matt.tansy
Muse
- Joined
- Feb 23, 2007
- Messages
- 991
I'm mainly here for the E in the forum name! Thanks Matt, I should have gone off and got it translated!
The shadow falls on the spinning dime.
I'm mainly here for the E in the forum name! Thanks Matt, I should have gone off and got it translated!
I'm mainly here for the E in the forum name! Thanks Matt, I should have gone off and got it translated!
I can't even say I did that!![]()
That's your argument? Really? Yeah, roll your eyes indeed. The problem is that you are such a partisan ideologue on this issue that you are incapable of being objective.
Well, the questions were rhetorical.
Nomonhan, 1939: The Red Army's Victory That Shaped World War II
Recommended reading.
Another non-revelation. This one is a two-fer.
Bobby, you are impressing yourself only. Those of us who know how this stuff works aren't impressed by 'stunning revelation' the Japanese were gathering intelligence on Pearl.
I'm pretty sure Kimmel had some clue even without the memo, he took the wrong precautions however as he expected sabotage, not an air assault.
Question for you, Bob. If Kido Butai was in calliope mode as you claim, why didn't anybody but your lone listener pick it up? I know for a fact that there were lots of sailors in the USN who didn't like FDR, and even those who did would not have sit quietly by while their shipmates were being murdered for political gain by the ebil presidente. If even one of those in the know had gone public every other person with knowledge that the approach of the enemy had been hidden would have felt it not only safer, but mandatory that they come forward as well.

The standard CT response kicks in:
"They were told to 'Shut up and soldier, soldier!' and they always obey such orders. always, without qualm or thought, completely, fully, and thoroughly, because they're without will or volition."
![]()
Conspiracy theorists can't engage in honest debate, they'd be out of the game in five minutes, on their best day.