Border Reiver
Philosopher
- Joined
- Sep 6, 2011
- Messages
- 6,726
Your description of who was told and under what circumstances is a silly strawman. A "motley collection"? Really? Do you know who Captain Ranneft was and the relationship he had with the U.S. Navy? And since when do an FBI Agent in Charge and the Director of the Red Cross War Services warrant the label of "motley"? Just more silly denialism.
If you'd dare yourself to take off your denialist blinders and do a little homework, you'd know exactly why ONI shared that info with Ranneft, how Shivers would have known about the attack, and why FDR would have informed Smith (he then demanded that Smith not tell anyone what he'd been told).
Ant's assessment of those people allegedly told by FDR or by folks in the know at ONI are pretty much spot on - motley, not because these are people who you might expect to be in motely, but rather a very diseparate group.
If you need a surpirse attack to be perpetrated against you, and you know that it's coming, and you've decided that intercepting that attack prior to it doing severe damage to your major warfighting assets you don't go telling people that they should prepare for it by:
a. Stocking up on medical supplies 10 months in advance of the attack (and coincidentally in advance of your enemy's commencement of PLANNING the attack);
b. Telling the FBI Agent In Charge in Hawaii, which would mean that Mr. Hoover knew;
c. Telling the Head of the Committee on Un-American Activities, I mean sure it's his job to look into espionage against the country, and it would be his job to bring impeachment proceedings to the House if he knew that the President was letting a major attack go forward against US defence assets, but hey it'll get the country involved in a two front war, and that usually goes so well for the country involved;
d. Telling an intelligence official of a foreign power - but keeping said official in the dark about the attack on his own country's colony; and
e. Apparently telling every second politician in Washington DC that Japan was coming to attack PH - I mean you can trust those guys not to try and score cheap political points by revealing that the attack is coming and we know the date, time, etc, or that the guy at the top knew and let it happen for his own purposes.
This is the worst conspiracy ever - at the rate you keep adding alleged conspirators the pre-war population of the US (less Charles Lindberg, Kimmel and Short) will have been in on it, along with Dolphie, Hirohito, Churchill, MacKenzie-King and a few others.