Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

That's your argument? Really? Yeah, roll your eyes indeed. The problem is that you are such a partisan ideologue on this issue that you are incapable of being objective.

As long as we'reon that sort of tack, why did you never take my challenge about radio direction finding after asserting that it was totes possible, temporarily drop the subject, and are now trying to sneak it back in to the discussion through the back door, as it were? Why did you ignore so many posts about whether the Japanese records say they transmitted?
 

Your friend did not mislead you.

I'm halfway through ATM and this is very good overview of the strategic and political/military situation in this area and how the battle developed so far.

The book is very readable, and ties in the Soviet actions with what was going on in Europe as well, allowing the reader to get a better appreciation for why things happened as they did.
 
Interesting: It came to light in late 2011, about 14 months ago, that on 4 December, three days before the attack, FDR received a 26-page memo from ONI that, among other things, warned him that Hawaii was one of the three areas where the Japanese were focusing their intelligence collection efforts, and that the Japanese were especially interested in information that could be used by the Japanese Navy (Craig Shirley, December 1941: 30 Days That Changed America and Saved the World, Nashville: Thomas Nelson Publishers, 2011, pp. 63-64). I quote part of the memo:

"In anticipation of possible open conflict with this country, Japan is vigorously utilizing every available agency to secure military, naval, and commercial information, paying particular attention to the West Coast, the Panama Canal, and the Territory of Hawaii. . . .

[The Japanese were] primarily interested in obtaining detailed technical information which could be used to advantage by the Japanese Navy."​

Now, given the veritable war that was fought over keeping Kimmel and Short in the dark about the bomb plot messages, it boggles the mind to imagine any innocent excuse for not informing Kimmel and Short that Hawaii was one of the three areas about which the Japanese were "vigorously" trying to obtain information that could be used by the Japanese Navy in the event that America and Japan went to war.

You'll recall that senior Navy intelligence officers, including McCollum, felt strongly that Kimmel should be told about the bomb plot messages (an obvious no-brainer). After being told no, these officers began to push back hard. The fight turned into such a battle royale that Admiral Stark had to personally intervene--and intervene he did: he ensured that Kimmel was not told about those messages.

So, now, on 4 December, FDR, Stark, and other high officials are informed that Hawaii is one of the three main areas where the Japanese are trying hard to obtain information that could be used by the Japanese Navy in the event of war. And it doesn't dawn on any of them to inform Kimmel or Short of this fact? It doesn't dawn on a single one of them that, gee, maybe there's some connection between this intel collection effort and the bomb plot messages? Are you kidding me?

The long-suppressed 4 December ONI memo also makes it all the more incomprehensible and suspicious that Stark refused to act when urged on the morning of 7 December by Admiral Wilkinson to "pick up the phone and call Kimmel" because it was obvious that war was imminent.
 
Bob, Pearl was the advanced base for the U.S. Fleet. Strange that the Japanese would want to know what was going on there, isn't it?

And drop the bomb plot nonsense, the information format was never used operationally, it was just a way to save money on telegrams.

And the "long suppressed" memo was published in 1946.
 
Another non-revelation. This one is a two-fer.

Bobby, you are impressing yourself only. Those of us who know how this stuff works aren't impressed by 'stunning revelation' the Japanese were gathering intelligence on Pearl.

I'm pretty sure Kimmel had some clue even without the memo, he took the wrong precautions however as he expected sabotage, not an air assault.
 
Another non-revelation. This one is a two-fer.

Bobby, you are impressing yourself only. Those of us who know how this stuff works aren't impressed by 'stunning revelation' the Japanese were gathering intelligence on Pearl.

I'm pretty sure Kimmel had some clue even without the memo, he took the wrong precautions however as he expected sabotage, not an air assault.

Actually, it was Short, the guy whose mission was "protect the fleet" that decided that his planes were too valuable to risk and kept them in nice neat, and easily guarded, rows instead of being dispersed. Yoshikawa reported this, of course.

Kimmel had his own problems, of course. The first was the mistake that allowed Yamamoto to bulldoze his plan through IGHQ. Kimmel had the fleet on a regular, and predictable, schedule. The good young lieutenant Takao notified Japan that there was usually a large contingent of the US Fleet in harbor on weekends. Without this intell the IGHQ folks would not have considered the risk worth the prize.
 
Question for you, Bob. If Kido Butai was in calliope mode as you claim, why didn't anybody but your lone listener pick it up? I know for a fact that there were lots of sailors in the USN who didn't like FDR, and even those who did would not have sit quietly by while their shipmates were being murdered for political gain by the ebil presidente. If even one of those in the know had gone public every other person with knowledge that the approach of the enemy had been hidden would have felt it not only safer, but mandatory that they come forward as well.

So, whatcha got?
 
Bob, before you do another shift of discussion, Nohmonhan 1939 - Chapters 6 and 7 do an excellent analysis of the strategic, and political reasons why Japan never went after the Soviets.
 
Question for you, Bob. If Kido Butai was in calliope mode as you claim, why didn't anybody but your lone listener pick it up? I know for a fact that there were lots of sailors in the USN who didn't like FDR, and even those who did would not have sit quietly by while their shipmates were being murdered for political gain by the ebil presidente. If even one of those in the know had gone public every other person with knowledge that the approach of the enemy had been hidden would have felt it not only safer, but mandatory that they come forward as well.

The standard CT response kicks in:

"They were told to 'Shut up and soldier, soldier!' and they always obey such orders. always, without qualm or thought, completely, fully, and thoroughly, because they're without will or volition."

:blackcat:
 
The standard CT response kicks in:

"They were told to 'Shut up and soldier, soldier!' and they always obey such orders. always, without qualm or thought, completely, fully, and thoroughly, because they're without will or volition."

:blackcat:

I ran into one person in my 20 years active duty that would have taken such an order. I got rid of him as soon as possible.
 
"Shut Up And Soldier" is a term I heard used a few times in my time in the US Army, but only when the person it was addressed to had gone over the line from normal, healthy bitching to whining,and most of the time it was other soldiers in his outfit that used it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom