Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Is that what you're saying, or do you not have a copy of The Pearl Harbor Papers? Just answer the question.

Why does he need a copy of that?
He has access to the original documents.

As for Ranneft, we went through that 2 months ago.
The diary does not say what Toland says it says, and has been repeated via conspiracy sites since.
 
Your dance is getting a bit old. Now, yes or no--do you have a copy of Goldstein and Dillon's The Pearl Harbor Papers? Every pre-attack 6-7 December Hawaii Operation message of which we have a record is reprinted on pages 242-244 therein (and, of course, the dates therein for those days are 7-8 December, since they're all in Tokyo Time).

Now, if I-72's transmission was sent after the attack, then that means Goldstein and Dillon royally screwed up the chronology for those messages, because they have I-72's message as being sent the day before Nagumo's message.

Is that what you're saying, or do you not have a copy of The Pearl Harbor Papers? Just answer the question.

Wow, that's got to be the most epic dodge of a question I've ever seen.
 
Wow, that's got to be the most epic dodge of a question I've ever seen.

Epic? No. I'd say it was bloated and clumsy, but distracting. Like watching a fat, clumsy egotistical guy trying to dance ballet so badly that you don't notice the actual talented dancers on the stage.
 
How did an officer in a foreign navy know about these aircraft carriers a few hundred miles away but apparently no one in the US Navy knew? Don't you think the ONI would have told one of their own officers first and a foreign naval officer not at all?
 
Why does he need a copy of that?
He has access to the original documents.

As for Ranneft, we went through that 2 months ago.
The diary does not say what Toland says it says, and has been repeated via conspiracy sites since.

Read: You haven't read a single non-traditionalist source on this issue. At the bare minimum, Ranneft's diary says ONI told him there were Japanese carriers near Hawaii, and that earlier they had detected Japanese carriers leaving Japan home waters and heading eastward. And I'm guessing you're just not interested in what Ranneft himself said when he was asked about this later, hey?

Will any of you ever break down and read Dr. Victor's analysis of the Ranneft evidence? The Pearl Harbor Myth, pp. 43-45. That part of the book is included in the version available via Google Books.

And, again, do you care what Ranneft himself said when he was asked about this later? Oh, but I forgot: Ranneft was a liar and a kook, right?
 
How did an officer in a foreign navy know about these aircraft carriers a few hundred miles away but apparently no one in the US Navy knew? Don't you think the ONI would have told one of their own officers first and a foreign naval officer not at all?

Sigh. . . . Take a swig of whiskey and dare yourself to read a scholarly work on Pearl Harbor that doesn't claim the emperor is wearing clothes. They explain, quite logically, why ONI would have shared this info with Ranneft. Just dare yourself to do a tiny bit of balanced research by reading, heaven forbid, a "revisionist" work that discusses this issue.

And your statement that "no one in the US Navy knew" is simply a claim, and it's a claim that's contradicted by a number of credible personnel, including some Navy intelligence personnel.
 
And, again, I'm making a very simple point about the timing of I-72's transmission: If you're saying that the I-72 transmission came after the attack, then you're saying that Goldstein and Dillon royally, horrendously screwed up the chronology for the pre-attack 6-7 December Hawaii Operation messages, since they have I-72's message as being sent the day before Nagumo's careless, risky 7 December message.
 
How did an officer in a foreign navy know about these aircraft carriers a few hundred miles away but apparently no one in the US Navy knew? Don't you think the ONI would have told one of their own officers first and a foreign naval officer not at all?


Then-Capt(N) Ranneft (later RAdm) was the Naval Attache for the Netherlands in the US from 1938 until his retirement in 1947. Allegedly, he was allowed to wander the ONI and the officers there, thinking he was OK shared intel with him that was not shared with their superiors.

Now, I will freely admit to not being a HQ type - but unless generally attaches are not given free access to sensitive areas unless they are part of a joint HQ. Since the Netherlands and the US were not military allies until after Pear Harbour, I find the notion that he was given access to ONI a little far-fetched and that the officers discussed sensitive intel with him even less plausible.
 
They explain, quite logically, why ONI would have shared this info with Ranneft. Just dare yourself to do a tiny bit of balanced research by reading, heaven forbid, a "revisionist" work that discusses this issue.

George Victor doesn't.

Why don't you tell us this "logical" explanation?
 
Then-Capt(N) Ranneft (later RAdm) was the Naval Attache for the Netherlands in the US from 1938 until his retirement in 1947. Allegedly, he was allowed to wander the ONI and the officers there, thinking he was OK shared intel with him that was not shared with their superiors.

Wait, really? "We think he's a cool guy, so we'll let him in on our conspiracy to purposefully let a hostile foreign power successfully attack or main fleet at one of our biggest military bases"?
 
FYI, Captain Fuchida, who led the air raid on Pearl Harbor, also said that I-72's report on the Lahaina Anchorage was sent on 6 December (note: the parenthetical comments are his):

At 12:55 p.m. on the seventh (4:55 p.m., 6 December in Honolulu), a message came in from the submarine I-72: "American fleet is not in Lahaina Anchorage." (Mitsuo Fuchida, "I Led the Air Attack on Pearl Harbor," in Paul Stillwell, editor, Air Raid: Pearl Harbor!: Recollections of a Day of Infamy, U.S. Naval Institute, 1981, p. 6, emphasis added)​
 
Last edited:
George Victor doesn't.

Why don't you tell us this "logical" explanation?

Ranneft enabled the U.S. Navy to obtain the Bofors 40-mm AA gun, in technical violation of the Swedish patent no less, and the Navy was very grateful, and as a result afforded Ranneft exceptional access. British scholar Colonel John Hughes-Wilson:

The US Navy was delighted with their new AA gun and afforded Ranneft all the easy, informal access that valued attaches strive so hard to achieve but rarely obtain. For Ranneft was not only a valued friend, he was also, in the eyes of the US naval officers based in Washington, a colleague, a senior officer, a friend to US interests, and overall a "regular guy." (Military Intelligence Blunders and Cover-Ups, p. 90)​
 
Ranneft enabled the U.S. Navy to obtain the Bofors 40-mm AA gun, in technical violation of the Swedish patent no less, and the Navy was very grateful, and as a result afforded Ranneft exceptional access. British scholar Colonel John Hughes-Wilson:

The US Navy was delighted with their new AA gun and afforded Ranneft all the easy, informal access that valued attaches strive so hard to achieve but rarely obtain. For Ranneft was not only a valued friend, he was also, in the eyes of the US naval officers based in Washington, a colleague, a senior officer, a friend to US interests, and overall a "regular guy." (Military Intelligence Blunders and Cover-Ups, p. 90)​

So, Ranneft pirated a Swedish AA gun for the US Navy, and in reward they... blabbed to him about a conspiracy to purposefully let a hostile foreign power successfully attack our main fleet at one of our biggest military bases despite?

In what way is that "logical"?
 
Will any of you ever break down and read Dr. Victor's analysis of the Ranneft evidence? The Pearl Harbor Myth, pp. 43-45. That part of the book is included in the version available via Google Books.

An analysis in which, even though he quotes Ranneft's diary as saying "West of Honolulu", he manages to turn this into "north west".

Is this where you learned your compass bearings?
 
FYI, Captain Fuchida, who led the air raid on Pearl Harbor, also said that I-72's report on the Lahaina Anchorage was sent on 6 December (note: the parenthetical comments are his):

At 12:55 p.m. on the seventh (4:55 p.m., 6 December in Honolulu), a message came in from the submarine I-72: "American fleet is not in Lahaina Anchorage." (Mitsuo Fuchida, "I Led the Air Attack on Pearl Harbor," in Paul Stillwell, editor, Air Raid: Pearl Harbor!: Recollections of a Day of Infamy, U.S. Naval Institute, 1981, p. 6, emphasis added)​

You're forgetting a couple of things:

a. the message was 2 character code group that signified "American fleet not in Lahaina Anchorage";
b. I-72 was not part of Kido Butai (different grouping with a different set of orders); and
c. This message was not decoded until 1946.
 
Your dance is getting a bit old. Now, yes or no--do you have a copy of Goldstein and Dillon's The Pearl Harbor Papers? Every pre-attack 6-7 December Hawaii Operation message of which we have a record is reprinted on pages 242-244 therein (and, of course, the dates therein for those days are 7-8 December, since they're all in Tokyo Time).

Now, if I-72's transmission was sent after the attack, then that means Goldstein and Dillon royally screwed up the chronology for those messages, because they have I-72's message as being sent the day before Nagumo's message.

Is that what you're saying, or do you not have a copy of The Pearl Harbor Papers? Just answer the question.

I bought the book first edition, Bob. Now, answer my question. You don't have the book, do you? You're just fishing in the footnotes.
 
You're forgetting a couple of things:

a. the message was 2 character code group that signified "American fleet not in Lahaina Anchorage";
b. I-72 was not part of Kido Butai (different grouping with a different set of orders); and
c. This message was not decoded until 1946.

Yeahbutisms: The I-boat transmitted! So did a few hundred fishing boats in that area, but the I-boat transmitted. So what if it was a mere blip? Who cares if it wasn't decoded until we were told what to look for? Who cares that the message was totally meaningless without context?
 
fyi, captain fuchida, who led the air raid on pearl harbor, also said that i-72's report on the lahaina anchorage was sent on 6 december (note: The parenthetical comments are his):

at 12:55 p.m. On the seventh (4:55 p.m., 6 december in honolulu), a message came in from the submarine i-72: "american fleet is not in lahaina anchorage." (mitsuo fuchida, "i led the air attack on pearl harbor," in paul stillwell, editor, air raid: Pearl harbor!: Recollections of a day of infamy, u.s. Naval institute, 1981, p. 6, emphasis added)​

.-- .... --- -.-. .- .-. . ... -... --- -... .-.-.-
 
An analysis in which, even though he quotes Ranneft's diary as saying "West of Honolulu", he manages to turn this into "north west".

Is this where you learned your compass bearings?



His compass bearings have seized up.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom