But we have records of a KB carrier talking directly to tankers, so they did transmit. To avoid this, you float the implausible theory that the IJN fake transmissions included transmissions between carriers and tankers on tactical circuits, even though this would have been abnormal for home-waters comms and even though such transmissions would indicate activity far away from port.
It is ironic that in your previous reply you refer to circular arguments. Your "KB did not transmit" is itself a rather egregious circular argument.
In your world, the documented transmissions between the Akagi and tankers had to be part of the IJN's deception because "KB did not transmit," never mind the fact that such transmissions would be abnormal for ships sitting in home waters.
In your world, the numerous military and civilian personnel who said they heard or saw intel from Japanese intercepts that indicated an attack on Pearl Harbor and/or who said they were informed of such intel from people who heard or saw it--they were all lying or "mistaken" because "KB did not transmit." And never you mind that most of these people didn't know each other and yet told the same basic account. "Mistaken"? What exactly would there be to have gotten confused about? "I've seen Japanese intel that says Pearl Harbor will be attacked." Or, "the intel I've seen from Japanese intercepts leads me to believe that Pearl Harbor could be attacked." One could think of dozens of variants, all of which would be easy to understand and rather hard to be "mistaken" about.
In your world, Grogan's signals were--well, let's go through the list: They were Russian ships. Yes, that's the scholarly consensus. Err, uh-oh, wait, they weren't Russian ships after all. Uh, they were some stray Japanese fishing ships--that's gotta be it. But, uh, hold on--no, they were signals that bounced all the way from a Japanese port to Grogan's RDF antennas, and somehow those signals gave him numerous bearings that indicated they came from an area northwest of Hawaii! Yeah! Of course, makes perfect sense! Or, hey, maybe they were actually American, British, or Dutch signals! Oh, rats, all ABD ships were in the southwestern quadrant of the Pacific at the time. Ah-hah . . . wait . . . we got it: Maybe Grogan just made up the whole story and he never heard any signals! Really, take any one of those, but you just can't believe that Grogan heard the KB because "KB did not transmit."