Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Does anybody know of a good analysis of how much the militarists modified the Bushido code to fit their agenda, if at all? I've seen claims that the kikusui concept was a perversion of the original code, but not confirmation of that claim.

The big element of the code the militarists modified was the seeking of death through combat. A warrior should always know death could happen, but never enter a fight knowing death was the only outcome to expect.

In terms of a true analysis it is hard to pin down. The code was never formalized and meant different things in different eras.
 
Bombs wouldn't have to penetrate the armour to do enough damage to a Battleship to put it out of action for many months, enough hits would wreck directors, secondary armamant, main turret tracks, deck fittings, superstructure and upperworks etc. Bomb damage could be seen as insurance.

It was a waste of destructive potential. A 250 kg bomb hit might cause enough damage to keep a battleship in repairs for a couple of months. That's about the limit that could be reasonably expected (*). More than one such hit wouldn't necessarily increase the repair time at all as it's likely that they can be be repaired in parallel, you only need to commit more men to it. If that ship has been hit by something larger - a torpedo or an AP bomb -, it will be in repairs for something like 6-10 months in any case and it becomes increasingly likely that the lighter bomb hasn't added anything to the time that the ship is out of action.

Compare that result to the case where the bomb hits a cruiser or a destroyer. That single hit will almost certainly cause enough damage that the ship is out of action for at least 6 months and several hits will knock a destroyer out for good and put a cruiser to the dockyards for at least a year. A much more useful result than superficial damage to a battleship.

(*) That dive bomber hits resulted in Nevada running aground was something that couldn't be reasonably expected before the attack. Basically, the watertight compartments of the ship weren't and its damage control party flooded the wrong compartment when fighting fires. And Nevada has been hit by a torpedo before the dive bombers attacked so it was already damaged seriously enough to keep it in repairs for the desired 6 months.
 
My friend Tracy White spent a few days dismantling the claims on the link listed above, so I won't bother going through that again. Bottom line is we have an CTista who's hot to trot with the Pet Theory and weak on fact checking. They don't make 'em like they used to.
Actually that seems exactly like they used to be.:)
 
It was a waste of destructive potential. A 250 kg bomb hit might cause enough damage to keep a battleship in repairs for a couple of months.

I thing you're a bit self-refuting in that post. But wartime exigencies sped up the repair process. I have 46 "War Damage Reports" on my desk here, doing a job for a certain library, and the turn around time was often quite amazing for a sailor used to working with peace-time shipyards.
 
Remarkable, how Roosevelt-hating just lives on and on. There must be fourth-generation FDR-gnashers out there by now -- and just as virulent as the old-time Wyoming Republicans I grew up with. "Thet Joo basterd Roozeeveld" was the boogeyman of my childhood, and by god he's a boogeyman to the politically childish of today!
 
Remarkable, how Roosevelt-hating just lives on and on. There must be fourth-generation FDR-gnashers out there by now -- and just as virulent as the old-time Wyoming Republicans I grew up with. "Thet Joo basterd Roozeeveld" was the boogeyman of my childhood, and by god he's a boogeyman to the politically childish of today!

The US rejected the conservative paradigm four times running. That's butthurt.
 
Bottom line is we have an CTista who's hot to trot with the Pet Theory and weak on fact checking. They don't make 'em like they used to.


If you check out bobtaftfan's website, he's also a fan of JFK conspiracy theories, but apparently rejects 9/11 conspiracy theories because they "are based on an ignorance of the relevant science, on an overly suspicious—almost paranoid—view of the federal government, and on a refusal to accept the overwhelming weight of the evidence."

I get the impression that he's more inclined toward the conspiracy theory when the event is historical (i.e. several decades or more in the past).
 
If you check out bobtaftfan's website, he's also a fan of JFK conspiracy theories, but apparently rejects 9/11 conspiracy theories because they "are based on an ignorance of the relevant science, on an overly suspicious—almost paranoid—view of the federal government, and on a refusal to accept the overwhelming weight of the evidence."

I get the impression that he's more inclined toward the conspiracy theory when the event is historical (i.e. several decades or more in the past).

Oh, I've been lurking in a conversation involving him for a while. The comedy gold is ... golden. :D
 
If you check out bobtaftfan's website, he's also a fan of JFK conspiracy theories, but apparently rejects 9/11 conspiracy theories because they "are based on an ignorance of the relevant science, on an overly suspicious—almost paranoid—view of the federal government, and on a refusal to accept the overwhelming weight of the evidence."

I get the impression that he's more inclined toward the conspiracy theory when the event is historical (i.e. several decades or more in the past).

CT snowball. Once you believe in one you are more likely to believe in more.
 
I thing you're a bit self-refuting in that post. But wartime exigencies sped up the repair process. I have 46 "War Damage Reports" on my desk here, doing a job for a certain library, and the turn around time was often quite amazing for a sailor used to working with peace-time shipyards.


The most famous repair story perhaps that of the Yorktown being patched up in time to participate in the Battle of Midway. Granted, not by any means a full repair, but nevertheless the damage was repaired enough to allow the ship to get back into combat.
 
If you check out bobtaftfan's website, he's also a fan of JFK conspiracy theories, but apparently rejects 9/11 conspiracy theories because they "are based on an ignorance of the relevant science, on an overly suspicious—almost paranoid—view of the federal government, and on a refusal to accept the overwhelming weight of the evidence."

I get the impression that he's more inclined toward the conspiracy theory when the event is historical (i.e. several decades or more in the past).

He's also a neo-Confederate "Restore the Constitution Articles-of-Confederation" believer. His love of DiLorenzo's anti-Lincoln screeds tells me all I need to know about his ability to weigh the validity of historical writing....

As for 9-11, i suspect if it were a Democrat instead of a Republican in office on 9/11/01 that he'd be a believer...
 
Last edited:
More than 12? How do you do that?
You start in your home country and travel to the military front in the east. Then you start in your home country and travel to the military front in the west. If the two trips involve crossing more than 180 degrees of longitude, the two fronts are more than 12 time zones apart.

Major arc vs. minor arc.
 
I navigated US Navy ships and submarines for 20 years as a quartermaster. I am an expert in visual, radar, celestial, satellite, bathymetric, and RDF navigation, target motion analysis (i.e. tracking targets with passve sonar and determining their range, course, and speed), and fleet operations so I know what I'm talking about. I also know when someone is trying to bluff their way through any of the above topics.

Then I guess you are the guy to ask about this:


Grogan noted that the ships were trying to conceal their movements.

If one is aligning and realigning one's directional antenna to pick up distant radio transmissions, how exactly does one know that the ships one is tracking are trying to conceal their movements?



,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

One last thought. With very few exceptions, the world is filled with much more misfeasance than malfeasance. Sometimes a message not being delivered in a timely manner is not evidence of a conspiracy; it is merely evidence that the system was not always able to deliver messages in a timely manner.
 
Last edited:
"It will take three months."

"You have three days."

Although that had been revised down considerably to two weeks by the time she got to Pearl. I think the ships long lead time in getting back to Pearl gave everyone time to organize parts game plan etc.

And you can imagine the mood of the repair crews at the dock. The Yorktowns back and she's just given the japanese a huge kick in the rear end...amazing what moral can do :)
 
It would have had to have been more then a Troopship,more like a whole fleet of them.I admit I am not sure of the exact numbers, but there were quite a few US Army and Marine Infanty on Oahu. A commando style raid was just impossible;you would have had to stage a full scale invaison and that would have been impossible.


I've often wondered just how much of a pain in the butt a small group of infantry landing on one of the other islands and taking the civilian population hostage might have been. Especially if they retreated into the interior with the intention to fight to the death without resupply or reinforcement.
 
If one is aligning and realigning one's directional antenna to pick up distant radio transmissions, how exactly does one know that the ships one is tracking are trying to conceal their movements?

I'll just butt in on this one.

One doesn't. One might speculate (based on what, I couldn't say), but using only direction finding, one cannot know.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom