Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Just curious: Given all that we now know, are any of you traditionalists willing to acknowledge that FDR's campaign to blame Kimmel and Short was unjustified and disgraceful?


Begging the question of whether there was a "campaign" to blame them, and the question of whether any such campaign, if it existed, was orchestrated by FDR.

If by chance there is anyone here who still buys the claim that Kimmel and Short were mostly/totally to blame, please specify which if any of the above books and articles you've read.


Sorry, you don't get to attempt to disqualify your critics on the grounds of not having read certain books or papers. The facts speak for themselves.

Kimmel and Short were explicitly warned that war was imminent, and that hostile Japanese action was possible "in any direction."

Tell us, BTF, how many interceptors did Short have on combat air patrol on the morning of December 7, 1941? And what sort of use did Short make of the radar sets his command had received?

Further, Short failed to read the extensive briefing materials prepared for him by his predecessor, appointed an officer with no intelligence training as his intelligence chief (apparently because he didn't want an unwashed reservist as part of his inner circle), and grossly overestimated the threat of sabotage from Hawaii's ethnic Japanese population. See Pearl Harbor: Final Judgement, by Henry Clausen and Bruce Lee, and the testimony of General Charles D. Herron before the joint Congressional investigation.

As for Kimmel, as Gawdzilla pointed out up-thread, he kept the fleet on a predictable schedule, which allowed the Japanese to know that they had an excellent chance of finding most of the Pacific Fleet's capital ships at anchor on a Sunday morning in Hawaii. He also failed to share intelligence or otherwise develop any sort of a coordinated defense plan with Short, as he'd been directed.

As the Dorn Report states (paraphrasing), Kimmel and Short were relieved because they had demonstrated a clear lack of the "superior judgement" required for high command. The evidence of this lack of superior judgement is incontrovertible, whether you, their families, or their other apologists like it or not.

The fact that others may have escaped blame for their failures is irrelevant (though you fail to note that Admiral Harold Stark was relieved as Chief of Naval Operations for his errors in judgement).
 
BTW, if you haven't read the Dorn Report, it's fun reading. Short form is the family wants Kimmel retired at his highest rank, full Admiral. This honor is reserved for officers that do exceptionally well in their jobs. Anybody who says Kimmel did "exceptionally well" should seek expert medical advice NOW.
 
BTW, Richardson testified before Congress that his only concern about "forward deployment" of the US Fleet was logistical. He stated that he was never worried about an attack on the base of any serious nature. Later, when he wasn't under oath, that changed a bit. I guess he was truthful when he was required to be.
 
That is one of the things that early on turned me off about the Pearl Harbor Conspiracy Theories: The belief that Kimmel and Short are Holy Figures Above Criticism.
The revisionists are also quiet about Mac Arthur's folly of letting most of the USAAF in the Phillipines being caught on the ground and destroyed nearly a day after Pearl Harbor;they let Mac off the hook because of their right wing political agenda.
 
That is one of the things that early on turned me off about the Pearl Harbor Conspiracy Theories: The belief that Kimmel and Short are Holy Figures Above Criticism.
The Great Nosferatu President set them up as scapegoats, so naturally we feel the need to rise them above the pathetic jobs they did on Hawaii.
The revisionists are also quiet about Mac Arthur's folly of letting most of the USAAF in the Phillipines being caught on the ground and destroyed nearly a day after Pearl Harbor;they let Mac off the hook because of their right wing political agenda.
Well, the bombers had just come back from a shot at Formosa, IIRC. You can hang a lot on Dugout Doug, but that fiasco really isn't one of them.
 
BTW, Richardson testified before Congress that his only concern about "forward deployment" of the US Fleet was logistical. He stated that he was never worried about an attack on the base of any serious nature. Later, when he wasn't under oath, that changed a bit. I guess he was truthful when he was required to be.

Or maybe, as he became aware of the Japanese intercepts and the other info withheld from Kimmel, he changed his mind and in hindsight realized that the fleet was put there as bait, that FDR knew the attack was coming, and that FDR scapegoated Kimmel and Short to cover his tracks and to appease a furious public.

You know, when you become aware of a lot more information, it can cause you to change your mind.

You might try it sometime.
 
Last edited:
Or maybe, as he became aware of the Japanese intercepts and the other info withheld from Kimmel, he changed his mind and in hindsight realized that the fleet was put there as bait, that FDR knew the attack was coming, and that FDR scapegoated Kimmel and Short to cover his tracks and to appease a furious public.
Really? What intercepts would Kimmel have found useful and why? Remember we've already discarded the "Bomb Plot" messages, they weren't used by the IJN in any fashion, so they weren't any kind of combat intell.
You know, when you become aware of a lot more information, it can cause you to change your mind.

You might try it sometime.
Yep, you're right. I should read a book or something. Maybe even more than one.
 
The revisionists are also quiet about Mac Arthur's folly of letting most of the USAAF in the Phillipines being caught on the ground and destroyed nearly a day after Pearl Harbor;they let Mac off the hook because of their right wing political agenda.

Again you show how shallow your research has been. A number of revisionists have been very critical of MacArthur for the very reason that you cite (along with others).

By the way, I lean to the right on most issues and I have no use for MacArthur. I think he's one of the most over-rated generals in history, that most of his "victories" were hyped, and that we should have followed Nimitz's Pacific strategy instead of MacArthur's.

And your comment about "their right wing [sic] political agenda" is erroneous. Quite a few revisionists--including John Toland, Robert Stinnett, and George Victor--are Roosevelt admirers who praise him in spite of his duplicity in the Pearl Harbor attack.

I've corrected you on this point before, but you just keep repeating it. Toland speaks glowingly of FDR in Infamy, though he criticizes him for his role in the attack. Stinnett and Victor not only praise FDR but opine that his Pearl Harbor treachery was actually wise and necessary, though they also opine that he should not have scapegoated Kimmel and Short.
 
Last edited:
I've corrected you on this point before, but you just keep repeating it. Toland speaks glowingly of FDR in Infamy, though he criticizes him for his role in the attack. Stinnett and Victor not only praise FDR but opine that his Pearl Harbor treachery was actually wise and necessary, though they also opine that he should not have scapegoated Kimmel and Short.
Is "opine" the word of the day from Urban Dictionary?

When I spoke with Stinnett he had nothing nice to say about FDR.
 
Really? What intercepts would Kimmel have found useful and why? Remember we've already discarded the "Bomb Plot" messages, they weren't used by the IJN in any fashion, so they weren't any kind of combat intell.

Yep, you're right. I should read a book or something. Maybe even more than one.

Uh, the bomb plot information was in fact used by the IJN. How can you not know that? I thought you were supposed to be an "expert," but it's becoming obvious that your expertise extends only to traditionalist writings and that your research has been rather incomplete.

And even if the IJN had not used the bomb plot intel, certainly Kimmel should have been informed that the Japanese were plotting the position of his ships in harbor on a grid map, which they did for no other harbor. As Kimmel and Layton both said when they learned of the bomb plot messages, that intel would have altered their thinking considerably.
 
Uh, the bomb plot information was in fact used by the IJN. How can you not know that? I thought you were supposed to be an "expert," but it's becoming obvious that your expertise extends only to traditionalist writings and that your research has been rather incomplete.
The "ships in port" messages were important. The Bomb Plot information wasn't even transmitted to the IJN in that fashion. They just got the distilled "ships in port" data. Try reading the records.
And even if the IJN had not used the bomb plot intel, certainly Kimmel should have been informed that the Japanese were plotting the position of his ships in harbor on a grid map, which they did for no other harbor. As Kimmel and Layton both said when they learned of the bomb plot messages, that intel would have altered their thinking considerably.
Kimmel had war warnings, which were actually pertinent to his job. The Bomb Plot was just a short-hand to save telegraph fees.
 
Ok, and in reply to the responses on blaming Kimmel and Short, the first thing that stands out is that every single argument made against Kimmel and Short in the replies has been demolished. The problem is that you guys simply have not done your homework.

By the way, the Navy Court of Inquiry and the Army Pearl Harbor Board placed most of the blame on Washington, not on the commanders in Hawaii.
 
Ok, and in reply to the responses on blaming Kimmel and Short, the first thing that stands out is that every single argument made against Kimmel and Short in the replies has been demolished. The problem is that you guys simply have not done your homework.
Short protected against only one of the possible threats to the US Fleet he was sent there to protect. Fail.
Kimmel is directly responsible for the IGHQ's go-ahead on the plan to attack Pearl Harbor, and I do mean directly. He kept the fleet on banker's hours, guaranteeing there would be a "big bag" when the attack arrived.
Both the Navy Court of Inquiry and the Army Pearl Harbor Board placed most of the blame on Washington, not on the commanders in Hawaii, by the way.
Both men were offered a chance to clear their names in formal courts-martial. Neither did. With good reason.
 
Begging the question of whether there was a "campaign" to blame them, and the question of whether any such campaign, if it existed, was orchestrated by FDR.

Gosh, it is surreal that you would say this, given all that we now know.

But your next comment explains why you would make such a downright silly statement.

Sorry, you don't get to attempt to disqualify your critics on the grounds of not having read certain books or papers. The facts speak for themselves.

Ohhhhhhh, I see. So you have not read both sides, but you're so sure you're right that you don't need to! Got it. Thanks for sharing.

Kimmel and Short were explicitly warned that war was imminent, and that hostile Japanese action was possible "in any direction."

FICTION. Never, ever, ever in any of the so-called "warnings" were they given any indication that HAWAII was a potential target, and every scrap of intel that indicated Hawaii was a target was withheld from them (except for one item way back in January, and that was presented as a wild, baseless rumor). Go read those "warnings."

Tell us, BTF, how many interceptors did Short have on combat air patrol on the morning of December 7, 1941? And what sort of use did Short make of the radar sets his command had received?

You must be joking. These arguments have been destroyed, utterly destroyed. If you'd do some balanced research, you wouldn't get on a public board and repeat fairy tales like these.

Ditto for the rest of your arguments. Dare yourself to read the other side. Maybe, just maybe, not everything is as it has been portrayed in the materials you have read. You could start with Professor Gannon's book.
 
Bobby's argument seems to be declaring that everyone else's argument has been 'demolished' without actually having done anything that deserves such a declaration.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom