Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

A statement like that makes me wonder about Halseys stars.

They were short on patrol craft. The best study called for 150 B-17s to do a thorough 360 search. There weren't that many in the whole US inventory. However, when Kimmel found out he didn't have enough planes for the best search he decided on ... you guessed, it ... no search. :eek:
 
The following people either claimed to have direct knowledge of Japanese intercepts or other intelligence that indicated an attack on Pearl Harbor or claimed to have been told of the existence of such intelligence by someone who had personally seen/heard/read it. And, surprisingly, this is not a complete list.

  • Colonel Carlton Ketchum
  • Admiral James Stahlman, longtime friend of Secretary of the Navy Frank Knox
  • Lieutenant Ellsworth Hosmer, Navy intelligence officer
  • Seaman Robert Ogg, who went on to become a successful businessman
  • Radio Operator Leslie Grogan
  • Victor Bentick, chairman of England's Joint Intelligence Committee in 1941
  • Julian Ridsdale, member of the Joint Intelligence Committee
  • Commander Malcolm Burnett, who served in the British FECB
  • Commander Raymond Mortimer, FECB
  • Joseph Leib, journalist and friend of Secretary of State Cordell Hull
  • General Albert Wedemeyer
  • General Elliott Thorpe
  • John Burns, head of the Honolulu Police Department's (HPD) Espionage Bureau in 1941, and later a governor of Hawaii (he gave his account in a series of taped interviews at the University of Hawaii after he knew he was dying)
  • William Kaina, detective in the HPD Espionage Bureau in 1941
  • William Casey, OSS member in WW II and later a CIA director
  • Captain Johan Ranneft, who went on to become an admiral in the Dutch Navy
  • Martin Dies, congressman and chairman of the House Un-American Activities in 1941
  • Richard Sorge, Soviet spy in Japan in 1941
  • Don Smith, director of the Red Cross War Services office in 1941 (via his daughter, Helen Hamman, who revealed her father's account in the 1990s when she saw news reports of efforts by the Kimmel family to clear Admiral Kimmel's name)
To accept the traditional version of the Pearl Harbor disaster, you'd have to believe that every single one of these people was lying. (The "mistaken" option just isn't plausible. Either they knew/were informed that Pearl Harbor was going to be attacked or they did not know or were not so informed. Only in the case of Grogan could one perhaps argue that he was honestly mistaken, although Jacobsen, perhaps sensing the weakness of his attack on Grogan's account, clearly implies that Grogan may have just made up the whole story.)
 
Last edited:
That's a beautiful Gish gallop you've laid out there. Do you have any evidence to suggest that these people had direct knowledge of the impending attack other than "because I said so"?
 
To accept the traditional version of the Pearl Harbor disaster, you'd have to believe that every single one of these people was lying. (The "mistaken" option just isn't plausible. Either they knew/were informed that Pearl Harbor was going to be attacked or they did not know or were not so informed. Only in the case of Grogan could one perhaps argue that he was honestly mistaken, although Jacobsen, perhaps sensing the weakness of his attack on Grogan's account, clearly implies that Grogan may have just made up the whole story.)

Okay, they were lying.
 
The following people either claimed to have direct knowledge of Japanese intercepts or other intelligence that indicated an attack on Pearl Harbor or claimed to have been told of the existence of such intelligence by someone who had personally seen/heard/read it. And, surprisingly, this is not a complete list.

  • Colonel Carlton Ketchum
  • Admiral James Stahlman, longtime friend of Secretary of the Navy Frank Knox
  • Lieutenant Ellsworth Hosmer, Navy intelligence officer
  • Seaman Robert Ogg, who went on to become a successful businessman
  • Radio Operator Leslie Grogan
  • Victor Bentick, chairman of England's Joint Intelligence Committee in 1941
  • Julian Ridsdale, member of the Joint Intelligence Committee
  • Commander Malcolm Burnett, who served in the British FECB
  • Commander Raymond Mortimer, FECB
  • Joseph Leib, journalist and friend of Secretary of State Cordell Hull
  • General Albert Wedemeyer
  • General Elliott Thorpe
  • John Burns, head of the Honolulu Police Department's (HPD) Espionage Bureau in 1941, and later a governor of Hawaii (he gave his account in a series of taped interviews at the University of Hawaii after he knew he was dying)
  • William Kaina, detective in the HPD Espionage Bureau in 1941
  • William Casey, OSS member in WW II and later a CIA director
  • Captain Johan Ranneft, who went on to become an admiral in the Dutch Navy
  • Martin Dies, congressman and chairman of the House Un-American Activities in 1941
  • Richard Sorge, Soviet spy in Japan in 1941
  • Don Smith, director of the Red Cross War Services office in 1941 (via his daughter, Helen Hamman, who revealed her father's account in the 1990s when she saw news reports of efforts by the Kimmel family to clear Admiral Kimmel's name)
To accept the traditional version of the Pearl Harbor disaster, you'd have to believe that every single one of these people was lying. (The "mistaken" option just isn't plausible. Either they knew/were informed that Pearl Harbor was going to be attacked or they did not know or were not so informed. Only in the case of Grogan could one perhaps argue that he was honestly mistaken, although Jacobsen, perhaps sensing the weakness of his attack on Grogan's account, clearly implies that Grogan may have just made up the whole story.)

Why is "mistaken" impossible?

We know that the Japanese were engaging in a signals deception plan. We know how they were doing it, and we have the records of them doing so. We have the ships logs from the KB - which show rad silence for the approach. At the end of WWII, your nation occupied Japan and seized that countries archives - unless you are prepared to assert that either the Japanese were altering their records in the event that they would be captured (and managing to keep the story straight over the years), or that some US servicemen decided to alter the records you really can't reconcile the CT you're putting out with the accepted history.

To accept the CT version of events you have to accept that the POTUS, the Secretaries of State, War and the Navy, plus the Army and Navy Chiefs decided to commit treason - and allowing a foreign power to attack you when you know its coming and where it will strike surely meets the criteria - and managed to encourage several hundred people to go along with it for the good of the nation, and who then talked about to a wide range of people who don't need to be brought into the conspiracy (because they aren't involved in the intelligence trade in the Pacific Theatre) such as a journalist, the FBI, local Law Enforcement, the Red Cross, the head of the House Un-American Activities Committee and a foreign military attache, while convincing them to keep quiet. Oh, and then you've got the folks who had NOTHING to fear from US gov't reprisals such as the Soviet agent you purport to have knowledge in addition to several UK int types (who missed the build ups for Hong Kong and Singapore)?

Yeah, I think that the people on you list were lying, or mistaken. In order for the CT to work there would need to be a cast of thousands, and some way to ensure that none of them spoke, got an attack of conscience, etc. There's an old saying, "Three people can keep a secret if two them are dead."
 
The following people either claimed to have direct knowledge of Japanese intercepts or other intelligence that indicated an attack on Pearl Harbor or claimed to have been told of the existence of such intelligence by someone who had personally seen/heard/read it. And, surprisingly, this is not a complete list.

  • Colonel Carlton Ketchum
  • Admiral James Stahlman, longtime friend of Secretary of the Navy Frank Knox
  • Lieutenant Ellsworth Hosmer, Navy intelligence officer
  • Seaman Robert Ogg, who went on to become a successful businessman
  • Radio Operator Leslie Grogan
  • Victor Bentick, chairman of England's Joint Intelligence Committee in 1941
  • Julian Ridsdale, member of the Joint Intelligence Committee
  • Commander Malcolm Burnett, who served in the British FECB
  • Commander Raymond Mortimer, FECB
  • Joseph Leib, journalist and friend of Secretary of State Cordell Hull
  • General Albert Wedemeyer
  • General Elliott Thorpe
  • John Burns, head of the Honolulu Police Department's (HPD) Espionage Bureau in 1941, and later a governor of Hawaii (he gave his account in a series of taped interviews at the University of Hawaii after he knew he was dying)
  • William Kaina, detective in the HPD Espionage Bureau in 1941
  • William Casey, OSS member in WW II and later a CIA director
  • Captain Johan Ranneft, who went on to become an admiral in the Dutch Navy
  • Martin Dies, congressman and chairman of the House Un-American Activities in 1941
  • Richard Sorge, Soviet spy in Japan in 1941
  • Don Smith, director of the Red Cross War Services office in 1941 (via his daughter, Helen Hamman, who revealed her father's account in the 1990s when she saw news reports of efforts by the Kimmel family to clear Admiral Kimmel's name)
To accept the traditional version of the Pearl Harbor disaster, you'd have to believe that every single one of these people was lying. (The "mistaken" option just isn't plausible. Either they knew/were informed that Pearl Harbor was going to be attacked or they did not know or were not so informed. Only in the case of Grogan could one perhaps argue that he was honestly mistaken, although Jacobsen, perhaps sensing the weakness of his attack on Grogan's account, clearly implies that Grogan may have just made up the whole story.)

No we don't have to believe that these people were lying because you have to date not supplied one contemporary document that proves any of these people actually had such knowledge. All you've done is provide second and third hand accounts brought forth decades later that may have been mangled out of all recognition.

The one name on that list that caught my eye was Richard Sorge, again where is the source that says he knew specifically about the Pearl Harbor attack? He certainly knew that the Japanese had turned their attention to the Pacific and weren't threatening the USSR but he was at no time privy to any source that had access to detailed Japanese war plans.

For that matter even if he did somehow know you would then have to show that Stalin passed this information along.
 
It's pretty clear that Bob is not driven by a quest for historical accuracy, but by a burning hatred for FDR.
 
The following people either claimed to have direct knowledge of Japanese intercepts or other intelligence that indicated an attack on Pearl Harbor or claimed to have been told of the existence of such intelligence by someone who had personally seen/heard/read it. And, surprisingly, this is not a complete list.

  • Colonel Carlton Ketchum
  • Admiral James Stahlman, longtime friend of Secretary of the Navy Frank Knox
  • Lieutenant Ellsworth Hosmer, Navy intelligence officer
  • Seaman Robert Ogg, who went on to become a successful businessman
  • Radio Operator Leslie Grogan
  • Victor Bentick, chairman of England's Joint Intelligence Committee in 1941
  • Julian Ridsdale, member of the Joint Intelligence Committee
  • Commander Malcolm Burnett, who served in the British FECB
  • Commander Raymond Mortimer, FECB
  • Joseph Leib, journalist and friend of Secretary of State Cordell Hull
  • General Albert Wedemeyer
  • General Elliott Thorpe
  • John Burns, head of the Honolulu Police Department's (HPD) Espionage Bureau in 1941, and later a governor of Hawaii (he gave his account in a series of taped interviews at the University of Hawaii after he knew he was dying)
  • William Kaina, detective in the HPD Espionage Bureau in 1941
  • William Casey, OSS member in WW II and later a CIA director
  • Captain Johan Ranneft, who went on to become an admiral in the Dutch Navy
  • Martin Dies, congressman and chairman of the House Un-American Activities in 1941
  • Richard Sorge, Soviet spy in Japan in 1941
  • Don Smith, director of the Red Cross War Services office in 1941 (via his daughter, Helen Hamman, who revealed her father's account in the 1990s when she saw news reports of efforts by the Kimmel family to clear Admiral Kimmel's name)
To accept the traditional version of the Pearl Harbor disaster, you'd have to believe that every single one of these people was lying. (The "mistaken" option just isn't plausible. Either they knew/were informed that Pearl Harbor was going to be attacked or they did not know or were not so informed. Only in the case of Grogan could one perhaps argue that he was honestly mistaken, although Jacobsen, perhaps sensing the weakness of his attack on Grogan's account, clearly implies that Grogan may have just made up the whole story.)

I believe somebodies lying.
 
It's pretty clear that Bob is not driven by a quest for historical accuracy, but by a burning hatred for FDR.

That's the part I don't understand. As I've said before, you can disagree with much of what FDR did on the domestic front without thinking he was a murderous thug who let 2000+ of his follow citizens die. It defies all reason.
 
That's the part I don't understand. As I've said before, you can disagree with much of what FDR did on the domestic front without thinking he was a murderous thug who let 2000+ of his follow citizens die. It defies all reason.

Maybe so, but we saw the same thing with Obama in 2012. Unreasoning, unthinking hatred for a person based solely on their politics.
 
No we don't have to believe that these people were lying because you have to date not supplied one contemporary document that proves any of these people actually had such knowledge. All you've done is provide second and third hand accounts brought forth decades later that may have been mangled out of all recognition.

In other words, you've never read a single scholarly work that challenges the traditional Pearl Harbor story. The accounts given by the people on the list have been documented in a number of scholarly revisionist works, but obviously you haven't read a single one of them. You could start with these three:

* George Victor, The Pearl Harbor Myth: Rethinking the Unthinkable
* John Toland, Infamy: Pearl Harbor and Its Aftermath
* Steven Sniegoski, "The Case for Pearl Harbor Revisionism," The Occidental Quarterly, Winter 2001, pp. 5-46.

All three scholars have published other works on American history and hold advanced degrees. Dr. Sniegoski's paper is available here:

http://home.comcast.net/~transparentcabal/pearlharbor.pdf

Dr. Victor's book is available via Google Books here:

http://books.google.com/books?id=n-mZwhST5KQC

The one name on that list that caught my eye was Richard Sorge, again where is the source that says he knew specifically about the Pearl Harbor attack? He certainly knew that the Japanese had turned their attention to the Pacific and weren't threatening the USSR but he was at no time privy to any source that had access to detailed Japanese war plans. For that matter even if he did somehow know you would then have to show that Stalin passed this information along.

Sorge knew that Pearl Harbor would be attacked, and he stated that his Moscow superiors advised him that they had passed along this intel to the Americans. Among other sources, you can find this discussed in Admiral Theobald's book The Final Secret of Pearl Harbor (New York: Devin-Adair, 1954), pp. 78–80.
 
That's the part I don't understand. As I've said before, you can disagree with much of what FDR did on the domestic front without thinking he was a murderous thug who let 2000+ of his follow citizens die. It defies all reason.

You might want to sign up for a logic and critical thinking course, not to mention a couple history courses. FDR would not be the first leader of a country to sacrifice a few thousand people for what he viewed as a necessary greater good. And it is downright sophomoric logic to argue that to suggest that FDR did this automatically qualifies as "defying all reason."

Many people believe that FDR allowed the Japanese to attack Pearl Harbor because they've concluded that there's a considerable amount of credible evidence that supports this theory. Quite a few of the people who believe this theory also believe that FDR did the right thing in allowing the attack, but they condemn him for scapegoating Kimmel and Short. Others who believe the theory believe that FDR made a huge mistake in provoking war with Japan, and they also condemn him for scapegoating Kimmel and Short.

Another odd argument that I keep seeing is that revisionist arguments are driven by "hatred of FDR," "blind hatred," etc. This is just a surreal, silly argument. Toland praised FDR profusely for his domestic policies and for his leadership qualities, but he also believed that FDR's policy toward Japan and allowing Pearl Harbor to be attacked were terrible mistakes. I don't know what Stinnett told Gawdzilla when they spoke, but I do know that in his book Day of Deceit, Stinnett makes it clear that he believes FDR did the right thing in allowing Pearl Harbor to be attacked. I have also heard radio interviews where Stinnett had nice things to say about FDR (along with some criticisms). Admiral James Richardson, who was fired by FDR, defended FDR's decision to allow Pearl Harbor to be attacked and urged those who wanted to expose the truth to just leave it alone.

So, really, you guys should stop embarrassing yourselves with these silly polemics about "FDR haters," "blind hatred of FDR," etc., etc.

Now, are some revisionists also conservatives who dislike FDR's domestic policies? Sure, you bet. But that does not mean their arguments about Pearl Harbor are invalid. It only shows your own ardent bias and closed mindedness when you summarily reject an author's arguments just because he's an FDR critic.

Finally, a correction to my list: James Stahlman was not an admiral. He was a reserve officer who served as a Navy intelligence officer during the war. And, as mentioned, he was a longtime friend of Secretary of the Navy Frank Knox.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom