potential attackers to kingdom come.
 
Did the US commander get full credit - the ship was only half finished when it was sunk - I agree there were only minor bits missing like water tight doors, fire control systems etc lol But still, a good nose blow would have taken it out :p

But to your point of how the Japanese valued their sub fleet. Their most successful commander Takakazu Kinashi finished last in a class of over 250 at the naval academy - says a lot in my mind

Actually I'd say they valued one other arm less than submarines, the anti-submarine forces
 
I was wondering what would have happened if the Japanese tried to bring a troop ship along with a few destroyers into Pearl Harbor right after the second attack wave and covered it with the third wave they had ready to go? Would they have been able to hold the island for a while and do more damage?

Ranb

The coastal defenses and controlled minefield might have been a slight deterant (note: most major US ports had controlled minefields, did Pearl?)

I use to live next to the Pearl Harbour channel, very narrow!
 
Last edited:
Regarding the link "The Myths of Pearl Harbor," I've written an article that answers most of its arguments (I say "most" because I agree with a couple of them). I can't link yet, but I assume I'm allowed to say that you can find the article by Googling "Six Myths of the Traditional Pearl Harbor Story."
 
Last edited:
Regarding the link "The Myths of Pearl Harbor," I've written an article that answers most of its arguments (I say "most" because I agree with a couple of them). I can't link yet, but I assume I'm allowed to say that you can find the article by Googling "Six Myths of the Traditional Pearl Harbor Story."

You can link after you've made 15 posts. Which you have.

http://www.mtgriffith.com/web_documents/sixmyths.htm
 
That's not what I said at all. You have simply ignored the plain English of my statement and answered a statement that I did not even imply.


Perhaps it's not what you meant, but it is exactly what you said:

So you think that I posit foul play in the Pearl Harbor case only or at least partly because I don't like FDR? It's actually much the reverse: The more I learn about FDR's handling of WW II, the more negatively I feel about him and his presidency.


"You accuse FDR of conspiracy because you don't like FDR."
"It's very much the opposite: the more I read about FDR, the less I like him."

Being generous, it's not even a counter to the accusation. It's just... a nonsensical response. Please clarify.
 
I was wondering what would have happened if the Japanese tried to bring a troop ship along with a few destroyers into Pearl Harbor right after the second attack wave and covered it with the third wave they had ready to go? Would they have been able to hold the island for a while and do more damage?

Ranb

It would have had to have been more then a Troopship,more like a whole fleet of them.I admit I am not sure of the exact numbers, but there were quite a few US Army and Marine Infanty on Oahu. A commando style raid was just impossible;you would have had to stage a full scale invaison and that would have been impossible.
 
Actually I'd say they valued one other arm less than submarines, the anti-submarine forces

Good point, Japan had no effective Sonar for much of the war, their tactics were more or less the same as those from WW1. Lay down set patterns of depth charges.
 
One moving ship can "essentially" triangulate another moving ship--that's why I said "essentially triangulate." If we were talking about objects that moved much faster, like cars, no, that would be impossible. But for a cruise liner to "essentially" triangulate a target like the task force, which was strung out over several hundred yards and was moving no faster than 20 mph, it would not have been hard at all. Again, we're talking about "essentially" triangulating or "ballpark" triangulation. When you can take DF bearings over the course of several days on a large, slow-moving target, you can most certainly get a reasonably accurate triangulation if you are moving no faster, or slower than, the target.

SLow moving at 20kts?

Over 24 hours the target has moved 480 miles at 20 kts. That's a big triangle.
 
Last edited:
Not so much disdain for Submarine Warfare, but disdain for Merchant and Transport shipping as targets. The IJN Sub force believes that Warships were the only really suitable targets. Than,and the doctrine that tied most of the Japanese Submarine force to Surface Fleet operations were why the Japanese Submarine force was not nearly as effective as the US and German Submarine forces were.

The impressions I have is that the Japanese submariners where the bottom of the pile, professionally and prestige-wise.
 
Regarding the link "The Myths of Pearl Harbor," I've written an article that answers most of its arguments (I say "most" because I agree with a couple of them). I can't link yet, but I assume I'm allowed to say that you can find the article by Googling "Six Myths of the Traditional Pearl Harbor Story."

Ah, you've been exchanging emails with some of the other PHHA people. I've had a great deal of amusement from your posts. May I say hear, "Thanks for the many chortles." I've shared them with friends.
 
I was wondering what would have happened if the Japanese tried to bring a troop ship along with a few destroyers into Pearl Harbor right after the second attack wave and covered it with the third wave they had ready to go? Would they have been able to hold the island for a while and do more damage?

Ranb

About 3 dozen very angry destroyers would have been very happy to see Japanese surface vessels outside Pearl that day.
 
About 3 dozen very angry destroyers would have been very happy to see Japanese surface vessels outside Pearl that day.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but weren't the Japanese especially worried about being discovered by our subs?
 
The impressions I have is that the Japanese submariners where the bottom of the pile, professionally and prestige-wise.

Maybe, but the fact is that even if they had more clout, there is little evidence that the Japanese Doctrine of "Warships are the main target,other shipping is of little importance" would have changed,since most Japanese Submariners agreed with it and few advocated Merchant Shipping as a major target.
I 100% agree that Japanese Anti Submarine warfare was woefully short changed and inadequate.How a nation dependent on maritime traffic for it's survival should have been so short sighted is incredible. You might argue that the British did not put enough resources into ASW before the War, but they did realise it's importance and devoted a respectable amount of resources to developing it (although they probably should have devoted even more). But Japanese ASW seems to have been on the absolute bottom of the barrel when it came to resources.
 
Maybe, but the fact is that even if they had more clout, there is little evidence that the Japanese Doctrine of "Warships are the main target,other shipping is of little importance" would have changed,since most Japanese Submariners agreed with it and few advocated Merchant Shipping as a major target.
I 100% agree that Japanese Anti Submarine warfare was woefully short changed and inadequate.How a nation dependent on maritime traffic for it's survival should have been so short sighted is incredible. You might argue that the British did not put enough resources into ASW before the War, but they did realise it's importance and devoted a respectable amount of resources to developing it (although they probably should have devoted even more). But Japanese ASW seems to have been on the absolute bottom of the barrel when it came to resources.

Are we disagreeing? I can't see a disagreement.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom