Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Your description of who was told and under what circumstances is a silly strawman. A "motley collection"? Really? Do you know who Captain Ranneft was and the relationship he had with the U.S. Navy? And since when do an FBI Agent in Charge and the Director of the Red Cross War Services warrant the label of "motley"? Just more silly denialism.

If you'd dare yourself to take off your denialist blinders and do a little homework, you'd know exactly why ONI shared that info with Ranneft, how Shivers would have known about the attack, and why FDR would have informed Smith (he then demanded that Smith not tell anyone what he'd been told).

Ant's assessment of those people allegedly told by FDR or by folks in the know at ONI are pretty much spot on - motley, not because these are people who you might expect to be in motely, but rather a very diseparate group.

If you need a surpirse attack to be perpetrated against you, and you know that it's coming, and you've decided that intercepting that attack prior to it doing severe damage to your major warfighting assets you don't go telling people that they should prepare for it by:

a. Stocking up on medical supplies 10 months in advance of the attack (and coincidentally in advance of your enemy's commencement of PLANNING the attack);
b. Telling the FBI Agent In Charge in Hawaii, which would mean that Mr. Hoover knew;
c. Telling the Head of the Committee on Un-American Activities, I mean sure it's his job to look into espionage against the country, and it would be his job to bring impeachment proceedings to the House if he knew that the President was letting a major attack go forward against US defence assets, but hey it'll get the country involved in a two front war, and that usually goes so well for the country involved;
d. Telling an intelligence official of a foreign power - but keeping said official in the dark about the attack on his own country's colony; and
e. Apparently telling every second politician in Washington DC that Japan was coming to attack PH - I mean you can trust those guys not to try and score cheap political points by revealing that the attack is coming and we know the date, time, etc, or that the guy at the top knew and let it happen for his own purposes.

This is the worst conspiracy ever - at the rate you keep adding alleged conspirators the pre-war population of the US (less Charles Lindberg, Kimmel and Short) will have been in on it, along with Dolphie, Hirohito, Churchill, MacKenzie-King and a few others.
 
Not only do we have the accounts of a number of American and Allied military personnel that KB transmissions were heard and tracked, we also have supporting accounts from non-military personnel, such as:

* Joseph Leib, a New Deal Democrat, journalist, and friend of Secretary of State Cordell Hull. Leib said Hull told him they had Japanese intercepts that revealed a coming attack on Pearl Harbor.

* Don C. Smith, head of the Red Cross War Service. His account was relayed by his daughter, Helen Hamman, in the 1990s when she heard about Kimmel family efforts to clear Admiral Kimmel's name. According to the daughter, Smith told her that shortly before the attack FDR met with him, told him that Pearl Harbor was about to be attacked, that they had to let the Japanese surprise Pearl Harbor to get the American people to support entering the war, and that Smith was to transfer extra supplies and personnel to Hawaii to prepare for the aftermath. Dr. Sniegoski notes that:

Borquist was able to confirm the basics of Hamman’s story--the Red Cross did quietly send large quantities of medical supplies and experienced medical personnel to Hawaii shortly before December 7, 1941. ("The Case for Pearl Harbor Revisionism," The Occidental Quarterly, Winter 2001, p. 35, http://home.comcast.net/~transparentcabal/pearlharbor.pdf)​

* John Burns, head of the Honolulu Police Department's Espionage Bureau. Burns reported that the FBI Agent in Charge in Honolulu, Robert Shivers, told him on 12/3 that the Japanese would attack Hawaii by the end of the week. By the way, Burns went on to become governor of Hawaii, and he gave his account after he knew he was dying. In addition, Burns' account was corroborated in 1982 by one of his deputies (William Kaina). Burns' account is lent further credence by the account of Colonel Carlton Ketchum.

* Martin Dies, senior Democratic congressman from Texas. Dies chaired the House Un-American Activities Committee. In the course of investigating Japanese espionage, Dies' committee came into possession of a Japanese military map that indicated plans for an attack on Pearl Harbor. When Dies called Secretary Hull, Hull asked him to keep quiet about the document and to let the president handle matter because this was a delicate matter of national security. Dies said officials from the State Department, the Navy, and the Army came to examine the map. Dies revealed this information in 1963 in his memoir. He expressed frustration at the failure to act on the information he provided to the White House:

I have never been able to understand why our government did not take the necessary precautions to protect our fleet from destruction after our committee had furnished such precise information on the proposed attack. (Martin Dies Story, New York: Bookmailer, 1963, p. 165)​

But, nah, according to traditionalists, ALL of these people were just lying--they just made it up. In fact, according to our resident "expert," all of this evidence is "nothing." So said the emperor's lackeys when the young boy noted that the emperor wasn't wearing any clothes.

Oh, but we're told that there are Japanese documents that claim that radio silence was maintained. Well, we also have a Dutch document that says that shortly before Pearl Harbor the U.S. Navy's Office of Naval Intelligence (ONI) knew there were Japanese naval ships near Hawaii: I refer to the official diary of Captain Johan Ranneft of the Dutch Navy in which Ranneft says that ONI personnel informed him shortly before the attack that there was a Japanese naval force a few hundred miles from Pearl Harbor. But, humm, let me guess: We're supposed to believe the Japanese documents and reject Captain Ranneft's official diary. Yeah, and never mind all the lies the Japanese were caught telling about the war.

A Leib said, Hull said?


Obviously the head of the Red Cross is someone the president would confide in.

The Japanese were communists?
 
A Leib said, Hull said?

So Leib was lying?

Obviously the head of the Red Cross is someone the president would confide in.

If he wanted to have extra medical supplies and personnel moved to Hawaii in advance, yes. We have several accounts of FDR saying that he had to allow a surprise attack in order to galvanize the public.

The Japanese were communists?

Uh, the House Un-American Activities Committee did not just investigate communists; they investigated anyone they thought posed a threat to American internal security. So Dies was lying too?

As for the argument, made by someone else, that it seems odd that the conspirators would have given information to Ranneft, Burns, and Smith about the upcoming attack, a few points:

* Who said the ONI officers who allowed Ranneft to look at the tracking of the KB were part of the conspiracy? It's entirely possible, in fact probable, that those officers were not part of the plot, and that they simply felt comfortable sharing the info with Ranneft given their relationship with him and given that they knew that he knew that it was classified info and they trusted him not to reveal it (he didn't reveal it until many years later).

In the Iran-Contra conspiracy, only a relatively small number of people knew all that was being done and why. The others who were involved were just loyal military and civilian personnel who did their jobs, who knew they were not supposed to divulge classified information to uncleared people, and who did not give the matter much thought beyond that. As in any such plot, a few of those personnel suspected what was going on but said nothing because they agreed with what was being done. And, as was brought out in the Iran-Contra hearings, if Oliver North had succeeded in shredding just one more particular document, the plot may very well have remained hidden and the press stories would have been made to look like unfounded rumors and speculation.

* As for Burns' account (that FBI SAIC Shivers told him Hawaii would be attacked in a few days), it is supported by a number of related accounts that claim that Hoover knew the attack was coming, which is not one bit surprising given Hoover's intelligence sources and access.

* By all accounts, Don Smith was an utterly honest, reliable man. It's plausible that Smith pressed FDR on why he was ordering him to send extra supplies and personnel to Hawaii, and that FDR judged that he could trust Smith to honor his directive not to reveal the info to anyone. Or, it's also plausible that FDR made this judgment at the outset and decided to explain to Smith the reason for the order. Smith's daughter says that when Smith strongly objected to allowing the attack to occur, FDR repeated his argument that it was necessary in order to get the American people to support America's entry into the war. Smith shared the story later with his daughter, who in turn only revealed in the 1990s when she saw news stories about the Kimmel family's efforts to clear Admiral Kimmel's name. Said the daughter,

. . . Shortly before the attack in 1941 President Roosevelt called him [Smith] to the White House for a meeting concerning a Top Secret matter. At this meeting the President advised my father that his intelligence staff had informed him of a pending attack on Pearl Harbor, by the Japanese. He anticipated many casualties and much loss, he instructed my father to send workers and supplies to a holding area at a P.O.E. [port of entry] on the West Coast where they would await further orders to ship out, no destination was to be revealed. He left no doubt in my father's mind that none of the Naval and Military officials in Hawaii were to be informed and he was not to advise the Red Cross officers who were already stationed in the area. When he protested to the President, President Roosevelt told him that the American people would never agree to enter the war in Europe unless they were attacked within their own borders.

. . . He [Smith] was privy to Top Secret operations and worked directly with all of our outstanding leaders. He followed the orders of his President and spent many later years contemplating this action which he considered ethically and morally wrong.​

Many people believe this has the strong ring of truth, and they note that it has been confirmed that extra medical supplies and personnel were shipped to Hawaii shortly before the attack.
 
As for the Hawiian Red Cross, they knew war was coming. Everybody who paid attention knew war was coming. Except Kimmel and Short, of course. So stocking up before the war comes to have supplies "just in case" and to help out with the flow of wounded heading back Stateside makes sense. ("makes sense" is something that you have trouble with, living in your VAR as you do.)
 
If he wanted to have extra medical supplies and personnel moved to Hawaii in advance, yes.

And it's your contention that there's no way they could have moved extra medical supplies to a port on the West Coast of the US even though the Pacific was a tense area where tensions were only increasing, unless the President directly informed the head of the Red Cross that he knew an attack on Pearl Harbor was coming and that he wanted it to happen?

* Who said the ONI officers who allowed Ranneft to look at the tracking of the KB were part of the conspiracy? It's entirely possible, in fact probable, that those officers were not part of the plot, and that they simply felt comfortable sharing the info with Ranneft given their relationship with him and given that they knew that he knew that it was classified info and they trusted him not to reveal it (he didn't reveal it until many years later).

And when these ONI officers reported the Japanese carriers they were tracking to their superiors, and nothing was done (and it was obvious after the attack that nothing was done), they just shrugged their shoulders and kept the whole thing to themselves forever afterward, leaving the only evidence that this ever happened in the diary of a Dutch naval officer who didn't himself tell anyone until many years after the fact?

* As for Burns' account (that FBI SAIC Shivers told him Hawaii would be attacked in a few days), it is supported by a number of related accounts that claim that Hoover knew the attack was coming, which is not one bit surprising given Hoover's intelligence sources and access.

Which doesn't answer the question of why he was told in the first place. Even assuming Hoover knew the attack was coming, what was telling Shivers supposed to accomplish?

* By all accounts, Don Smith was an utterly honest, reliable man.

Which may be why he never actually told any stories like the one his daughter started telling after his death.

It's plausible that Smith pressed FDR on why he was ordering him to send extra supplies and personnel to Hawaii,

Except in the daughter's account that you reproduced, unless FDR blabbed about the attack up front, Smith wouldn't have known that the extra supplies and personnel were for Hawaii at all. She says he was told "to send workers and supplies to a holding area at a P.O.E. [port of entry] on the West Coast where they would await further orders to ship out, no destination was to be revealed".

Again, is it your argument that if FDR had merely said, "Relations with the Japanese are getting worse, so we want to stockpile a bunch of supplies and personnel on the West Coast, ready to ship out just in case they're needed somewhere" (or even "Relations with the Japanese are getting worse, so we want to stockpile a bunch of supplies and personnel at our main forward base in the Territory of Hawaii,, ready to ship out just in case they're needed somewhere") that Smith wouldn't have done it? That Smith had to be told specifically that the supplies and personnel were for an attack on Pearl Harbor that FDR knew about and wanted Smith to keep quiet about?

Or, it's also plausible that FDR made this judgment at the outset and decided to explain to Smith the reason for the order.

Why on Earth do you find that "plausible"?
 
Which may be why he never actually told any stories like the one his daughter started telling after his death.

It's one of the ongoing problem with BTF's theory; all he can come up with are second and third hand accounts of these dramatic warnings. Not one letter or diary from the time that indicates the parties involved were aware of the attack prior to it happening. You would think with Roosevelt apparently telling all and sundry about the conspiracy there would be at least one contemporary account...
 
It's one of the ongoing problem with BTF's theory; all he can come up with are second and third hand accounts of these dramatic warnings. Not one letter or diary from the time that indicates the parties involved were aware of the attack prior to it happening. You would think with Roosevelt apparently telling all and sundry about the conspiracy there would be at least one contemporary account...

And the further problem that these "sources" have trotted out before and debunked. Nothing new here at all, which makes this whole thread just a practice round for me. Not a single experience point gained in, what, fifty pages now? At least it exercises the muscle that pulls my ears together. :)
 
Regarding Admiral Kimmel's performance, Admiral Halsey said the following:

I think everyone present knew that the disaster would be formally investigated, but I'll take my oath that not one of us would have guessed that the blame would fall on Kimmel, because not one of us thought he deserved it—any part of it. I want to emphasize my next statement. In all my experience, I have never known a Commander in Chief of any United States Fleet who worked harder, and under more adverse circumstances, to increase its efficiency and to prepare it for war; further, I know of no officer who might have been in command at that time who could have done more than Kimmel did. I also want to repeat and reemphasize the answer I made when the Roberts Commission asked me how I happened to be ready for the Japanese attack. I told them, ‘Because of one man: Admiral Kimmel.’" (William F. Halsey, Admiral Halsey's Story, New York: McGraw Hill, 1947, p. 82)​

Concerning Kimmel's decision not to use his few dozen available aircraft for reconnaissance without specific threat information but to save them for future combat operations, Halsey said,

Any admiral worth his stars would have made the same choice. (Admiral Halsey's Story, p. 71)​

Admiral William Standley, a former CNO and a member of the Roberts Commission, had this to say about Kimmel's performance:

I knew from first hand experience the shortcomings of our base at Pearl Harbor, for which . . . Kimmel was in no way responsible. . . .

I can’t help regretting that Admiral Kimmel had to go. I have never seen the Fleet in a higher state of efficiency than was evidenced during the course of our investigations at Pearl Harbor. . . . (Admiral Ambassador to Russia, New York: Regnery, 1955, pp. 82-83, emphasis added)​

Finally, regarding the original bomb plot message, Admiral David Richardson notes the following:

The bomb plot message was sent September 24th, 1941 to the Japanese consul-general in Honolulu. It divided Pearl Harbor into five areas, and specified that reports were to be made regarding identity of ships within each area, including those at anchor, those that were moored and those moored alongside others. This information was of a specificity that made plain its purpose: planning for an air attack. . . .

. . . important indicator of interest in detailed information needed by Japan to plan air assaults against ships in port there. (http://www.kimmelfamily.net/ERK02.htm)​
 
Last edited:
Bob, how do you explain the fact that Yamamoto guaranteed a "big bag" and got the IGHQ accept the attack based on Kimmel's allowing the US Fleet to go on "banker's hours"?

And the bomb plot is irrelevant to the attack, we've been over that.
 
The "Bomb Plot" messages are useless as a planning tool for the attack itself.

The messages would have told IGHQ planners what was in port and in what area of the harbour - about 2 days before the attack goes in. Since the pilots were the ones going in to do the attack, their canopies combined with a Mk1 eyeball would give better targetting information than the messages.

The only way those messages could have been used tactical purposes would be if:

a. The message contained precise map co-ordinates for each ship (and ID'd said ship);
b. The ships remained in the same location; and
c. The Japanese were planning to use long range gunfire or an ICBM where there is a requirement to know precisely where the target is in order to hit it.

Since none of those criteria have been met, the messages were only valuable as a means of determining if, several days before the attack, there were sufficient capital ships in port to make the attack worthwhile.
 
CTers fixate on the ex post facto term "bomb plot" to the exclusion of any taint of reality in the matter.

To go mildly off-topic, CTs in general are based on post facto reasoning. It's Monday morning quarterbacking taken to its logical extreme. Combined, of course, with a healthy dose of confirmation bias and backwards reasoning.
 
To go mildly off-topic, CTs in general are based on post facto reasoning. It's Monday morning quarterbacking taken to its logical extreme. Combined, of course, with a healthy dose of confirmation bias and backwards reasoning.

To an extent I agree. But I believe they're front-loaded with prejudices that make them seek out these things.
 
I've taken more time than this really deserves and done up a little chart showing who, according to Bob knew, or who at least had enough information to make life extremely uncomfortable during the various Courts of Inquiry, Investigations and Congressional Hearings and has been mentioned in this thread.

It isn't exhaustive, and I've probably missed a couple of people, but when you start to realize just how many people are supposed to have known about the "secret" that FDR just Let it Happen, or even Made it Happen, and how none of them came forward until generally 20 or more years after the fact, you start to get a rough idea just how ludicrous the idea is that a 'secret' of this magnitude could have been kept secret. Especially if you stop to consider that this doesn't include the hundreds of clerks, signallers, etc who would have had some involvement, and the foreign miltary folks who would have had exactly 0 to fear from saying rather publically that PH wasn't a masterpiece of deception and military art.
 

Attachments

Concerning Kimmel's decision not to use his few dozen available aircraft for reconnaissance without specific threat information but to save them for future combat operations, Halsey said,

Any admiral worth his stars would have made the same choice. (Admiral Halsey's Story, p. 71)

A statement like that makes me wonder about Halseys stars.
 
I've taken more time than this really deserves and done up a little chart showing who, according to Bob knew, or who at least had enough information to make life extremely uncomfortable during the various Courts of Inquiry, Investigations and Congressional Hearings and has been mentioned in this thread.

It isn't exhaustive, and I've probably missed a couple of people, but when you start to realize just how many people are supposed to have known about the "secret" that FDR just Let it Happen, or even Made it Happen, and how none of them came forward until generally 20 or more years after the fact, you start to get a rough idea just how ludicrous the idea is that a 'secret' of this magnitude could have been kept secret. Especially if you stop to consider that this doesn't include the hundreds of clerks, signallers, etc who would have had some involvement, and the foreign miltary folks who would have had exactly 0 to fear from saying rather publically that PH wasn't a masterpiece of deception and military art.

Cool! May I have a copy for the files?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom