Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Round and round you go.

This is Textbook Conspiracy Theory. Substitute Pearl Harbor for Apollo or 911 and we can almost 'call the plays'

Your last two posts are classic.
Wait a couple of weeks and make the same claims again with the same references and hope people have forgotten I did it before.
Back to the RDF next is it?
 
Weather report, please? I haven't heard anything from you on that since I posted the charts with the aerological data.

You're aware that even one of the KB sailors mentioned the bad weather and said that he'd never seen swells so huge, right? Right? Right? You know this, right? Extreme weather was common in the North Pacific at that time of year.

John Gresham, an ardent traditionalist, notes that the task force's "was shielded from observation by a weather front that was moving about the same speed across the North Pacific" (http://www.defensemedianetwork.com/stories/pearl-harbor-the-attack/). Paul Stillwell, another reliable traditionalist, observes that the KB "crossed the North Pacific in rough seas" (http://www.accuweather.com/en/weather-news/partly-cloudy-skies-during-pea/58654).

Even the Wikipedia article on the attack notes that bad weather became a factor even on the day of the attack, saying "Weather had deteriorated notably since the first and second wave launching, and rough seas complicated takeoff and landing for a third wave attack."

BTW, Kido Butai didn't transmit.

Yes, they did, and we have evidence of KB transmissions, but you'll only admit that one of them came from the KB (Nagumo's transmission shortly after the planes left the carriers, which was a risky move that shows a rather casual attitude toward radio silence). We have records of a KB carrier talking directly with tankers on a tactical circuit, but your "explanation" is that these were just deception broadcasts from Japan. Right, let's try to get the Americans to think that our carriers are in home waters, so let's send fake transmissions that have a carrier talking directly to tankers on a tactical circuit! You bet.

We also have numerous people, military and civilian, who said they knew of or were informed about Japanese intercepts indicating that Pearl Harbor would be attacked. One of them, Captain Ranneft of the Dutch Navy, said ONI knew the location of the KB and showed him the tracking on a map.
 
Sorge knew that Pearl Harbor would be attacked, and he stated that his Moscow superiors advised him that they had passed along this intel to the Americans. Among other sources, you can find this discussed in Admiral Theobald's book The Final Secret of Pearl Harbor (New York: Devin-Adair, 1954), pp. 78–80.

There are some issues with Sorge as having prior knowledge and that intel being passed on.

The Soviet Union was not an ally of the US at prior to the entry of the US into the war and was under no obligation to pass on any info. Given the recent Non-Agression Pact that the Soviets and Japan had entered into April 14, 1941, and the commencement of Barbarossa on June 20, 1941 the Soviets were more likely to be relieved that Japanese attention was not being directed their way.

Stalin had allegedly received intel from Sorge re the date for Barbarossa - and ignored it. How likely is he to have passed on a possible threat to a non-ally, when he was prepared to ignore a direct threat to his own nation?

Finally, Sorge was arrested for espionage October 18, 1941 and held until his execution in 1944.

According to Adm(Ret'd) Theobald in his book - Sorge confessed in 1942 to passing the info on Pearl Harbour in October to the Soviets, who acknowledged it and told Sorge that it was passed on to the Americans. Theobald expressed outrage that the document (ie the warning from the Soviets) was not in US records. However, given the way the Soviets treated some of the intelligence from Sorge (ie. ignoring Barbarossa) I would posit that it is more likely that the information was never passed on.
 
Robert Hanyok, another ardent traditionalist, notes that high swells and mist caused Nagumo to pull back the three scouting submarines, saying:

At six o’clock on 26 November, the ships of the Kido Butai raised their anchors, slowly steamed into the northern Pacific, and settled into a cruising formation, within a box some thirty kilometers on a side. Initially, the three submarines scouted ahead on the surface. (The submarines were later pulled back, because high swells and mist slowed them and hindered their ability to sight ships.) (http://www.usnwc.edu/getattachment/218c27dc-ad99-40a4-8d1e-03bee0db32e3)​

So not only did the swells slow the subs but the swells and the mist made it hard for them to spot ships. Humm. . . .
 
Round and round you go.

This is Textbook Conspiracy Theory. Substitute Pearl Harbor for Apollo or 911 and we can almost 'call the plays'

Your last two posts are classic.
Wait a couple of weeks and make the same claims again with the same references and hope people have forgotten I did it before.
Back to the RDF next is it?

Lincoln knew the South was going to bombard Fort Sumter yet he did nothing. Conspiracy!
 
For goodness sake, a submerged Sub using it's Periscope has a very limited horizon. any kind of swell over a couple of feet will obscure it's view unless it surfaces.

As for weather hampering flying, it doesn't take a huge storm to do that. We couldn't fly our Wasp off in any kind of a see on the Tribal Class Frigates, doesn't mean we were in a storm.

One sailors opinion that it was the worst storm he had been in just tells us about the storms he has been in, what was his previous experience?

North Atlantic Convoys managed to stay together in radio silence through huge storms. We managed to keep station on other ships in the task Force on the way to the South Atlantic in Radio Silence. That's what ships do, it's what Navigators and Bridge Officers train for, it's their job.

Just 25 years earlier the battle fleets of the world managed to steam in formation and at high speed through storms both day and night with no kind of radio at all.
Ships would navigate a rendezvous thousands of miles across oceans just using a watch and sextant.

You know nothing of ships or the sea.
 
No, Lincoln tricked the South into bombarding Fort Sumter . He made it happen on purpose.

Ahh, so clearly Booth was an agent of the Vast Conspiracy who killed Lincoln to keep him silent.

The same Vast Conspiracy that FDR was part of so naturally Pear Harbor was an inside job.

CT's are wonderful where else can you get so much theorizing out of so few facts.
 
You're aware that even one of the KB sailors mentioned the bad weather and said that he'd never seen swells so huge, right? Right? Right? You know this, right? Extreme weather was common in the North Pacific at that time of year.

John Gresham, an ardent traditionalist, notes that the task force's "was shielded from observation by a weather front that was moving about the same speed across the North Pacific" (http://www.defensemedianetwork.com/stories/pearl-harbor-the-attack/). Paul Stillwell, another reliable traditionalist, observes that the KB "crossed the North Pacific in rough seas" (http://www.accuweather.com/en/weather-news/partly-cloudy-skies-during-pea/58654).

Even the Wikipedia article on the attack notes that bad weather became a factor even on the day of the attack, saying "Weather had deteriorated notably since the first and second wave launching, and rough seas complicated takeoff and landing for a third wave attack."
Weather deteriorated to that state. Meaning it was better before. AS for the "witness", why doesn't the record agree with him? Everybody's lying if they don't agree with you, right?

Yes, they did, and we have evidence of KB transmissions, but you'll only admit that one of them came from the KB (Nagumo's transmission shortly after the planes left the carriers, which was a risky move that shows a rather casual attitude toward radio silence). We have records of a KB carrier talking directly with tankers on a tactical circuit, but your "explanation" is that these were just deception broadcasts from Japan. Right, let's try to get the Americans to think that our carriers are in home waters, so let's send fake transmissions that have a carrier talking directly to tankers on a tactical circuit! You bet.

We also have numerous people, military and civilian, who said they knew of or were informed about Japanese intercepts indicating that Pearl Harbor would be attacked. One of them, Captain Ranneft of the Dutch Navy, said ONI knew the location of the KB and showed him the tracking on a map.
No, we don't have records of transmissions, because they didn't transmit.
 
As for weather hampering flying, it doesn't take a huge storm to do that.

Agreed. Smaller aircraft are even forbidden to fly in just potentially severe weather, larger aircraft are forbidden to take off or land in same.
 
Agreed. Smaller aircraft are even forbidden to fly in just potentially severe weather, larger aircraft are forbidden to take off or land in same.
In the RN an aircraft is Recovered, not landed on a ship :)
 
In other words, you've never read a single scholarly work that challenges the traditional Pearl Harbor story. The accounts given by the people on the list have been documented in a number of scholarly revisionist works, but obviously you haven't read a single one of them. You could start with these three:

You are the one making the claims and thus the burden falls on you to provide evidence that the people in question had this information in their possession prior to Pearl Harbor; and the same anecdote recounted in any number of books is not evidence. When you can point to original documents that substantiate your claims then perhaps I might find these books worth perusing but not before.
 
One thing is certain.

The Japanese signals deception plan was a huge success - Bob and his ilk are still being decieved to this day.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom