Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Another non-revelation. This one is a two-fer.

Bobby, you are impressing yourself only. Those of us who know how this stuff works aren't impressed by 'stunning revelation' the Japanese were gathering intelligence on Pearl.

I'm pretty sure Kimmel had some clue even without the memo, he took the wrong precautions however as he expected sabotage, not an air assault.

Short was even worse when it comes to emphasizing sabotage and ignoring the possibilities of any other kind of attack.
IMHO Kimmel and Short were at fault but did not deserve being the scapegoats. Kimmel certainly was a good adminstrator and should have been giving a desk job.
The thing is the COnspriacy kooks take this too far and make Kimmel and Short tragic heros stabbed in the back the evil FDR, George Marshall,and Admiral Stark......
 
Short was even worse when it comes to emphasizing sabotage and ignoring the possibilities of any other kind of attack.
IMHO Kimmel and Short were at fault but did not deserve being the scapegoats. Kimmel certainly was a good adminstrator and should have been giving a desk job.
The thing is the COnspriacy kooks take this too far and make Kimmel and Short tragic heros stabbed in the back the evil FDR, George Marshall,and Admiral Stark......

What stuns me is the Kimmel family is trying to get Husband retroactively restored to his highest rank, full admiral.

Let me set this up. Full admiral rank was given so one guy could give orders to the others. It was never meant to be a permanent rank back then, it was "for the duration of the assignment". However, if a person did a really, really good job they could be granted that rank again when they retired or died.

The Kimmel family evidently think Husband E. Kimmel did a "really, really good job" at Pearl Harbor. I would beg to differ.
 
The standard CT response kicks in:

"They were told to 'Shut up and soldier, soldier!' and they always obey such orders. always, without qualm or thought, completely, fully, and thoroughly, because they're without will or volition."

:blackcat:

I ran into one person in my 20 years active duty that would have taken such an order. I got rid of him as soon as possible.

That is what they believe; and if/when confronted, will say that you were told to "Shut up and soldier, soldier!" yourself and ordered to say that, and of course you always thoroughly obey orders.

That's what the conspiracists think.
 
That is what they believe; and if/when confronted, will say that you were told to "Shut up and soldier, soldier!" yourself and ordered to say that, and of course you always thoroughly obey orders.

That's what the conspiracists think.

Without that line of thinking they would have to admit the great conspiracies wouldn't last long at all.
 
That is what they believe; and if/when confronted, will say that you were told to "Shut up and soldier, soldier!" yourself and ordered to say that, and of course you always thoroughly obey orders.
That's what the conspiracists think.

Then the Striking Force would have not transmitted.
 
The standard CT response kicks in:

"They were told to 'Shut up and soldier, soldier!' and they always obey such orders. always, without qualm or thought, completely, fully, and thoroughly, because they're without will or volition."

:blackcat:

Except, of course, for the brave whistle-blowers they're using for support.
 
Except, of course, for the brave (three or more times removed from the actual events and strangely without any hard evidence at all )whistle-blowers they're using for support.

fixed.gif
 
I used to laugh at the idea that British frogmen put limpet mines on the USN BBs to guarantee they'd sink, this because the Japanese weren't good enough fliers to get-r-done.

However, a couple of days ago I found solid evidence that a member of the Royal Family and a very high ranking RN officer to boot was in an airplane watching an attack on Pearl Harbor.
 
In case you're wondering, the officer was Lord Louis Mountbatten, who was taking the short way from from the CBI (through Washington DC), and stopped in T.H. to tell war stories and generally shmooze. He was treated to a eagle's eye view of the USN attacking an "enemy" anchorage from carriers. Date was September 29-30, 1941, about ten weeks before the attack.

Irony is as irony does.
 
I used to laugh at the idea that British frogmen put limpet mines on the USN BBs to guarantee they'd sink, this because the Japanese weren't good enough fliers to get-r-done.

However, a couple of days ago I found solid evidence that a member of the Royal Family and a very high ranking RN officer to boot was in an airplane watching an attack on Pearl Harbor.
Lord Louis wasn't a member of the UK Royal Family yet, and it could be argued he never was. His nephew Phillip didn't marry Elizabeth until '47. He was, of course, cousins with them, as Victoria was his great-grand mother. If we figure it this way, it would mean most royalty of Europe would be part of the UK Royal Family.
 
Lord Louis wasn't a member of the UK Royal Family yet, and it could be argued he never was. His nephew Phillip didn't marry Elizabeth until '47. He was, of course, cousins with them, as Victoria was his great-grand mother. If we figure it this way, it would mean most royalty of Europe would be part of the UK Royal Family.

Meh, close enough for us colonials, old bean. ;)
 
Meh, close enough for us colonials, old bean. ;)
Fair enough, old chap ;) I'd read a biography about the Mountbattens (THE MOUNTBATTENS: The Last Royal Success Story, Random House 1965) years ago that I'd picked up at a 2nd hand book store, that briefly discussed Dickey's (his family nickname) visit to Pearl, including his observation of that exercise.
 
Fair enough, old chap ;) I'd read a biography about the Mountbattens (THE MOUNTBATTENS: The Last Royal Success Story, Random House 1965) years ago that I'd picked up at a 2nd hand book store, that briefly discussed Dickey's (his family nickname) visit to Pearl, including his observation of that exercise.

I have the minutes of his speech to the officers. It will be online eventually, along with the reactions by various USN senior commanders.
 
Ironically he was killed in a surprise bomb attack on his boat. His own 'Pearl Harbour' kind of.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom