Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Really? I'd never heard that. Interesting. Details please?

Commander Taylor was returned to the US on request of the Navy Department. His experience, in Scotland IIRC, with Fighter Intercept Control was considered very important. The Navy got first shot at him, but with the FIC was far enough along to start training he was loaned to the Army. However, the department that was building the system refused to give it over to the people who would actually use it. This foot dragging stopped after Dec. 7th.
 
For the benefit of newcomers and open-minded lurkers (and I have reason to believe there are a few such folks), it might be helpful to explain that there are basically two groups of "revisionists": revisionists and semi-revisionists.

Captain Ed Beach called himself a "semi-revisionist." He was more or less typical of your average semi-revisionist. He rejected most of the Roberts Commission's conclusions and agreed that there was a cover-up, but he also rejected the theory that FDR knew Pearl Harbor would be attacked, and he rejected certain other components of the revisionist case as well. Beach opined that the cover-up was to conceal the mistakes of FDR and other high officials in relation to Pearl Harbor.

Other semi-revisionists include the likes John Costello, Edwin Layton, Percy Greaves, and Michael Gannon--and also, by the way, Herbert Hoover. Costello came to believe that high officials covered up the fact that the East Wind Rains execute message was broadcast and intercepted a few days before the attack, but some other semi-revisionists believe the story that the EWR execute message was not broadcast and that a different execute message was confused for the EWR one.

Greaves came the closest to being a full-blown revisionist. His only major difference with revisionists was that he said he wasn't sure if FDR had advance knowledge of the attack.

Revisionists include scholars/naval experts like John Toland, George Victor, Admiral Robert Theobald, Admiral David Richardson (not to be confused with Kimmel's predecessor, Admiral James Richardson), Admiral Kimmel, John Flynn, George Morgenstern, Richard F. Hill, and Tom Kimmel.

Contrary to what some folks on this board continue to erroneously claim, revisionists hold a wide range of political views. Toland was a big FDR fan. So is Victor. Other revisionists are clearly conservatives (and there's nothing wrong with that, in my view). Also, some revisionists, such as Victor and Theobald, believe FDR did the right thing in allowing the Japanese to attack Pearl Harbor by surprise, while other revisionists, such as Toland and Flynn, opine that it was a horrible mistake.

My own political views are hard to label. I'm an Independent with conservative views on some issues, libertarian views on some issues, and left-of-center views on some issues. I couldn't care less about party affiliation. For example, I believe that, on balance, all things considered, America would have been better off if Al Gore had won the 2000 election. I also think we'd be better off if Hillary Clinton had been elected in 2008 instead of Obama. But in 2012 I was definitely pulling for Romney. In my view, the presidents who did the best job with the budget and the economy in the last 50 years were Kennedy, Clinton, and Reagan.
 
Last edited:
So why do you get so many things wrong? Just asking. Could it be that your agenda isn't to tell the fact but to snipe at FDR? Every conspiracy theory you've put forward has failed to stand up to scrutiny. That should be a hint to "newcomers and open-minded lurkers" that you don't care about the overt issues you purport to be concerned with.
 
Bob, Pearl was the advanced base for the U.S. Fleet. Strange that the Japanese would want to know what was going on there, isn't it?

So are you saying Kimmel and Short didn't need to be informed that Japanese intelligence was seeking info on Hawaii that could be used by the IJN in the event of war?

And drop the bomb plot nonsense, the information format was never used operationally, it was just a way to save money on telegrams.

What nonsense. You're seeing the Emperor's New Clothes again, and are also showing the one-sided, incomplete nature of your research. A number of senior intel officers disagreed with your dismissal of the bomb plot messages, and even some of MacArthur's staffers discerned that the BP messages indicated preparations for an air raid. As you should know, there was a huge battle over withholding those messages from Kimmel and Short, and it took Stark's personal intervention to keep the messages from being forwarded to Hawaii. But, yeah, right: they were meaningless. Of course.

And how can you not know that info from the BP messages were in fact used? They were used to train/brief some of the attack force members, and the most recent BP messages were the basis for Nagumo's final Go/No Go decision. Again, how can you not know this?

You might recall, or perhaps not, that for years the Japanese denied that the task force received any intel from the Japanese consulate in Hawaii. But of course that was later exposed as yet another lie. Yet, you continue to trust the Japanese claim that the attack force never broke radio silence, even though we have radio transmissions in hand that prove otherwise. (Oh, but of course, your argument is that radio transmissions from subs that were part of the "Hawaii Operation" attack force, that were operationally attached to the KB and working in support of it, and that were under Nagumo's overall command--well, nah, those don't count as breaking radio silence. Yeah, right.)

And the "long suppressed" memo was published in 1946.

Craig Shirley and several news stories say it was not disclosed until 2011. Whether it was disclosed in '46 or '11, the point is that it should have been forwarded to Kimmel and Short.
 
Last edited:
Craig Shirley and several news stories say it was not disclosed until 2011. Whether it was disclosed in '46 or '11, the point is that it should have been forwarded to Kimmel and Short.

Actually surely the point is that it demonstrates you have once again failed to do your research properly, instead of checking the actual records you just took the word of some second/third hand source. That seems to be the basic problem with your 'evidence'; its all A's account of what B says C told them about D decades after the event.
 
So are you saying Kimmel and Short didn't need to be informed that Japanese intelligence was seeking info on Hawaii that could be used by the IJN in the event of war?
You still haven't figured out that the "Bomb Plot" wasn't a bomb plot, have you? The Japanese had a secret technology on their airplanes that allowed for exact location of the ships in Pearl. It was called "glass". It was a passive system, undetectable by our technology and utterly reliable.
 
Actually surely the point is that it demonstrates you have once again failed to do your research properly, instead of checking the actual records you just took the word of some second/third hand source. That seems to be the basic problem with your 'evidence'; its all A's account of what B says C told them about D decades after the event.

He doesn't even know Yoshikawa wrote a book about this. :rolleyes:
 
So are you saying Kimmel and Short didn't need to be informed that Japanese intelligence was seeking info on Hawaii that could be used by the IJN in the event of war?

No, we are saying that senior military commanders make themselves aware of the general diplomatic situation as a matter of course and can apply their training and judgement as to the likelyhood of conflict and take appropriate measures. Kimmel did not, and Short only took very limited measures to deal with potential sabotage.

It would be negligence of a very high order for Kimmel and Short not to realize that a foreign power, already at war with a significant trading partner of the US and raising a very public outcry against the US not selling them the materiel they are using to prosecute said war would be using their intelligence service to gather information about the US. Indeed it would be negligence to presume that any foreign power would not be attempting to gain information about your military bases for possible use in times of war - either for friendly or not-so-friendly purposes.



What nonsense. You're seeing the Emperor's New Clothes again, and are also showing the one-sided, incomplete nature of your research. A number of senior intel officers disagreed with your dismissal of the bomb plot messages, and even some of MacArthur's staffers discerned that the BP messages indicated preparations for an air raid. As you should know, there was a huge battle over withholding those messages from Kimmel and Short, and it took Stark's personal intervention to keep the messages from being forwarded to Hawaii. But, yeah, right: they were meaningless. Of course.

So, Bob - this beign the text of the "Bomb Plot Message" from September - what useful information do you glean?

“Henceforth, we would like to have you make reports concerning vessels
along the following lines insofar as possible:

“1. The waters (of Pearl Harbor) are to be divided roughly into five
subareas (We have no objections to your abbreviating as much as you
like.)

Area A. Waters between Ford Island and the Arsenal.
Area B. Waters adjacent to the Island south and west of Ford Island.
(This area is on the opposite side of the Island from Area A.)
Area C. East Loch.
Area D. Middle Loch.
Area E. West Loch and the communication water routes.

2. With regard to warships and aircraft carriers, we would like to have
you report on those at anchor (these are not so important) tied up at
wharves, buoys and in docks. (Designate types and classes briefly. If
possible we would like to have you make mention of the fact when
there are two or more vessels along side the same wharf.)”

And given that the message of December 2 was:
"Striking Force telegram No. 994. Two battleships (Oklahoma, Nevada), 1 aircraft carrier (Enterprise) 2 heavy cruisers, 12 destroyers sailed. The force that sailed on 22 November returned to port. Ships at anchor Pearl Harbor p.m. 28 November were 6 battleships (2 Maryland class, 2 California class, 2 Pennsylvania class), 1 aircraft carrier (Lexington), 9 heavy cruisers (5 San Francisco class, 3 Chicago class, 1 Salt Lake class), 5 light cruisers (4 Honolulu class, 1 Omaha class)"

Note that this message was out of date almost immediately, and that all it served to do was alert the IJN that the fleet was generally in anchorage on a weekend. A reasonable commander would note that, given the war warning he had recieved a week earlier, that keeping to a set schedule allows an enemy to take advantage of said routine.

Now as to that infamous in-clear transmission of December 2 "Climb Mount Niitaka 1208" without the OP order for the attack (which was NOT sent by radio), the intelligence boys have a phrase that could mean anything, or nothing.

And how can you not know that info from the BP messages were in fact used? They were used to train/brief some of the attack force members, and the most recent BP messages were the basis for Nagumo's final Go/No Go decision. Again, how can you not know this?

You might recall, or perhaps not, that for years the Japanese denied that the task force received any intel from the Japanese consulate in Hawaii. But of course that was later exposed as yet another lie.

Because of course all intelligence agencies are open and honest brokers.

Yet, you continue to trust the Japanese claim that the attack force never broke radio silence, even though we have radio transmissions in hand that prove otherwise. (Oh, but of course, your argument is that radio transmissions from subs that were part of the "Hawaii Operation" attack force, that were operationally attached to the KB and working in support of it, and that were under Nagumo's overall command--well, nah, those don't count as breaking radio silence. Yeah, right.)

Actually, they don't count as breaking radio silence because they were made after the attack had begun - if the US didn't know they were under attack at that point, nothing would have helped....

Craig Shirley and several news stories say it was not disclosed until 2011. Whether it was disclosed in '46 or '11, the point is that it should have been forwarded to Kimmel and Short.

If Kimmel didn't take precautionary measures on receipt of the war warning, why would you presume that he would have done so on receipt of a message that says "They know what ships are in port."?
 
For those of you who are still not certain about the utility of the "Bomb Plot" information in a combat situation, take a look at what the IJN pilots might have seen.

Sorry, without the transcript of an old telegram telling me where the ships were, how would I know I had to bomb the warships in the photo? they might not have been the right American Fleet!
 
Last edited:
You still haven't figured out that the "Bomb Plot" wasn't a bomb plot, have you? The Japanese had a secret technology on their airplanes that allowed for exact location of the ships in Pearl. It was called "glass". It was a passive system, undetectable by our technology and utterly reliable.

Ah, but FDR secretly sold glass technology to Japan long before the war.
 
For the benefit of newcomers and open-minded lurkers (and I have reason to believe there are a few such folks), it might be helpful to explain that there are basically two groups of "revisionists": revisionists and semi-revisionists.

Captain Ed Beach called himself a "semi-revisionist." He was more or less typical of your average semi-revisionist. He rejected most of the Roberts Commission's conclusions and agreed that there was a cover-up, but he also rejected the theory that FDR knew Pearl Harbor would be attacked, and he rejected certain other components of the revisionist case as well. Beach opined that the cover-up was to conceal the mistakes of FDR and other high officials in relation to Pearl Harbor.

Other semi-revisionists include the likes John Costello, Edwin Layton, Percy Greaves, and Michael Gannon--and also, by the way, Herbert Hoover. Costello came to believe that high officials covered up the fact that the East Wind Rains execute message was broadcast and intercepted a few days before the attack, but some other semi-revisionists believe the story that the EWR execute message was not broadcast and that a different execute message was confused for the EWR one.

Greaves came the closest to being a full-blown revisionist. His only major difference with revisionists was that he said he wasn't sure if FDR had advance knowledge of the attack.

Revisionists include scholars/naval experts like John Toland, George Victor, Admiral Robert Theobald, Admiral David Richardson (not to be confused with Kimmel's predecessor, Admiral James Richardson), Admiral Kimmel, John Flynn, George Morgenstern, Richard F. Hill, and Tom Kimmel.

Contrary to what some folks on this board continue to erroneously claim, revisionists hold a wide range of political views. Toland was a big FDR fan. So is Victor. Other revisionists are clearly conservatives (and there's nothing wrong with that, in my view). Also, some revisionists, such as Victor and Theobald, believe FDR did the right thing in allowing the Japanese to attack Pearl Harbor by surprise, while other revisionists, such as Toland and Flynn, opine that it was a horrible mistake.

My own political views are hard to label. I'm an Independent with conservative views on some issues, libertarian views on some issues, and left-of-center views on some issues. I couldn't care less about party affiliation. For example, I believe that, on balance, all things considered, America would have been better off if Al Gore had won the 2000 election. I also think we'd be better off if Hillary Clinton had been elected in 2008 instead of Obama. But in 2012 I was definitely pulling for Romney. In my view, the presidents who did the best job with the budget and the economy in the last 50 years were Kennedy, Clinton, and Reagan.

There are pecans and filberts but they're both nuts.
 
Now as to that infamous in-clear transmission of December 2 "Climb Mount Niitaka 1208" without the OP order for the attack (which was NOT sent by radio), the intelligence boys have a phrase that could mean anything, or nothing.

And it's a total non-starter anyway, we didn't decode that message until after the war, when we went looking for it after the Japanese told us about it.

Other equally clear messages:

John has a long moustache.
The chair is against the wall.
The long, slow violins of Autumn.
 
In addition, we have record of radio transmissions between a Kido Butai carrier and some tankers on a tactical circuit. The traditionalists can only respond with the implausible claim that those transmissions were part of the IJN's radio deception effort. This is absurdly silly. Why on earth would the Japanese send out "fake" radio transmissions in which carriers conversed with tankers on a tactical circuit if they were trying to fool us into thinking that those carriers were in home waters?
 
And it's a total non-starter anyway, we didn't decode that message until after the war, when we went looking for it after the Japanese told us about it.

Other equally clear messages:

John has a long moustache.
The chair is against the wall.
The long, slow violins of Autumn.

Fill my heart with a montonous languor...
 
In addition, we have record of radio transmissions between a Kido Butai carrier and some tankers on a tactical circuit. The traditionalists can only respond with the implausible claim that those transmissions were part of the IJN's radio deception effort. This is absurdly silly. Why on earth would the Japanese send out "fake" radio transmissions in which carriers conversed with tankers on a tactical circuit if they were trying to fool us into thinking that those carriers were in home waters?

There was no need to talk to the tankers on the radio, they were in visual signalling range on the outbound trip until they split off to wait in safety for the return trip. So, once again you're lame assertions don't stand up when one has done the reading.
 
In addition, we have record of radio transmissions between a Kido Butai carrier and some tankers on a tactical circuit. The traditionalists can only respond with the implausible claim that those transmissions were part of the IJN's radio deception effort. This is absurdly silly. Why on earth would the Japanese send out "fake" radio transmissions in which carriers conversed with tankers on a tactical circuit if they were trying to fool us into thinking that those carriers were in home waters?


Do you even know what a "tactical circuit" is used for?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom