SpitfireIX
Philosopher
Just curious: Given all that we now know, are any of you traditionalists willing to acknowledge that FDR's campaign to blame Kimmel and Short was unjustified and disgraceful?
Begging the question of whether there was a "campaign" to blame them, and the question of whether any such campaign, if it existed, was orchestrated by FDR.
If by chance there is anyone here who still buys the claim that Kimmel and Short were mostly/totally to blame, please specify which if any of the above books and articles you've read.
Sorry, you don't get to attempt to disqualify your critics on the grounds of not having read certain books or papers. The facts speak for themselves.
Kimmel and Short were explicitly warned that war was imminent, and that hostile Japanese action was possible "in any direction."
Tell us, BTF, how many interceptors did Short have on combat air patrol on the morning of December 7, 1941? And what sort of use did Short make of the radar sets his command had received?
Further, Short failed to read the extensive briefing materials prepared for him by his predecessor, appointed an officer with no intelligence training as his intelligence chief (apparently because he didn't want an unwashed reservist as part of his inner circle), and grossly overestimated the threat of sabotage from Hawaii's ethnic Japanese population. See Pearl Harbor: Final Judgement, by Henry Clausen and Bruce Lee, and the testimony of General Charles D. Herron before the joint Congressional investigation.
As for Kimmel, as Gawdzilla pointed out up-thread, he kept the fleet on a predictable schedule, which allowed the Japanese to know that they had an excellent chance of finding most of the Pacific Fleet's capital ships at anchor on a Sunday morning in Hawaii. He also failed to share intelligence or otherwise develop any sort of a coordinated defense plan with Short, as he'd been directed.
As the Dorn Report states (paraphrasing), Kimmel and Short were relieved because they had demonstrated a clear lack of the "superior judgement" required for high command. The evidence of this lack of superior judgement is incontrovertible, whether you, their families, or their other apologists like it or not.
The fact that others may have escaped blame for their failures is irrelevant (though you fail to note that Admiral Harold Stark was relieved as Chief of Naval Operations for his errors in judgement).