Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

So, Ranneft pirated a Swedish AA gun for the US Navy, and in reward they... blabbed to him about a conspiracy to purposefully let a hostile foreign power successfully attack our main fleet at one of our biggest military bases despite? In what way is that "logical"?

Who said they told Ranneft about a conspiracy to allow Pearl Harbor to be attacked? Ranneft said no such thing. In fact, Ranneft said he believed Pearl Harbor was fully prepared. He logically assumed that ONI had informed Hawaii about the Japanese carriers nearby, and he was very surprised when he heard that Pearl had been caught off guard.

In fact, many of the foreknowledge witnesses believed the same thing--that Pearl Harbor knew the same information that they knew--and that's why they were so troubled when they learned that Pearl had been caught off guard. They were baffled precisely because they naturally assumed that the Hawaiian commanders had been given the same intelligence that they had seen or learned about.
 
And they are consistently unsupported by factual evidence. "Ranneft was startled when one of the Americans pointed to a map on the wall and said, "This is the Japanese Task Force proceeding east."" Really? How many people had to know the attack was LIHOP'd to get a freaking WALL CHART hung up? Reality challenged people, they are endless fun.
 
You're forgetting a couple of things:

a. the message was 2 character code group that signified "American fleet not in Lahaina Anchorage";
b. I-72 was not part of Kido Butai (different grouping with a different set of orders); and
c. This message was not decoded until 1946.

My, my, what happened to all that sneering, dismissive posturing that, gee, I couldn't even get the date of the transmission correct? It turns out that you folks are the ones who blundered on the transmission date. Anyway, to your arguments:

A. It was still a transmission, a transmission made by a Hawaii Operation submarine that was under the command of Nagumo and operationally attached to the KB.

B. For all intents and purposes, I-72 was part of Kido Butai. You're grasping at a distinction without a difference. Perhaps you have no military experience, but a unit that's attached to your unit, that's working in support of your unit, and that's under the command of your commander is, for all intents and purposes, part of your unit.

C. The point is that it was sent before the attack. I don't care when it was decoded. That's not the issue. It was a transmission sent by a KB-attached submarine, by a submarine that was part of the Hawaii Operation force that attacked Pearl Harbor, and it was sent before the attack.
 
I bought the book first edition, Bob. Now, answer my question. You don't have the book, do you? You're just fishing in the footnotes.

Huh? What a juvenile argument. Yes, of course I have the book. How do you suppose I quoted all those statements about the extreme weather that the KB encountered? (And there are more where those came from, by the way.) Why on earth would you think I don't have the book? Such an argument says volumes about how utterly closed your mind is on this subject.

If you'd bothered to check the messages in the book, you could have quickly discerned that I-72's transmission was sent on 6 December.
 
The subs were not in Nagumo's chain of command.
The transmission gave no indication of an attack on Pearl Harbor. It was just a quick coded message. They didn't want to tip off the attack no matter how stupid you think they were.

"For all intents and purposes, I-72 was part of Kido Butai." You just refuted your point A. Stop that, it takes the fun out of this.

C. is irrelevant, because A and B are wrong.
 
And they are consistently unsupported by factual evidence. "Ranneft was startled when one of the Americans pointed to a map on the wall and said, "This is the Japanese Task Force proceeding east."" Really? How many people had to know the attack was LIHOP'd to get a freaking WALL CHART hung up? Reality challenged people, they are endless fun.

So mutually supportive testimony does not constitute "factual evidence," even when, as in the case of the Don Smith account, it's supported by records that confirm a key part of the story? The fact that numerous credible people independently gave the same basic account is meaningless, hey?

They are not "endless fun," but you are becoming rather fun with your silly arguments. No one has said that the ONI officers who spoke with Ranneft were part of the plot or that they even knew an attack was coming.

As I've said before, it's probable that those officers knew nothing of the plot to withhold intelligence from Hawaii so the Japanese could surprise Pearl Harbor. In fact, Ranneft said when he asked about the carriers' intentions, the ONI officers speculated they were trying to discern our intentions and movements. And he added that he believed Hawaii was fully prepared for hostilities in any event. That's why he was so surprised when he learned that Pearl had been caught by surprise.

And, by the way, regarding your silly remark that if you had been Stark you wouldn't have let a kook into your office either, in point of fact Stark agreed to meet with Ranneft and only cancelled the meeting when he realized that Ranneft wanted to discuss foreknowledge of the attack and why/how Hawaii was caught off guard.
 
Last edited:
Bob, there's a reason all these "whistle-blower" stories dead end. They get check out, the facts show they're wrong, and that's the end of it. You seem to be under the impression that you are presenting these seastories for the first time. Your book (and you really do need more than one, btw) got you pay the author for repeating a bunch of tall tales that you could have found on the internet for free.
 
The subs were not in Nagumo's chain of command.

Oh, come now. You know that's hair splitting. They were under his command.

Do you have any military experience? I spent 21 years in the Army and did deployments where we had units attached to ours, under our command, and working ahead of or behind us. We considered them part of our unit for that operation.

The transmission gave no indication of an attack on Pearl Harbor. It was just a quick coded message. They didn't want to tip off the attack no matter how stupid you think they were.

Now, who in the world has said they were "stupid" or that they wanted to "tip off the attack"? Sheesh, that's just juvenile.

And you're supposed to be an "expert"? I'm tempted to ask about your level of education, because you're making truly sophomoric arguments that suggest a lack of any training in logic and critical thinking.

I've said that Japanese believed, as did we, that low-powered transmissions were safe from intercept because they thought, as did we, that they had a limited reception range.

Now, as for the I-72 transmission, now that we've debunked your adamant-but-erroneous claim that it was sent after the attack, the issue is not how long it lasted or whether it was coded. The point is that it was a transmission by a KB-attached submarine, a submarine that was part of the Hawaii Operation force attacked Pearl Harbor.

"For all intents and purposes, I-72 was part of Kido Butai." You just refuted your point A. Stop that, it takes the fun out of this.

Huh??? How does my point that I-72 was part of KB for all intents and purposes contradict, much less "refute," my point A that the transmission in question was "made by a Hawaii Operation submarine that was under the command of Nagumo and operationally attached to the KB"? Huh? How?

C. is irrelevant, because A and B are wrong.

Yeah, uh-huh. Wow, I'm floored by the persuasive power and substance of that reply.

Folks, if this is your "expert," your side has big problems.
 
Last edited:
These are the 2 bits of Rannefts diary that are quoted in The Pearl Harbour Myth.
First the 2nd December:
"
2-12-41. Conference at Navy Department, they show me on the map the location of 2 Japanese carriers departed from Japan on easterly course.
"
And then the 6th:
"
At 1400 to Navy Dept., the department is closed, except the division ONI where a night watch is kept.
Everyone present at ONI confer Director Admiral Wilkinson, Capt. MacCollum, Lt. Cmdr. Kramer ...
At my request, they show me the location of the 2 carriers (see 2-12-41) west of Honolulu.
"

According to this these are the same pair of carriers.
Since KB ended up North of Honolulu this is clearly wrong.

By the way, there's three clear names there...
 
Do you have any military experience? I spent 21 years in the Army and did deployments where we had units attached to ours, under our command, and working ahead of or behind us. We considered them part of our unit for that operation.

I'm a retired E-7. And you know jack about the naval procedures, as you've shown endless times.
 
Huh??? How does my point that I-72 was part of KB for all intents and purposes contradict, much less "refute," my point A that the transmission in question was "made by a Hawaii Operation submarine that was under the command of Nagumo and operationally attached to the KB"? Huh? How?
Okay, small words for Bob. You said it was under his command. Then you said "for all intents and purposes", which means you want it to be under his command but DO understand it wasn't.
 
Who said they told Ranneft about a conspiracy to allow Pearl Harbor to be attacked? Ranneft said no such thing. In fact, Ranneft said he believed Pearl Harbor was fully prepared. He logically assumed that ONI had informed Hawaii about the Japanese carriers nearby, and he was very surprised when he heard that Pearl had been caught off guard.

In fact, many of the foreknowledge witnesses believed the same thing--that Pearl Harbor knew the same information that they knew--and that's why they were so troubled when they learned that Pearl had been caught off guard. They were baffled precisely because they naturally assumed that the Hawaiian commanders had been given the same intelligence that they had seen or learned about.

Then why didn't anyone at ONI back Ranneft's claims up? If none of them were in on the conspiracy, why didn't any of them (especially Wilkinson, McCollum, and Kramer) say "we were tracking Japanese carriers near Hawaii in the days before the attack"? Why is the only evidence that ONI was doing this in Ranneft's diary?
 
Then why didn't anyone at ONI back Ranneft's claims up? If none of them were in on the conspiracy, why didn't any of them (especially Wilkinson, McCollum, and Kramer) say "we were tracking Japanese carriers near Hawaii in the days before the attack"? Why is the only evidence that ONI was doing this in Ranneft's diary?

I think I remember someone going through the records and proving those three guys couldn't have been there on that day because one or more wasn't even on the East Coast. I'll have to check on that.
 
As for the argument that Ranneft said the carriers were west of Hawaii, instead of northwest, this seems nit picky on its face. He said ONI told him the carriers had left Japan, were heading "easterly," and were halfway between Japan and Hawaii, and in one diary entry said they were "west of Honolulu." In another account, he said they were "north of Honolulu." Gosh, that seems pretty close to the mark. But some want to make a big deal out of the fact that he didn't say "northwest."

However, Ranneft himself later said, when asked about this issue, that Toland's treatment in Infamy was accurate, and he added that ONI had tracked the task force en route to Hawaii and that on 6 December ONI told/showed him that the carriers were about 300 miles "northwest" of Honolulu (Victor, The Pearl Harbor Myth, p. 46).
 
Then why didn't anyone at ONI back Ranneft's claims up? If none of them were in on the conspiracy, why didn't any of them (especially Wilkinson, McCollum, and Kramer) say "we were tracking Japanese carriers near Hawaii in the days before the attack"? Why is the only evidence that ONI was doing this in Ranneft's diary?

Oh, gosh, I just can't imagine why those ONI officers would not have backed up Ranneft's account! Shucks, who'd have thought that they would not have said, "Yeah, he's right: We knew there were Japanese carriers near Pearl Harbor on 6 December, and weshowed him their location"?

A better question is, What possible motive would Ranneft have had for lying about this? Why would he have made false entries in his diary about this? Why?

Kramer changed his story and perjured himself about the Winds execute message. And all three--Wilkinson, McCollum, and Kramer--would have invited enormous condemnation if they'd admitted that they knew there were Japanese carriers near Hawaii on 6 December and failed to inform Kimmel and Short.

Again, what possible would Ranneft have had to lie about this? His journal is hard evidence that some officers in ONI knew there were Japanese carriers near Hawaii on 6 December. And Ranneft himself later confirmed the accuracy of Toland's treatment of his account.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom