Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Two lengthy articles available online answer the most common criticisms of Kimmel and Short:

Dr. Steven Sniegoski, "The Case of Pearl Harbor Revisionism"
http://home.comcast.net/~transparentcabal/pearlharbor.pdf

Lt. Cmdr. Matthew Pettinger, Held to a Higher Standard
http://www.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a416925.pdf

And then there's Admiral Richardson's point-by-point reply to the Dorn Report:

http://www.kimmelfamily.net/ERK02.htm

Old soldiers telling war stories and polishing each others' medals.
 

FRom that link:

ERRORS ATTRIBUTABLE TO KIMMEL

- He failed to increase readiness to the next level by ordering General Quarters, an error attributable to inadequate intelligence support from Washington. Dorn Report errors allegedly committed by Kimmel reflect ignorance of operational realities.

COMMENT:

- What Admiral Kimmel did, and for whatever reasons, the fact is that retaining the fleet in Pearl Harbor was his only sensible option, since he lacked air support, his 2 (versus 6 Japanese) aircraft carriers not having yet returned from reinforcing Wake and Midway. His battleship speeds were 18 knots, his striking range 15 miles. Japanese carrier forces speed was 30 knots, striking range 300 miles.

- My challenge to anyone to identify what Kimmel should have done differently that would have had a measurable Impact on the outcome stands.

What?!
 
"Point-by-point" doesn't mean factual.

Especially when what Bobby considers 'refutation' is actually just a lot of special pleading. "I mean, just because Kimmel was 'in charge' of PH doesn't mean he was actually responsible or 'in charge' knowwhatimean?"
 
FICTION. Never, ever, ever in any of the so-called "warnings" were they given any indication that HAWAII was a potential target, and every scrap of intel that indicated Hawaii was a target was withheld from them (except for one item way back in January, and that was presented as a wild, baseless rumor). Go read those "warnings."

Bob, if a senior commander of a command needs to be told that in a time of war that his forward operational base is a probable target, then he never deserved to be an ensign, let alone admiral.
 
:snork: He could have moved the fleet to the east, if anybody except the Japanese had known the attack was coming. He could have had the ships buttoned up tight, not open for a Monday morning inspection. He could have had all guns manned and ready, supplied with ammo. He could have had a line of DDs anchored east of Battleship Row, making torpedo attacks impossible.

And he could have the fleet on an unpredictable schedule, as I mentioned above.
 
Bob, if a senior commander of a command needs to be told that in a time of war that his forward operational base is a probable target, then he never deserved to be an ensign, let alone admiral.

The Hearings' Exhibits include a bunch of headlines from Honolulu papers screaming the warnings of war approaching. If Kimmel could read, he would have known war was close. The war warnings sent from DC were also kind of a clue.
 
Kimmel's decision not to use his relatively few available aircraft for surveillance was not even remotely dereliction of duty; rather, it was a perfectly rational, logical decision based on the information and orders he had at the time, as the Navy Court of Inquiry pointed out and as many scholars and naval experts have pointed out.

As for Kimmel's alleged "failure" to take swift action on the report of the sighting of a Japanese sub, Kimmel did take immediate action: he ordered that the sighting be confirmed, since there had been a number of false sub-sighting reports in recent months. As Kimmel explained, given that there had been several sub sightings that turned out to be false, he wanted to get confirmation of this most recent one before he took further action. Again, a perfectly rational, logical decision, based on the circumstances and on the information he had at the time--not even remotely dereliction of duty.

I'm reminded that many admirals, including Admiral Nimitz, said later that they would have done the same things that Kimmel did, given the circumstances and the information that he had at the time.

You want dereliction of duty? How about Admiral Stark's refusal to follow Admiral Wilkinson's urgent recommendation that he "pick up the phone and call Kimmel" after he received the Japanese 14-part reply and its two accompanying messages? THAT was dereliction of duty. Here he had the head of ONI telling him what he obviously already could see--that the Japanese intercepts in his hand clearly, obviously indicated war was imminent--and urging him to "pick up the phone" and call Kimmel. Instead, Stark tried to call FDR, and when he couldn't reach him, he did . . . NOTHING. He sat there and did NOTHING, even though as CNO he had the absolute right and authority to call Kimmel. THAT is what you call dereliction of duty.

Another clear case of dereliction of duty was General Marshall's downright criminal stalling after he was given the 6-7-December Japanese intercepts. He had the head of Army G-2 and another senior Army intel officer urging him to read the crucial time-of-delivery message first, but he refused to read it until he had read--slowly and out loud--the entire 14-part main message. Even Captain Beach said it looked like Marshall was stalling. THAT was dereliction of duty.

Then, after Marshall finally got around to reading the time-of-delivery and code-destruction messages, he stalled further by calling Admiral Stark to get his opinion on what should be done! After this pointless chit-chat, Marshall finally, finally wrote out--in messy handwriting--a rather vague 'warning" message and dispatched Bratton to send it. Yet, incredibly, Marshall did not direct that this crucial message be marked as urgent or that it be sent as a priority transmission. Even after he learned that the message would have to be sent via Western Union wire and that it might take 40 minutes just to get to Hawaii, he took no further action. He knew he could simply pick up the scrambler phone on his desk and order Short to go to full alert, and he could have done this without mentioning intercepts at all. But he did nothing. THAT was dereliction of duty.
 
Last edited:
Actually, you've been the only one to mention Kimmel's reaction to Outerbridge's messages. CinUS did indeed call for immediate action, against submarine threats.

The rest of your post is merely would-coulds-shoulda stuff and I won't be addressing it. (Unless you get funnier, anyway.)
 
Bob, you claim to have been in the army for 20 years, so lets do a TEWT.

How do you secure your FOB? Do you establish sentry points at the perimeter, along with listening/observation points further out with patrols? Do you keep everything on a set schedule or do you mix it up to keep your own side and the OPFOR unsure? Do you liaise with the other units to ensure a co- ordinated defense? What about rehearsals?

I think these things are covered in PLQ (first leadership course for NCOs) and DP1.1(what qualifies you to be an Lt).
 
So we point out how Kimmel kept to a predictable schedule, set his defenses up for stopping sabotage rather than air attack, and several other points of neglect and Bobby brings up several other completely unmentioned issues.

...yeah.
 
BTF, the "Roosevelt is evil" camp rules the conspiracy nuts who believe the LIHOP idiocy.
I'm convinced that if FDR hadn't pushed to get the U.S. on the path to rearmament, and then the war had dragged on for several extra years, the FDR haters would be using that as evidence of how evil he was. It seems that they start with FDR=evil, and therefore anything he did or did not do has to be "proof" of that evilness.
 
Yeah, well that's Conspiraloon 101: Start with the conclusion.

Or as the Red Queen said: Sentence first, verdict afterwards!
 
I'm convinced that if FDR hadn't pushed to get the U.S. on the path to rearmament, and then the war had dragged on for several extra years, the FDR haters would be using that as evidence of how evil he was. It seems that they start with FDR=evil, and therefore anything he did or did not do has to be "proof" of that evilness.

Of course. The issues aren't the issue, if you get my meaning.
 
Small fix. ;)

Oops.

In any case, while there is a certain amount of blame to be attributed to Short & Kimmel, it not like they are being utterly demonized like so many other incompetent generals & admirals in history. They showed an amazing penchant for mediocrity in an area much to close for that to be acceptable. It wasn't as if FDR himself came down to strip the buttons of their uniforms personally.
 
Oops.

In any case, while there is a certain amount of blame to be attributed to Short & Kimmel, it not like they are being utterly demonized like so many other incompetent generals & admirals in history. They showed an amazing penchant for mediocrity in an area much to close for that to be acceptable. It wasn't as if FDR himself came down to strip the buttons of their uniforms personally.

In the US we fire the coach when the team doesn't win.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom