mikegriffith1
Muse
- Joined
- Sep 25, 2012
- Messages
- 805
Based on the research I've done so far, there is very little if any weather information for the western part of the North Pacific for November-December 1941, and of course that's where the KB traveled. Available weather data for the eastern North Pacific inform us that there were several severe storms and other weather issues in the November-to-December timeframe.
Anyway, in addition to the evidence that I cited earlier of bad weather for the KB, we also have Admiral Sadao Chigusa's account of the KB's voyage. He noted the following--I'm going to work backwards from 5 December (and I'll change Japanese time to Hawaii time):
* On 5 December in the morning there was "a southwest wind blowing over 10 m (20 kts)," and the wind "increased strongly in the evening to about 15 m or 16 m (30 kts or 32 kts) bringing us very high waves." (Goldstein and Dillon, The Pearl Harbor Papers, p. 189) 20 kts equals 23 mph, and 32 kts equals 37 mph. And the waves were "very high."
* On 4 December "after a long interval, the sea became calm," which of course means that it was not calm during that long interval. (The Pearl Harbor Papers, p. 189)
* On 3 December at dusk the wind "fell below 10 m (20 kts) and the sea became fairly calm." (The Pearl Harbor Papers, p. 189) So the wind had been above 20 kts (23 mph) before dusk, and at dusk it became "fairly" calm, which tells us that before dusk the sea was not even "fairly" calm.
* On 2 December there was "a strong south wind at 18 m (35 kts)" and visibility was "short owing to heavy drizzle" (The Pearl Harbor Papers, p. 188) 35 kts is 40 mph, and visibility was "short." But that's not all. Chigusa goes on to tell us that his ship reached a 47-degree of roll to one side and that he'd never experienced anything like that before: "[the roll] was the largest roll since leaving Hitokappu Bay, and of course I hadn't experienced anything like it ever before." (The Pearl Harbor Papers, p. 188)
So an admiral had never seen a ship roll the way his ship did in that weather, and this was the same day that Grogan discerned that the ships he was monitoring were "bunched up." My, my, what a coincidence.
* On 1 December "the roll of our ship was severe" and winds were at 26-28 kts, or 30-32 mph. (The Pearl Harbor Papers, p. 188)
Anyway, in addition to the evidence that I cited earlier of bad weather for the KB, we also have Admiral Sadao Chigusa's account of the KB's voyage. He noted the following--I'm going to work backwards from 5 December (and I'll change Japanese time to Hawaii time):
* On 5 December in the morning there was "a southwest wind blowing over 10 m (20 kts)," and the wind "increased strongly in the evening to about 15 m or 16 m (30 kts or 32 kts) bringing us very high waves." (Goldstein and Dillon, The Pearl Harbor Papers, p. 189) 20 kts equals 23 mph, and 32 kts equals 37 mph. And the waves were "very high."
* On 4 December "after a long interval, the sea became calm," which of course means that it was not calm during that long interval. (The Pearl Harbor Papers, p. 189)
* On 3 December at dusk the wind "fell below 10 m (20 kts) and the sea became fairly calm." (The Pearl Harbor Papers, p. 189) So the wind had been above 20 kts (23 mph) before dusk, and at dusk it became "fairly" calm, which tells us that before dusk the sea was not even "fairly" calm.
* On 2 December there was "a strong south wind at 18 m (35 kts)" and visibility was "short owing to heavy drizzle" (The Pearl Harbor Papers, p. 188) 35 kts is 40 mph, and visibility was "short." But that's not all. Chigusa goes on to tell us that his ship reached a 47-degree of roll to one side and that he'd never experienced anything like that before: "[the roll] was the largest roll since leaving Hitokappu Bay, and of course I hadn't experienced anything like it ever before." (The Pearl Harbor Papers, p. 188)
So an admiral had never seen a ship roll the way his ship did in that weather, and this was the same day that Grogan discerned that the ships he was monitoring were "bunched up." My, my, what a coincidence.
* On 1 December "the roll of our ship was severe" and winds were at 26-28 kts, or 30-32 mph. (The Pearl Harbor Papers, p. 188)
Last edited: